教育王國

標題: 香港讀醫港大好定中大好？ [打印本頁]

作者: Queeniewin 時間: 16-6-15 22:05 標題: 香港讀醫港大好定中大好？

請問兩間大學的課程內容有何分別，出路如何？

作者: 美之選468 時間: 16-6-16 17:16

當然港大啦.

作者: kingchun 時間: 16-6-17 15:19

通常精英就會讀港大

作者: Queeniewin 時間: 16-6-18 23:39

港大醫科出路是否比中大好？

作者: dora2009 時間: 16-6-22 16:26

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: mamavee 時間: 16-6-22 16:27 標題: 回覆：香港讀醫港大好定中大好？

queen Mary 無乜中大人係真嘅。
課程係點、教學方式有分別就自己研究一下

到做多幾年野，老細都不會太理邊間出。反而，邊個勤力、不斤斤計較、考member/fellow 快、肯出paper等因素會更重要。

當然，入港大的，family background 如父母是HKU med alumni 等機會又大D、有其他關係嘅又可能大D。

作者: ANChan59 時間: 16-6-22 20:30

Queeniewin 發表於 16-6-18 23:39
港大醫科出路是否比中大好？

Same rank, same package.

After that, depend on your performance and destiny.

作者: Queeniewin 時間: 16-6-22 20:46

多謝各位指教☺希望囡囡入到她想讀的學系

作者: caramelpudding 時間: 16-6-28 12:22 標題: 回覆：香港讀醫港大好定中大好？

聽過有尖子IB 45分揀中大global medicine

作者: nintendo 時間: 16-7-9 19:17

caramelpudding 發表於 16-6-28 12:22
聽過有尖子IB 45分揀中大global medicine

Generally, IB (or IS) students that got offers from both HKU and CU, would choose CU in the end.

作者: ANChan59 時間: 16-7-10 08:58 標題: 引用：Quote:caramelpudding+發表於+16-6-28+12:2

原帖由 nintendo 於 16-07-09 發表
Generally, IB (or IS) students that got offers from both HKU and CU, would choose CU in the end.

...

Why?

作者: nintendo 時間: 16-7-10 12:12

ANChan59 發表於 16-7-10 08:58
Why?

Most of them I do not know personally so I would not know why. But according to my kids, most that got double offers eventually chose CU. I was only able to really speak to 2 of them. Both have spent time with both schools (e.g. summer program, attachment etc). Basically they like the campus, faculty and staff more at CU. One of them did say that PBL at HKU is "quite like IB" though but he still chose CUHK. I think IB and local curriculum raise students very differently. I think the background of students would nurture them into very different types of young people.
Apparently most local school students still prefer HKU in general (not only med students).

作者: ANChan59 時間: 16-7-10 12:32

nintendo 發表於 16-7-10 12:12
Most of them I do not know personally so I would not know why. But according to my kids, most that ...

According to my son and other parents' experience - Mutual Respect is the common reason to differentiate two medical schools. Just the interview, they can feel and observe the difference.

Yes, most local parents favour HKU > CUHK, me too. But, I let him make the shot, he loves CUHK > HKUST >HKU, so follow his heart, even I explain the biased toward HKU in our society and the possible consequence of the choice.

作者: nintendo 時間: 16-7-10 12:46

I was educated in the US and I think CU has always been like a typical US university (in terms of the curriculum design). I am very open minded so I have always let my kids choose their universities.
You have raised a good point: the society still somehow rank HKU highest. And most people would rather simply follow that.
I think IB want students to have their own opinion and stand up for what they believe. So IB students may thus be "more adventurous" and would go out to choose a path very different from what most locals would believe in.

作者: ANChan59 時間: 16-7-10 13:38

nintendo 發表於 16-7-10 12:46
I was educated in the US and I think CU has always been like a typical US university (in terms of th ...

Your last paragraph highlighted some attributes of typical international IB students, but not for all local IB students and parents, they may focus more on Scores, elite programs and NJ quota.

作者: nintendo 時間: 16-7-10 13:47

ANChan59 發表於 16-7-10 13:38
Your last paragraph highlighted some attributes of typical international IB students, but not for al ...

Sure. Everyone has a different background. So as long as a person is happy of what he choose.

作者: Queeniewin 時間: 16-7-10 16:52

作者: duffy_bear 時間: 16-7-13 21:52 標題: 回覆：Queeniewin 的帖子

If my son got 4+2 39marks and 4+3 45marks, which uni would be a better choice for medicine?

作者: 73662710 時間: 16-7-13 23:41

duffy_bear 發表於 16-7-13 21:52
If my son got 4+2 39marks and 4+3 45marks, which uni would be a better choice for medicine?

Both are good medical schools and train good doctors. Ask your son what type of teaching style he prefers, PBL or system based. Only your son know the answer.

作者: duffy_bear 時間: 16-7-14 21:47 標題: 回覆：73662710 的帖子

謝謝各位！

作者: ANChan59 時間: 16-7-15 09:01 標題: 引用：If+my+son+got+4+2+39marks+and+4+3+45mark

原帖由 duffy_bear 於 16-07-13 發表
If my son got 4+2 39marks and 4+3 45marks, which uni would be a better choice for medicine?

Happy problem.

What's the package from both medical schools? Like scholarship, exchange or plus a master degree⋯⋯

作者: ksenia 時間: 16-7-22 14:52

My daughter is a medical student at CUHK (Global Physician-Leadership Stream) and she prefers CUHK to HKU. A lot of her friends at HKU say CUHK medics are more friendly to their peers and tend to cooperate while HKU medics are more competitive. Also, CUHK provides more resources for med students if they want to pursue medical research. Also, professors are nicer in CUHK according to her friends.

作者: brother4 時間: 16-7-22 17:20 標題: 回覆：香港讀醫港大好定中大好？

医科合狀元及不怕辛苦(有人轉科，有人要食藥，有人。。)，讀5年書，1年實習on call 36 月薪約3萬，再上專科生又3年，高級專科又3年，畢業出來有10萬，升顧問15萬起約做多20後，再升高級顧問20萬一個月起(又想多咗出路)

作者: little_yolky 時間: 16-8-6 00:03 標題: 引用：請問兩間大學的課程內容有何分別，出路如何

原帖由 Queeniewin 於 16-06-15 發表
請問兩間大學的課程內容有何分別，出路如何？

老實講，睇醫生如果有得揀，都儘量唔揀中大畢業的。

作者: ypmummy 時間: 16-8-12 17:47 標題: 回覆：little_yolky 的帖子

真心請問點解睇醫生唔揀中大畢業生？大家都考同一個執業試架喎。

作者: ANChan59 時間: 16-8-12 23:31 標題: 引用：真心請問點解睇醫生唔揀中大畢業生？+大家

原帖由 ypmummy 於 16-08-12 發表
真心請問點解睇醫生唔揀中大畢業生？大家都考同一個執業試架喎。

她一是開玩笑，一是無知。我估是前者！

作者: MC1128 時間: 16-8-14 15:54

ANChan59 發表於 16-8-12 23:31
她一是開玩笑，一是無知。我估是前者！

首先講明不是挑機, 係從病人角度講揀醫生的問題

大家抱恙時, 如何揀醫生?

1.醫生資歷
選擇醫療服務不同於其他消費項目, 無得試用、試看。純靠口碑, 看知名度,看資歷。如果閣下樓下開了兩間新診所, 你對兩名醫生一無認識, 自然要看對方是LMCHK, MBBS(HK), MBChB(CUHK),或MBBS(Camb)畢業吧? 所以, 病人看醫生畢業院校來作參考, 十分合理, 並不是幼稚或無知。設想, 你手上只有醫生卡片, 卡片上只有醫生的畢業資歷, 點揀? 重申, 不是論斷中大定港大醫科畢業生較優勝, 是說明醫生畢業於哪一間大學, 對病人的選擇肯定有參考價值

2.看價錢
中環,深水埗, 天水圍, 柴灣, 不同地區,診金可以相差很遠。

醫生同病人, 處於極不平等的資訊層面。一名醫生到底有無料, 最清楚是他本人及同行, 病人未接觸醫生前, 得個估字。醫生不可以賣廣告, 專業守則規定不可以詆毀同行, 因此, 醫生即使知道某行家浪得虛名, 也不可以唱人。病人只能在有限的資訊裡, 按個人能力, 選擇他/她最信賴的醫生。

這些年聽到關於醫生的一些值得深思的說話:
*行運醫生醫病尾
*沒有醫生手下沒有死過病人
*甚麼環球醫學、國際交流? 先教出不要醫死人的醫生吧!

作者: nintendo 時間: 16-8-14 16:40

MC1128 發表於 16-8-14 15:54
首先講明不是挑機, 係從病人角度講揀醫生的問題

大家抱恙時, 如何揀醫生?

你對兩名醫生一無認識, 自然要看對方是LMCHK, MBBS(HK), MBChB(CUHK),或MBBS(Camb)畢業吧?

=======

真心問，比你會點排？

作者: MC1128 時間: 16-8-14 16:50

本帖最後由 MC1128 於 16-8-14 17:01 編輯

nintendo 發表於 16-8-14 16:40
你對兩名醫生一無認識, 自然要看對方是LMCHK, MBBS(HK), MBChB(CUHK),或MBBS(Camb)畢業吧?

真心答:

係香港, 若只按這幾項執業資格來揀的話,我的先後次序是:

MBBS(HK), MBBS(Camb), MBChB(CUHK) , LMCHK

現實生活中, 當然, 還會了解埋畢業年份、專科資歷, 口碑等等

補充多句:上述純假設, 現實中不存在, 希望沒有冒犯任何人

六年醫科訓練只是基本, 離開大學後, 行醫需要終生修練, 沒有名醫是剛畢業的

作者: ANChan59 時間: 16-8-14 18:50 標題: 引用：Quote:ANChan59+發表於+16-8-12+23:31+她一

原帖由 MC1128 於 16-08-14 發表
首先講明不是挑機, 係從病人角度講揀醫生的問題

大家抱恙時, 如何揀醫生?

香港暫時都是理論上言論自由！

你說到資歷，現正排第一反而要考執業試？

另一點，普通科及專科是有不同考量，有醫保，沒有醫保亦有不同考量！

作者: jackymammy 時間: 16-9-7 19:48

回覆 duffy_bear 的帖子

請問你仔入咗邊間嘅醫呢？

作者: jackymammy 時間: 16-9-7 19:55

回覆 Queeniewin 的帖子

請問你女入咗邊間醫科呢？可否分享下DSE嘅成績吖？唔該先！☺

作者: brother4 時間: 16-9-8 00:36 標題: 回覆：香港讀醫港大好定中大好？

看番舊post 用非聯招AL入HKU易少少，情義結，另中大要求分多D

作者: slamai 時間: 16-9-8 14:59

brother4 發表於 16-9-8 00:36
看番舊post 用非聯招AL入HKU易少少，情義結，另中大要求分多D

I think it is the other way round.

作者: manning2014 時間: 16-9-8 15:16

Which Medic school is more attractive to 尖子? Once again, data speaks for fact but not hearsay. That is the choice of 尖子 having considered all those factors like course content, teaching quality, study environment, connection, future career opportunity etc.

http://www.edu-kingdom.com/forum ... amp;extra=page%3D10

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)