12網小一選校

燕尾蝶

原帖由 mow-mow 於 09-7-31 15:17 發表
If you want to play safe, put Hennessy Road as your first choice (am 1st choice & pm 2nd choice should be safe enough but pm 1st choice would be ultra-safe!).
If you want to gamble, then put Wah Yan o ...

thanks a lot!

燕尾蝶

原帖由 臻媽 於 09-8-1 00:01 發表
基灣今年(09/10), 囝囝個師姐NET16, 1ST ROUND & 2ND ROUND 都選佢, 大抽獎時甲部選NET 14嘉諾撒,乙部選佢做第一, 都唔中, 叩門都失敗....所以跨區真係微乎其微, 仲加埋好多人都會因佢升BAND 1中學曾試過90%而選佢,  ...

臻媽.你對為0左個囝囝真你花了不少的心思.做了好多的資料搜集.佩服.亦都因為有你們的分享.才令我這些對選校毫無頭緒的媽咪不致於傍偟無幫助.tks!
另:可否分享一下對軒小的看法嗎?

charlotteling

如果得15分係本區大抽獎抽st Jospeh, 華仁, 機會大唔大 ??

hinhinmummy

原帖由 julihui 於 09-7-31 18:42 發表
Charlotte_mom,

我覺得您對 net 12 選校很有心得, 請問您意見, 老公家往cayseway bay, 但我們住在沙田,  如小朋友由沙田到
灣仔返學會很辛苦嗎,  我不知道有沒有保母車走這條線, 不知道值不值得, 不過我覺得灣仔區 ...

我日日甘沙田----->causeway 來回, 車程長, 我係大人都幸苦啦, 更何況係個小朋友

臻媽

機會微D, 其實只得15分, 於ROUND 1, 所有NET的熱門之選機會都好微, 況且以下兩間是不只屬NET 12的家長心水之選吧 !!! 而大抽獎是講彩數, 2選1放第一較安全, 第2選其他吧!!!  如想進取一點, 呢兩間選多位果間做第2, 少位果間做第1, 但真係好有機會派唔到, 所以第3必然唔可以係熱門之選的NET 12好學校吧....


燕尾蝶, 你太客氣, 我都只係同各位家長一樣, 想為子女作出適當的選擇吧!!! 況且我好多資料都係從BK所得, 而家只係將呢D資料+個人愚見同大家分享, 絕對唔係專業意見, 所以大家作參考時要自己再作分析+搜集資料吧!!!

大家不防多D交流吧...我而家只選了一所學校遞表, 以只有15分情況, ROUND 1 情況唔太樂觀, 所以都搜集緊更多的資料於ROUND 2時排位, 中到1ST 志願當然開心, 否則都希望可以入到2ND 或 3RD 志願吧!!!

原帖由 charlotteling 於 09-8-1 10:44 發表
如果得15分係本區大抽獎抽st Jospeh, 華仁, 機會大唔大 ??

[ 本帖最後由 臻媽 於 09-8-1 17:56 編輯 ]

lamlauanita

臻媽,

Thanks for your comments!  That mean only choice one of them Wah Yan or Hennessy (a.m) for the first choice, St James for the second choice and Precious Blood for the third choice.  Because Hennessy (p.m) is not my choice.  It my more safety.

brian61950

老老實實,15分男仔+小班+12網揀聖若瑟或華仁真係好難有機會,唯一好處係叩門時比校長睇首輪同首志都係揀佢間學校印象好啲姐.
不如博軒小啦,入到帶埋個妺嘛.

臻媽

我見愚見係.....由於軒下唔係你杯茶, 次選聖雅各定寶血, 視乎係男仔定女仔, 因寶血有直屬的寶血女子中學, 如女孩選此為次選更理想!!!而且若寶血放2nd, 中籤率應高於聖雅各吧!! 所以如你想選擇穩中求勝, 華小/軒上只選其一放第一, 寶血放第2, 咁中首2志願的率是非常高!!! 當然聖雅各放2nd, 寶血放3rd都可以, 但唔怕一萬最怕萬一, 有機會3甲不入!! 都係果句, 唔好盲目追求名校, 以孩子為本, 去選一間適合他的小學!! 今年9月選小的競爭因出生率上升應比舊年大, 舊年中籤率都只有8成多d, 要中首3志願,務必排位要保守d吧!!!     

原帖由 lamlauanita 於 09-8-1 20:44 發表
臻媽,

Thanks for your comments!  That mean only choice one of them Wah Yan or Hennessy (a.m) for the first choice, St James for the second choice and Precious Blood for the third choice.  Because He ...

臻媽

軒小係我目標之一, 因它係活動教學, 校風優良, 升中派位結果理想, 唔過份摧谷, 教職員都好友善, 對學生好開愛, 係net 12的名校, 但基於灣仔沒有位置起新校舍, 所以未來幾年都唔會轉全日, 而我要選擇全日制, 所以選了聖雅各吧!!

如對軒小有興趣, 不防睇睇有關它的學校報告(只有幾年前), 或對你有幫助吧!!!

http://www.edb.gov.hk/FileManager/TC/Content_4325/ep07-henrd_a.pdf

http://mail.hrgps.edu.hk/~amit/report/08-09/0809sclplans.pdf

原帖由 燕尾蝶 於 09-8-1 10:04 發表


臻媽.你對為0左個囝囝真你花了不少的心思.做了好多的資料搜集.佩服.亦都因為有你們的分享.才令我這些對選校毫無頭緒的媽咪不致於傍偟無幫助.tks!
另:可否分享一下對軒小的看法嗎? ...

mow-mow

This year 寶血女子中學 only kept 2 seats for their primary school because over the years, hardly any of the primary school kids apply to the secondary section (perhaps due to the distance - secondary school is in Chai Wan).
So although they are 直屬, you should perhaps treat them as separate entity!

原帖由 臻媽 於 09-8-2 02:37 發表
我見愚見係.....由於軒下唔係你杯茶, 次選聖雅各定寶血, 視乎係男仔定女仔, 因寶血有直屬的寶血女子中學, 如女孩選此為次選更理想!!!而且若寶血放2nd, 中籤率應高於聖雅各吧!! 所以如你想選擇穩中求勝, 華小/軒上只 ...

臻媽

咩直屬唔係 = 該中學可留8成半學位俾直屬小學咩???

原帖由 mow-mow 於 09-8-3 11:27 發表
This year 寶血女子中學 only kept 2 seats for their primary school because over the years, hardly any of the primary school kids apply to the secondary section (perhaps due to the distance - secondary  ...

mow-mow

Since hardly anybody from the primary school has ever applied to go there, the secondary section decided not to keep too many places for them.
I guess if you are from the primary section & you apply to go there, there shouldn't be a problem because there won't be any competition!
But most of your primary school friends will not be going there.

原帖由 臻媽 於 09-8-3 11:37 發表
咩直屬唔係 = 該中學可留8成半學位俾直屬小學咩???

臻媽

明白...THX!!! 寶血中學唔好嗎?? 想請教寶血小學的升中結果理想嗎??

原帖由 mow-mow 於 09-8-3 11:43 發表
Since hardly anybody from the primary school has ever applied to go there, the secondary section decided not to keep too many places for them.
I guess if you are from the primary section & you apply t ...

mow-mow

On the whole, 寶血小學的升中結果 are quite good.
Being in Causeway Bay net, there are plenty of good secondary schools to choose from.
That's why not many of them would want to travel to Chai Wan for the secondary school.
If the results are not good, I would expect more of them to go up to their own secondary section.

原帖由 臻媽 於 09-8-3 12:02 發表
明白...THX!!! 寶血中學唔好嗎?? 想請教寶血小學的升中結果理想嗎??

starmami

Dear mow-mow / 臻媽,
May I consult you if I am targeting St Francis Catholic, I have 20 points (since my girl is a Catholic) but I am not living at Net 12, how is the possibility?  

Would you please advise how I should rank at Round 1 and Round 2?

I can move to Net 12 indeed if it is too risky for me to 跨區.  Any advice?  Thanks

[ 本帖最後由 starmami 於 09-8-3 15:01 編輯 ]

lamlauanita

Dear mow-mow / 臻媽

As I said before my child is a son.  Which school would you put in the second and third choice that seems more safety? (my first choice is Wah Yan)

Thanks!

esmehouse

20 分入 St. Francis 應該冇問題，因為我有個朋友攞住 15 分都入到

原帖由 starmami 於 09-8-3 14:31 發表
Dear mow-mow / 臻媽,
May I consult you if I am targeting St Francis Catholic, I have 20 points (since my girl is a Catholic) but I am not living at Net 12, how is the possibility?  

Would you please  ...

mow-mow

Yes, 20 points for St Francis should have a very good chance in the 1st Round.
Whether it is a sure win, I cannot say.
But you should try it anyway.
And if you fail, you should move to Net 12 before the 2nd Round & put St Francis down as 1st choice in the 2nd Round.
You should have a very good chance of getting in as most girls in Net 12 will try for Marymount as 1st choice.

mow-mow

To be absolutely safe, I would put Hennessy Road Government School (PM section) as 2nd choice.
You could try AM section as 2nd choice then PM section as 3rd choice but I think there is a certain amount of risk as most people will probably be thinking of doing the same.

原帖由 lamlauanita 於 09-8-3 15:32 發表
Dear mow-mow / 臻媽

As I said before my child is a son.  Which school would you put in the second and third choice that seems more safety? (my first choice is Wah Yan)

Thanks!

starmami

Thanks esmehouse and mow-mow for your kind advice.

If I move to Net 12, how I should rank the rest of choices at both round 1&2?  Can you advise further?

Sorry for so many questions since I don't know the schools very well.  In my concept, I know St. Paul's Catholic, Henessy AM/PM are also good schools.  (I understand Marymount is at high risk, I will not choose it indeed).