教育王國

標題: 韋氏第五版及第四版分別 [打印本頁]

作者: bbandww 時間: 17-4-5 13:19 標題: 韋氏第五版及第四版分別

以前一直聽聞都是做笫四版，今天兒子在中大做了笫五版（英文美國版）請問知不知道這兩個版本有什麼分別？有沒有這兩個版本的分數比較嗎?

作者: Radiomama 時間: 17-4-5 15:52

bbandww 發表於 17-4-5 13:19
以前一直聽聞都是做笫四版，今天兒子在中大做了笫五版（英文美國版）請問知不知道這兩個版本有什麼分別？ ...

點解你唔直接問中大的CP?

作者: bbandww 時間: 17-4-5 17:31

Radiomama 發表於 17-4-5 15:52
點解你唔直接問中大的CP?

問了，佢話係最新版，比較update. 我也問了笫4版及笫五版同一數值，有没有分別，她沒有正面'回答，只說內容更新了，所以看看EK有冇人知。我自己也會做些research比較一下。

作者: piglet0529 時間: 17-4-22 18:43 標題: 回覆：bbandww 的帖子

可以分享一下結果的分類嗎？

作者: bbandww 時間: 17-4-26 18:49

回覆 piglet0529 的帖子

I did some research in the last two weeks about the difference between WISC edition V and IV.
WISC-V is implemented in 2014 replaces its predecessor, the WISC-IV in US. However, WISC-IV is still used. Edition V consists of five composite score indices, which spited the Perceptual Reasoning Index (PRI) into two different indices named Visual Spatial Index (VSI) and Fluid Reasoning Index (FRI). Meanwhile, the edition V has no Chinese version.
The Five Indices are:
- Verbal Comprehension (VCI)
- Visual Spatial Index (VSI)
- Fluid Reasoning Index (FRI)
- Working Memory Index (WMI)
- Processing Speed Index (PSI)

On WISC-IV, there have four score indices
- Verbal Comprehension Index (VCI)
- Perceptual Reasoning Index (PRI)
- Working Memory Index (WMI)
- Processing Speed Index (PSI)

There are also many changes on the subtests in each area. For details, please look at this link. link http://downloads.pearsonclinical ... -Handout-020515.pdf

WISC-IV was published 2003 and V was on 2013, so there are 11 years different. according to Flynn effect (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flynn_effect), "test score increases have been continuous and approximately linear from the earliest years of testing to the present". My conclusion is the Edition V will give more accurate result while Edition IV will have more high FSIQ.

作者: piglet0529 時間: 17-4-26 21:57 標題: 回覆：bbandww 的帖子

請問你仔做前有先做心理評估嗎？

作者: bbandww 時間: 17-4-26 23:20

piglet0529 發表於 17-4-26 21:57
請問你仔做前有先做心理評估嗎？

沒有

作者: elmobeebee 時間: 17-5-6 22:26

piglet0529 發表於 17-4-26 21:57
請問你仔做前有先做心理評估嗎？

我個仔有。
CP唔肯第ㄧ次就做，要了解吓佢&家庭狀況先(父母要ㄧ齊見)

作者: piglet0529 時間: 17-5-19 08:51 標題: 回覆：elmobeebee 的帖子

見CP即是學校要求做的嗎？是否有狀況出現學校才建議做測試?

作者: elmobeebee 時間: 17-5-22 10:06

piglet0529 發表於 17-5-19 08:51
見CP即是學校要求做的嗎？是否有狀況出現學校才建議做測試?

本帖最後由 elmobeebee 於 17-5-22 10:07 編輯

班主任建議check 吓係咪資優
佢觀察咗佢兩年，覺得佢可能係資優
CP 係我地自己揾

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)