Eastern District, please pls comment !

MinnieMum

Dear all esteemed parents,

小女是東區band1 (top 5 in the form), 自行 has applied BPS. Please kindly help me 分析 the following order.

(1)  BPS
(2)  中國婦女會
(3)  嘉諾撒
(4)  民生

Any chance to go to one of the first 3 choices?
會不會太搏 ?  



Or should exchange no. (2) and no. (3), If put 嘉諾撒 on 2nd, 是否保守?  A very big headache!

請大家幫助給予意見,萬分謝謝   Khmama, also appreciate your great comments.

tse530

i recommend you can be:

(1)  BPS

(2)  嘉諾撒
(3)  民生

MinnieMum

非常感謝意見.

原帖由 tse530 於 09-4-30 12:15 發表
i recommend you can be:

(1)  BPS
(2)  嘉諾撒
(3)  民生

Q蝦毛joba

For Eastern District, the ratio for allocated to an EMI is 6:1, that means only half of the band 1 students can allocate to an EMI, so, if you have failed in the 1st choice, it's meaningless to put another EMI in 2nd, 3rd and so on.

ksnghk

I think putting 民生 as the third choice has little chance.  For the six Band 1 EMI, they will be filled (or very little places remaining) after the 1st choice.  So I think only those put 民生 as 2nd choice or above has the chance.  Remember some of the band 1 students may even put 民生 as the first choice to ensure entrance.

But for you case, you may take this risk, as your girl got good results, so most probably she has already got BPS discretionary place.

原帖由 MinnieMum 於 09-4-30 12:12 發表
Dear all esteemed parents,



小女是東區band1 (top 5 in the form), 自行 has applied BPS. Please kindly help me 分析 the following order.

(1)  BPS
(2)  中國婦女會
(3)  嘉諾撒
(4)  民生

Any chance to  ...

[ 本帖最後由 ksnghk 於 09-4-30 13:02 編輯 ]

tse530

原帖由 ksnghk 於 09-4-30 13:00 發表
I think putting 民生 as the third choice has little chance.  For the six Band 1 EMI, they will be filled (or very little places remaining) after the 1st choice.  So I think only those put 民生 as 2nd  ...

i agree with you, if the girl has good interview result for BPS, the parent can take the risk.

But one thing need to be ensure, whether the banding is confirmed and do your daughter has any talent on sport or music which can add mark for First round intake!

Also, MinnieMum, please check PM for further discussion

MinnieMum

Q蝦毛joba, 非常多謝你的資料,感謝.

MinnieMum

ksnghk, 萬分感謝你的意見, although my daugher said she performed well in the interview, there is really strong competition to enter BPS!!

tse530, thanks again for your inputs.  感謝萬分.

bubblex2

原帖由 tse530 於 09-4-30 12:15 發表
i recommend you can be:

(1)  BPS

(2)  嘉諾撒
(3)  民生

同意..:loveliness:

樓主個小朋友係top 5,
話唔定interview時都巳經收左..
如果放民生第二..
雖然比較穩鎮..
但入左的話..
樓主會甘心嗎?

btw, 朋友女兒讀緊..
佢話BPS都幾睇重音樂架..

tse530

無論 BPS or 嘉諾撒 都係好學校
好學校=>功課壓力愈大

LittleKidult

其實係大抽獎時已經唔會理你考第1定考第80, 只要係band1就一齊抽, 所以係睇好唔好運.
至於自行時top5會唔會已經收左....記住自行時係全港不分地區, 唔係剩係你本區先會報BPS, 你要諗下自行時會有幾多過江龍黎爭? 我想講既係如果係好top既英中, 剩考第5未必夠....

MinnieMum

bubbles2, 感謝萬分你的意見 & valuable input. You just quoted what I wanted to say!  

LittleKidult, yr comments are well noted & thanks for sharing.  

原帖由 bubblex2 於 09-4-30 14:45 發表
同意..:loveliness:
樓主個小朋友係top 5,
話唔定interview時都巳經收左..
如果放民生第二..
雖然比較穩鎮..
但入左的話..
樓主會甘心嗎?
btw, 朋友女兒讀緊..
佢話BPS都幾睇重音樂架.. ...

CuteCuteMa

Dear MinnieMum,

可否說說你女兒是東區的那所小學.  若你女兒小學的banding 高, 不妨進取d,

ksnghk

同意，但這情況只是在自行跟第一志願（即隨機號碼亦不理想）皆落空時才會入民生，若是這樣選Band 1 中中的民生無疑比選Band 1 英中穩陣。注意首志願落選代表隨機號碼非前列的號碼。

原帖由 bubblex2 於 09-4-30 14:45 發表


同意..:loveliness:

樓主個小朋友係top 5,
話唔定interview時都巳經收左..
如果放民生第二..
雖然比較穩鎮..
但入左的話..
樓主會甘心嗎?

btw, 朋友女兒讀緊..
佢話BPS都幾睇重音樂架.. ...

bubblex2

原帖由 ksnghk 於 09-4-30 21:56 發表
同意，但這情況只是在自行跟第一志願（即隨機號碼亦不理想）皆落空時才會入民生，若是這樣選Band 1 中中的民生無疑比選Band 1 英中穩陣。注意首志願落選代表隨機號碼非前列的號碼。

...

明白,
正所謂有得必有失..
所以"博"之餘要諗定後路..
諗定最壞打算會係點..
有家長教落不妨報定"直資"做保險才去博..

若然真係好担心的話..
咪將民生放第二..
真的會隱陣啲..

但話番轉頭..
入左又怕唔甘心喎..
真係好難決定..

我咁睇..
"博" ~ 可能得, 可能唔得, 甚至更差..結果要自己承擔架..
但"唔博" ~ 就一定無機會..

樓主你考慮清楚吧!
自己是進取型還是穩陣型啦..
:loveliness: :loveliness:

btw,
我自己都未填表..
祝大家好運啦..
:loveliness: :loveliness:

mp3

真係煩到死!

我係保守派, 考慮緊:
1.張祝珊 or 婦女會
2.民生 or 金文泰

老師就 suggest:
1.張祝珊 or 婦女會  
2.嘉諾撒 or 聖馬可
3.民生 or 金文泰
老師重話係較保守既意見tim.

davidmimi

呢個post對東區分析得很透徹.

原帖由 wahyanpooh 於 08-8-28 11:14 發表
將東區Band 1學校分類：
極想入：庇理羅士  張祝珊  中國婦女會
可以入：嘉諾撒  筲官  聖馬可
免強入：中華基金  民生  金文泰

Band 1學生的男女比例係1:2，但細分下是：(大約啦)
Band 1頭  女3：男1
Band 1中  女2：男1
Band 1尾  女1：男1

Band 1頭女生選校傾向：
自選1st & 統一1st：庇理羅士
Band 1中女生選校傾向：
自選 2nd：嘉諾撒  統一1st：庇理羅士
Band 1尾女生選校傾向：
自選1st & 統一1st：嘉諾撒

因而估計，在可選擇的9間學校中，兩間女校競爭是最大的。

同時，張祝珊、中國婦女會只屬地區名校，而庇理羅士則屬傳統名校，兩者分別是前者只吸納到同區學生，而後者則會吸納他區學生慕名而來。

相比下，東區小學普遍不及他區名小/英小，估計庇理羅士40-50%的自選學額，會被他區(軒尼詩官立、聖心等)的女生搶走。

**上述只屬個人意見，請家長們用心分析！

tse530

張祝珊屬全港名校
地位與庇理羅士同等(奪a數字)

庇理羅士名氣較大

bubblex2

原帖由 davidmimi 於 09-5-2 16:26 發表
呢個post對東區分析得很透徹.

wahyanpooh真的很不錯..:loveliness: :loveliness:

唉!
當時明明仲PM緊佢,
佢又答緊我野..
但...答答吓..
佢就比人激走左喇..

davidmimi

原帖由 tse530 於 09-5-2 17:56 發表
張祝珊屬全港名校
地位與庇理羅士同等(奪a數字)

庇理羅士名氣較大

單計成績,張祝珊可能較庇理羅士還要好.

但"女校"是很多家長的心頭好,應該係庇理羅士多人揀d.