NET14/16(2011-2012入讀小一)入o黎一齊分享

ms.aeroplane

原帖由 DoReMiMama 於 10-9-14 22:11 發表


一向以來丘佐榮都劣評如潮，我並不覺得佢係net 16 top 4，丘放乙二都入到既，大有人在

AGREE,丘佐榮,最初算係我心水FIRST CHOICE,但E+我已經降低左佢嘅排位!因為都收到D佢嘅劣評,令我卻步!但我相信依然有佢嘅叫座力!
E+我响NET 16可以剔到出邊幾間一定"NO"!但係真係剔唔到邊一間一定要"入"嘅!

Cmcl

係?? 如果深左又真係值得考慮
實在太多講法,
都唔知邊D真邊D假,
但我都考慮將明德擺係乙三,
如命運按排左入去,
便接受啦.....

原帖由 angelcheung 於 10-9-14 22:39 發表


我聽人講明德早幾年課程就真係好淺，但上年已經唔係喇，深左好多喇。
反而，d朋友問我揀邊間，我話明德，佢米就話明德多功課同程度好深。
我自己都驚，程度太程，我仔跟唔上。 ...

angelcheung

原帖由 Cmcl 於 10-9-14 23:19 發表
係?? 如果深左又真係值得考慮
實在太多講法,
都唔知邊D真邊D假,
但我都考慮將明德擺係乙三,
如命運按排左入去,
便接受啦.....

我都係聽幾個朋友講，因為佢地有小朋友係入面讀緊，因為學校想谷佢地做bank 1 wor..

hui_bb

成日聽人講, 睇到電視喊哂口, 真係有原因, 四圍睇學校, 睇資料, 成日訓唔著去想個排位, 如派得唔好, 真係令人好傷心...

hui_bb

學校表明左, 放乙一, 乙二先可叩門喎!

原帖由 Cmcl 於 10-9-14 23:19 發表
係?? 如果深左又真係值得考慮
實在太多講法,
都唔知邊D真邊D假,
但我都考慮將明德擺係乙三,
如命運按排左入去,
便接受啦.....

mimi1102

劣評如潮 ?? 我見佢升中派位唔錯, 仲諗住唔錯 ..可唔可以講下佢有咩野唔好呀 ? 學生 ? 老師 ? 定校長 ?

謝謝 ?

原帖由 ms.aeroplane 於 10-9-14 23:17 發表


AGREE,丘佐榮,最初算係我心水FIRST CHOICE,但E+我已經降低左佢嘅排位!因為都收到D佢嘅劣評,令我卻步!但我相信依然有佢嘅叫座力!
E+我响NET 16可以剔到出邊幾間一定"NO"!但係真係剔唔到邊一間一定要"入"嘅! ...

rebecca333

我都考慮緊 揀丘佐榮, 因為本身冇宗教分, 只得15分, 揀新/舊基灣/柴米 都係冇乜機會, 除非乙部再揀佢地 等叩門有誠意分.

依家聽幾個 mummy都話丘佐榮唔好, 請問係邊方面呢?

可能轉揀舊基灣, 另外 我老公係 炮米舊生 , 揀炮米 定係照駁舊基灣??

angelcheung

係咪得十五分，邊一間都好難入啊???

DoReMiMama

原帖由 angelcheung 於 10-9-15 10:33 發表
係咪得十五分，邊一間都好難入啊???

睇你要求吧

其實大家幫小朋友選小學，首要是為小朋友揀選適合的小學，並不要太注重首輪是否進得了。好的學校憑十五分真係好難入，次一級的學校俾你十五分入得到又如何呢.....

第一輪的學位比率其實好低，如果只拿著十五分，大家不如接受現實，把心思都投放在第二輪統一派位啦

DoReMiMama

原帖由 rebecca333 於 10-9-15 09:56 發表
我都考慮緊 揀丘佐榮, 因為本身冇宗教分, 只得15分, 揀新/舊基灣/柴米 都係冇乜機會, 除非乙部再揀佢地 等叩門有誠意分.

依家聽幾個 mummy都話丘佐榮唔好, 請問係邊方面呢?

可能轉揀舊基灣, 另外 我老公係 炮米舊 ...

每個人觀感不同，我個人覺得丘這所學校太著重成績忽略了教導學生的德行，在這所學校名列前矛就沒有問題，萬一成績差或孩子品德較差的，就會受到白眼或當此學生透明棄之不顧。

上樑不正下樑歪，此等辦學作風我實在不欣賞

Cmcl

係??
我上次去佢都只係話往年都係擺乙一及乙二就一定派佢地,
間間話要咁先可以叩門,
咁點揀呀,
咁唔使叩門啦.
唉~幾時先玩完呢個遊戲??
日日都滿腦係揀邊間先啱~~

原帖由 hui_bb 於 10-9-15 07:39 發表
學校表明左, 放乙一, 乙二先可叩門喎!

Cmcl

請間大家有無做Portfolio??
我就無做,
請問叩門係咪一定要有架??
內容要有咩呢??
我一向都無要我個女學呢樣學果樣,
要做的話,內容一定得好少資料.

hui_bb

魚與熊掌, 仲未想好.

成績好就一定要多功課多練習 = 辛苦

成績一般就無甘多練習但又怕中學辛苦.

甘點呀??

其實俾錢讀直資OR私校係咪無甘辛苦呢?

現在D學校真係要求小朋友琴棋書畫樣樣精....

ms.aeroplane

原帖由 hui_bb 於 10-9-16 10:56 發表
魚與熊掌, 仲未想好.

成績好就一定要多功課多練習 = 辛苦

成績一般就無甘多練習但又怕中學辛苦.

甘點呀??

其實俾錢讀直資OR私校係咪無甘辛苦呢?

現在D學校真係要求小朋友琴棋書畫樣樣精.... ...

所以無論你小朋友讀邊類嘅學校,家長都要比唔同嘅BACKUP比小朋友,有時去間輕鬆D嘅,家長都不等於會輕鬆好多!
而琴棋書畫ED野,似乎係FOR第時升中到派用場LAW...其實真係幾慘架做香港小朋友嘅家長

jasmine4711

原帖由 chanbaby 於 10-9-14 21:30 發表
點解話丹循只有兩班50個位?東區小學概覽到寫有4班bor~~

有關丹循請問:
1/平均幾多樣功課?
2/活動教學嗎?
3/升中結果ok嗎?

有媽咪可以分享下嗎?? thanks

...

They have their open day this Sat (18/9) from 3-5pm. Number of classes differs from yr to yr. Cause they accepted 4 classes before, Education Dept restricts it to only 2 this year, else not enough classrooms.

They say it is 活動教學, 35%+ goes to band 1. Less pressure than old am school. am school has slightly better grades but more pressure.

melbby

hi all,

if only have 15分 ... 1st round pick 北角衞理 = impossible ??

i went to their open day last week, their school is really "old" but it's v close to my place and I like “活動教學” …

pls. share if any schools in net 14 are “活動教學” while having good reputation … thanks a lot !!

jasmine4711

melby:
Last year, even 20 points need to draw lots. 15 is impossible for top schools in net 14 like 北角衞理, either am or pm

I missed the open day this year. Did the principal say you must put the school in round 1 this year and then in A1 and B1 next year before u can knock door. (pls reply the answer as I did not go)

If so , are u prepared to sacrifice the 15 points in order to knock door with higher chance, knowing they give places to their own kindergarten first.

[ 本帖最後由 jasmine4711 於 10-9-16 14:50 編輯 ]

melbby

原帖由 jasmine4711 於 10-9-16 14:48 發表
melby:
Last year, even 20 points need to draw lots. 15 is impossible for top schools in net 14 like 北角衞理, either am or pm

I missed the open day this year. Did the principal say you must put the s ...

jasmine4711,

yes, the principal mentioned if u put 衞理 in the 1st round and 2nd round (part A and part B first choices) ... then, she will consider if we need to "knock the door" later ...
but as u said, they have their own KG kids to consider ...

will 丹循 / 北循 have bigger chance ? as i think they are similar to 衞理, aren't they ?

headache ...

TSEHANG

我仔仔在明德讀小二,功課不多,外籍老師也是低年班才有,中文是普通話教,而英文我仔仔說是全英語上堂,我只知學校會收有問題的學生!派位我見今年都沒有公開,可能都不是太理想!
上年我看到明德排第3或第4位都入到,所以有心想去最TOP的學校,可臨不考慮 !
老實說當年我自知仔仔不是一點就明或者好叻那類,所以我都吾要求學校好TOP,佢讀吾上比學校吾理仲死!

hui_bb

已經參觀埋滬江, 都仲係十五十六, 未有決定... 點算.