教育王國

標題: 認真請教！民生 vs 培正 [打印本頁]

作者: AidenChan2012 時間: 15-2-7 14:20 標題: 認真請教！民生 vs 培正

兩間都收am, 應如何選擇？

作者: hilouisll 時間: 15-2-7 14:25 標題: 引用：兩間都收am,+應如何選擇？

原帖由 AidenChan2012 於 15-02-07 發表
兩間都收am, 應如何選擇？

培正，直升小學，中學b1a

作者: winnietingting 時間: 15-2-7 14:28 標題: 引用：Quote:原帖由+AidenChan2012+於+15-02-07+

原帖由 hilouisll 於 15-02-07 發表
培正，直升小學，中學b1a

yes, 唔洗問。

作者: Lulupan 時間: 15-2-7 14:34 標題: 回覆：認真請教！民生 vs 培正

但培正係中文為主⋯民生有1中1net班主任。呢方面我都好concern

作者: sailob 時間: 15-2-7 14:36 標題: 回覆：認真請教！民生 vs 培正

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: miffyli 時間: 15-2-7 14:38

英文補習ＥＶＥＲＹＷＨＥＲＥ，　ＰＵＩ　ＣＨＩＮＧ　ＬＡ

作者: AidenChan2012 時間: 15-2-7 14:42

Thanks for reply. 本人是英華舊生，所以小一應該會幫小朋友報英華，請問哪一間會比較幫到小朋友？ thx very much

作者: Googoo2012 時間: 15-2-7 14:43 標題: 回覆：認真請教！民生 vs 培正

我家姐個仔讀緊民生k2，我家姐唔係太鍾意間學校，佢話York 都好過民生。例如民生啲功課淨係係重複做一樣野，冇乜意義。又覺得啲老師冇乜心。呢個係我家姐的意見。

利申，我個女讀培正k2,

作者: hilouisll 時間: 15-2-7 14:56 標題: 引用：Thanks+for+reply.+本人是英華舊生，所以小

原帖由 AidenChan2012 於 15-02-07 發表
Thanks for reply. 本人是英華舊生，所以小一應該會幫小朋友報英華，請問哪一間會比較幫到小朋友？ thx ver ...

如果小一報英華，我民生培正也不會考慮，你有冇SC, KV offer?

作者: 99dogdog 時間: 15-2-7 15:03 標題: 引用：Quote:原帖由+AidenChan2012+於+15-02-07+

原帖由 hilouisll 於 15-02-07 發表
如果小一報英華，我民生培正也不會考慮，你有冇SC, KV offer?

Agree！報英華，民生/培正可能反而成為绊脚石，人地覺得你好大機會原校直升！

作者: lotteyi 時間: 15-2-7 15:05 標題: 回覆：認真請教！民生 vs 培正

但培正係中中，淨係睇到top 學生嘅DSE result ，冇level 4, 5嘅%
好多傳統名學喺dse 都站不住腳，唔知佢DSE 成績點？
俾我都唔知點揀

作者: hosuper 時間: 15-2-7 15:26 標題: 回覆：99dogdog 的帖子

Agree! 真是要慎重考慮！

作者: 布希亞 時間: 15-2-7 15:28

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: Googoo2012 時間: 15-2-7 16:00 標題: 回覆：認真請教！民生 vs 培正

If you don't like 中中 and have no idea why puiching has chosen to stay with it, then you can simply release the offer. But one should note that the passing rate of DSE Chinese nowadays is much lower than that of English.
I also had exactly the same struggle when I chose PC for my daughter two years ago. I was worried that 中中would be the deprived minority in Hk, but I Truly think it's much difficult to learn good Chinese than English. And I'm happy I had made the right choice when I look back.

作者: winnietingting 時間: 15-2-7 16:30 標題: 引用：但培正係中中，淨係睇到top+學生嘅DSE+resu

原帖由 lotteyi 於 15-02-07 發表
但培正係中中，淨係睇到top 學生嘅DSE result ，冇level 4, 5嘅%
好多傳統名學喺dse 都站不住腳，唔知佢DSE ...

但民小唔收，點算？

作者: AidenChan2012 時間: 15-2-7 16:36

Thanks for all replies and suggestions. I also got the kv offer. I will consider carefully.........

作者: AidenChan2012 時間: 15-2-7 16:41

其實真係怕龍年競爭大，雖然係舊生但唔一定入到，所以想有個好backup....

作者: tsangnamnam 時間: 15-2-7 16:49

培正

作者: helenmelody 時間: 15-2-7 17:57 標題: 回覆：AidenChan2012 的帖子

擔心考小一，便培正。
但如果想十拿九穩叩門英華就應該揀kv, st cat, 這些學校叩門命中率較高。
我朋友的仔仔都係st cat升上英華。

作者: happyapple 時間: 15-2-7 18:24 標題: 引用：其實真係怕龍年競爭大，雖然係舊生但唔一定

原帖由 AidenChan2012 於 15-02-07 發表
其實真係怕龍年競爭大，雖然係舊生但唔一定入到，所以想有個好backup....

我朋友個仔舊年培幼到英華，所以面試表現最重要，但又最難把握，畢竟都只是5歲人仔。如我選，我傾向'袋住先', 大人細路都冇咁大壓力。當然大前提，你亦喜歡所選的龍校,

作者: babyaabb 時間: 15-2-7 18:32 標題: 引用：擔心考小一，便培正。但如果想十拿九穩叩

原帖由 helenmelody 於 15-02-07 發表
擔心考小一，便培正。
但如果想十拿九穩叩門英華就應該揀kv, st cat, 這些學校叩門命中率較高。
我朋友的仔 ...

英華入唔到 3rd in 應該也冇得叩門啦
讀 KV 也不是好大機會入 YW 呀咋

作者: chucimama 時間: 15-2-7 18:47

甘KV 學術好好多同上小學會輕鬆好多

作者: NICOLE123 時間: 15-2-7 18:52 標題: 引用：但培正係中文為主⋯民生有1中1net班主任。

原帖由 Lulupan 於 15-02-07 發表
但培正係中文為主⋯民生有1中1net班主任。呢方面我都好concern

培幼每天net都在班房

作者: Googoo2012 時間: 15-2-7 19:05 標題: 回覆：認真請教！民生 vs 培正

If your target is Ying Wa, probably PC may not be the right choice for you.
The focuses of PC and KV/SC are really different I suppose. The former is to provide pre school education for the kids who would eventually be admitted 100% to the primary school, so you really don't need much boosting during the pre-school stage. The latter is kindergarten that pays more attention to the p1 results,which essentially helps build the credential/reputation of its own. So they target different groups of students really.

作者: Gary_family 時間: 15-2-7 19:07 標題: 引用：Thanks+for+all+replies+and+suggestions.+

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: Gary_family 時間: 15-2-7 19:10 標題: 引用：Quote:原帖由+helenmelody+於+15-02-07+發

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: Googoo2012 時間: 15-2-7 19:18 標題: 回覆：認真請教！民生 vs 培正

And. I thought the topic of this thread was MS vs PC, but not SC/KV vs PC.
If it's between MS vs PC, I would vote for PC given the first hand experience I had and the comments from my sister.

But if it's between SC/KV and PC, I would have given a deeper thought on which primary I would actually be "satisfied".

Like it or not, one always needs to take risk to achieve "higher". But for my case, I'm perfectly happy with the "less ideal" but risk-free outcome. And in fact I don't think PC is less ideal to us.

One important consideration is that I don't want to put stress on both my kid and myself in the fight for P1, if it can be avoided.

作者: helenmelody 時間: 15-2-7 20:09 標題: 回覆：Gary_family 的帖子

Agree w you.

作者: Bonbonita 時間: 15-2-7 20:52

回覆 Googoo2012 的帖子

Can't agree with you more! Very logical and reasonable! You have picked the best school for your kid!

作者: hilouisll 時間: 15-2-7 20:58 標題: 引用：Quote:原帖由+Lulupan+於+15-02-07+發表但

原帖由 NICOLE123 於 15-02-07 發表
培幼每天net都在班房

想問培幼每天有幾多時間有net?

作者: 1130 時間: 15-2-7 23:09 標題: 引用：Thanks+for+all+replies+and+suggestions.+

原帖由 AidenChan2012 於 15-02-07 發表
Thanks for all replies and suggestions. I also got the kv offer. I will consider carefully.........

樓主，你而家hold緊3間幼稚園？

作者: apple_love 時間: 15-2-7 23:13 標題: 引用：Quote:原帖由+AidenChan2012+於+15-02-07+

原帖由 1130 於 15-02-07 發表
樓主，你而家hold緊3間幼稚園？

兩間姐，培正都未註冊

作者: babyaabb 時間: 15-2-7 23:16 標題: 回覆：認真請教！民生 vs 培正

I would choose PC over MS.
Despite one of your target is YW, at least you don't have to worry P1 interviews， just to focus on your desired schools later.

作者: Googoo2012 時間: 15-2-7 23:43 標題: 回覆：babyaabb 的帖子

Agree. So it boils down to PC vs KV, if you are convinced that KV will give your son better training for the p1 fight.

The struggle for me was KM vs PC, and I chose PC, very much because my kid was a girl and she has a sibling to follow.

作者: HealthyB 時間: 15-2-8 10:13 標題: 回覆：認真請教！民生 vs 培正

If target YW, should pick KV

作者: bubuG 時間: 15-2-8 10:17 標題: 回覆：認真請教！民生 vs 培正

你的情況PC／KV都好，MS不用了

作者: leocatcat 時間: 15-2-8 23:52

If you want YW or other famos P1 (rather than PC), I advise you think it seriousely, since PC K doesn't provide you a formal academic report like subject marks or ranking. So it is quite embarrass when you cannot provide a formal report in applying other P1.

作者: ottomum 時間: 15-2-9 02:38

There are still many ways to show your kid's ability, like cambridge YLE starter/mover/flyer, public putonghua exam, graded piano exam, etc.

作者: happyguy1028 時間: 15-2-9 11:21

回覆 HealthyB 的帖子

同意, 但PC VS MS, 我選MS, PC 偏向傳統 AND 幼稚園課程偏淺.. 好多MS 幼的家長分享課程活動很多，而我朋友曾在民小教, 對民小學生讚不絕口，但如果想100%直上小學, 咁就另計

作者: HMmummy 時間: 15-2-9 13:28 標題: 回覆：認真請教！民生 vs 培正

兩間都緊張學生成績，入邊間都要跟足！我會選培正。

作者: isoalc 時間: 15-2-9 14:27 標題: 回覆：認真請教！民生 vs 培正

我都係英華舊生，亦心儀英華，如果
SC, KV, PC, kln Hkps, 那一間較有優勢？thanks.

利申:將升讀hkps k1, 冇其他offer

作者: leocatcat 時間: 15-2-9 22:42

本帖最後由 leocatcat 於 15-2-9 22:43 編輯

回覆 isoalc 的帖子

SC and KV is definitely adventagous in applying private P1.
FYI, PC has very very few cases of transferring to other P1 in this few years, may be due to keen competition in P1

For HKPS I have no idea.

作者: chucimama 時間: 15-2-10 05:09

如您是喜歡英華，一定是選KV了

作者: isoalc 時間: 15-2-10 08:59 標題: 回覆：leocatcat 的帖子

Thanks a lot Leocatcat
想問下kv 收K2插班嗎？

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)