用戶登入
用戶名稱:
密      碼:
搜索
教育王國 討論區 課外活動 考二級定一級鋼琴好?
發新帖
查看: 2332|回覆: 18
go

考二級定一級鋼琴好?

Rank: 5Rank: 5


1047
發表於 09-9-14 17:38 |顯示全部帖子
小兒4歲半讀K2,私人學琴已一年而我也有6級程度,現在用緊 John Tomson - First Grade and 輕鬆鋼琴2(almost finish)。 正想幫他報下年4,5月考琴。 跟老師商量過,一級應該冇問題但冇用,二級對小兒有難度,所以佢唔主張考。但為了明年考小學,我好想考一或二級。

考小學,一級是否作用不大? 還是試考二級好呢?

謝謝!

Rank: 1


25
發表於 09-9-14 18:35 |顯示全部帖子
原帖由 BigBoyMaMa 於 09-9-14 17:38 發表
小兒4歲半讀K2,私人學琴已一年而我也有6級程度,現在用緊 John Tomson - First Grade and 輕鬆鋼琴2(almost finish)。 正想幫他報下年4,5月考琴。 跟老師商量過,一級應該冇問題但冇用,二級對小兒有難度,所以佢唔主張考。但 ...


我的case和你一樣,囝囝學小提琴.我們決定明年考一級,因怕二級考不好會弄巧成拙.

Rank: 5Rank: 5


2663
發表於 09-9-14 19:45 |顯示全部帖子
除非令郎表現極高天份,贏硬校際,否則得個1-2級,無mud用。

Rank: 3Rank: 3


244
發表於 09-9-14 21:55 |顯示全部帖子
其實你考左1,2級對考小學真係無乜幫助, 不如比佢輕輕鬆鬆, 開開心心咁學吧

Rank: 5Rank: 5


1047
發表於 09-9-15 12:51 |顯示全部帖子
多謝各位意見!  我會再跟老師商量。我傾向考二級,但當12月也沒有點進步,那一,二級也不考了。

Rank: 5Rank: 5


3327
發表於 09-9-15 14:11 |顯示全部帖子
嚟近有校際音樂節, 不如幫佢報名, 試係參加, 有機會贏到幫助會大d.

Rank: 3Rank: 3


225
發表於 09-9-15 14:16 |顯示全部帖子
Participating in Music Festival competition will be a good exposure for him too.
EsmondMaMa = Esmond'sMom

Rank: 5Rank: 5


1047
發表於 09-9-15 14:39 |顯示全部帖子
謝謝G-Ma and EsmondMama 的意見!

相比皇家exam,如同是參加二級,Music Festival 是否較易預備 (因只須考一首)? 認受是也是一樣嗎? 大多數考小一的小朋友也會參加Music Festival 多過皇家試嗎 如是,我可能暫時不考皇家Grade 1 or Grade 2 exam,只參加 Music Festival,那樣也不會影響老師的安排,小兒也不會太辛苦。

Many thanks in advance!!!

原帖由 EsmondMaMa 於 09-9-15 14:16 發表
Participating in Music Festival competition will be a good exposure for him too.

Rank: 5Rank: 5


1047
發表於 09-9-15 18:06 |顯示全部帖子
Any knows?  Thanks!

原帖由 BigBoyMaMa 於 09-9-15 14:39 發表
謝謝G-Ma and EsmondMama 的意見!

相比皇家exam,如同是參加二級,Music Festival 是否較易預備 (因只須考一首)? 認受是也是一樣嗎? 大多數考小一的小朋友也會參加Music Festival 多過皇家試嗎 如是,我可能暫時不考皇家G ...

Rank: 4

醒目開學勳章


994
發表於 09-9-16 00:10 |顯示全部帖子
其實考級對考學校不是太大作用,相反比賽攞獎學校就鍾意得多,因為日後你讀果間學校,代表出賽,有機会為校增光!

如其只係考1,2級,倒不如參加比賽!

Rank: 5Rank: 5


3327
發表於 09-9-16 00:13 |顯示全部帖子
校際音樂節係一個比賽, 只係彈一首歌, 同考皇家試單對單考唔同, 相對我覺得壓力會大d, 而且要贏亦唔係咁易, 真係要perform得好好先得.

如果講認受性更係皇家試會好d, 但對於小學黎講, 如果個小朋友係比賽中有贏過, 加以培養將來又可以幫學校羅獎, 咁學校當然會加多d分.

Rank: 5Rank: 5


3211
發表於 09-9-16 07:35 |顯示全部帖子
看你小朋友 e+ ge 程度不是應該考一級嗎?  以前d老師係要學生學完果級就報果級而5係報下一級 ga 嘛 = 你讀ing P.1 mic 考P.1 試 lor.....e+5同晒.  你自己是學琴的應該更清楚.  abrsm 除3首歌外, 還要練 scale 呢....only pass 其實都5係 gum 有用.  打好底子學上去不是更好嗎?   

同意, 不如試吓玩校際.
原帖由 BigBoyMaMa 於 09-9-14 17:38 發表
小兒4歲半讀K2,私人學琴已一年而我也有6級程度,現在用緊 John Tomson - First Grade and 輕鬆鋼琴2(almost finish)。 正想幫他報下年4,5月考琴。 跟老師商量過,一級應該冇問題但冇用,二級對小兒有難度,所以佢唔主張考。但 ...

[ 本帖最後由 asinai 於 09-9-16 07:37 編輯 ]

Rank: 5Rank: 5


2663
發表於 09-9-16 09:35 |顯示全部帖子
不過,贏一級校際唔易架,好多參賽者已經唔只一級。

Rank: 5Rank: 5


3327
發表於 09-9-16 10:48 |顯示全部帖子
無錯, 好多係2-3級去賽一級, 有d年紀又會大d, 所以一d都唔易.

原帖由 小伊 於 09-9-16 09:35 發表
不過,贏一級校際唔易架,好多參賽者已經唔只一級。

Rank: 4


626
發表於 09-9-16 13:30 |顯示全部帖子
The issue is not grade 1 or 2 or HKSMA competition winning or not.... the main point should be, WHAT experience will make your son a "better" being ?

Any good school really ultimately look at the interview performance of your child. By exposing him to different experience, including performance, and preparation for an appropriate level of exam, or competition, the "journey" itself is ultimately what will benefit your child the most. Any experienced interviewer will see this when your child has gone through it. Not what grade is stated on your piano exam certificate, because if your child doesn't speak in there, or is really shy, and when asked how does he like playing piano.. he doesn't say anything, or shows negative feelings, then whatever grade level is still pointless.

Of course winning HKSMA would be a big bonus, shows your child has talent, however, I wouldn't hold my life plans for it.

Just try to let your child enjoy the journey of piano learning, and music appreciation, the benefits from it will far exceed what "grade" he took for an exam.

It's the journey of getting to the exam that counts, not the "ends" of completing the exam.

Good luck ! (Just my humble opinion).

Rank: 5Rank: 5


1047
發表於 09-9-16 14:51 |顯示全部帖子
Thank you for all of you to give me the valuable opinion especially Pianokc.  I don't think your opinion is humble, is fact, it help me to think deeply  how to plan the way for my son and what is the most important for the P1 application - Intervew performance instead of the cert.

After considered all of  your opinion, I decided not to  let my son to take exam next year, but I will try to enroll the Music Festival (grade 1).  Of course it is a bonus if he can win, otherwise, it can give a chance to perform in front of the public.

Anyway, thanks all of you to help me to make my decision.

bigboymama


原帖由 Pianokc 於 09-9-16 13:30 發表
The issue is not grade 1 or 2 or HKSMA competition winning or not.... the main point should be, WHAT experience will make your son a "better" being ?

Any good school really ultimately look at the in ...

Rank: 5Rank: 5


3327
發表於 09-9-17 14:44 |顯示全部帖子
good luck!!

Rank: 5Rank: 5


2528
發表於 09-9-17 14:58 |顯示全部帖子
其實一, 二級分別唔大, 我上年見有k3同學仔已係校際4級攞到第一, 咁呢張cert對考小學一定有幫助 !  (好似入埋女拔)

原帖由 BigBoyMaMa 於 09-9-15 12:51 發表
多謝各位意見!  我會再跟老師商量。我傾向考二級,但當12月也沒有點進步,那一,二級也不考了。

Rank: 5Rank: 5


2528
發表於 09-9-17 15:08 |顯示全部帖子
囝囝老師既囡囡8yr考了8級, 跟住攞scholoarship入演藝,  最後因piano成就而入了女拔. 不過呢d天份唔係係人都有.

原帖由 Pianokc 於 09-9-16 13:30 發表
The issue is not grade 1 or 2 or HKSMA competition winning or not.... the main point should be, WHAT experience will make your son a "better" being ?

Any good school really ultimately look at the in ...