用戶登入
用戶名稱:
密      碼:
搜索
教育王國 討論區 課外活動 請教租琴問題
發新帖
查看: 2579|回覆: 12
go

請教租琴問題

Rank: 4


673
發表於 07-10-18 11:26 |顯示全部帖子
請問有無人試過係通利租琴?可否分經驗?

另外若果只係租幾年,大陸(Richmann/Pearl River)定韓國(Ottostein/Samick)琴適合啲?

Rank: 5Rank: 5

醒目開學勳章


1771
發表於 07-10-18 14:25 |顯示全部帖子
若果諗住租幾年, 不如買仲化算, 大陸琴平的都唔使一萬就有.

原文章由 samer 於 07-10-18 11:26 硐表
請問有無人試過係通利租琴?可否分經驗?

另外若果只係租幾年,大陸(Richmann/Pearl River)定韓國(Ottostein/Samick)琴適合啲?

Rank: 3Rank: 3


262
發表於 07-10-18 14:46 |顯示全部帖子
我都覺得如果租超過兩年以上, 不如買部二手 around 3-4k  Ottostein or 全新的

原文章由 samer 於 07-10-18 11:26 硐表
請問有無人試過係通利租琴?可否分經驗?

另外若果只係租幾年,大陸(Richmann/Pearl River)定韓國(Ottostein/Samick)琴適合啲?

Rank: 5Rank: 5


2839
發表於 07-10-18 16:39 |顯示全部帖子

但是在大的琴倉租琴 - 只$250- 350/月, 已可是 YAMAHA (二手), 那化算嗎? 信得過嗎?

Rank: 5Rank: 5


3211
發表於 07-10-18 19:58 |顯示全部帖子
如果$250一個月,一年就$3,000,兩年就$6,000,三年就$9,000,不如買部全新大陸琴,都係$10,000唔駛,用完三年賣返出來都仲可以執返多少,計落買新琴抵D喎!
而且琴倉我覺得信唔過,除非你自己好熟琴,唔係俾人呃左都唔知!

原文章由 mrsanthony 於 07-10-18 16:39 硐表

但是在大的琴倉租琴 - 只$250- 350/月, 已可是 YAMAHA (二手), 那化算嗎? 信得過嗎?

Rank: 4


626
發表於 07-10-18 23:41 |顯示全部帖子
As a Canadian piano teacher of over 17 years, this is my opinion on "renting" pianos in HK. (Sorry ,I can only read chinese, cannot type or write)

1) Renting pianos in HK- typically, the good condition pianos will NOT be rented to private homes. Most of them are pretty bad shape. It's really quite bad to have a beginner student to have to learn from these type of pianos. Unless you are renting for play for leisure as an experienced adult pianist.

2) Ottostein, Samick, and Pearl River- STAY away from these pianos. The acoustics, and action and response of the piano keys and sounds are really quite terrible from my professional opinion. In some ways, I had a bias against Parson's Toyama, however, recently, I tried one out for fun, I think Toyama is even better than the three previously mentioned.

3) I recommend my students and parents who don't want to invest in an expensive piano because they are not sure whether their child is really going to learn the piano seriously, or just simply do not have the budget. Either way, getting a REALLY nice Used piano is good idea. I had a student who bought a really nice Kawai for $ 12 000.00 HKD. It's 20 years old, but you cannot tell it's that old. Everything is good about the piano. It's within her budget, and in 3-4 years, when she wants to upgrade to a new piano or a better one, the used one here will NOT be worthless. It will be at least $ 7000.00-$ 8000.00HKD because it is nevertheless  kawai (or Yamaha).....

Just my opinion.



原文章由 samer 於 07-10-18 11:26 硐表
請問有無人試過係通利租琴?可否分經驗?

另外若果只係租幾年,大陸(Richmann/Pearl River)定韓國(Ottostein/Samick)琴適合啲?

Rank: 5Rank: 5


3898
發表於 07-10-19 22:39 |顯示全部帖子
聽講 tomlee 租琴 d 租金 可用番o黎買琴 ??...

原文章由 samer 於 07-10-18 11:26 硐表
請問有無人試過係通利租琴?可否分經驗?

另外若果只係租幾年,大陸(Richmann/Pearl River)定韓國(Ottostein/Samick)琴適合啲?

Rank: 5Rank: 5


3898
發表於 07-10-19 22:51 |顯示全部帖子
pianokc,

請問 我 完全 唔識音樂 & 彈琴...是否 只睇 牌子 kawai or Yamaha 買 就 ok... ??

成 20年 都無問題嗎 ??... 如果保養得唔好, 或 無tune 琴.... 是否一樣 無問題呢 ??...

如2手 應去 琴倉 or 琴行 買呢 ??...


Thanks a lot ...

Rank: 4


626
發表於 07-10-21 01:42 |顯示全部帖子
Please check your messages.

Rank: 5Rank: 5


2839
發表於 07-10-22 10:50 |顯示全部帖子

Rent OR Buy

Dear Pianokc,

Thanks a lot for the sound advice. Would you pls give us more tips about the topic?

It is difficult to find a second hand Kawai or Yamaha piano. (exp in such good price - $12K)

I saw some piano factory/shop claiming that they sell Kawai or Yamaha old piano. Nevertheless, many of their parts were changed. How can we (as a layman in the field) choose?



原文章由 Pianokc 於 07-10-18 23:41 硐表
... getting a REALLY nice Used piano is good idea. I had a student who bought a really nice Kawai for $ 12 000.00 HKD. It's 20 years old, but you cannot tell it's that old. Everything is good about the piano. It's within her budget, and in 3-4 years, when she wants to upgrade to a new piano or a better one, the used one here will NOT be worthless. It will be at least $ 7000.00-$ 8000.00HKD because it is nevertheless  kawai (or Yamaha).....

Rank: 4


980
發表於 07-10-22 12:29 |顯示全部帖子
Hello pianokc

we also not familar with piano, which model of kawai / yamaha you will recomend for a beginner for buy or rent ?  and where can we find such good piano (good price & good condition)?  what will be the price range ?
原文章由 mmak 於 07-10-19 22:51 硐表
pianokc,

請問 我 完全 唔識音樂 & 彈琴...是否 只睇 牌子 kawai or Yamaha 買 就 ok... ??

成 20年 都無問題嗎 ??... 如果保養得唔好, 或 無tune 琴.... 是否一樣 無問題呢 ??...

如2手 應去 琴倉 or 琴行 買呢  ...

Rank: 4


673
發表於 07-10-24 18:05 |顯示全部帖子
其實都有考慮過買,但覺得租好似比較flexible.  買二手我又唔識揀,萬一買咗先知有問題,就要自己bear loss.  買平啲嘅新琴,計過最少要用多過三年先叫做抵過租,但租琴就可以隨時改變主意。

通利價錢一定貴過琴倉,但諗住大公司可靠啲,退返嗰時唔會亂屈我按金,尤其我唔諗住幫襯琴倉買琴,所以想打聽吓關於通利租琴嘅口卑。

Rank: 8Rank: 8

醒目開學勳章


15757
發表於 08-4-11 16:21 |顯示全部帖子
原文章由 samer 於 07-10-24 18:05 發表
其實都有考慮過買,但覺得租好似比較flexible.  買二手我又唔識揀,萬一買咗先知有問題,就要自己bear loss.  買平啲嘅新琴,計過最少要用多過三年先叫做抵過租,但租琴就可以隨時改變主意。

通利價錢一定貴過琴倉,但諗住大公 ...


有無人試過0係通利租琴 ?