教育王國

標題: 聖士提反書院附屬小學 VS 番禺會所華仁小學 [打印本頁]

作者: Micheal_Chan    時間: 16-12-25 12:24     標題: 聖士提反書院附屬小學 VS 番禺會所華仁小學

How to compare them? Kid is from 寶山幼兒園

Thank u

作者: Tintin926    時間: 16-12-25 13:31

Micheal_Chan 發表於 16-12-25 12:24
How to compare them? Kid is from 寶山幼兒園

Thank u
兩間都好學校,你又付擔到寶山和聖提,不如放華仁比d負擔唔起學費既小朋友啦!

再者,聖提應該會多些有你所需的人際網絡

作者: retriever    時間: 16-12-25 22:22     標題: 回覆樓主:

我都覺得既然from寶山,讀聖提岩d.

作者: AEteam    時間: 16-12-25 22:56

有冇細佬跟?否則一定係聖堤啦
作者: LittleButter    時間: 16-12-25 22:58

Vote for 聖提!
作者: adriantai    時間: 16-12-26 09:52

寶山->聖提

作者: 星星的後裔    時間: 16-12-26 09:59

retriever 發表於 16-12-25 22:22
我都覺得既然from寶山,讀聖提岩d.

X2

作者: TaroMum    時間: 16-12-29 00:43

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: Micheal_Chan    時間: 16-12-29 00:46

TaroMum 發表於 16-12-29 00:43
聖士提反的語境比華仁好

I heard that parents are reluctant to send their kids to such an far location, and so the school may take students who haven't quite met the standards, and Wah Yan seems academically stronger. Students from both schools are from very good background?

Thank u for all replies

作者: Tintin926    時間: 16-12-29 02:05

Micheal_Chan 發表於 16-12-29 00:46
I heard that parents are reluctant to send their kids to such an far location, and so the school ma ...
What kind of good background are you looking for? Elite in repute or rich in wealth? If so......
I don't think the parents who not to send kids to this school because of the far location, should be to stay away from the peer's parents like you.

作者: dreamdream081    時間: 16-12-29 10:00

聖提
作者: AEteam    時間: 16-12-29 11:34

回覆 Micheal_Chan 的帖子

其實華仁係津小,大部份學生都無得interview,你又點解會覺得它的學生standard 會高很多?St stephen 因地點問題,我同意入讀的可能不會是面試中表現最好的一班,但其實用小朋友5/6歲時面試表現來看學生將來的成就/學習能力,又太膚淺。以前的SPCC,DBS,DGS都係無interview, 咪一樣出好多叻仔叻女,學校/老師/家長怎樣引導學生才最重要。兩間都係好學校,但st stephen因為係私校,資源會多一些,語境會好一點。但如果你想小朋友見識不同階層的人,機會會小D,華仁因為有抽獎位,學生層面會廣D。
作者: AEteam    時間: 16-12-29 11:40

另外,寶山係專科專教,st. stephen 都好似係,但華仁一定不是,老師可能會又教數學又教visual arts (如有錯,華仁用家請指正),你都要考慮一下。
作者: hkpapa852    時間: 16-12-29 11:55

Micheal_Chan 發表於 16-12-25 12:24
How to compare them? Kid is from 寶山幼兒園

Thank u
讀得寶山, 應該放眼國際, 去德瑞.

記住係港島個間, 唔好去錯大埔個間

作者: 雲牛    時間: 16-12-29 12:10

回覆 AEteam 的帖子

香港官津小學, 尚未有專科專教. 小學教師的培訓(教育大學) 都是 take 個 major , 加個 minor. (有新資料請指正)

作者: Lindytiger    時間: 16-12-29 15:08

hkpapa852 發表於 16-12-29 11:55
讀得寶山, 應該放眼國際, 去德瑞.

記住係港島個間, 唔好去錯大埔個間

以樓主既標準,聖提同華仁都唔應該㨂。應該讀德瑞或者漢基!

作者: hzch    時間: 16-12-29 17:39

不論是讀寶山還是一般幼稚園,每個家長都想選最合適的.除錢外,不如樓主講講你對兩校的認識,小朋友的特點,家長的願景,希望其他家長可以提供一些切實的意見。我知道讀SS的小朋友所有都很開心,但不太清楚學術,但應該都是跟香港curriculum。
作者: Lindytiger    時間: 16-12-29 21:09

每年寶山都有唔少學生入St Stephen, 樓主可以向老師了解一下嗰d學生係咪就係你口中較為差既一羣

作者: Micheal_Chan    時間: 16-12-29 21:13

Thank u for all parents' feedback.
What is the different in resources / facilities, teacher to student ratio, students' English ability between the two schools?


Thank u so much!!!

作者: ratafan    時間: 16-12-29 22:44

Micheal_Chan 發表於 16-12-29 21:13
Thank u for all parents' feedback.
What is the different in resources / facilities, teacher to stude ...

Wah Yan is more down to earth local school and they take majority of the boys to secondary school. I'm not sure if it is too far away to consider as you are talking about a 5 year old. It runs DSE in S6.
SSC is more relaxing in primary years and provides boarding facilities in P6. They offer  boarding in secondary school too. When it gets to secondary, it gets more academically demanding with a lot of assessments and tests. SSC offers IB in S6.
DSE and IB are two very different streams.

If you look for happy childhood in primary school.I think both can do it!
Some Wah Yan parents think that their secondary school is not competitive enough when compared to La Salle, St Jo, DBS.


作者: ratafan    時間: 16-12-29 22:46

Micheal_Chan 發表於 16-12-29 21:13
Thank u for all parents' feedback.
What is the different in resources / facilities, teacher to stude ...

In terms of English ability in primary, no doubt SSC!
I see they use a lot or tailor made teaching materials or foreign texts for English while Wah Yan uses local textbooks.


作者: ratafan    時間: 16-12-29 22:53

Micheal_Chan 發表於 16-12-29 21:13
Thank u for all parents' feedback.
What is the different in resources / facilities, teacher to stude ...

Most most most importantly, Wah YAN is boy school and SSC is co ed. Do you want your child to grow up in single sex school or co ed?
There are a lot of boys in WY whose fathers are old boys who r most likely professionals. But other than that, be prepared that those get selected by lucky draw are from a wider community and hence quite different profile from the your current parents group.

作者: iamadc    時間: 16-12-30 11:25

Micheal_Chan 發表於 16-12-29 21:13
Thank u for all parents' feedback.
What is the different in resources / facilities, teacher to stude ...

聖提初小的主科有兩個老師,英文一定係native. 教得唔深(但英文應比本地深),功課不多,但大部分家庭都會用餘下的時間,發展小朋友的長處。可能同華仁比較,學術教學進度不會較快,但不代表學生學術能力較差,小朋友都係presentable 和有自信。

作者: adriantai    時間: 16-12-30 11:51

其實兩間除左都係名校,其餘分別好大喎,想英文叻就直資啦

作者: Micheal_Chan    時間: 16-12-30 23:36

Perpahs IB vs local curriculum?
IS vs LS?

Thank u for all favourable feedbacks

作者: Micheal_Chan    時間: 16-12-30 23:36

I am helping a parent





歡迎光臨 教育王國 (/) Powered by Discuz! X1.5