教育王國

標題: AISHK or HKA 之選 [打印本頁]

作者: Happytogether33 時間: 23-6-10 15:43 標題: AISHK or HKA 之選

想問問大家意見, 小兒收到 AISHK and HKA 2024 的入學offer (Reception), 目標將來是去英國或美國讀大學, 請問那一間會比較好? 想問問上述兩間學校的用家, 謝謝!

作者: Goodluck2022 時間: 23-6-10 16:44

回覆 Happytogether33 的帖子

HKA doesnt disclose its students’ IB results for an obvious reason.
AISHK academic track record is not impressive either.

Does your kid have FP?

作者: Happytogether33 時間: 23-6-10 17:13

回覆 Goodluck2022 的帖子

Thanks, we don't have FP.

作者: Goodluck2022 時間: 23-6-10 17:52

回覆 Happytogether33 的帖子

With no FP, you should expect to spend 400,000 hkd to 500,000 hkd per year for overseas study at a later stage.
With a few million of reserved cash for kid’s education, you can have better options.

Try to look for schools that require expensive debenture but with a track record of academic excellence.

作者: dem0cracy 時間: 23-6-10 22:19

本帖最後由 dem0cracy 於 23-6-10 22:33 編輯

HKA's US university placements are actually quite impressive. For UK universities, I think the two schools were similar.

A minor but practical concern...If you're definitely targeting UK and US universities, AISHK's school calendar may be a headache when your child applies for universities.

作者: dem0cracy 時間: 23-6-10 22:31

HKA does disclose IBDP results in the school profile, which is available in the public domain.

I'm sure OP has already known this from the school tour. I'm writing this lest other parents get misled by biased and misinformed posts above.

(Disclaimer: I don't have children in either of the above schools.)

作者: Goodluck2022 時間: 23-6-10 22:36

回覆 dem0cracy 的帖子

You guys can look up below web site.

https://hkacademy.edu.hk/class-of-2022-university-acceptances/

作者: Goodluck2022 時間: 23-6-10 22:38

回覆 dem0cracy 的帖子

Demo, the US schools on the list are not that great.
What is the average IB score for HKA students?

作者: Goodluck2022 時間: 23-6-10 22:43

https://hkacademy.edu.hk/congratulations-class-of-2022/

Oh, with so many students as spotted in the picture, they said they had 4 scoring 40+.

Tuition fees are not exceptionally cheap.
https://hkacademy.edu.hk/school-fees/

作者: reyskywalker 時間: 23-6-11 09:07

Happytogether33 發表於 23-6-10 15:43
想問問大家意見, 小兒收到 AISHK and HKA 2024 的入學offer (Reception), 目標將來是去英國或美國讀大學, ...

本帖最後由 reyskywalker 於 23-6-11 09:09 編輯

HKA唔係個個學生都考IB，尤其去美國讀大學嗰啲學生。

如果覺得HKA IB成積差，除非插高小或中學，其實可以讀完小學再插去其他international school中學，咁多年都有小學生插到HKIS, CIS, GSIS, CDNIS, ESF高小或中學。

想知多啲HKA可以search 下我之前既帖或pm我。

作者: Radiomama 時間: 23-6-11 16:45

Happytogether33 發表於 23-6-10 15:43
想問問大家意見, 小兒收到 AISHK and HKA 2024 的入學offer (Reception), 目標將來是去英國或美國讀大學, ...

澳洲國際學校在接英國/美國的大學時有啲論盡，考完11月IB個試要等大半年才入大學。如果諗住讀澳洲大學就perfect.

HKA 在西貢，交通不是問題嘅話，佢個student mix 同大學個record唔錯喎。

作者: poonseelai 時間: 23-6-11 17:09

Radiomama 發表於 23-6-11 16:45
澳洲國際學校在接英國/美國的大學時有啲論盡，考完11月IB個試要等大半年才入大學。如果諗住讀澳洲大學就pe ...

可以放多半年假

作者: Happytogether33 時間: 23-6-15 20:47

Thx all

作者: Poyau 時間: 23-6-16 12:17

dem0cracy 發表於 23-6-10 22:31
HKA does disclose IBDP results in the school profile, which is available in the public domain.

I'm ...

Hong Kong Academy
May 2022 IBDP results
-------------------------------------------------------
Students taking IBDP 93%
40+ 4 students
Average points 35
Pass rate 90%

作者: Poyau 時間: 23-6-16 12:22

dem0cracy 發表於 23-6-10 22:31
HKA does disclose IBDP results in the school profile, which is available in the public domain.

I'm ...

Hong Kong Academy
May 2022 IBDP results
-------------------------------------------------------
Score distribution
7 14%
6 33%
5 32%
4 16%
3 5%
2 -
1 -

作者: Poyau 時間: 23-6-16 12:25

dem0cracy 發表於 23-6-10 22:31
HKA does disclose IBDP results in the school profile, which is available in the public domain.

I'm ...

Hong Kong Academy
IBDP % Students | Average | Pass
-------------------------------------------------------
2022 93% | 35 | 90%
2021 95% | 36 | 100%
2020 95% | 34 | 100%
2019 100% | 33 | 94%
2018 97% | 33 | 85%

作者: Poyau 時間: 23-6-16 12:35

Goodluck2022 發表於 23-6-10 22:43
https://hkacademy.edu.hk/congratulations-class-of-2022/

Oh, with so many students as spotted in the ...

Hong Kong Academy
----------------------------------------------------------
Class of 2022 30 students
Students taking IBDP 93% × 30 = 28
IBDP 40+ 4 / 28 = 14.3%

作者: poonseelai 時間: 23-6-16 12:57

Poyau 發表於 23-6-16 12:35
Hong Kong Academy
----------------------------------------------------------
Class of 2022 30 stude ...

考生人數少, 一兩個取唔到diploma % 已經不算少, 唔知問題在subjects 定 core 部分

作者: Goodluck2022 時間: 23-6-16 13:13

回覆 Poyau 的帖子

35 is really bad. For ESF, the average is like 38 or above.
For Band1B school like st stephen college, where 1/3 of their students get to attempt, the average score is like 39 49.

I reckon in the following years, many local schools will start organizing IB program

When that happens, I reckon even band 2 students (after they changed the banding, around top 130 schools are classified as band 1A/B/C.) can score an average of 36/37).

作者: poonseelai 時間: 23-6-16 14:03

Goodluck2022 發表於 23-6-16 13:13
回覆 Poyau 的帖子

35 is really bad. For ESF, the average is like 38 or above.

本帖最後由 poonseelai 於 23-6-16 14:03 編輯

35怎會係bad? 仲要 really bad? 唔好只睇平均分，EK有不少這方面討論，不在此重覆

作者: Poyau 時間: 23-6-16 14:34

Goodluck2022 發表於 23-6-16 13:13
回覆 Poyau 的帖子

35 is really bad. For ESF, the average is like 38 or above.

HK Academy 40+% and Average
amongst international schools ...

HK May 2022 IB results #309
https://www.edu-kingdom.com/forum.php?mod=redirect&goto=findpost&ptid=3868970&pid=49166178

作者: flora625 時間: 23-6-16 14:57

回覆 poonseelai 的帖子

本人新手IB家長，小朋友剛完成第一年IB小學課程。弱弱一問，如果取唔到diploma, 請問係唔係冇下一年retake呢樣野？請問一般有啲咩後路？是否報foundation 再駁上大學咁樣？謝謝

作者: Poyau 時間: 23-6-16 15:05

flora625 發表於 23-6-16 14:57
回覆 poonseelai 的帖子

本人新手IB家長，小朋友剛完成第一年IB小學課程。弱弱一問，如果取唔到diploma, ...

IBDP 可以 retake
最好問學校是否可以原校重讀

作者: poonseelai 時間: 23-6-16 15:15

flora625 發表於 23-6-16 14:57
回覆 poonseelai 的帖子

本人新手IB家長，小朋友剛完成第一年IB小學課程。弱弱一問，如果取唔到diploma, ...

剛完成第一年唔洗咁早想定，享受下同孩子分享學習過程先。

真的要問學校有無安排retake, 身邊無咁嘅例子

作者: Goodluck2022 時間: 23-6-16 17:56

回覆 Poyau 的帖子

What ? 13.3% with 40 + or above ?
I m not trying to compare it with SPCC or DBS with like 90 % above 40 +, and an average of 43, as only one third of students from those schools are picked to attempt IB.

Still, HKA is not a free school. It costs 20K per month.

It is a school for those with no FP and absolute no other choices.

Or else, for thar kind of money, I rather send my kid to study overseas.

作者: kooliestgirl 時間: 23-6-17 10:05

Happytogether33 發表於 23-6-10 15:43
想問問大家意見, 小兒收到 AISHK and HKA 2024 的入學offer (Reception), 目標將來是去英國或美國讀大學, ...

2間學校的價錢同location都相差好遠，對HKA唔太認識， AISHK個人覺得幾好

作者: 964000 時間: 23-6-17 12:24

Happytogether33 發表於 23-6-10 15:43
想問問大家意見, 小兒收到 AISHK and HKA 2024 的入學offer (Reception), 目標將來是去英國或美國讀大學, ...

HKA is a non selective and highly inclusive school, my friend who works there said there are relatively more SENs and the teacher : students ratio is higher than other IS.

作者: BHA 時間: 23-6-17 14:18

flora625 發表於 23-6-16 14:57
回覆 poonseelai 的帖子

本人新手IB家長，小朋友剛完成第一年IB小學課程。弱弱一問，如果取唔到diploma, ...

https://ibo.org/programmes/diploma-programme/assessment-and-exams/getting-results/assessment-faq/

If a candidate is unsuccessful in earning the diploma, are they eligible to attend university?

In order to find out if a candidate/graduate is eligible for admission into a university, they should check admission requirements with individual universities directly.

Can any subjects be retaken? Can retake subjects only be taken in the school where the candidate originally tried to obtain the diploma?

If a candidate wishes to retake a subject, he/she can do this in any future examination session and at any IB World School offering the Diploma Programme. However, there are restrictions that apply so he/she must consult with the DP coordinator at the school where he/she wishes to register. In addition, an IB World School is under no obligation to accept retake candidates. You can find IB World Schools here.

作者: Happytogether33 時間: 23-6-17 18:26

回覆 kooliestgirl 的帖子

Thanks! 我們決定選擇AISHK.

作者: Tutor_kong 時間: 23-6-17 22:09

Happytogether33 發表於 23-6-17 18:26
回覆 kooliestgirl 的帖子

Thanks! 我們決定選擇AISHK.

Good (emoji) 你幫小朋友揀左咩session ？

作者: flora625 時間: 23-6-18 09:38

回覆 BHA 的帖子

謝謝你的資料呀。我上網都有搵到呢版FAQ, 但係咁即係可以combine 兩次考試的results 變成一個diploma?

作者: BHA 時間: 23-6-18 14:35

flora625 發表於 23-6-18 09:38
回覆 BHA 的帖子

謝謝你的資料呀。我上網都有搵到呢版FAQ, 但係咁即係可以combine 兩次考試的results 變成 ...

Yes.

https://ibo.org/globalassets/new-structure/assessment/pdfs/dp-assessment-procedures-2023-en.pdf

A2.2 Award of the diploma
A2.2.1 Core requirements
…
• They must meet all of the requirements within a maximum of three examination sessions
…

作者: Happytogether33 時間: 23-6-18 15:31

回覆 Tutor_kong 的帖子

Reception full day class

作者: Tutor_kong 時間: 23-6-18 20:56

Happytogether33 發表於 23-6-18 15:31
回覆 Tutor_kong 的帖子

Reception full day class

Same here (emoji)I pm you :)

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)