教育王國

標題: St Catherine v Victoria v 聖公會，大家會點簡 [打印本頁]

作者: Cmmy 時間: 17-12-4 17:05 標題: St Catherine v Victoria v 聖公會，大家會點簡

St Catherine v Victoria v 聖公會，大家會點簡

作者: Andrewchan918 時間: 17-12-4 17:16

聖公會！如住香港

作者: Andrewchan918 時間: 17-12-4 17:59

我住九龍ST cat 收左！吾IN 聖公會了

作者: edniebridge 時間: 17-12-4 19:17

Cmmy 發表於 17-12-4 17:05
St Catherine v Victoria v 聖公會，大家會點簡

聖公會都未in

三間學校取向、課程不同，樓主有什麼考慮因素呢？

作者: happygirl1284 時間: 17-12-4 20:40 標題: 回覆樓主

為什麼無人選Victoria?

作者: Lalaji 時間: 17-12-5 12:14 標題: 回覆樓主:

個人認為維記較難同另外兩間比較。因為佢啲家長傾向小朋友唔單止幼稚園快樂上學，日後升小亦傾向今讀IB. 可能上維小式國際學校。

而skh and SC, 家長大多心頭高，希望日後入local神校。

你最好先問自己係邊種家長先。

作者: Andrewchan918 時間: 17-12-5 12:45

回覆 Lalaji 的帖子

不能同意更多

作者: sesamebabe 時間: 17-12-5 13:36

Lalaji 發表於 17-12-5 12:14
個人認為維記較難同另外兩間比較。因為佢啲家長傾向小朋友唔單止幼稚園快樂上學，日後升小亦傾向今讀IB. 可 ...

即Vic出路傾向讀international school，SC同SKH就傾向讀local school，對嗎？

作者: Lalaji 時間: 17-12-5 14:03

sesamebabe 發表於 17-12-5 13:36
即Vic出路傾向讀international school，SC同SKH就傾向讀local school，對嗎？

從家長特質上看係。但當然vic也有不少入本地學校。因為維小根本冇咁多位俾幼稚園。或者咁講，想谷小朋友入名校的未必day one揀vic. 日後考到乜學校，講到尾都係睇父母有幾谷。成日覺得揀乜學校，只係表示你小朋友同邊類家長小朋友一起學習，升小結果始終睇你自己付出多少。例如維記家長個個家長都有啲家底，抱住大不了讀國讀國際學校或出國的心態。相反一啲本地幼稚園家長就希望入到名津，錢都唔洗俾。我咁講唔係話你將來條路一定咁行，只係你嚟緊三年將會係咁樣的peers environment上學。

事實上維記成功之處係夠騎牆，一方面俾到家長感覺小朋友上學有如international school般開心，又可維持升本地小一的競爭力。但針冇兩頭利，有得必有失。維記近年有意提升學術水平，課程加深了，咁又會唔會令小朋友冇咁happy呢？

作者: sesamebabe 時間: 17-12-5 14:51

Lalaji 發表於 17-12-5 14:03
從家長特質上看係。但當然vic也有不少入本地學校。因為維小根本冇咁多位俾幼稚園。或者咁講，想谷小朋友入 ...

好多謝你嘅意見 :)
如你所講，家長嘅因素好重要。
要入local名小，係咪要好多外補？咁細個，要補d乜？

作者: Andrewchan918 時間: 17-12-5 15:01

St cat 只有少部分外補！都有好offer !

作者: edniebridge 時間: 17-12-5 18:24

sesamebabe 發表於 17-12-5 13:36
即Vic出路傾向讀international school，SC同SKH就傾向讀local school，對嗎？

如target入VSA，就最好入維記幼稚園。

反而入其他international school, 在維記又未必好有優勢。不過維記兩文三語係做得幾好，也鼓勵大量閱讀。不過模式同本地學校始終有分別，如果小學想入傳統學校，可能也要些時間適應。

作者: Lalaji 時間: 17-12-5 18:25

sesamebabe 發表於 17-12-5 14:51
好多謝你嘅意見 :)
如你所講，家長嘅因素好重要。
要入local名小，係咪要好多外補？咁細個，要補d乜？

呢方面我敢扮專家，我小朋友應該同你嗰個差唔多大。

我對維記的分享資料源於我好close的外甥。我家姐是維記鐵粉，所以才知這麼多。FYI, 我外甥都有補普通話，英文.

作者: sarawa 時間: 17-12-5 19:03

Lalaji 發表於 17-12-5 18:25
呢方面我敢扮專家，我小朋友應該同你嗰個差唔多大。

我對維記的分享資料源於我好close的外甥。我家姐是維 ...

維記都需要外補英文？自家的phonics 和oral 不夠？定還是要上Cambridge trinity 班考cert?

作者: Lalaji 時間: 17-12-5 19:07

sarawa 發表於 17-12-5 19:03
維記都需要外補英文？自家的phonics 和oral 不夠？定還是要上Cambridge trinity 班考cert?
...

正確啲講係phonics先岩。

作者: healthno1 時間: 17-12-6 01:36

Lalaji 發表於 17-12-5 18:25
呢方面我敢扮專家，我小朋友應該同你嗰個差唔多大。

我對維記的分享資料源於我好close的外甥。我家姐是維 ...

若target入一線直私，VSA備選，
1、vic+外補
2、SC
邊個成功率大D?
語境係唔係vic 好D? 小朋友可以全英溝通？

作者: peanutbuttercup 時間: 17-12-6 08:36

healthno1 發表於 17-12-6 01:36
若target入一線直私，VSA備選，
1、vic+外補
2、SC

Like the previous people have said, i think whichever kg you choose, parents effort is more important.

But i can tell you that they can all communicate fluently in english among themselves.

作者: peanutbuttercup 時間: 17-12-6 08:40

Lalaji 發表於 17-12-5 19:07
正確啲講係phonics先岩。

surprised that vic kids need phonics extra class

作者: halvard 時間: 17-12-6 08:53

本帖最後由 halvard 於 17-12-6 09:02 編輯

i think the reason to have extra classes is mainly because parents wish to increase their kids' competitiveness, rather than the kids are not up to standard...

for the three schools mentioned,
i have a friend who switched from cwb vic to skh,
and her reason is very simple,
just because of skh's connection to spcc

She mentioned that in terms of workload and academic requirements in school, actually, vic may be a bit more challenging
but she also mentioned that SKH has a very good environment to develop moral values
but she stressed that if it wasn't because of that intangible connection,
she definitely would not have changed

作者: Lalaji 時間: 17-12-6 09:10

peanutbuttercup 發表於 17-12-6 08:40
surprised that vic kids need phonics extra class

vic 提供很好的語境，這對學習英文很有用處。佢哋學生conversationwl english都很不錯。

但如對學生學術有要求，單靠學校係唔夠的。哪管係語境咁好的vic.

作者: peanutbuttercup 時間: 17-12-6 09:26

halvard 發表於 17-12-6 08:53
i think the reason to have extra classes is mainly because parents wish to increase their kids' comp ...

Same to the comment my frd has made about cckg and vic. She said vic’s teaching is more systematic and challenging than cckg but she targets at dgjs. So she has to change because of the connection.

作者: halvard 時間: 17-12-6 09:33

回覆 peanutbuttercup 的帖子

yes, i also have a friend who is planning to do the same!
afterall, most parents are result-oriented...

作者: Lalaji 時間: 17-12-6 09:59

healthno1 發表於 17-12-6 01:36
若target入一線直私，VSA備選，
1、vic+外補
2、SC

唔熟sc，只可以話入親呢間的對升小都有期望。見你問得呢個問題，己可見你期望不小，可能sc啱你。

今年我有不少朋友考小一。發現考試再唔會好似pn k1咁可靠少少運氣，唔少神童同你掙，真係考真功夫的。sc聽聞係呢方面做得幾好，詳情可問吓用家。

作者: Lalaji 時間: 17-12-6 11:18

halvard 發表於 17-12-6 09:33
回覆 peanutbuttercup 的帖子

yes, i also have a friend who is planning to do the same!

I can't agree more on hk parents being very result oriented. Taking SHK as an example, heard that around 40 kids go to SPCC. this number is so hard to resist by most parents. but then I am a bit conservative on this given around half of those kids have connection to get in, only around 20 out of those actually get in by themselve. I think it is not easy too although it is already a very good number compares to most school

作者: Nomos 時間: 17-12-6 11:30

回覆 Andrewchan918 的帖子

從何得知呢?

作者: fluty 時間: 17-12-6 11:34 標題: 回覆樓主

我識得sc 既家長又target top local school 都一定有外補，仲要係上證書班。有部分由pn 已開始補習。

好多人話vic target Intl school ,其實可以掉返轉講target intl school 既家長好少會選擇sc .

作者: halvard 時間: 17-12-6 13:21

回覆 Lalaji 的帖子

Yes, i have been one of the parents before, considered those number of graduates to particular schools as a factor of choosing a kindergarten and i am so wrong.
One of the ek parents is right, how do u know u r one of those graduates getting into the so called elite or most popular schools? So long as u r NOT one of them, the percentage, no matter how impressive it is, is meaningless...

And those who could get in paid a lot of efforts too, if you are not that kind, i dont think merely by getting into those kindergartens will help much at all..

作者: Lalaji 時間: 17-12-6 13:44

halvard 發表於 17-12-6 13:21
回覆 Lalaji 的帖子

Yes, i have been one of the parents before, considered those number of graduates ...

that is what I believe too. but honestly the statistic sometimes makes you so difficult to resist as this is the only tangible thing you can rely on. so I prefer龍校, if you are smart, you will get those first tier school anyway, if you are not, at least you get a chance to get in an ok school

作者: halvard 時間: 17-12-6 14:40

回覆 Lalaji 的帖子

totally understand...
life is so difficult for kids now.. and stressful for parents...

作者: maymay27 時間: 17-12-9 21:15

Andrewchan918 發表於 17-12-5 15:01
St cat 只有少部分外補！都有好offer !

SC少外補？無可能囉

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)