用戶登入
用戶名稱:
密      碼:
搜索
教育王國 討論區 小一選校 港大同學會 vs. 聖保祿天主教小學 (跑馬地), 你地會點揀 ...
樓主: OpheliaMama
go

港大同學會 vs. 聖保祿天主教小學 (跑馬地), 你地會點揀?

Rank: 4


512
發表於 10-6-10 13:27 |顯示全部帖子
我個人決定選主流學校, 大前題是基於經濟考慮. 今天仍能搵2萬元人工的, 不擔保明年仍可. (參考本港入息中位數). 但學費頂多凍結,很難減. 我較杞人憂天, 寧願未雨綢繆.

至於外國升學的打算, 我認為本地"名"津校的學生,在外地依然進取, 可能講英文方面要適應一陣, 但基本上,整體表現都很好.  我在外地求學時, 正正看到這些學生的主動, 進取,連本土人都冇佢地咁多野發表(當時上堂討論都計入平時分). 我才體會到, 香港"名"校, 的確有其成名原因. 刮目相看.  (只恨自己不是名校出身. ) 我那個年代當然未有現在的直資學生, 不能比較.

最近看到施永青的文章, 很認同他說現今孩子不能面對壓力, 郁d就自殺,跳樓,沒有"成"擔, 只求開心.  

作為父母,只有自己才了解自己的小孩(除了不面對現實那種父母), 給他們能應付的,再加多少少作磨練, 讓他們知道, 人是要有求生技能,不能終生靠父蔭.  只要父母不鑽牛角尖, 孩子便能在逆境成長, 鍛鍊出意志. 不要奢望靠學校教好自己個仔. 家教才是最重要.  

原帖由 NatalieBaby 於 10-6-10 12:46 發表
想將來公開試取好成績升本地大學
又唔怕谷

---> St Paul's  
因有track record 睇比較有保証


打算遲早外国升學
想小朋友活d, 多些思考空間

-->  港同 ...

Rank: 3Rank: 3


149
發表於 10-6-10 13:31 |顯示全部帖子
多謝各位意見,最後我地決定St. Paul, 如果真係讀唔嚟,再叩門轉校。
港同好吸引,但其實我地係跨區抽到St.Paul,所以唔捨得放手。

Rank: 4


512
發表於 10-6-10 13:38 |顯示全部帖子
但港同不是直資嗎. 點解又可以抽獎?!?!?

原帖由 OpheliaMama 於 10-6-10 13:31 發表
多謝各位意見,最後我地決定St. Paul, 如果真係讀唔嚟,再叩門轉校。
港同好吸引,但其實我地係跨區抽到St.Paul,所以唔捨得放手。

Rank: 3Rank: 3


170
發表於 10-6-10 14:34 |顯示全部帖子
Allow me to share my views here re school selecting.  My boy is going to be P1 this coming Sept.  Over last year, I was under constant debate on what to do.  My observations as follows:

Government schools (good ones) - Very grade driven.  Since students are form many types of families, it can also serve better as a "society/value" learning place.  Problem is kids from different background are also equipped very differently.  This makes teaching hard.  The traditional curriculum can also be dull and less stimulating.

Good traditional schools that turned private - Very competitive and kids like school in general.  Official home work not as much.   However this is because these schools expect their kids to know the stuff before going to class.  80+ marks are considered low.  A majority of the kids have tutors.  At home, they study hard and play less.  Thus, their fun time is actually in school when they can actually play.... Value building can be a problem for some schools.

New open learning type school - No guarantee.  If take this route, the parents need to input lots of effort to study with the kid.  Course material may be easy or hard but once take this approach, should expect the kid to be lively and active.  Cannot expect the kid to have fun while doing superb in public exams.  Some schools are better in value building but some are less.  Very school depending.  Kids in general are happy while parents need not go thru the hell-like exam drilling part that can kill the fun of studying.

In short, all schools have their merits.  Most important is to make an educated and informed decision.

Of coz, I am over generalizing here.  Again, just sharing.

[ 本帖最後由 easydad 於 10-6-10 14:39 編輯 ]

Rank: 5Rank: 5


3728
發表於 10-6-10 15:32 |顯示全部帖子
樓主係港同是後補, 同時間大抽獎, 抽完後港同的後補位又成功左, 所以要作決定。

iwff

原帖由 愛愛地球 於 10-6-10 13:38 發表
但港同不是直資嗎. 點解又可以抽獎?!?!?

Rank: 3Rank: 3


358
發表於 10-6-10 15:49 |顯示全部帖子
st. paul 中學近年是否down 了?  我見中學排名是1xx.  it's the end of band 1 school!

Rank: 4


512
發表於 10-6-10 15:52 |顯示全部帖子
請問在那裡看得倒呀? 唔該.

原帖由 yutung 於 10-6-10 15:49 發表
st. paul 中學近年是否down 了?  我見中學排名是1xx.  it's the end of band 1 school!

Rank: 4


512
發表於 10-6-10 20:27 |顯示全部帖子
哦. 咁當初不是正取生, 真係嫣知非福.

恭喜

原帖由 iwff 於 10-6-10 15:32 發表
樓主係港同是後補, 同時間大抽獎, 抽完後港同的後補位又成功左, 所以要作決定。

iwff

Rank: 14Rank: 14Rank: 14Rank: 14

醒目開學勳章 王國長老


58755
發表於 10-6-10 20:59 |顯示全部帖子
果d所謂排行榜, 得啖笑, 唔好盡信
我間"寶貝"母校排90幾, 但我識既所有舊同學, 無一個俾個女返去讀

原帖由 yutung 於 10-6-10 03:49 PM 發表
st. paul 中學近年是否down 了?  我見中學排名是1xx.  it's the end of band 1 school!

Rank: 3Rank: 3


126
發表於 10-6-10 21:13 |顯示全部帖子
I will choose St Paul Cath if I have a girl. Don't  like HKUGA personally. Just personal opinion.
8-)

Rank: 3Rank: 3


347
發表於 10-6-15 11:52 |顯示全部帖子
Don't forget our kids will sit for new NSS, not the traditional HKCEE.

[ 本帖最後由 savoy 於 10-6-15 12:44 編輯 ]

Rank: 3Rank: 3


197
發表於 10-6-17 13:51 |顯示全部帖子
原帖由 OpheliaMama 於 10-6-10 13:31 發表
多謝各位意見,最後我地決定St. Paul, 如果真係讀唔嚟,再叩門轉校。
港同好吸引,但其實我地係跨區抽到St.Paul,所以唔捨得放手。


你這個決定很好O 唔試過點知自己個女讀唔讀得嚟, 聖保祿似終是名校, 值得一試, 支持o