優才和SFA，大家會點選擇呀？

huicheukbb

小朋友係仔仔，優才和SFA也收了，真心求意見，謝謝！

enidchiu

bubuG 發表於 14-11-23 01:33
Ek有人引述GT話自己不是活動教學喎。係學生多D活動咋喎。

我都覺，可能在香港生存要面對現實。

bubuG

原帖由 enidchiu 於 14-11-23 發表
莫講話六歲，兩三歲也應培養坐定定專心看書，幼稚園一有功課，也應坐定定做功課和温習，這是基本的學習態度 ...

Ek有人引述GT話自己不是活動教學喎。係學生多D活動咋喎。

enidchiu

bubuG 發表於 14-11-22 04:40
我想指出的是SFA課程需要一個六歲小一學生已經肯坐定定做功課和溫習，又能夠有能力handle 比較深課程。SFA ...

莫講話六歲，兩三歲也應培養坐定定專心看書，幼稚園一有功課，也應坐定定做功課和温習，這是基本的學習態度，否則讀邊間小學都無法長期讀得好。還有一個point 好重要，真正的活動教學更需要小朋友的專注和很強的自制能力。

bubuG

原帖由 huicheukbb 於 14-11-22 發表
謝謝大家的寶貴意見，會放棄今天優才的註冊，決定選SFA。真的謝謝大家！



  ...

Sfa 仲可以大抽獎

huicheukbb

謝謝大家的寶貴意見，會放棄今天優才的註冊，決定選SFA。真的謝謝大家！

hoihoima

huicheukbb 發表於 14-11-21 10:07
小朋友係仔仔，優才和SFA也收了，真心求意見，謝謝！

SFA收得，應該讀得上。選SFA。

KikiDaddy

回覆 bubuG 的帖子

Well said. E.g. A kid performs well at HKUGC doesn't mean he can do the same at SFA and vice versa. There are many good DSS / private schools and the parents need to choose one suitable to their kid.

bubuG

原帖由 enidchiu 於 14-11-22 發表
同我了唔了解某間學校無關係。只是覺得做父母的，無論小朋友讀邊間學校，甚至派到一間不願意去讀的學校，  ...

我想指出的是SFA課程需要一個六歲小一學生已經肯坐定定做功課和溫習，又能夠有能力handle 比較深課程。SFA是私校，家長覺得不合適，可以不報考。與大抽獎被派往入讀官津校是兩回事。如果家長認為不需要了解學，出現錯配只會令全家人受苦。

爸爸愛您

嘩，兩間都收？你小朋友好叻呀

enidchiu

bubuG 發表於 14-11-21 19:49
你不如了解下SFA先啦

同我了唔了解某間學校無關係。只是覺得做父母的，無論小朋友讀邊間學校，甚至派到一間不願意去讀的學校， 都應該相信自己的孩子是讀得書的。

gau1010

想問下女仔升Band one中學多數係邊幾間？

KikiDaddy

回覆 ymq 的帖子

My ratio is just counting the boys. In fact, girls of SFA has a better secondary school allocation than boys. Over 40 girls (60%) are allocated to Band 1a schools in 2014. Combining boys and girls, >50% of the students can be allocated to secondary schools which are better than GT.

bubuG

原帖由 enidchiu 於 14-11-21 發表
相反，真係唔讀得書嘅人才揀優才？？？
五歲人仔已經要被人分辨為讀唔讀得書？？？ ...

你不如了解下SFA先啦

cwclsh

有朋友個大仔讀SFA, 細女讀GT.
她說SFA 是辛苦得來(谷)的成績; 而GT是"較"輕鬆學習得此成績.
就是看你小朋友係受傳統教定活D教. 選對了合適自己的學校,
成績才會好. 其實過來人經驗, 家長自已可放幾多時間去溫習做功課?
這個問題也要考慮.

ymq

回覆 KikiDaddy 的帖子

Yes. We are calculating based on the same data. 40% around higher than GT, 30% around=GT, 30% around lower than GT.
The Secondary schools which are better than GT ratio is 34/82=41%
(ST joseph 11+WAH Yan 10 +DBS 7 +LA 3 +ST Paul co-edu 2+ Ying Wa 1)=34
This ratio is still not attracting enough to dominate GT Since there is till 30% SFT boys went to Secondary schools lower than GT.
For the best students in GT primary division, they will also transfer the top secondary school. If the transfer ratio is 20%, then the distribution ratio will be 20% higher than GT and the left 80% =GT.

enidchiu

KikiDaddy 發表於 14-11-21 16:01
回覆 ymq 的帖子

In 2014, 35 out of 82 boys are allocated to the following schools which I think are ...

Who knows what will happen to your kid after 6 years. If you are one of high flyers at GT, you may still aim at other top schools, otherwise, GT secondary is not a bad choice.

enidchiu

bubuG 發表於 14-11-21 15:31
如果真係讀得書嘅人，梗係SFA。

相反，真係唔讀得書嘅人才揀優才？？？
五歲人仔已經要被人分辨為讀唔讀得書？？？