教育王國

標題: 中大醫？港大醫？ [打印本頁]

作者: kenwoodwood 時間: 16-7-14 09:28 標題: 中大醫？港大醫？

7科42，6科36
中大電話要求put CU medicine as first choice 就肯定錄取。

如果報港大醫as first choice, 中大醫as second choice，是否會失去中大的錄取機會？

不明白為什麼把first choice作為錄取條件？院校應該看不到學生的choice?

盼賜教！

作者: kenwoodwood 時間: 16-7-14 11:01

回覆 kenwoodwood 的帖子

請教elbar 及諸位，如果港大沒錄取，中大的機會怎樣？中大會因為不擺1st choice落空嗎？
中大電話講的擺1st choice是錄取條件？還是advice or wish?

作者: workingmom 時間: 16-7-14 11:52

應是成績已達中大要求，所以如果中大是首志願，便必入中大。

作者: kenwoodwood 時間: 16-7-14 12:36

回覆 workingmom 的帖子

是這樣，中大擺第一肯定錄取。
如果中大擺第二，機會怎樣？擔心港大錄不到中大也落空！

作者: workingmom 時間: 16-7-14 17:02

入了港大，中大便無機會。
港大不收，中文當然會收。

作者: dativebond 時間: 16-7-14 17:21 標題: 回覆：中大醫？港大醫？

理論上佢只睇到你放band A睇唔到排名。所以可能靠嚇。不過，呢件事咁緊要，你問下老師睇下佢係咪真係想「大」你?

作者: andrew 時間: 16-7-14 17:25

中大電話要求put CU medicine as first choice 就肯定錄取。

如果港大收你, 你放中大在首位, 港大就收不到你.

中大用這方法, 一年不知嚇倒幾多人.

作者: kenwoodwood 時間: 16-7-14 20:16

多謝各位分享！
希望中大只是「嚇」人，真的不會看到1st or 2nd choice。

據Jupas網頁講是看不到。

作者: Feimum 時間: 16-7-25 13:34 標題: 引用：7科42，6科36中大電話要求put+CU+medicine+

原帖由 kenwoodwood 於 16-07-14 發表
7科42，6科36
中大電話要求put CU medicine as first choice 就肯定錄取。

今日亞女intervew CU, professor 話知佢成個band A 點排

作者: kingchun 時間: 16-7-25 22:02

Feimum 想請問妳個女7科幾多分、中大醫有得 in.

作者: Bettyblue 時間: 16-7-25 23:25

Feimum, 你女不是放榜前已经interview左嗎？再有second in？請問兩次的面試内容有什麽分別？

作者: Feimum 時間: 16-7-26 06:13 標題: 回覆：Bettyblue 的帖子

唔係呀！medic 夢應完,佢收拾心情interview 第二個學系, 但ㄧ入去, professor A 就話知佢㨂medic , professor B 就問佢點解你Band A 全揀CU。

作者: ANChan59 時間: 16-7-27 23:21

Feimum 發表於 16-7-25 13:34
今日亞女intervew CU, professor 話知佢成個band A 點排

It's very easy, MBChB must be A1, other two programs may have different admission scores, you won't put a low admission score program before a high admission score program, so it's very easy to know your rational priorities.
It's doesn't matter.

作者: kenwoodwood 時間: 16-8-1 18:22

回覆 ANChan59 的帖子

So that means every institution would easily figure out your priority of choices?

作者: ANChan59 時間: 16-8-1 18:26

kenwoodwood 發表於 16-8-1 18:22
回覆 ANChan59 的帖子

So that means every institution would easily figure out your priority of choic ...

Not necessary, if A1, A2, A3 have very close admission scores, you can't say which one is A1 or A3.

Medicine and some programs forced you to put in A1, so if A2 and A3 have significant difference, you can deduce the priorities.

作者: kenwoodwood 時間: 16-8-1 18:43

回覆 ANChan59 的帖子

Thanks!
But in my case, CU would definitely know I didn't put it as 1st choice.

So worried. . .

作者: ANChan59 時間: 16-8-1 19:04

kenwoodwood 發表於 16-8-1 18:43
回覆 ANChan59 的帖子

Thanks!

If the score is high, put HKU as A1, so go to HKU MBBS.

No need to worry.

Congratulation in advance.

作者: kenwoodwood 時間: 16-8-1 19:33

回覆 ANChan59 的帖子

Thank you for your kindness!

作者: youma 時間: 16-8-1 22:15

本帖最後由 youma 於 16-8-2 00:54 編輯

kenwoodwood 發表於 16-8-1 18:43
回覆 ANChan59 的帖子

Thanks!

I know quite a number students putting CU medi in higher priority than HKU Medi. HKU medi is no longer better than CU Medi in all aspects.
In other words, both medi schools can no longer "guess" the students' priority. It is meaningless to guess. They can only give offers to as many as eligible students and let the students priority count.

No worry!

作者: kenwoodwood 時間: 16-8-1 22:47

回覆 youma 的帖子

Such a relief reading your reply! Thank you so much!

作者: DKmum 時間: 16-8-2 19:10 標題: 引用：回覆+ANChan59+的帖子 Thanks!But+in+my+c

原帖由 kenwoodwood 於 16-08-01 發表
回覆 ANChan59 的帖子

Thanks!

have you attended interview of both medical schools before result announcement? My son 's friend having same marks as yours has received calls from both universities already, have you?

It really depends your favour of which medical school, go ahead to enrol your favourite school, if not, you will feel regret!

even if they know your priority, it really doesn't matter as long as you meet their requirement & put them in A choice.

作者: manning2014 時間: 16-8-3 11:41

本帖最後由 manning2014 於 16-8-3 15:12 編輯

kenwoodwood 發表於 16-7-14 09:28
7科42，6科36
中大電話要求put CU medicine as first choice 就肯定錄取。

No one can answer your question for 100% sure. But you know your score is a marginal case for both schools (in fact 36 is the lowest entry mark for HKU last year). Ask yourself which of the following will upset you most: (1) Can't study medic at HKU or (2) Can't study medic at all in HK, need to study and work as something else in future. Then you know very well how to make your choice.

作者: brother4 時間: 16-8-3 14:20 標題: 回覆：中大醫？港大醫？

今日痛失一位名醫，畢業難，做好醫生更難

作者: MC1128 時間: 16-8-3 14:57 標題: 回覆：brother4 的帖子

警方接獲懷疑有醫院職員用假文件請假的報案，上月底拘捕一名26歲醫院女職員，涉嫌「行使虛假文書」。據了解，該名女職員是沙田威爾斯親王醫院的女醫生，今年初涉以考試為由，提供假的證明文件，向主管請假3天，但被揭發文件有可疑。

消息指，涉事女醫生畢業於中大醫學院，去年取得執業資格，現於沙田威爾斯親王醫院工作。她今年3月初以考試為由，提供有關證明文件，向上司請假。但上司認為文件有可疑，遂向女醫生查問，女醫生承認有關證明屬虛假，威院於是透過醫院管理局報警。東網已向威院查詢有關事件

來源：on.cc

所以，能否做醫生，不要只問分數

作者: ANChan59 時間: 16-8-3 16:14 標題: 回覆：MC1128 的帖子

這一單，行使假文件詐騙，衰硬！

就算法庭緩刑，都要停牌！

要九個月前訂假期，是否特殊情況，抑或正常情況？

作者: MC1128 時間: 16-8-3 17:33

ANChan59 發表於 16-8-3 16:14
這一單，行使假文件詐騙，衰硬！

有醫生朋友話, 人手緊張, 新仔醫生當然最難攞假

但無論咩理由都無得原諒, 自毀前程

作者: allyri 時間: 16-8-3 20:54

香港醫生太缺,公家不打打私家,好快又有人請.因專業操守問題停牌一陣又如何?

作者: catcatlun 時間: 16-8-5 16:55 標題: 回覆：中大醫？港大醫？

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)