用戶登入
用戶名稱:
密      碼:
搜索
教育王國 討論區 初中教育 聖保羅書院(男) 對 旅港開平
查看: 6690|回覆: 43
go

聖保羅書院(男) 對 旅港開平

Rank: 3Rank: 3


225
發表於 09-10-6 11:59 |顯示全部帖子
請問那間好一d
因學校今日call

Rank: 1


25
發表於 09-10-7 08:29 |顯示全部帖子
May I ask you which school call you, for offering a F1 place to your daughter/son?

Rank: 2


59
發表於 09-10-15 22:41 |顯示全部帖子
我和阿仔都鐘意聖保羅書院,
(校風純樸、校舍設備完善、老師友善、
學校知名度高、同學視野廣闊)

希望日後多些該校的家長上來談談!

Rank: 2


59
發表於 09-10-15 22:42 |顯示全部帖子
樓主最终選了SPC嗎?

我個仔話佢果班十月份
多了兩個插班生,
其中一個是來自旅港。

Rank: 5Rank: 5


3560
發表於 09-10-18 02:24 |顯示全部帖子
spc is better...

Rank: 6Rank: 6


9147
發表於 09-10-18 10:51 |顯示全部帖子
請問各位

我在中學概覽見到St.Paul Boys是直資校,但聽聞有人派位入到,是什麼回事?請指教。

Rank: 4


719
發表於 09-10-18 14:36 |顯示全部帖子
原帖由 yph2005 於 09-10-6 11:59 發表
請問那間好一d
因學校今日call


請問你孩子讀中幾呢?旅港開平走寶!唉!

Rank: 1


6
發表於 09-10-18 17:39 |顯示全部帖子
原帖由 Singpiano 於 09-10-18 02:24 發表
spc is better...

In what aspect do you think SPC is better than HPCCSS?
Academically for this year HKCEE, HPCCSS scored 7X% for students with marks over 14 for the best six subjects. Average credits for an average student exceeds 5. Both scores are ever best for the school history. For SPC, this year's results are not known. But we do know the status of the first round of F6 admission from its own F5 students. There were 13 places left. So we can deduce the percentage of students with marks over 14. It is around 50%. Suppose some best students left for other schools, say, 5-10% at most. The best scores could not be better than 60%! So I disagree with your saying SPC is better.

Rank: 5Rank: 5


4405
發表於 09-10-18 18:18 |顯示全部帖子
請注恴旅港中六只得2班 ,相對其他中學有3班中六比旅港多位‧

Rank: 1


6
發表於 09-10-18 19:01 |顯示全部帖子
原帖由 secyw 於 09-10-18 18:18 發表
請注恴旅港中六只得2班 ,相對其他中學有3班中六比旅港多位‧

Sorry for any misunderstanding caused if i put it too brief. There are about 150 f5 students and there are total 88 places ( 3 classes) in F6. If there are 13 places left, own students got admitted are 88-13 = 75 which is about 50% of the total. ( You can refer to Khamama's post about F1 admission analysis " Central/Western district" which i think is excellent ) Actually my data is quoted from this source.

Rank: 5Rank: 5


3560
發表於 09-10-18 20:26 |顯示全部帖子
If your child study in SPC, u will feel how better it is.

Rank: 1


6
發表於 09-10-18 21:56 |顯示全部帖子
原帖由 Singpiano 於 09-10-18 20:26 發表
If your child study in SPC, u will feel how better it is.

I'm not saying SPC is not good. Actually i used to live in western district and studied in HKU a long time ago. I walked past SPC every school day en  route to University and had a fond memory of the students there.
I think most parents of HPCCSS would have the same impression of their school like you and think how better it is.

Rank: 2


59
發表於 09-10-19 01:04 |顯示全部帖子
For SPC, this year's results are not known. But we do know the status of the first round of F6 admission from its own F5 students. There were 13 places left. So we can deduce the percentage of students with marks over 14. It is around 50%. Suppose some best students left for other schools, say, 5-10% at most. The best scores could not be better than 60%
TO:dadylee
以上的比率純屬你個人推測,並不能完確實,亦請不要過於數字化去衡量一間學校的好與壞。
我本人當初擇校時,除了看Academic,還非常關注校舍設備、老師和同學的態度。
我鐘意聖保羅書院,首先因為學校知名度比較高,令我較為有信心。而且我多次感覺到該校的教職員很友善、很關愛學生,學校並舉辦很多課外活動、交流團等,
故此該校學生視野一般都較廣闊。

Rank: 2


59
發表於 09-10-19 01:29 |顯示全部帖子
至於旅港開平,我曾到該校網址查看過,並非每年都有 7X%  students scored over 14 marks for the best six subjects in HKCEE.
即係想帶出衡量一間學校,並不能單看某年的會考成績。

畢竟,聖保羅書院和旅港開平,是兩間性質不同的學校。一間係歷史悠久的名校(男校、要比學費),另一間係地區受歡迎的英中(男女校、不用比學費),它們都各自有捧場客。

Rank: 2


59
發表於 09-10-19 01:45 |顯示全部帖子
再說在選校前,我曾經去過一些學校聽簡介會。旅港校長說話的態度,令人不太舒適,我一D都唔buy佢。(純個人感覺,請旅港家長見字勿插)

Rank: 2


59
發表於 09-10-19 01:55 |顯示全部帖子
我在中學概覽見到St.Paul Boys是直資校,但聽聞有人派位入到,是什麼回事?請指教。

學校有留位比St.Pau lBoys 小學(大約80個),自行考中西區(大約60個),最後有小量位比中西區大抽獎(即派位)

無論你點入,都要比3800學費
(低入息家庭可申請減免部份學費)

Rank: 2


59
發表於 09-10-19 01:57 |顯示全部帖子
更正:自行考無分區(大約60個)

Rank: 5Rank: 5


3610
發表於 09-10-19 09:10 |顯示全部帖子
原帖由 ching2009 於 09-10-15 22:41 發表
我和阿仔都鐘意聖保羅書院,
(校風純樸、校舍設備完善、老師友善、
學校知名度高、同學視野廣闊)

希望日後多些該校的家長上來談談!


ching2009,

Thank you for your sharing about SPC!  Is your kid from SPCPS?  

I do agree with your comments, esp. about 同學視野廣闊.  How about leadership?  I believe it is also important for a boy.


1972
發表於 09-10-19 17:17 |顯示全部帖子
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽

Rank: 4


719
發表於 09-10-19 17:59 |顯示全部帖子
我覺得旅港與聖保羅是兩間完全不同的學生校,一間是直資,另外聖保羅在香港區,學生的背景與旅港差好遠,至於成績,我覺得是睇你的孩子,如果他成績一路是好的,我相信去第三組別的學校一樣會好。
但我好肯定,聖保羅抑或旅港都一定有心去教好學生無論在品格及學業成績上。
有什麼好比呢?考慮的是你自己的意向及子女的成績。