教育王國
標題: 德望小學 [打印本頁]
作者: teambuilder 時間: 17-8-25 20:12 標題: 德望小學
如果本身已有一龍校offer，是否值得為左德望放棄龍校？大家會考慮咩？
呢兩日先收到call，我想盡快放位，謝謝
作者: Felix223 時間: 17-8-25 20:15
teambuilder 發表於 17-8-25 20:12 
如果本身已有一龍校offer，是否值得為左德望放棄龍校？大家會考慮咩？
呢兩日先收到call，我想盡快放位， ...
要留意一點GH不是一條龍，唔知你現在手揸那間龍校，介唔介意講出來？看值不值得？
作者: fujitasze 時間: 17-8-25 21:52
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: teambuilder 時間: 17-8-25 21:57 標題: 回覆樓主:
如果係培僑呢？
作者: siden 時間: 17-8-25 22:09 標題: 回覆樓主
如果小朋友資質佳
做事專注
你有理由相信佢係GH成績keep到頭1/3
去GH
作者: teambuilder 時間: 17-8-25 22:40
siden 發表於 17-8-25 22:09
如果小朋友資質佳
做事專注
阿女資質唔錯，就係認字差小小，記性差小小。運動又係差d，音樂亦冇天份。講野都幾叻嘅，但就唔太開口講同重來唔主動叫人，比較被動，好怕羞，社交能力差，但都坐得定嘅。鍾意思考，諗野有文有路，打機都幾專心嘅。
作者: Jane1983 時間: 17-8-25 23:18
聽你咁講，兩間相比，我會搏。
小朋友資質唔錯，有心讀書，家長又肯栽培，小學成績唔會差。
作者: 1998Ruby1998 時間: 17-8-25 23:24
聽你描述，如果係我，我都會搏 GH。GH 唔係想像中咁恐怖，只要家長肯栽培，小朋友係功課測驗上唔用「拖延戰術」的話，讀呢間學校會好多活動，多姿多彩。
作者: b3410 時間: 17-8-26 07:02
坐的定已經唔使驚讀GH，又愛思考，叻講嘢，都幾適合
不過住在哪裏？路程都需要考慮，因為GH返學早。
囡囡考的GH，應該都幾叻女，加油呀
作者: lovemanna 時間: 17-8-26 08:11 標題: 回覆樓主：
本帖最後由 lovemanna 於 17-8-26 08:12 編輯
如果你手上是100%上中學的小學,而中學又是你想要的英中,校風又好的,我會選一條龍,因為不用煩升中,好好多,不用有好大壓力,見到我身邊的朋友小四,已煩定中學,加油!同時看小孩合不合適更重要。
作者: Felix223 時間: 17-8-26 10:19 標題: 回覆樓主
如你所說囡囡坐得定，愛思考，資質唔錯，比我係你會GH。
作者: 已刪除用戶 時間: 17-8-26 10:30
teambuilder 發表於 17-8-25 21:57
如果係培僑呢？
本帖最後由 章太郎 於 17-9-11 21:12 編輯
(emoji)
作者: kittyc1234 時間: 17-8-26 11:42 標題: 回覆樓主
我會選GH
如小朋友讀得好，出來不止是去培橋，選擇多好多
作者: gracelam 時間: 17-8-26 12:28 標題: 回覆樓主:
牌面應該揀GH, 但6年小學生涯要承受嗰種keep住頭33%壓力, 問下自己同囡囡做唔做到, ok冇問題就go ahead。
作者: hoivy 時間: 17-8-26 13:47
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: gracelam 時間: 17-8-26 14:09
hoivy 發表於 17-8-26 13:47
請問GH升德望中學的比率是多少，另外升B1中學的比率又是多，好像找不到相關資料。 ...
本帖最後由 gracelam 於 17-8-26 14:10 編輯
升中版冇真正用家分享過, 傳聞德小升德中40%-60%都有咁傳過, 小學但唔會一早通知你, 即全個小五小六都law law luen. 唔知跳唔跳船好!!!
作者: ericby 時間: 17-8-29 14:48
培僑 for sure
作者: HappiMom 時間: 17-8-29 15:32
my gal is in GH. She is focused, fast learner and can keep up good results....but i don't like the school ..... so do most of other parents.....far away, traditional, not typically good in teaching, every thing charges, etc etc. you can find a lot of such criticism in other forums and threads....
作者: Jane1983 時間: 17-8-29 15:55
回覆 HappiMom 的帖子
記得你當年好開心有offer，想不到3年下來，感受截然不同。你女喜歡嗎？最緊要小朋友喜歡。如果小朋友唔鍾意，成績好升中亦海闊天空，轉校亦無乜大不了。
作者: HappiMom 時間: 17-8-29 16:02
Jane1983 發表於 17-8-29 15:55
回覆 HappiMom 的帖子
記得你當年好開心有offer，想不到3年下來，感受截然不同。你女喜歡嗎？最緊要小朋友 ...
發生了各小插曲，令我作為家長的覺得學校真的很守舊。我囡不會不開心上學，如果弄至不開心地步才處理就太遅了。小朋友成班人一齊是開心的，不過,有一樣是肯定的，如果小朋友成績不標青，其實老師不會注意到你的，朋輩間亦然。
作者: HappiMom 時間: 17-8-29 16:03
Jane1983 發表於 17-8-29 15:55
回覆 HappiMom 的帖子
記得你當年好開心有offer，想不到3年下來，感受截然不同。你女喜歡嗎？最緊要小朋友 ...
Btw, u hv such a good memory ! Can even remember the years !
作者: HappiMom 時間: 17-8-29 16:11
as to the matter of going to GH secondary school, it is a critical issue here. While one will say that maintaining in top 1/3 is not a great challenge, you never know... there is so many uncertainties in a kid that you cannot control.... plus all other kids in the same form is very competitive...so the pressure is still there... in short, the exams is difficult and your gal cannot get good marks easily, or even not so good marks...how can you go to other secondary schools to compete....meanwhile, the General Science of exams covers 8 units !!!!! this is crazy !!!
作者: hkpapa852 時間: 17-8-29 16:26
本帖最後由 hkpapa852 於 17-8-29 16:26 編輯
HappiMom 發表於 17-8-29 16:11
as to the matter of going to GH secondary school, it is a critical issue here. While one will say th ...
門外看的通常都是美好的風景, 門內看的是實在的環境, 感受自然有所不同
作者: Felix223 時間: 17-8-29 16:30 標題: 回覆樓主：
本帖最後由 Felix223 於 17-8-29 16:32 編輯
可以咁講，如果只是頭30%先上到德中，真的搵鬼在GH 讀，連一間地區二線不如，咁又無咁低，唔好以訛傳訛。
不過day one 呢間是傳統女校，唔會係玩玩下嗰隻。
作者: HappiMom 時間: 17-8-29 16:42
回覆 Felix223 的帖子
the rate of GH primary gals going to GH secondary schools is around 50% to 60%
the assumption of maintaining to be the top 1/3 in form is referring to the academic performance under which the student will be at a more secure ranking to compete with others.
meanwhile, GH secondary school is direct subsidized school. this put the gals in a very tricky conditions for securing a place in the government/ subsidized secondary schools out there.
i don't want others to think that i am bad mouthing the school too much.. hahaha..let me talk about some good things of GH...all the girls have very strong english level due to the reading culture. but most of them like English and hate Chinese. The parents background are all middle class and quite educated...meaning that the good peer group influence can be more secured....if you want to switch schools mid way, it is not difficult except for the very top schools. if you aim for the very top schools, the girl has to achieve top 10 in grade among the 200 plus students...
作者: hkpapa852 時間: 17-8-29 17:14
本帖最後由 hkpapa852 於 17-8-29 17:14 編輯
gracelam 發表於 17-8-26 14:09
本帖最後由 gracelam 於 17-8-26 14:10 編輯
升中版冇真正用家分享過, 傳聞德小升德中40%-60%都有咁傳 ...
唔係無用家講過:
今年:
https://www.edu-kingdom.com/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=3469179
上年:
https://www.edu-kingdom.com/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=3252174&extra=page%3D2
作者: siden 時間: 17-8-29 17:19
HappiMom 發表於 17-8-29 16:02
發生了各小插曲，令我作為家長的覺得學校真的很守舊。我囡不會不開心上學，如果弄至不開心地步才處理就太 ...
I agree with you there are drawbacks and good aspects of this school.
But I don't think "如果小朋友成績不標青，其實老師不會注意到你的，朋輩間亦然。" counts. This is the reality of most traditional schools, and the brutal fact of our society.
個人經驗，要老師注意你，一係好曳，一係好醒。我寧願冇人注意，免得樹大招風。
GH有足夠機會俾學生發揮。
我識人五音不全體育白痴都憑努力入到school team。
不過，考試惡啃加升中壓力大的而且確係事實。父母要跟得貼。
作者: Felix223 時間: 17-8-29 17:27
HappiMom 發表於 17-8-29 16:42
回覆 Felix223 的帖子
the rate of GH primary gals going to GH secondary schools is around 50% to 60% ...
首先我想你誤會我意思，我意思外間一直以訛傳訛好多低至只有30%可升上德中。
一間傳統女校作風多是你所謂守舊，家長選擇學校都要了解清楚，真的預咗樣樣都嚴丶管，否則會做成錯配。
當然無需要比太大壓力自己同個女嘅！
作者: HappiMom 時間: 17-8-29 17:31
回覆 Felix223 的帖子
作者: nicolelaiyy 時間: 17-8-29 17:40
HappiMom 發表於 17-8-29 16:42
回覆 Felix223 的帖子
the rate of GH primary gals going to GH secondary schools is around 50% to 60% ...
if the student is only good in academics (top 1/3)but is not good at music and sports, can she still be promoted to the secondary?
作者: HappiMom 時間: 17-8-29 17:50
nicolelaiyy 發表於 17-8-29 17:40
if the student is only good in academics (top 1/3)but is not good at music and sports, can she stil ...
無人知，不過幾肯定成績同conduct 最重要
作者: whitepurin 時間: 17-8-29 19:38
HappiMom 發表於 17-8-29 17:50
無人知，不過幾肯定成績同conduct 最重要
我自己覺得有時都係你睇我好，我睇你好啫。我估要在四大名私keep top 30%咪一樣辛苦。咁入到女神津又唔使錢又升中比率高更係正啦，但呢d機會又不屬於我，咪唯有努力d囉。
作者: ok3 時間: 17-8-30 12:34
本帖最後由 ok3 於 17-8-30 12:38 編輯
其真係每人嘅需要同要求都唔同。我都不知幾想學校同老師嚴啲、傳統啲，幫我教下我隻馬騮
作者: ok3 時間: 17-8-30 12:34
本帖最後由 ok3 於 17-8-30 17:07 編輯
Deleted
作者: mytambb 時間: 17-8-30 14:09
teambuilder 發表於 17-8-25 20:12
如果本身已有一龍校offer，是否值得為左德望放棄龍校？大家會考慮咩？
呢兩日先收到call，我想盡快放位， ...
本帖最後由 mytambb 於 17-8-30 14:10 編輯
德望。始終小朋友有得著，多少則隨緣吧。
努力！
作者: dadachin 時間: 17-8-30 14:10
回覆 whitepurin 的帖子
請問"四大名私"指邊四間呀?
作者: mcl203 時間: 17-8-30 14:42
dadachin 發表於 17-8-30 14:10
回覆 whitepurin 的帖子
請問"四大名私"指邊四間呀?
呢度指既4大名私，相信只係指九龍區，或者無聯繫中學既私校，4私校係九龍塘私小，九龍塘宣道，聖方濟各，陳守仁等等～
作者: candeelian 時間: 17-8-30 14:49
本帖最後由 candeelian 於 17-8-30 17:44 編輯
Case closed.
作者: hkpapa852 時間: 17-8-30 14:50
本帖最後由 hkpapa852 於 17-8-30 14:51 編輯
whitepurin 發表於 17-8-29 19:38
我自己覺得有時都係你睇我好，我睇你好啫。我估要在四大名私keep top 30%咪一樣辛苦。咁入到女神津又唔使 ...
其實係4大名私呢D學校, 同所謂有"一條龍中學"既學校情況好唔同.
係4大名私, 因為升中無任何保障, 家長都勇往直前, 學校亦會配合家長, 為家長提供資訊, 盡量協助學生升讀理想既中學.
但就讀所謂有"一條龍中學"既直資小學, 家長要面對以下問題:
1. 到底直升上中學部既條件是否清晰? 幾時先知?
2. 萬一未能直升上中學部, 小學部對學生升中有何支援? (至少都希望學校話到俾家長知, 小朋友係邊個Banding)
現實中, 願意做好以上兩點既直資一條龍學校既小學部, 似乎唔多.
作者: hkpapa852 時間: 17-8-30 15:01
candeelian 發表於 17-8-30 14:49
Today, I went there for interview but an incidence happened. Due to long journey and bumpy road, we ...
However, I will say GH had made the right decision.
A kid vomitting during interview, this indicate the kid may has healthly issue, or even is under illness condition. Therefore, stop the interview and request the kid back to home is a right action for safety consideration.
I will suggest you to write a letter to the principal of GH to ask for the chance to have an interview again.
作者: Penipony 時間: 17-8-30 15:35
candeelian 發表於 17-8-30 14:49
Today, I went there for interview but an incidence happened. Due to long journey and bumpy road, we ...
作者: b3410 時間: 17-8-30 15:46
candeelian 發表於 17-8-30 14:49
Today, I went there for interview but an incidence happened. Due to long journey and bumpy road, we ...
不過既然已經過去，唯有唸開D，開解下自己，咁遠路，收都未必讀。。。。。。
吃一塹，長一智，下一場面試時，調節好小朋友狀態，加油！
作者: mrsmacaroon 時間: 17-8-30 16:04
hkpapa852 發表於 17-8-30 15:01
I am sorry to hear about that.
However, I will say GH had made the right decision.
本帖最後由 mrsmacaroon 於 17-8-30 16:07 編輯
agree
作者: Tsundis 時間: 17-8-30 16:05
candeelian 發表於 17-8-30 14:49
Today, I went there for interview but an incidence happened. Due to long journey and bumpy road, we ...
睇到都有點唔舒服，明白你心情。
不過覺得入一間學校，入一間公司，有時都講雙方既緣份，
或許你小朋友跟另一間優秀既學校有更深既緣份。加油！
作者: siden 時間: 17-8-30 16:35 標題: 回覆樓主
本帖最後由 siden 於 17-8-30 16:36 編輯
Vomiting is often a symptom of gastroenteritis or other viral illnesses e.g. Influenza. It is impossible for the school to know the cause of vomiting of the kid. The school has its responsibility to protect the staff and other candidates.
I sympathise your situation, but I am sorry to say that the action of the school was appropriate. Pls add oil for the coming interviews of other primary schools.
作者: candeelian 時間: 17-8-30 17:42
Actually, I just want to see if there is another date and time for interview.
That's all. My child is healthy...just a bit bumpy during the road trip as we drove to a wrong place. It made the trip longer than usual.
作者: hkpapa852 時間: 17-8-30 17:45
candeelian 發表於 17-8-30 17:42
Actually, I just want to see if there is another date and time for interview.
That's all. My child ...
作者: candeelian 時間: 17-8-30 17:45
回覆 hkpapa852 的帖子
Thanks for your suggestion.
Case closed for me. Cheers.
作者: 國家 時間: 17-8-30 17:54
As there's only 2 days interview for all candidates, there were lots of preparation and manpower involved, I do sympathize your situation, however, it's not too fair for other candidates if another interview will be arranged in the future, which is not in the same occasion and cannot see the behavior / response in the group.
作者: candeelian 時間: 17-8-30 18:09
回覆 國家 的帖子
Noted your view. Case closed!
作者: whitepurin 時間: 17-8-30 18:51
hkpapa852 發表於 17-8-30 14:50
其實係4大名私呢D學校, 同所謂有"一條龍中學"既學校情況好唔同.
係4大名私, 因為升中無任何保障, 家長都勇 ...
針無兩頭利，其實我並不是想比較不同小學，因為根本大前提是德中是否你杯茶，唔係就咩都唔使講。我只是想講，在另外一些升band 1率高的學校，一様會充滿競爭，做top也不容易。我自己始終覺得no pain no gain, 完全不用下苦功就升到神校相信只有少數人。
作者: dadachin 時間: 17-8-31 09:34
回覆 mcl203 的帖子
Thanks !!
| 歡迎光臨 教育王國 (/) |
Powered by Discuz! X1.5 |