一日之內學英文及普通話, 有無影響?

yancw

對於一個4歲半的小朋友, 如果一日之內學英文及普通話, 兩者之間只有15mins休息, 對佢學習會唔會有混淆? 請給些意見.

joyjoyma

平日or周末? 如果平日,又要返學....分開唔同日學唔同嘢好d.

小鹿斑比

未必會混淆，但個腦應該好倦，我囡囡細個果時學，我有一小時比佢休息(中午食飯)，食完飯行一陣再俾佢上堂。

原帖由 yancw 於 09-1-3 11:02 發表
對於一個4歲半的小朋友, 如果一日之內學英文及普通話, 兩者之間只有15mins休息, 對佢學習會唔會有混淆? 請給些意見.

jennytms

我諗應該唔會, 我囝囝亦是同一日學普通話班及英文班, 但就中間有一小時的休息. 另同一日就學鋼琴及繪畫班, 中間亦只是有15分鐘休息. 因以本人意見, 不想分太多日的興趣班給他, 這樣他只是辛苦兩日.

原帖由 小鹿斑比 於 09-1-4 14:04 發表
未必會混淆，但個腦應該好倦，我囡囡細個果時學，我有一小時比佢休息(中午食飯)，食完飯行一陣再俾佢上堂。

winchoy16888

其實問吓小朋友意見好Ｄ﹕佢不太倦就冇所謂啦

delimama

i think even for adult, it's tough to have phonics course and putonghua class one after the other. It's because the same set of alphabets produces 2 very different sets of sounds.

For example:
In English, we all know the sound of "you". But in Putonghua, "you" is 有 and 友; and the sound is very different from the one in English.

In English, "ran" is the past tense of run. But Putonghua "ran" in the 2nd tone is 然後的 "然".  Of course the sounds are very different.

In English, "re" is a prefix e.g. repeat, review, remove. In Putonghua, "re" is 熱 in the 4th tone... so as the sounds are different.

As the sounds of the vowels and the consonants in English are very different from 普通話的聲母及韻母, 但他們卻以同樣的英文字母代表; therefore, 個人覺得孩子們會較易混淆. 故可考慮k3 to p1學phonics, 有了根基後再接觸普通話拼音... just a thought to share...

Cheers,
delimama

cecichan

學不同的語言我建議分開兩日學, 因為有不同的發音要記, 如同一日小朋友吸收會比較慢, 有可能會亂.

cecichan

本人囝囝在k2 開始學phonics , 同普通話的聲母及韻母, 是分開兩日的, 他進展得很好, 沒有混淆, 現在已k3了沒有問題. 所以本人建議可分開不同日子學.