ST Catherine 對兒童照顧不足

Minniechung

今年我女女將會九月讀K1,  我朋友同我講,  佢個仔仔係ST CAT 已讀左一年,  今年升K2.  佢叫我CONSIDER 清楚讀唔讀,  甘我就問佢乜野事啦.   佢話,  佢個仔O係學校校跌過幾次,  番到屋企先發現個頭受傷,  問過班主任.  佢竟然發現唔到,  答我朋友話留意唔到, 不過下次會留意番.  

第二次,  一個小組活動,  一個老師睇住十幾個學生.   佢個仔離開班房時,  已著錯鞋,  因著得好導致成日跌,  亦無老師發現.  搭校車媽咪接先發現.  

我覺得哩D過失唔應該羅.   有D學校對家長既投訴都好緊張的, 但ST CAT 就好懶懶閒.   甘樣係咪好有問題呢.  我都有D擔心.

kerkermui

thanks for your information..
真係好唔細心喎!

仔仔錫錫你

好多幼稚園經常都有呢d情況出現, 你朋友小見多怪姐, 而且呢d係同幼稚園無咩關係, 只係老師唔夠細心.

另外, 跌親無流血係好難即時發現, 通常要一段時間"於"血先會浮出來, 所以老師發現唔到亦係正常.

clarasun

I don't know how to type  in chinese, and my english is not that good, I try my best to express what I want to say...

I pass st. cat this afternoon around 3:15, I saw about more than 10 little child sit on a little chair just outside the school which is beside of driveway. and I saw just only one teacher to take care them. I'm driving at that time. When I see it, I feel scare and slow down the car. I think if just one of that child is naughty and walk or run few step, they will fall on the driveway. it's quite dangerous.

i'm wondering are the child waiting their parent to pick them up or they are attending class?

bbirene

I also saw them, they were drawing might be drawing the cars.  But I also think that it's too dangerous.

Yanamami

They were counting different vehicles that passed the Kindergarten.  Learning statistics.  They have been doing the same thing many years ago.  I think they fulfill the Educational Dept. requirement of 1 teacher to 10 students ratio.

原帖由 clarasun 於 09-5-13 00:02 發表
I don't know how to type  in chinese, and my english is not that good, I try my best to express what I want to say...

I pass st. cat this afternoon around 3:15, I saw about more than 10 little child  ...

Minniechung

我諗亦係老師方面既問題.  唔關學校事.    但個老師同我朋友講話留意唔到,   我女女讀緊維記,  佢一跌倒學校就即刻打電話俾我,  仲緊張過我,  ST CAT 都係有名學校.  我覺得除左學術要教得好外.   都要留意下小朋友.

HebeMama630

我個小朋友响荃灣讀緊N,每次佢跌親,事後有冇明顯傷痕都會話我知嫁!

Minniechung

原帖由 HebeMama630 於 09-5-13 23:57 發表
我個小朋友响荃灣讀緊N,每次佢跌親,事後有冇明顯傷痕都會話我知嫁!

我個重點就係一D唔太出名既KINDER,  學校都會即時通知父母.  我係度提出哩個題目,  係想讀ST CAT 媽咪留意下哩方面,  亦俾學校有少少壓力.

howo

Agree, 除左學術要教得好外.   都要留意下小朋友

原帖由 Minniechung 於 09-5-13 19:04 發表
我諗亦係老師方面既問題.  唔關學校事.    但個老師同我朋友講話留意唔到,   我女女讀緊維記,  佢一跌倒學校就即刻打電話俾我,  仲緊張過我,  ST CAT 都係有名學校.  我覺得除左學術要教得好外.   都要留意下小朋友. ...

jk923

原帖由 Yanamami 於 09-5-13 09:32 發表
They were counting different vehicles that passed the Kindergarten.  Learning statistics.  They have been doing the same thing many years ago.  I think they fulfill the Educational Dept. requirement of 1 teacher to 10 students ratio.

出到校門外個比率就唔同，要多一個成人先得，就算係嬸嬸都要。

beetoy

Minnie,

My daughter also going to St. Cat this Sept for K1. To be honest my expectation is very low for this school regarding giving individual attention to kids. My perception is that this is a big famous factory producing lots of good (academic) products every year to good primary schools. Nevertheless as parents we should keep the bar high and keep the pressure up for the school in terms of our expectation to them. We must do it collectively, as individual effort is not strong enough.

I wonder if there are PTA at St. Cat? Do want to be a member of these groups in order to voice out these concerns.

On contrary, other types of schools like Victoria really pay attention to each individual's development and safety..

Minniechung

原帖由 beetoy 於 09-5-15 17:14 發表
Minnie,

My daughter also going to St. Cat this Sept for K1. To be honest my expectation is very low for this school regarding giving individual attention to kids. My perception is that this is a big  ...

BEETOY,  

其實我都好擔心照顧既問題.  訓練小朋友有一定的獨立和自理能力係好的,  太過照顧和保護唔係一件好事.  但做為父母的.  最唔想係小朋友O係學校受左傷, 而無第一時間知道或老師不知情的情形發生.    ST CAT 唯一我想要的, 係佢派小學好.  跟得上傳統的小學.   不過,  我都會俾佢讀住先.  如果今年開學不久有甘既情況發生,  我就會俾壓力學,  但其他父母商議.   所以今次係到俾大家父母做個REF,  & 留意.

仲有一件事,  近排既豬流感. 各地方及學校都會做定好多措施, 但我朋友話,  佢同班主任講左好多次,  痳煩老師幫佢個仔帶上MASK.  個老師都無做到.  洗手方面亦唔係好多.  哩方我都只係聽我朋友講, 我無親眼見到,  所以都不能全信.

希望各位家長KEEP 住 聯絡

Mqchris

我有個朋友都係今年讀k1--st.cat...同樣，覺我照顧不週... 跌倒無老師打電話來報告，這也算了..但連小朋友情緒唔好，唔適應、都無老師理...
不過, 學大家話頭，老牌名校...無計，咪照讀囉...當然，佢又真係谷到小朋友、學到野，適應到的就開開心心囉...

但我個人認為名校重左力谷，大工作量，要協調，咪令到老師無心思及時間再去應乎個別小朋友的需要囉... 大家想，假若入去的小朋友是有特別學習需要的，那點呢...自生自滅..?? 學術vs照顧..真的值得家長自己心思的問題

[ 本帖最後由 Mqchris 於 09-5-15 20:02 編輯 ]

hongchung

原帖由 Yanamami 於 09-5-13 09:32 發表
They were counting different vehicles that passed the Kindergarten.  Learning statistics.  They have been doing the same thing many years ago.  I think they fulfill the Educational Dept. requirement o ...

咁的學校都有，幾歲大坐在街邊食塵數車？？？學統計？當時空氣污染指數是幾多？坐在馬路邊數車對幾歲大的幼稚園生好嗎？
你証明年年做即是佢學校唔改善，年年去食塵，吸毒氣，不知進取，每年因循做乜就做乜。點解無家長投訴校方的？正如上面有版友話，校外一個老師帶著10個幾歲大的細路，有個細路見到自己喜歡的貨櫃車而突然衝出馬路如何？

[ 本帖最後由 hongchung 於 09-5-15 21:08 編輯 ]

hongchung

原帖由 Mqchris 於 09-5-15 20:01 發表 我有個朋友都係今年讀k1--st.cat...同樣，覺我照顧不週... 跌倒無老師打電話來報告，這也算了..但連小朋友情緒唔好，唔適應、都無老師理...
不過, 學大家話頭，老牌名校...無計，咪照讀囉...當然，佢又真係谷到小朋友、學到野，適應到的就開開心心囉...

但我個人認為名校重左力谷，大工作量，要協調，咪令到老師無心思及時間再去應乎個別小朋友的需要囉... 大家想，假若入去的小朋友是有特別學習需要的，那點呢...自生自滅..?? 學術vs照顧..真的值得家長自己心思的問題

請問St. Cat 有乜學術見得人？好過人？
有乜幼稚園學界學術上佢學校得獎？佢學校演說？佢校長有演講？

Minniechung

原帖由 hongchung 於 09-5-15 21:12 發表



請問St. Cat 有乜學術見得人？好過人？
有乜幼稚園學界學術上佢學校得獎？佢學校演說？佢校長有演講？

其實我都唔知架.  學校有乜學術好,  只係有朋友和親戚D仔女讀過話好,  好的係小朋友自立,  唔依賴, 名小學鍾意ST CAT 的學生等等.   不過,  我都會照俾女女讀.  開頭開學一個月我會番學校觀察下教師和學生學習既情況.