教育王國

標題: York, HKPS and St. Cat. 如何排位？ [打印本頁]

作者: Superbird 時間: 11-12-5 01:10 標題: York, HKPS and St. Cat. 如何排位？

York, HKPS and St. Cat. 如何排位？

是否
1. St. Cat.
2. HKPS
3. York

I only apply this 3 kindergarten. Got York PN(PM)offter, did HKPS interview last Sat. and going to apply St. Cat. next Thur. Anybody knows how many kids apply each of them?

作者: loveannis 時間: 11-12-5 08:15

我唔知SC同HKPS邊間好D，但York就應該係第三

作者: wingcrown 時間: 11-12-5 09:02

1. St. Cat.
2. HKPS
3. York

我會咁排TOO

作者: sarubuta 時間: 11-12-5 09:11

三間都係英文好的學校
我都係排york第三
ST cat 同hkps 都好好，一間四十年歷史，一間九年。一間超大校三個校舍k1幾百個學生，一間細校小班得4班。
論名氣st cat 大，論難入應是hkps。
有同事說hkps好d，但我唔識人讀hkps, ST cat PN 又新, 唔知課程好唔好, 地點也要考慮
好難排，我諗我排
Hkps＞st cat>York
Hkps＞st cat＞york

作者: hei2222 時間: 11-12-5 09:16

我會咁排.
1. St. Cat.
2. HKPS
3. York

作者: cclemon2009 時間: 11-12-5 09:19

論pn，我會hkps >sc>York
York 一定排尾，hkps和sc差不多，但hkps有室外playground，sc 新校只有室內和無校車，所以排第二

作者: joanna1388 時間: 11-12-5 09:42

1) SC 2) York 3) HKPS

HKPS interview schedule arrange not
maturity.
York with introduce by principal and warm up for all kids before interview, also, arrange schedule quite good with experience. And good environment for kids.

作者: tinnybiz 時間: 11-12-5 14:22

Totally agree with joanna

作者: Nicole825 時間: 11-12-5 14:29

Any HK Island parents planning to apply for St. Cat PN? We live in Ap Lei Chau and we are struggling between long distance of travel and good quality of PN....

作者: jloved 時間: 11-12-5 16:14

Ap Lei Chau 咁遠真係要好好考慮, 不過我都聽有人住將軍澳去港島蘇浙.

作者: loveannis 時間: 11-12-5 18:00

咁如果係火炭HKPS同York又會點排呢？

作者: ccuuhhkk 時間: 11-12-5 21:02

排名都要睇排乜架由面試安排只可看到一部分

作者: sarubuta 時間: 11-12-5 22:35

同意! interview 安排睇的主要係admin 方面, 平時點會一日有千幾個小朋友, 幾千個家長出入學校喎. 去到interview 可能睇埋校舍設施.

但點排位應以老師教學課程為先.

原帖由 ccuuhhkk 於 11-12-5 21:02 發表
排名都要睇排乜架由面試安排只可看到一部分

作者: junyi 時間: 11-12-5 23:55

作者: yslgirl 時間: 11-12-6 00:02

排難入程度 : hkps>sc>york

排名氣 : sc>hkps>york

排面試安排 : york=hkps>sc (唔like佢攞表都要親身, 同真係好big nose)

排我接觸佢教職員nice既程度 : york=hkps>sc(之前打過電話去問收生日期, 幾次都很悔氣)

排校舍 : york>hkps (sc唔知, 不過無戶外playground就差少少)

排課程同老師教學水準 : 呢樣好重要, 但其實我都只可看網頁的教學理念, 方法, 但好似太high level, 實際o係到讀會係點, 我就真的不很了解, 因為無家長會讀過晒三間, 但聽個個都話三間都讀得開心, 學到野.

你話sc畢業生係咪一定醒過其餘兩間? 咁我又不太認同. 不過, 您講出黎又真係入到sc, hkps會虛榮d, 因為名氣大ma. 以上只是我個人意見, 很主觀的.

作者: Superbird 時間: 11-12-6 00:14

Thanks for all the comments!!

作者: Superbird 時間: 11-12-6 00:58

80% agree with you, yslgirl!

It's very trouble to get an application form from St. Cat. We have to drop the info. and cheque into a big box they provided, but can't get the application form immediately. The staff will post the form to us. Wasting time and postage. It might be a long long queue on the day(8/12). I guess most parents will go to St. Cat on the first day of applying PN coz 先到先得，派完即止. I went to St. Cat(Hunghom) and talk to a staff face to face today. Her attitude is so so, just told me to check the website for the details and come back on 8/12. Then she shut the door quickily. A bit rude...

Compare with other 2, teachers from York are very nice and helpful. HKPS is good too. York's facility and the environment are also the best among the 3 kindergarten. St. Cat(Hunghom) doesn't have outdoor playground. The HKPS's one is a bit old and messy. However, St. Cat's reputation is the top one. Heard that Kelly Chan's son study there as well.

原帖由 yslgirl 於 11-12-6 00:02 發表
排難入程度 : hkps>sc>york

排名氣 : sc>hkps>york

排面試安排 : york=hkps>sc (唔like佢攞表都要親身, 同真係好big nose)

排我接觸佢教職員nice既程度 : york=hkps>sc(之前打過電話去問收生日期, 幾次都很悔氣)
...

[ 本帖最後由 Superbird 於 11-12-6 01:17 編輯 ]

作者: Superbird 時間: 11-12-6 01:23

Too far away laaa...

How about if traffic jam in the morning? you got 2 tunnel have to pass. 香港仔和红隧.

原帖由 Nicole825 於 11-12-5 14:29 發表
Any HK Island parents planning to apply for St. Cat PN? We live in Ap Lei Chau and we are struggling between long distance of travel and good quality of PN....

作者: sarubuta 時間: 11-12-6 09:19

Ap Lei Chau 去hung Hom ST cat 真係好遠，這麼遠未必有校車，自己接送要留意成個紅磡朝早都traffic jam 到爆（本人紅磡返工，朝朝經過海濱南岸對面）。坐mtr 要行十五分鐘左右到st cat. 建議你自己試一次路程，想想能否接受每天帶2歲小朋友行呢條路

原帖由 jloved 於 11-12-5 16:14 發表
Ap Lei Chau 咁遠真係要好好考慮, 不過我都聽有人住將軍澳去港島蘇浙.

作者: careysum 時間: 11-12-6 09:49

樂基,ST.CAT,YORK

作者: joanna1388 時間: 11-12-6 10:10

I'm sure interview document schedule by admin only. But arrangement of Interview by both admin & teachers.

Because all the interview handle by teachers only. Not admin clerk.

You can see something during interview by school teacher. Therefore, you can know a little bit of which school teachers to be suitable for your kids.

作者: giyim 時間: 11-12-6 10:12

SC/HKPS/YORK

York 一定排尾, 老實講, 如果有幸入到SC/HKPS, YORK根本諗都唔會諗.......

作者: cclemon2009 時間: 11-12-6 10:34 標題: 回復 21# joanna1388 的帖子

其實面試安排好吾好，都要睇吓申請的人數，York 申請人數少，足夠1歲多已可面試，而且大部分都收，相對其他校少比waiting，所以有足夠時間安排好面試，比多多時間小朋友面試無問題，因為york最緊要你肯讀。
相反，hkps and sc 超多人申請，安排時間相對困難，你吾like安排，絕對可以吾去的唸法。
這就是學校選人，定人選校嘅分別。

作者: floria2011 時間: 11-12-6 13:00

My boy now studies PN in HKPS, and will start his K1 in SC next year.

作者: dada1113 時間: 11-12-6 13:20 標題: 回復 1# floria2011 的帖子

My boy is in St Cat PN now and we went for HKPS K1 interview last Saturday....so much people and was a long wait cos they combine the PN and K1 interview together.

To me both St Cat and HKPS are already very good. I missed the PN application for HKPS last year because I was also preparing for P1 interviews for my daughter so when St Cat annouced that they will have PN class I was over the moon and was very lucky to get offer for my son. He is very happy now at St Cat but I still want to keep his chance for HKPS open.

[ 本帖最後由 dada1113 於 11-12-6 13:26 編輯 ]

作者: cclemon2009 時間: 11-12-6 13:23 標題: 回復 25# dada1113 的帖子

讀緊sc，點解要考hkps k1?
Sc可直升k1架？！

作者: sarubuta 時間: 11-12-6 13:53

floria2011, 讀緊 HKPS 點解要轉SC?

原帖由 floria2011 於 11-12-6 13:00 發表
My boy now studies PN in HKPS, and will start his K1 in SC next year.

作者: ILOVEBEAN 時間: 11-12-6 14:54 標題: 回覆 23# cclemon2009 的文章

I think we need to give the fair comments to the kinders though here's the open forum.

York arranges the interview starting from August (if I remember correctly) & she keeps launching the interview though the seats are occupied entirely in case there are people giving up the seat once got another better offers later.Their arrangement can be more orangized by seperating those interviews at different days so there won't be squeezed all the applicants to be examined at one/two days.

HKPS / ST.CAT. just spends one or two days (I believe so) so all the applicants are lined up / be set the time slot to conduct the interview.
(I'm not critizing their arrangment cos it's their policy)

It's not fair to say York accepts all the applicants for Her PN. The mangement office says there are only 180seats ? Is it possible to have 180 applicants only for this year term so she accepted all.

This is an Educational Forum, we need to be logical / responsible for what we said & share the positive advice.

作者: LITTLESPICY 時間: 11-12-6 23:57 標題: 回復 24# floria2011 的帖子

why you change to SC? Any comment about HKPS?

作者: junyi 時間: 11-12-7 04:01 標題: 回復 23# cclemon2009 的帖子

作者: Chocolatefree 時間: 11-12-8 09:37

Totally agree with u! York actually only accepts 160 PN students( AM 80 ; PM 80 )! Applicants are over 3000 as told by the admin! I dunno why the outsiders always says York accepts all once you apply! I have friends have no offer both for PN & K1 after interview!

原帖由 ILOVEBEAN 於 11-12-6 14:54 發表
I think we need to give the fair comments to the kinders though here's the open forum.

York arranges the interview starting from August (if I remember correctly) & she keeps launching the interview t ...

作者: 虎媽媽 時間: 11-12-8 09:58

原帖由 ILOVEBEAN 於 11-12-6 14:54 發表
I think we need to give the fair comments to the kinders though here's the open forum.

York arranges the interview starting from August (if I remember correctly) & she keeps launching the interview t ...

但係，佢地出offer比率亦的確相當高
我唔相信呢個大氣候底下，仲有熱門學校一個位出一個offer，佢地應該計算埋offer 嘅accepting rate，越係人人地報好多學校，accepting rate就越低，咁學校應該出offer比率就越高
而有趣地，york係出offer最早嘅學校之一，所以，好多家長都會俾留位費，而最後都唔會去讀，亦即是話，佢地嘅offer accepting rate係相對地低嘅

作者: pekkle321 時間: 11-12-8 10:00

原帖由 Nicole825 於 11-12-5 14:29 發表
Any HK Island parents planning to apply for St. Cat PN? We live in Ap Lei Chau and we are struggling between long distance of travel and good quality of PN....

香港仔隧道太恐怖，我以前番工都會經過，對面出紅磡好塞車，除非你好早出門口啦！唔塞車都ok既，因佢出完香港仔tunnel就到紅隧！

作者: pekkle321 時間: 11-12-8 10:06

原帖由 jloved 於 11-12-5 16:14 發表
:lover: Ap Lei Chau 咁遠真係要好好考慮, 不過我都聽有人住將軍澳去港島蘇浙.

將軍澳去北角蘇浙好近架，搭MTR只係十多分鐘車程！

作者: joanna1388 時間: 11-12-8 10:45 標題: reply:cclemon2009

My friend told me 2-3 Dec are interview both PG (PN) & N at the same 2 days. Therefore, so many persons to queue up at long time. Do you know it before?

Why HKPS will arrange two age group kids interview at the same 2 days?
But not separte same as other KG.

作者: joanna1388 時間: 11-12-8 11:01 標題: ask: cclemon2009

York's accept 160 kids PN only :80kids (AM) + 80kids (PM).
Why you will said York's are easy to apply. If you read the York's forum, you can understand so many are without offer or waiting list.

Why you don't like York's so much??
____________

<York York York! 1 2 3 4 5 6 .. 38 陳雙兒
11-10-10 756 /
37763 11-12-8 00:38 >

作者: jcckeung 時間: 11-12-8 11:19

原帖由 joanna1388 於 11-12-8 10:45 發表
My friend told me 2-3 Dec are interview both PG (PN) & N at the same 2 days. Therefore, so many persons to queue up at long time. Do you know it before?

Why HKPS will arrange two age group kids in ...

無他是為了慳Admin cost！遊戲係咁玩，做家長只有接受或唔參與！
其實幼稚園好唔好真係好難講，因為老師這個因素可以在短時間內有好大變化…
暫時我只接觸了York和HKPS的老師與職員，相差不大。st cat就未接觸過。課程就好似york同st cat〝谷〞D。接唔接受這一套就自行決定了
我自己三間都會apply，暫時只有york知結果，其他兩間出結果再算。到有offer時我就會嘗試接觸下學校 eg 去參觀下或看看有沒有活動參與下…自己和小朋友親身感受下才決定。始終名氣不等於一切！怎樣排名暫時我覺得無用！

作者: kartimmi 時間: 11-12-8 12:10 標題: 回復 37# jcckeung 的帖子

"始終名氣不等於一切！怎樣排名暫時我覺得無用！" << Agree

作者: HaYi 時間: 11-12-8 12:18

我覺得仔就 SC = HKPS > york
女就 SC > HKPS > york

我大仔讀SC , 我覺得名氣是可以幫小小小學面試, 細仔遲些我都會考SCPN, 也會報埋 HKPS, 因為小學校親切些, 同SC 大學校又應會有不同的好處. York就不會報, 但會報 KM.

作者: kwansoyee 時間: 11-12-8 14:59

自從知st cat今年收生咁樣玩D家長(排通宵).我覺HkPs 好似受歡迎得嚟，又謙虛一点.我都係認同HKPS > sc>york .

作者: ILOVEBEAN 時間: 11-12-9 13:52 標題: 回復 32# 虎媽媽的帖子

If you put it in this way, I agree with what you said.

作者: hangyodon 時間: 11-12-9 14:25

原帖由 yslgirl 於 11-12-6 00:02 發表
排難入程度 : hkps>sc>york

排名氣 : sc>hkps>york

排面試安排 : york=hkps>sc (唔like佢攞表都要親身, 同真係好big nose)

排我接觸佢教職員nice既程度 : york=hkps>sc(之前打過電話去問收生日期, 幾次都很悔氣)
...

好認同你既分析!

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)