教育王國

標題: St Clare's versus St Paul's Catholic [打印本頁]

作者: candeelian 時間: 17-11-27 11:47 標題: St Clare's versus St Paul's Catholic

Thanks God. We got offers from both school. Both schools are similar, traditional girl's school which suits my daughter. The only thing is that I prefer an English primary school, but St Paul's Catholic ranks higher.

Which one will you choose?

作者: 1998Ruby1998 時間: 17-11-27 12:08

本帖最後由 1998Ruby1998 於 17-11-27 12:45 編輯

Congrats! St Paul Catholic for sure! The school focuses a lot on English, their English performance can be as competitive as St Clare's.

Comparing the two secondary school, SPSS is more academic. However, a lot of St Clare girls would opt for secondary school such as St Steven Girl's, DGS, St Paul Co-ed....if you are aiming for schools like these, it would better to study in St Clare's then.

作者: gurgur 時間: 17-11-27 12:26

Have you ask your girl? What is her choose?

作者: happysin 時間: 17-11-27 12:39

1998Ruby1998 發表於 17-11-27 12:08
Congrats! St Paul Catholic for sure! The school focuses a lot on English, their English performance ...

st paul's catholic not direct to spcs (st paul's convent school) but to st paul's secondary. pls correct if i am wrong.

作者: cmchang0927 時間: 17-11-27 12:44

happysin 發表於 17-11-27 12:39
st paul's catholic not direct to spcs (st paul's convent school) but to st paul's secondary. pls co ...

st paul cat係去st paul’s secondary.

作者: 1998Ruby1998 時間: 17-11-27 12:44

回覆 happysin 的帖子

Sorry, that was a typo.

作者: cmchang0927 時間: 17-11-27 12:45

candeelian 發表於 17-11-27 11:47
Thanks God. We got offers from both school. Both schools are similar, traditional girl's school whic ...

我女now s2， 8 yrs ago i had the same choices. I chose st paul cat finally.

作者: cmchang0927 時間: 17-11-27 12:49

1998Ruby1998 發表於 17-11-27 12:08
Congrats! St Paul Catholic for sure! The school focuses a lot on English, their English performance ...

2年前st paul cat. p6 ， 3 st paul coedu, 1 dgs, 3 bps, 1 hys, 1 spcs, 1 mss, 1 ssgc, 1 st mary....

作者: yubaba 時間: 17-11-27 12:52 標題: 回覆樓主:

spcps la. 諗埋個外孫女嘛!

作者: BBQporkpork 時間: 17-11-27 12:54

本帖最後由 BBQporkpork 於 17-12-30 20:15 編輯

如果只有一個小朋友, 我會揀St Clare's

因為返柴灣其實真係好遠 😅

作者: 1998Ruby1998 時間: 17-11-27 13:02

回覆 cmchang0927 的帖子

按學生人數同「挑戰學校」人數，St Clare‘s 多 d 。

作者: cmchang0927 時間: 17-11-27 13:49

1998Ruby1998 發表於 17-11-27 13:02
回覆 cmchang0927 的帖子

按學生人數同「挑戰學校」人數，St Clare‘s 多 d 。

sppcs only had 11x kids 2 yrs ago
中途又有2個已插了dgjs

作者: BBHHO 時間: 17-11-27 14:02

BBQporkpork 發表於 17-11-27 12:54
We had same choices last year

we chose SPPCS finally, as we have 2 girls

St Paul 唔系跑馬地咩？

作者: cmchang0927 時間: 17-11-27 14:07

BBHHO 發表於 17-11-27 14:02
St Paul 唔系跑馬地咩？

因重建，現暫借柴灣校舍

作者: NatalieBaby 時間: 17-11-27 14:24 標題: 回覆樓主:

本帖最後由 NatalieBaby 於 17-11-28 09:22 編輯

首先恭喜樓主, 二選其一都還得神落.

兩間都識人讀, 少少個人意見：

1) sc 学生向外闖的心比sp強烈, 這是以我認識的人計, 可能 sc 中学隔涉, 所以 sc 外闖%多d不為奇

2) 感覺sc 嚴d, 當年參觀高小課室是單行坐不是孖同學坐, 執字体較要求高, 好處是較淑女

3) sc功課少但有不少 continuous assessment.

3) sp 少d continuous assessment, 而每日午飯後不上主科, 連va, music 都是早上上堂. 而逢一至四下午有一節功課堂, 不少女女放学前已完成大部份功課. 所以個人觉得頗平衡

4) sp 雖暫借柴灣校舍但仍比Sc 寬敞

5) 如家庭對英文支援少, 可選英小平衡下

作者: candeelian 時間: 17-11-27 16:12

Thanks all for your view. Giving up either one is a heart-pain.

Studying in Chai Wan for a year is not a problem. This borrowed campus is also very spacious and comfortable.

I like a balanced development and prefer an English primary school. Having said so, giving up on St Paul's Catholic seems like an unwise decision.

作者: cmchang0927 時間: 17-11-27 16:24

candeelian 發表於 17-11-27 16:12
Thanks all for your view. Giving up either one is a heart-pain.

Studying in Chai Wan for a year is ...

Also i know a few girls of spss were from st clare ’s primary, but havent heard of vice versa situation....

作者: mcl203 時間: 17-11-27 16:26

cmchang0927 發表於 17-11-27 16:24
Also i know a few girls of spss were from st clare ’s primary, but havent heard of vice versa situ ...

可能，摩星嶺係一主因～～～

作者: ^GGmami^ 時間: 17-11-27 19:54

NatalieBaby 發表於 17-11-27 14:24
首先恭喜樓主, 二選其一都算還得神落.

兩間都識人讀, 少少個人意見：

非常同意，sp應該係少數唔谷嘅津校，小一上學期無測考(係有評估)，默書由開學到而家都只係默過3中3英，功課基本上喺學校已做晒，我個女依然係每日放學返屋企就玩玩玩，佢每日返學都好開心!

作者: Bunnygirl 時間: 17-11-27 21:40

其實SC kindergarten 都有好多人大抽獎後扣灣仔三大女津, 如果有三大其中一間中咗多數會走. 可能都係同中學位置有關. 尤其st Francis 同st Paul cath都係全新校捨. 太吸引!

作者: elbar 時間: 17-11-27 21:55

candeelian 發表於 17-11-27 11:47
Thanks God. We got offers from both school. Both schools are similar, traditional girl's school whic ...

阿 Paul

作者: candeelian 時間: 17-11-27 23:08

回覆 elbar 的帖子

Hi Elbar,
In your previous reply to St Clare's versus St. Francis, you vote for St Clare. haha.
But in my case, you vote for St Paul. Why this is so gei?

作者: dreamdream081 時間: 17-11-27 23:44

candeelian 發表於 17-11-27 23:08
回覆 elbar 的帖子

Hi Elbar,

haha

作者: 千語mami 時間: 17-11-28 01:14 標題: 回覆樓主：

本帖最後由千語mami 於 17-11-28 01:15 編輯

-----

作者: candeelian 時間: 17-11-28 07:15

It is a very hard decision for me. I like St. Paul Catholic needless to say. Having said so, there are not many English primary schools now in HK. It is hard to replicate an English environment because English is almost non-existent in our everyday life, to strengthen needs a lot of effort. I don't want to miss out the golden language learning time.

作者: cmchang0927 時間: 17-11-28 07:33

candeelian 發表於 17-11-28 07:15
It is a very hard decision for me. I like St. Paul Catholic needless to say. Having said so, there a ...

If eng primary school is yr 1st priority, then better choose st clare’s

作者: NatalieBaby 時間: 17-11-28 09:18

本帖最後由 NatalieBaby 於 17-11-28 09:21 編輯

candeelian 發表於 17-11-27 23:08
回覆 elbar 的帖子

Hi Elbar,

I guess in that case the girl has a younger sister so SF guarantee a spot for her sister. Therefore every case is different. Btw, you better assume SP will stay in Chai Wan til 2020 instead of 2019 , in case the completion date of the project delays.

作者: candeelian 時間: 17-11-28 10:05

回覆 NatalieBaby 的帖子

staying in Chai Wan for a while is not a problem for us. In fact, I quite like the campus in Chai Wan. It is spacious and comfortable. SC's campus is small anyway.

作者: Muigg 時間: 17-11-28 12:14

NatalieBaby 發表於 17-11-27 14:24
首先恭喜樓主, 二選其一都還得神落.

兩間都識人讀, 少少個人意見：

樓上說種視英文，是嗎？我識的朋友說重視中文多於英文，請指教

作者: maggielfc 時間: 17-11-28 14:15

本帖最後由 maggielfc 於 17-11-28 14:37 編輯

其實要學好中文比英文難好多............
我囡讀私幼睇得較多英文書依家變咗冇咁like睇中文書我有啲擔心
-_-......所以返而想佢學好啲中文
我自己覺得中英同樣重要,我小時中英都唔叻,不過英文還可靠日後努力和浸淫特飛猛進,相反中文就.....

作者: maggielfc 時間: 17-11-28 14:24

For reference. We got SC, SH and SPPCS last year and finally chose SPPCS as there's no school fee and we have a little sis following =)

作者: maggielfc 時間: 17-11-28 14:36

回覆 candeelian 的帖子

The campus in Chai Wan is quite good. It's not as modern as other new schools but it is tidy and the space is enough for a primary school though it does not have its own sports playground. The environment there is also nice although some people may not like the location.

作者: hppa 時間: 17-11-28 15:33

prefer St. Paul's Catholic

作者: lokkayung 時間: 17-11-30 09:07

St. Paul cat

作者: BooBooYau 時間: 17-11-30 19:47

candeelian 發表於 17-11-28 07:15
It is a very hard decision for me. I like St. Paul Catholic needless to say. Having said so, there a ...

in terms of Eng environment, st Clare is better

作者: Pigdripy 時間: 17-11-30 22:17

candeelian 發表於 17-11-27 16:12
Thanks all for your view. Giving up either one is a heart-pain.

Studying in Chai Wan for a year is ...

I read from ek that the building project may likely delay for at least one more year, that means your girl may need to stay in Chai Wan at least for 2 years.

作者: candeelian 時間: 17-11-30 22:50

回覆 BooBooYau 的帖子

We have decided to choose st paul cat. I can supplement my girl with English，whereas I cannot provide the hardware which the school can provide. I feel very comfortable about this decision.

作者: pekovian 時間: 17-11-30 22:55

candeelian 發表於 17-11-30 22:50
回覆 BooBooYau 的帖子

We have decided to choose st paul cat. I can supplement my girl with English ...

good choice!

作者: meowymeowy 時間: 17-11-30 23:53

BooBooYau 發表於 17-11-30 19:47
in terms of Eng environment, st Clare is better

Agree. Personally would prefer St Clare's culture and curriculum. (More western/French approach)

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)