統計---小學應否將考試或評估排名次?

ykwong

Wunma:

I know you have two kids, one is being F 1 this year, can you tell what I ask Rosaline?

ykwong

Thanks wunma, you always provide information even sometime we have different opinion.

That's what I concern, the abilities test only test for 3 main subject swhile the ranking in school counts  all subjects.

As I know, the EMB will use a similar evaluation method to decide students' banding at 07/08 term. Only the different is, the old test was done by the 學兄 while the new one will be done by the 學弟.

肥仔媽咪

A. 反對作任何形式之排名次,更反對公開
B. 贊成公佈每班及每級之所有排名次
C. 只贊成公佈每班之首10-20名(以不超出一半人數作上限)
D. 只贊成公佈每班之首10-20名及每級之首20-40名
E. 只贊成按科目公佈每班或每級之首10-20名
F. 其他 (請註明)[按成績分上/中/下 3組,只公開所屬組別]

--------------------------------------------------------
A (0) :
B (5) : rr; Zoey; illias; hhma;ballpen; 肥仔媽咪
C (2) : PinPin; Hanhanma
D (3) : Rosaline; stccmc; Mimi_Ma
E (2) : collin; So;Teresa
F (2) : yk; qio;

hhma

wunma
唔緊要啦, 人生係充滿無奈架ma

WongWong

[quote]
illias 寫道:
[quote]
qio 寫道:
今晚,小女幼稚園之舊同學聚餐,聊起許多小學將考試或評估排名次,大家意見紛紜,極之分岐!

不知各位對此有何高見?
不如粗略概分如下,作一個簡單之統計:

A. 反對作任何形式之排名次,更反對公開
B. 贊成公佈每班及每級之所有排名次
C. 只贊成公佈每班之首10-20名(以不超出一半人數作上限)
D. 只贊成公佈每班之首10-20名及每級之首20-40名
E. 只贊成按科目公佈每班或每級之首10-20名
F. 其他 (請註明)

--------------------------------------------------------
1. collin: E
2. ykwong:F
3. PinPin:C
4. rr: B
5. Rosaline:D
6. Hanhanma :C
7. Zoey: B
8. stccmc: D
9. qio:F
10.illias: B
11.wongwong: D

Collin

[size=large]整理：

A. 反對作任何形式之排名次,更反對公開
B. 贊成公佈每班及每級之所有排名次
C. 只贊成公佈每班之首10-20名(以不超出一半人數作上限)
D. 只贊成公佈每班之首10-20名及每級之首20-40名
E. 只贊成按科目公佈每班或每級之首10-20名
F. 其他1 (請註明)[按成績分上/中/下 3組,只公開所屬組別]
G. 其他2(請註明)[每科列出分數,在旁附以該科之全級總平均]

--------------------------------------------------------
A (0) :
B (5) : rr; Zoey; illias; hhma;ballpen; 肥仔媽咪
C (2) : PinPin; Hanhanma
D (4) : Rosaline; stccmc; Mimi_Ma,wongwong
E (3) : collin; So;Teresa
F (2) : yk; qio;
G(1) : wunma

rr

Hi all mummy,

So far I see the result that more mummy 贊成公佈每班及每級之所有排名次.  I would like to ask one silly question.

各位媽媽要求小學子女達到幾多分先滿意呢? 我好想知自己係咪過高要求? 或不入流?  

我要求小一成績表4主科 chin. Eng. Maths and 常識 - 每科要有90分以上. 係咪過分呢?

想在此作小小的統計. 請赐教!

rr

ballpen

我雖然讚成公怖名次同分數,但我唔會太執著,我只會著意我小朋友係唔係已盡了力,如果因為唔夠勤力已得到唔理想嘅成績,咁我就會鞭策吓佢,勸介吓佢,如想要好成績,下次就要加倍努力,而且同佢講,佢係有能力做好啲的,但如果發現佢已盡了力,但成績都係一般,咁就要同小朋友一起探討,為可佢只能拿這樣的成績,盡力去幫助佢,絕唔會打擊佢嘅自信心.

其實要知道名次嘅目的,係想知道自己嘅小朋友係'還需努力'嗰隻丫,定係'保持水準,繼續努力,更上一層樓'嗰隻啫.

ykwong

rr:

marks are really unimportant, my sons got 96 in maths, but he was classified as C in this subject. What is C? it means that in that subject, his performance laid at the middle stream when compare with all others. (total five grade)

Am I satisfied? yes to 96 but no in C. 96 doesn't make you band one but A will. So ranking (in school, and the school in the society) is the main point, not the marks. And different school has different degree. You got 100 in A school may still be ranked in band 3. while in B school, you may got 80 but still in the range of band one.

gigi2

I vote for option E of subjects classification but top 10 of each class whilst top 20 of each level at
primary school.

ballpen

其實小朋友是否已努力,我諗身為父母無咩理由會唔知,如果有幸自己個小朋友可以去到科科一百分,又考第一,咁都不可自滿,應該要繼續不斷努力,去增加課本以外嘅知識,不斷開發小朋友嘅潛能,正所謂學無止境,唔好話父母貪得無厭,其實小朋友學到嘅嘢,就係佢將來嘅財富,當然學習都需要技巧啦,如果唔係,好容易就會變為讀死書,書呆子了.

千其唔好覺得盡力就係壓力,我覺得每個人都應該'盡自己嘅努力'去學習,不斷求上進,咁先至不枉此生,人生跟本就係活在學習之中.

ballpen

整理：

A. 反對作任何形式之排名次,更反對公開
B. 贊成公佈每班及每級之所有排名次
C. 只贊成公佈每班之首10-20名(以不超出一半人數作上限)
D. 只贊成公佈每班之首10-20名及每級之首20-40名
E. 只贊成按科目公佈每班或每級之首10-20名
F. 其他1 (請註明)[按成績分上/中/下 3組,只公開所屬組別]
G. 其他2(請註明)[每科列出分數,在旁附以該科之全級總平均]

--------------------------------------------------------
A (0) :
B (6) : rr; Zoey; illias; hhma;ballpen; 肥仔媽咪
C (2) : PinPin; Hanhanma
D (4) : Rosaline; stccmc; Mimi_Ma,wongwong
E (4) : collin; So;Teresa; gigi2
F (2) : yk; qio;
G(1) : wunma

timtim-mame

A. 反對作任何形式之排名次,更反對公開
B. 贊成公佈每班及每級之所有排名次
C. 只贊成公佈每班之首10-20名(以不超出一半人數作上限)
D. 只贊成公佈每班之首10-20名及每級之首20-40名
E. 只贊成按科目公佈每班或每級之首10-20名
F. 其他1 (請註明)[按成績分上/中/下 3組,只公開所屬組別]
G. 其他2(請註明)[每科列出分數,在旁附以該科之全級總平均]

--------------------------------------------------------
A (1) : timtim-mame
B (6) : rr; Zoey; illias; hhma;ballpen; 肥仔媽咪
C (2) : PinPin; Hanhanma
D (4) : Rosaline; stccmc; Mimi_Ma,wongwong
E (4) : collin; So;Teresa; gigi2
F (2) : yk; qio;
G(1) : wunma



名次像錦上添花，無論點形式公佈都會做成大部份小朋友對自我評價有負面影嚮