教育王國

標題: Malvern Preschool [打印本頁]

作者: pinkmania 時間: 16-9-24 11:39 標題: Malvern Preschool

知唔知係咪直升malvern college?

作者: ksun26 時間: 16-9-25 13:17

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: ksun26 時間: 16-9-25 13:22

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: lovecasey 時間: 16-9-25 13:53

回覆 ksun26 的帖子

are you sure.......

作者: poonseelai 時間: 16-9-25 14:32

ksun26 發表於 16-9-25 13:22
聽好多人講Malvern HK間野會猛料過Harrow HK，所以估計肯定好難入。佢地個校長好似係英國Malvern直接調到香 ...

兩間同是用franchise形式

作者: ksun26 時間: 16-9-25 19:00

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: ksun26 時間: 16-9-25 19:05

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: hkparent 時間: 16-9-25 20:09 標題: 引用：回覆+poonseelai+的帖子我研究過，好似玩

原帖由 ksun26 於 16-09-25 發表
回覆 poonseelai 的帖子

我研究過，好似玩法不同。

行IB定AL?

作者: ksun26 時間: 16-9-25 21:06

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: JM_wyw 時間: 16-9-26 16:38

Malvern College 只係收10% non-foreigner passport的學生......... 而且開的班也不多.............

作者: andre133 時間: 16-9-26 22:36

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: andre133 時間: 16-9-26 22:45

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: ksun26 時間: 16-9-27 00:23

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: easyparent 時間: 16-9-27 09:44

Just to share my fact findings. According to Malvern UK website, in 2015 there were 7 offers from Oxbridge out of 119 applications made to the UK universities (Harrow HK had 7 confimed places with Oxbridge out of 49 students in the cohort of year 13 in 2016). Also Malvern UK achieved 70% A*-B at 2016 A levels ( Harrow HK 89.9%). By the way the current and founding headmaster of Harrow HK was deputy headmaster and had been with Harrow UK for over 20 years before moving to HK in 2012.

作者: dtemplar 時間: 16-9-27 13:22

yes, it seems to me that the Malvern in hk has a strong linkage with the uk's one, not just franchise like 7-11.

however, there is an uncertainty whether the kids in malvern prep school could garantee/has very high priority in getting into malvern college though as there is no pass record for reference.

作者: JM_wyw 時間: 16-9-27 19:48

The INR of Malvern needs $1,250,000

作者: my_lau_wong 時間: 16-9-30 09:50

JM_wyw 發表於 16-9-27 19:48
The INR of Malvern needs $1,250,000

呢間是不是天賦海灣將會開？
李xx c fu 已幫半歲女買債券準備入讀？

作者: ksun26 時間: 16-9-30 10:16

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: my_lau_wong 時間: 16-9-30 10:23

ksun26 發表於 16-9-30 10:16
小學中學應該係嗰間啊，可能風水好旺文昌位哈哈！我響科學園踩單車時踩入天賦海灣條路仔見到有個地方，用 ...

但125萬債券買左係必入嗎？transferable?

肯定環境一流

作者: 964000 時間: 16-9-30 10:33

呢間同ESF不知如何比較呢？

作者: ksun26 時間: 16-9-30 10:37

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: 貝珠 時間: 16-9-30 12:11 標題: 回覆：Malvern Preschool

一定要買債券？anyway 報左先

作者: my_lau_wong 時間: 16-9-30 16:24

而家報係報year one or kindergarten ?

作者: my_lau_wong 時間: 16-9-30 16:26

ksun26 發表於 16-9-30 10:37
睇新聞好似話有forest school，我覺得呢樣野好有用，可以令小朋友學到課本以外更多practical knowledge， ...

我都係了解中... 聽朋友講好想入，但又未清楚好到咩狀況，有無幼稚園部既呢？

作者: ksun26 時間: 16-9-30 17:02

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: hkparent 時間: 16-9-30 18:06 標題: 引用：Quote:my_lau_wong+發表於+16-9-30+16:26+

原帖由 ksun26 於 16-09-30 發表
我都好想小朋友入，身邊好多英國返黎既朋友都話呢間必報，所以我驚好大競爭，不過點都要試下。。。聽日準備 ...

Ksun26, are you from Malvern marketing team?

作者: ksun26 時間: 16-9-30 18:35

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: Choochootrain 時間: 16-9-30 18:49

hkparent 發表於 16-9-30 18:06
Ksun26, are you from Malvern marketing team?

作者: Cismama11 時間: 16-9-30 18:49

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: Cismama11 時間: 16-9-30 18:51

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: queenie1985 時間: 16-9-30 18:56 標題: 回覆：Malvern Preschool

我尋晚去左佢地個seminar, 有幾個重點
1. 90% 外國護照
2. 同好多學校一樣，一定要搭school bus
3. 佢地staff搭話有reserved quota 去英國boarding school

由於仲係好空中樓閣，所以我so far 聽完對間學校仲未有feel, 哈哈。

新校設施一定好得，感覺佢地會保持番英國學校傳統，再加行IB.

作者: Cismama11 時間: 16-9-30 18:58

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: queenie1985 時間: 16-9-30 18:58 標題: 回覆：Cismama11 的帖子

目測90%是chinese...

作者: Cismama11 時間: 16-9-30 19:02

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: Choochootrain 時間: 16-9-30 19:05

其實90%外國passport唔等於多culture mix, 可能90%係內地文化....

作者: Cismama11 時間: 16-9-30 19:09

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: lovecasey 時間: 16-9-30 19:19

回覆 hkparent 的帖子

exactly my thought....

作者: lovecasey 時間: 16-9-30 19:22

回覆 Choochootrain 的帖子

90% passport can be 90% Chinese with dual citizenship.

作者: ksun26 時間: 16-9-30 20:28

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: easyparent 時間: 16-9-30 23:14

回覆 Cismama11 的帖子

Thx for your feedback. Regarding IB results, as Malvern website does not suggest there is any differentiation between the quality mix of IB group and A level one, one could assume by statistics both groups achieve similar public results performance pattern. In fact the College website did mention both groups had students going to Oxbridge. Secondly, for the British schools, a typical measurement of their success as quoted in the local press is the number of Oxbridge entries. Anyway take an international perspective, Malvern did state two went to Harvard in 2015 while Harrow HK had two attending the medical course at CUHK in the latest graduation class. Other than the key facts, i tend not to make the comparisions between different schools based on my personal, subjective impressions. As i said in the other post, the best school is the one which suits you and your kids. The key is to make sure we know the school well before makkng the conclusions.

作者: easyparent 時間: 16-10-1 00:50

回覆 Cismama11 的帖子

Based on my observations including the student surnames as well as exchanges on many occasions, the proportion of the mainlanders at Harrow HK is far less than 50%.

作者: JM_wyw 時間: 16-10-1 01:20

my_lau_wong 發表於 16-9-30 10:23
但125萬債券買左係必入嗎？transferable?

肯定環境一流

不是必入，買個面試機會。但環境真的不錯，必須搭校車

作者: Cismama11 時間: 16-10-1 01:21

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: easyparent 時間: 16-10-1 10:19

Cismama11 發表於 16-10-1 01:21
Thank you, I respect your claim on "tend not to make the comparisions between different schools bas ...

By going to the section of student achievements at the website of Harrow HK, there are some student names at mostly at the senior years(say year 11 to year13). We may have a guess of their origins in light of surnames. My understanding is in hk international schools, on average the senior levels have a higher proportion of chinese students than the junior levels. For the rest, i have no comments.

作者: easyparent 時間: 16-10-1 10:37

As hong kong has more openings from the increasing number of international schools and more locals are sending kids to those schools, by mathematics, assuming the demand from the non chinese group being statics, we have to live with the fact that chinese students take a higher proportion at the IS. It is also a common phenomenon at both the elite schools and universities overseas.

作者: luckyveronique 時間: 16-10-1 11:14

hkparent 發表於 16-9-30 18:06
Ksun26, are you from Malvern marketing team?

作者: FattyDaddy 時間: 16-10-1 13:21

I have no comments on judging a school by the amount of mainland Chinese students in it, but it is inaccurate to use romanized names to differentiate between Hongkongers and mainland Chinese, because when mainland Chinese settle in HK, they are given the option to change their names from China's PinYin to Hongkong style Yale Cantonese romanization, e.g. from Zhang Xiao Yong to Cheung Hiu Wing, and most of them do take up that option.

作者: easyparent 時間: 16-10-1 14:00

FattyDaddy 發表於 16-10-1 13:21
I have no comments on judging a school by the amount of mainland Chinese students in it, but it is i ...

I did say it was a guess. I also said i got the feel based on some other exchanges. You are right it is free for any one to have his/her name under Pin Yin or Hong Kong style. However my contacts with the typical " mainland chinese" possessing hkid card hardly show the majority have hk style english name. There are lots of kids coming to hk at their infancy and adopting the hk style. If we count them "mainland chinese", i am afraid there are lots of different definitions about the " mainland chinese" in hong kong. Before there is a consensus about the identity of the "mainland chinese", the number is never scientific.

作者: easyparent 時間: 16-10-1 14:04

easyparent 發表於 16-10-1 14:00
I did say it was a guess. I also said i got the feel based on some other exchanges. You are right i ...

Furthermore, it is always inaccurate to do so. Because it is also free to change one's name to say Wiston Churchill or Lord George Bryon. Just kidding.

作者: FattyDaddy 時間: 16-10-1 15:07

easyparent 發表於 16-10-1 14:00
There are lots of kids coming to hk at their infancy and adopting the hk style ...

I agree, the adults may not want to change because they may already have other legal documents using their PinYin names, but they would do it for their children so they could blend in if not fit in.

作者: hkparent 時間: 16-10-1 15:29 標題: 引用：+本帖最後由+Cismama11+於+16-10-1+01:23+

原帖由 Cismama11 於 16-10-01 發表
本帖最後由 Cismama11 於 16-10-1 01:23 編輯

I guess Cismama11 is also from the same Malvern marketing team. Mind these 民房 new comers.

作者: hkparent 時間: 16-10-1 15:32 標題: 引用：+本帖最後由+Cismama11+於+16-10-1+01:23+

原帖由 Cismama11 於 16-10-01 發表
本帖最後由 Cismama11 於 16-10-1 01:23 編輯

I dare say for the secondary sections of most IS in Hk, the majority are Chinese (Hk or mainland). Most expatriate kids go back to their own countries for secondary school.

作者: ksun26 時間: 16-10-1 17:05

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: pinkmania 時間: 16-10-1 17:09

ksun26 發表於 16-10-1 17:05
今日去完個talk，有人問左呢個問題。佢地答話幼兒園上小學部要再assess，唔係保證直升小學部，希望幫到你啦 ...

Thanks. 我13/10 先去talk.

作者: ksun26 時間: 16-10-1 17:27

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: Choochootrain 時間: 16-10-1 18:20

但讀國際學校其中一樣好處culture mix, 如果大部分國內人仕，我不如回國內吧！

作者: pinkmania 時間: 16-10-1 19:00

Choochootrain 發表於 16-10-1 18:20
但讀國際學校其中一樣好處culture mix, 如果大部分國內人仕，我不如回國內吧！
...

各人有自己選擇啊.

作者: Choochootrain 時間: 16-10-1 19:09

pinkmania 發表於 16-10-1 19:00
各人有自己選擇啊.

當然...只是發表一下而已....

作者: Cismama11 時間: 16-10-1 20:09

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: Cismama11 時間: 16-10-1 20:12

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: Babybaby2011 時間: 16-10-1 20:56

ksun26 發表於 16-10-1 17:05
今日去完個talk，有人問左呢個問題。佢地答話幼兒園上小學部要再assess，唔係保證直升小學部，希望幫到你啦 ...

Do u know how big is Malvern Preschool campus?

作者: ksun26 時間: 16-10-1 21:18

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: easyparent 時間: 16-10-1 21:29

Cismama11 發表於 16-10-1 20:12
Exactly. Couldn't agree more with you, this is why I dislike Harrow Hong Kong and watching Malvern ...

I just try to be helpful and make sensible dialogue on this forum. I was asked "to share the source of the fact" and was told "keen to know more about this school" (but because already disliked the school !!??). I thought It was appropriate to point to one of the possible souces in the public domain which did show some foriegn names in the senior years vs 100% chinese student population. I mentioned previously my knowledge also relied partly from the exchanges on a few occasions which of course included a school tour. I had different impressions from yours. But as a matter of respect, i did not feel any need to make comments about your school tour experiences. Anyway there is no point to debate whether an IS with a high percentage of chinese is good or not. It is very personal as long as we pay for our own school bills.

作者: ksun26 時間: 16-10-1 21:33

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: Babybaby2011 時間: 16-10-1 21:35

ksun26 發表於 16-10-1 21:18
opps sorry～呢個我唔知啊，無留意過呢點，你一問起我都想知。。。我只係見到今日派既小冊子，個場地設計 ...

Is it located at a shopping mall? Guess it won't have any outdoor play area?

作者: ksun26 時間: 16-10-1 21:42

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: ksun26 時間: 16-10-1 21:53

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: Cismama11 時間: 16-10-2 01:57

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: winghanglai 時間: 16-10-2 02:54

4. 入場費需312萬
香港凱莉山國際學校總經理學校總經理Paul Measor稱，每年學費預算屆乎於15萬至18.5萬元，報讀學生亦必須持有價值高達192萬港元的個人提名債券（Individual Nomination Certificates），最終不獲取錄或已完成第八班的學生，方可全額退款。
假設小朋友入讀此校，以15萬學費計算，8年的學費便是120萬，加上192萬的個人債劵，入場費便高達312萬，可謂名符其實的貴族學校！
5. 明年9月能否開校？
教育局今年7月25日撤回香港凱莉山國際學校的註冊申請，引發明年能否如期開辦學校的質疑。香港凱莉山國際學校回覆《經濟日報》查詢時表示，相關學校註冊將在短期內再提交，強調計劃並無延期，仍預計明年9月開校。

??????????????????

作者: FattyDaddy 時間: 16-10-2 03:52

winghanglai 發表於 16-10-2 02:54
可謂名符其實的貴族學校！ ...

I would totally agree if the above sentence was changed to 可謂名符其實的貴價學校！

作者: easyparent 時間: 16-10-2 10:45

Cismama11 發表於 16-10-2 01:57
I have the right to like or dislike any schools, yet still being open minded and keen to know more ...

Although i was intending not to make further comments on this topic, i could not help making a correction. I did not state Harrow HK was great. I have so far shared some of my data collections with other parents, and let them make their own mind. I never jump to any conculson if a school is excellent. Just don't mis-quote my posts, please.

作者: Babybaby2011 時間: 16-10-2 11:46

winghanglai 發表於 16-10-2 02:54
4. 入場費需312萬
香港凱莉山國際學校總經理學校總經理Paul Measor稱，每年學費預算屆乎於15萬至18.5萬元， ...

Paul (general manager) and Jenny (admission n admin) of Mount Kelly HK have resigned in July 2016. who is the new management now?

作者: ksun26 時間: 16-10-2 12:54

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: ksun26 時間: 16-10-2 13:06

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: Cismama11 時間: 16-10-2 13:40

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: Cismama11 時間: 16-10-2 13:44

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: 宮二 時間: 16-10-2 14:32 標題: 引用：Quote:原帖由+Cismama11+於+16-10-01+發表

原帖由 hkparent 於 16-10-01 發表
I guess Cismama11 is also from the same Malvern marketing team. Mind these 民房 new comers.

路過。太著跡了。

作者: hkparent 時間: 16-10-2 15:04 標題: 引用：Quote:原帖由+hkparent+於+16-10-01+發表I+

原帖由宮二於 16-10-02 發表
路過。太著跡了。

It now seems that ksun26 is from Malvern and Cismama is from Mount Kelly. Both of them are defending their schools (bosses) and say negative comments on Harrow which is their major competitor in the Hk market. Harrow is the first mover, and Malvern and Mount Kelly are followers. Interesting discussion. As an outsider, I tend to check the track record of Harrow HK first, which has shown very good academic results and university entrance in the past few years, even comparable top local schools such as SPCC and DBS.
I am not a parent of any of these new schools but an established IS. But I have friends with kids studying at Harrow. According to them, its primary section has more than 50% expatriate/white kids. The secondary section has increasing percentage of Asians just like other IS. I know ESF has only a few non-Chinese (maybe Indians) in secondary school classes.

作者: Radiomama 時間: 16-10-2 15:18

hkparent 發表於 16-10-2 15:04
It now seems that ksun26 is from Malvern and Cismama is from Mount Kelly. Both of them are defending ...

Thanks for your illustration! Finally understand their points ^^

作者: ksun26 時間: 16-10-2 15:28

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: lovecasey 時間: 16-10-2 16:27

回覆 hkparent 的帖子

cant agree anymore.... it is just too obvious....

作者: caa 時間: 16-10-2 17:08

hkparent 發表於 16-10-2 15:04
It now seems that ksun26 is from Malvern and Cismama is from Mount Kelly. Both of them are defending ...

Agree just too obvious... hard selling

作者: HKTHK 時間: 16-10-2 17:43

推銷計劃失敗, 請重新登記新身份再重作

作者: canteen31 時間: 16-10-2 18:45

ksun26 發表於 16-10-2 15:28
哎呀我俾你講到我暈啦。。。我講左邊句說話，令你覺得我講左Harrow既負面評價啊，Harrow我都有了解過，我 ...

I don't think ksun is from Malverns marketing team, cus his/her marketing techniques (or lack thereof) isn't doing the school any good! Hahaha.... Just kidding.

作者: winghanglai 時間: 16-10-2 21:09

*位於掃管笏的校舍仍未開展動工，Measor亦表示「只搬運了建築材料入內（工地）」。校方料需待校舍完工，才可讓消防等政府部門進行審查，檢程通過方可獲教育局發出牌照，惟Measor表示對2017年開學仍有信心。*

http://hk.apple.nextmedia.com/news/art/20160708/19686293

?????????

作者: dbchu 時間: 16-10-2 21:12

非常hard sell, 某人仲即係係咁留言其他post, 諗住分散注意

作者: ksun26 時間: 16-10-2 22:05

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: balloonbulu 時間: 16-10-2 22:19 標題: 回覆：pinkmania 的帖子

it's what i learned from their info session, priority is given to:
1. CNR holder
2. INR holder
3. siblings
4. pre school students / alumni of other Malvern schools

it seems there are many knowledge parents here, please correct me if i m wrong...

btw, i think the concept of forest school is good. but it seems not practical given that the preschool campus is located in west kowloon...

作者: canteen31 時間: 16-10-3 00:43

ksun26 發表於 16-10-2 22:05
只可以話你比較聰明。。。何德何能係人地marketing啊，我就唔信呢間學校會係師奶論壇傾計啦。。。
我與呢個 ...

其實你也不用太熱心吧，可能你真係好開心share因為你覺得呢間係你嘅Dream school.但係你講到咁好咪增加咗competition ，減低咗貴子女入學嘅機會？好彩入到，又會話你唱好間學校...... 定係陰謀論，你特登唱好，等d人反感，少d人同你爭呀？ hahaha.... Again, Please excuse my weird sense of humor/thinking

作者: venuslll 時間: 16-10-3 09:09

想問下去完info session 既家長佢地既pn係咪full day 上堂？有無休息或午睡時間？幾耐？幾點開始報名？Tks a lot, 我報唔到名去info session , 麻煩各位解答🙏🏻

作者: hyacinthus 時間: 16-10-3 12:13 標題: 回覆樓主：

本帖最後由 hyacinthus 於 17-7-10 20:35 編輯

作者: newmama2015 時間: 16-10-3 16:53

canteen31 發表於 16-10-2 18:45
I don't think ksun is from Malverns marketing team, cus his/her marketing techniques (or lack there ...

作者: Watchingparents 時間: 16-10-3 19:16

作者: aurora2020 時間: 16-10-3 19:19 標題: 引用：想問下去完info+session+既家長佢地既pn係

原帖由 venuslll 於 16-10-03 發表
想問下去完info session 既家長佢地既pn係咪full day 上堂？有無休息或午睡時間？幾耐？幾點開始報名？Tks ...

有nap呀

作者: Watchingparents 時間: 16-10-3 19:27

本帖最後由 Watchingparents 於 16-10-11 15:21 編輯

After detailed investigations, I have found out information on some interesting users on this forum.

I have found:
       A PR guy of Mount Kelly
       A stupid diehard follower of Malvern
       Two Harrow parents
       One ESF Hillside parent
       One parent of Think International School
       A clever follower of Canadian International
       One parent of HKIS
       One smart Canadian Chinese

Should I share my findings in details? Readers will be surprised.

Update new findings:

Two more Harrow parents, in which one of them has three accounts.... This is funny

作者: Sweetie_lemon 時間: 16-10-3 20:22 標題: 回覆：ksun26 的帖子

請你做好research 先發表唔好做謠。Harrow HK 的Head Master 係直接由英國Harrow 過黎的。並非你口中的毫無關係。

師資方面亦大部分是英國黎的。
請自重。

作者: thvicny 時間: 16-10-4 00:23

Sweetie_lemon 發表於 16-10-3 20:22
請你做好research 先發表唔好做謠。Harrow HK 的Head Master 係直接由英國Harrow 過黎的。並非你口中的毫 ...

英國harrow副校長

作者: Babybaby2011 時間: 16-10-7 21:00

hyacinthus 發表於 16-10-3 12:13
PN Full day 一年學費接近15萬:，

想問吓知唔知道Malvern preschool 其實教育局approve 咗未？因為佢話2017/9月開學？

作者: Jackieson 時間: 16-10-8 02:03

回覆 Babybaby2011 的帖子

應該係預算2018年9月開學

作者: Babybaby2011 時間: 16-10-8 08:13

Jackieson 發表於 16-10-8 02:03
回覆 Babybaby2011 的帖子

應該係預算2018年9月開學

College 2018/9, Preschool 2017/9

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)