教育王國

標題: BHS or RCHK? still struggling... [打印本頁]

作者: cindyinhk 時間: 15-2-24 00:27 標題: BHS or RCHK? still struggling...

Can you please share your insights regarding these two schools' primary... need to make decision soon... I know both are very popular with different emphasis, but really like to hear more discussions... Thanks a lot in advance!

作者: myjasmine 時間: 15-2-24 02:28 標題: 回覆：BHS or RCHK? still struggling...

My daughter changed from RC to BHS. What do you want to know?

作者: Ruth0329 時間: 15-2-24 10:41 標題: 引用：My+daughter+changed+from+RC+to+BHS.+What

原帖由 myjasmine 於 15-02-24 發表
My daughter changed from RC to BHS. What do you want to know?

Hi myjasmine, why did you quit RC for BHS? Would you share your rationale behind?

作者: Ruth0329 時間: 15-2-24 10:44 標題: 回覆：Ruth0329 的帖子

Did yr girl start BHS yet?

作者: Janet._. 時間: 15-2-24 11:09

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: myjasmine 時間: 15-2-24 13:54 標題: 回覆：BHS or RCHK? still struggling...

My girl has been with BHS for over two years. Both are good schools.

The main reasons for our change were location and language environment.  That does not mean one is better than the other, it just depends on what is the most suitable one for your kid.

For me, the main differences between BHS and RCHK are:
1. Location
2.  Language environment (both Eng and Chi)
3.  IGCSE then IB vs through train IB
4.  Traditional Chinese words vs Simplified Chinese words
5.  Campus facilities

Which school you choose would mainly depend on which is of the first priority to you.

作者: Sheep006 時間: 15-2-24 15:16

回覆 myjasmine 的帖子

Which year is your girl now?

作者: Ruth0329 時間: 15-2-24 15:58 標題: 回覆：cindyinhk 的帖子

I vote for RC because traditional Chinese learning, through train, newer campus and facilities, I don't mind there are more local hk families as they probably be more academic focus.
My struggle for BHS is under government subsidies (this year still valid) and BHS kids may be more humble and simple (word of month only: RC students can buy everything with a card in campus and they used to enjoy a luxurious library and canteen etc.)

作者: 964000 時間: 15-2-24 18:08

myjasmine 發表於 15-2-24 13:54
My girl has been with BHS for over two years. Both are good schools.

The main reasons for our chan ...

Hi do you agree that RC has a better chinese level than BHS? And RC english is native level?I agree with you that both are good schools, to choose one over the other is just a decision of priority.

作者: myjasmine 時間: 15-2-24 20:45 標題: 回覆：BHS or RCHK? still struggling...

首先我想強調我是真心想分享一下關於這兩間學校，並沒任何惡意。兩年前我們也於這兩間學校之間掙扎了一番，所以希望給有同樣掙扎的家長一些分享吧！

就先從小女自我感覺分享一下。她今年year 5, 兩年RCHK 兩年BHS。至目前為止，她比較喜歡BHS。她認為BHS 學校雖然細D舊D，但反而全校師生關係很密切很warm , 像大家庭一樣。老師比較親切，同時對品行要求比較高，同學仔一般也比較有紀律。校內沒人說中文，同學全用英語溝通。

由於BHS 比較像一個大家庭，小女很愛學校。

作者: myjasmine 時間: 15-2-24 20:59 標題: 回覆：964000 的帖子

我覺得RCHK 中文程度較高，學繁體字，很多學生有在外補習。BHS 學生就基本上英語口語很好。我覺得中文反正要在外補習一下，所以選擇了英語環境較好的，這也純粹是個人選擇呢！

作者: Ruth0329 時間: 15-2-24 22:25 標題: 回覆：myjasmine 的帖子

Thx for your sharing myjasmine, I felt the same. During the interview I found that BHS kids are very well behaved.

作者: cindyinhk 時間: 15-2-24 23:39

Thanks a lot for your kind input! We also feel that Chinese language is very difficult to learn and RC has certainly more homework and tests to push the students to master it. But BHS also has very good reputation in solid English education...RC is a little bit far away for us, while BHS is quite close. If going to RC, maybe one extra hour on the bus? I don't mind learning simplified Chinese, although I feel that in Hong Kong, it is easier to learn traditional Chinese as it is everywhere and kids can use it more often in daily life.

About facilities.. how many Chinese books and English books can kids borrow each week? I heard in RC, kids can play soccer on the rooftop during recess time. How about in BHS？

作者: Radiomama 時間: 15-2-25 08:24 標題: 回覆：cindyinhk 的帖子

It's very clear then! Choose BHS coz it's nearby.

作者: Ruth0329 時間: 15-2-25 09:30 標題: 回覆：Radiomama 的帖子

I am planning to move to Ma On Shan for my daughter 's future 13 years education. I believe through train without primary to secondary social circle change may minimise a teenager 's personal change and eliminate a lot of stress

作者: Radiomama 時間: 15-2-25 10:05

回覆 Ruth0329 的帖子

That's great. Many RCHKers moved to MOS because of schooling. Me too

作者: oooray 時間: 15-2-25 10:27

一間讀過；一間讀緊；
不相伯仲；各有千秋。
大有大好；細有細妙。

作者: myjasmine 時間: 15-2-25 11:03 標題: 回覆：BHS or RCHK? still struggling...

Hi oooray! Nice to see you here and i totally share the same view!

作者: oooray 時間: 15-2-25 11:29

回覆 myjasmine 的帖子

恭喜發財；身體健康!同路人意見當然相近。
街外人總是比較簡體繁體；有泳池冇泳池；一條龍兩條龍....
呢d並非唔重要；但係校園生活比較少人講。

我覺得地呢類working parents；係RCHK大校園裡生存是比較吃虧；
收風機會少左；慢左；資訊唔平衡；跟老師距離遠左；總是差dd；
小校園其實學生比較投入；跟大部份老師關係好d；
參加校園活動機會多d；人少d即使沒有18般武藝都有多d機會參加校隊出代表學校出外比賽；
(雜牌軍當然大多是殺羽而歸...但有得玩總是興奮的)；
學校冇泳池咪包車出去政府泳池上swimming class；
學校冇pitch咪包車出去政府人造草場上PE；
[仲唔使夾錢(交學費)維修保養泳池同人造草場...]

作者: picture 時間: 15-3-3 09:36 標題: 回覆：BHS or RCHK

Slightly off topic here, but may I justclarify that BHS does IGCSE for grade 10 and then IB DP fo grades 11 and 12?

wouldnt it be very stressful for kids to switch into IB straight away and not having some time to adjust?

作者: lui 時間: 15-3-3 14:32 標題: 引用：Slightly+off+topic+here,+but+may+I+justc

原帖由 picture 於 15-03-03 發表
Slightly off topic here, but may I justclarify that BHS does IGCSE for grade 10 and then IB DP fo gr ...

Bhs follow by ESF secondary. So follow IGCSE then IB.

作者: picture 時間: 15-3-3 15:06 標題: 引用：Quote:原帖由+picture+於+15-03-03+發表Sli

原帖由 lui 於 15-03-03 發表
Bhs follow by ESF secondary. So follow IGCSE then IB.

I see. Thx

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)