教育王國

標題: 求各位指點: 堅道真光，玫瑰崗點選擇？ [打印本頁]

作者: baroncount 時間: 14-12-27 21:40 標題: 求各位指點: 堅道真光，玫瑰崗點選擇？

阿女本身而家讀緊玫瑰崗pn. 其實我都好中意玫記，阿女讀得好開心，返左學之後進步左好多乖左好多又有禮貌，老師又好。不過玫記小學普通，中學就真係mama地。
我有同阿囡報坑真，聖心同聖嘉勒，但全炒粉得堅真有offer,但我總係覺得堅真升真小機會比坑真低。其實堅真有冇一條龍優勢？有個妹妹跟尾。求賜教！！

作者: cpychung 時間: 14-12-27 21:59

我會偏向相信堅真同坑真既升學優勢基本係一樣....至於係咪你期望就唔知.....

作者: kscullie 時間: 14-12-31 02:04 標題: 回覆：求各位指點: 堅道真光，玫瑰崗點選擇？

同意樓上

作者: meowymeowy 時間: 14-12-31 03:56 標題: 回覆：求各位指點: 堅道真光，玫瑰崗點選擇？

你不如去堅真望下，其他小朋友番放學，或同家長打下牙骹，睇下係咪真係你杯茶。

作者: baroncount 時間: 14-12-31 10:12 標題: 回覆：meowymeowy 的帖子

我未識啲家長呀，上去又冇咩籍口入去

作者: lovebunny 時間: 14-12-31 23:33 標題: 引用：我會偏向相信堅真同坑真既升學優勢基本係一

原帖由 cpychung 於 14-12-27 發表
我會偏向相信堅真同坑真既升學優勢基本係一樣....至於係咪你期望就唔知..... ...

我是堅真用家，我同意你睇法

作者: vanwy 時間: 15-1-1 21:23 標題: 回覆：求各位指點: 堅道真光，玫瑰崗點選擇？

但堅真同玫幼學習環境差好遠喎!

作者: candeelian 時間: 15-1-2 11:35

Hi,
I have a similar case as with. My girl is studying in Rosaryhill PN and she learns a lot from there. I am very pleased with the school so far.

I got an offer from Tai Hang True Light. I am thinking if I should switch school given it is a through-train school. But TL's primary is a chinese school.

If you were me, will you let your girl to switch to Tai Hang True Light from Rosaryhill given all the stress of primary school's admission?

作者: brrbaby2007 時間: 15-1-2 12:05

candeelian 發表於 15-1-2 11:35
Hi,
I have a similar case as with. My girl is studying in Rosaryhill PN and she learns a lot from th ...

RHS真係好好，但如果沒宗教考慮我楝TL，因為TL小學好，就算唔全收真幼也收好大部份。另外中文真係難學過英文好多。

作者: cpychung 時間: 15-1-2 13:07

講真兩間真係南轅北轍，應該自己好清楚要揀邊個吧...

作者: candeelian 時間: 15-1-2 14:16

回覆 cpychung 的帖子

I know. That's why I asked here law.
Or else, why do i need to ask?
There are good points in both schools. Of course, we need to think carefully needless to say. You don't have to repeat
mothers are women. Thanks. haha.

作者: Ammeyogi 時間: 15-1-2 14:42 標題: 回覆：求各位指點: 堅道真光，玫瑰崗點選擇？

Rhs vs 堅真, will choose rhs
Rhs vs 坑真, will choose 坑真unless you have backup (sufficent points in 自行收生)

作者: brrbaby2007 時間: 15-1-2 14:57

candeelian 發表於 15-1-2 14:16
回覆 cpychung 的帖子

I know. That's why I asked here law.

可能佢指你小朋友係乜type fit 乜school你自己清楚d

作者: brrbaby2007 時間: 15-1-2 15:00

Ammeyogi 發表於 15-1-2 14:42
Rhs vs 堅真, will choose rhs
Rhs vs 坑真, will choose 坑真unless you have backup (sufficent points ...

坑真同堅真是不同校長？

我沒報堅真只報坑真，因感覺坑真校舍好ｄ

作者: candeelian 時間: 15-1-2 15:47

回覆 brrbaby2007 的帖子

Thanks for your sincere advice.

作者: baroncount 時間: 15-1-2 16:12 標題: 回覆：candeelian 的帖子

好煩惱啊，我仲未決定到

作者: luiluibaby 時間: 15-1-2 18:14

堅真同坑真今年入讀的學生如真小有offer就不可以參加政府小一大抽獎，RHs可以！如果你心目中首選小學係真小，就坑真幼啦！另外也最好統計可真小的學位是否充夠比哂堅真同坑真幼小朋友，是否全部可以直上！

作者: baroncount 時間: 15-1-4 21:01 標題: 回覆：luiluibaby 的帖子

都做過统計，佢地唔會收得晒坑真同堅真既小朋友，有小朋友可能會選其他學校，嗰個又少錦批，另外我都係想阿女讀真小，不過睇學校說法好似話今年開始唔會再100%guarantee入晒真小囉

作者: luiluibaby 時間: 15-1-4 22:47

以我所知（我不是坑真或堅真用家，但朋友是），因過往真小比大抽獎，而net11, 12校網靚特別是女仔，所以好多時坑真或堅真幼的學生會抽到更好而放棄真小，所以一直都有充夠學位上哂真小，但今年入去的不可大抽獎，那大部分家長可能會要真小offer, 那學位是否仍足夠？但機會總有，總比收外來學生多，所以如果你好鍾意真小，就揀真幼，不過這3年的幼稚園生活當然要爭爭爭la! RHS 就進可攻退可守，不過中學唔好但快會轉直資！

作者: candeelian 時間: 15-1-6 14:26

回覆 luiluibaby 的帖子

Your analysis is very good.

True Light's primary school is not my ideal one. I prefer an English primary local school like marymount or st. paul's convent school. I live in the wanchai district. I wonder whether RHS or True Light can let me best position to get into the said schools. But true light primary is at least a backup if I choose true light KG.

RHS KG's curriculum is quite solid. My child is in pre-nursery class. She manages to grasp a lot of Cantonese, Mandarin and English. Her vocabularies' bank surprises me sometimes. She utters words like "let's go to washroom", "it is slippery", "forward", "backward", "it is not yours, it's mine." I can work in peace when I leave my girl with RHS.

It is a very difficult choice between TL and RHS.

作者: erikobb823 時間: 15-1-12 13:41 標題: 引用：回覆+luiluibaby+的帖子 Your+analysis+is

原帖由 candeelian 於 15-01-06 發表
回覆 luiluibaby 的帖子

Your analysis is very good.

Hi Candeelian,

My son got an offer from rhs pm class this year, at the same time he also got offer from Pods. At first i am struggling and frustrated about which pn should i choose. From many forums, comments towards rhs are almost positive and highly rated. But at the same time, i appreciate pods教學理念 because this school encourages students to explore and discover. By intense reading scheme, i have heard that students from pods are strong in intellectual thinking and very presentable.

But after i read this post and got comments from several users here, rhs gained back my confidence. Thank you for your positive comments here.

I know rhs is strong in academic in general. For their pn class, can students get enough support for reading and learning engligh?

作者: candeelian 時間: 15-1-13 10:22

回覆 erikobb823 的帖子

Hi Erikobb823,

While I am not a user of Pods, I can tell you my experience with RHS and why I selected it in the first place. It has been my first choice all along.

First, RHS is all-round in language, not only in English. Honestly, it is easier to learn English than Chinese. RHS focuses on both languages. Apart from Cantonese, Mandarin and English, the children will have exposure in Spanish in K1. So, the children's language potential can be stimulated. I was given a lot of English books in the first quarter of PN. They started to learn phonics (starts from a, b, c) step by step. They have two English teachers in a class. To answer your question, I find the support in learning English is very sufficient. My child can flexibly apply English in her daily life. Yesterday, she saw a picture with her footprints. She said "it's footprints." I am quite amazed that she learns this word and I don't remember when I have taught her this word.

In sum, I am pleased with RHS' English learning environment.

Second, they also encourage the children to explore themselves. There are projects regularly to let the child to present their ideas, after having worked with the parents at home. They will bring back to school the homework and present it in front of the class. My child says she loves going to school every day.

Third, their campus is huge. It gives a lot of space to let the children to run around and stretch themselves.

Last but not least, the teacher-parents' communication is unmatchable by other school. The teacher whatsapp us on nearly daily basis about our children's behaviour, weekly communication book where the parents can write their thoughts about the children to the teacher and the teacher will feedback to us, handbook with weekly curriculum and quarterly parent's meeting to get a thorough update of our children. My sister looked at all the materials I have and was very impressed by this school. She said she had never received such caring during her kindergarten at St. Paul's Convent School. Both my sister and I attended that school. My sister is very strong in academic and is a Cambridge graduate. What she said has some value to me.

In any case, I am still undecided between RHS and True Light.

作者: Susu922 時間: 15-1-13 11:43

candeelian 發表於 15-1-13 10:22
回覆 erikobb823 的帖子

Hi Erikobb823,

Since both you and your kid like RHS so much, why would you even consider a transfer? For an unpromised possible primary slot that you may eventually decide not to take in the end, and at the risk of your kid being exposed to an unknown/unfamiliar environment?

I am not related to either RHS or True Light. But if I were you, I would not transfer unless I am not satisfied with the current school or if the benefit of such transfer is significant.

作者: candeelian 時間: 15-1-13 11:47

回覆 Susu922 的帖子

but everyone knows applying to primary school is a torturing and stressful process.
TL's primary and secondary school is good.
It is natural for people to choose a through-train school.
Hence, that's the struggle.

作者: dragonb2012 時間: 15-1-15 08:21 標題: 引用：回覆+erikobb823+的帖子 Hi+Erikobb823,Wh

原帖由 candeelian 於 15-01-13 發表
回覆 erikobb823 的帖子

Hi Erikobb823,

Haha, Im also a cambridge graduate. I went to rhs kindergarten and primary school.

作者: sakbbjaijai 時間: 15-1-15 09:42 標題: 回覆：求各位指點: 堅道真光，玫瑰崗點選擇？

rhs 英文語境會好D, 堅真聽講每日有NET 20 mins 英文堂，坑真就 30 mins NET 英文堂 per week, 英文來講rhs 稍勝，但小學的話，真小一定好過玫小，堅真同坑真其實話就唔係100%, 其實到最後好高%入返，而且堅真的話，siblings 係有優先的，就算唔係穩入，都一定比無家姐哥哥讀的大機會。所以，如果你想避開小一呢場硬仗，又ok 真小的話，就真光。如果你覺得develop better language foundation 比升小更重要的話，可能rhs 會好DD....當然，如果你小朋友無論讀邊間都會出外補習的話，咁真光就最好了，又有學卷，又升小唔洗煩，你又唔洗擔心佢英文會差。

作者: candeelian 時間: 15-1-15 10:28

回覆 sakbbjaijai 的帖子

Thanks for your advice. It is really helpful.

作者: candeelian 時間: 15-1-15 10:29

回覆 dragonb2012 的帖子

That means RHS's foundation is quite good. Thanks for your information.

作者: dragonb2012 時間: 15-1-15 12:40 標題: 回覆：candeelian 的帖子

F.1 syllabus is a repetition of what i learnt in p.6

作者: candeelian 時間: 15-1-15 14:22

回覆 dragonb2012 的帖子

which school did you go to for secondary?

作者: erikobb823 時間: 15-1-16 00:56 標題: 引用：回覆+erikobb823+的帖子 Hi+Erikobb823,Wh

原帖由 candeelian 於 15-01-13 發表
回覆 erikobb823 的帖子

Hi Erikobb823,

Candeelian, I am very impressed by your reply, it's so detail, covering many aspects that I concerned and emphasized.

More questions i would like to ask…

In your second point, you mentioned rhs has some projects which require parents' help to complete with students and they have to bring back those projects to school and present their ideas in front of the class...may i know what kinds of "project" they are usually asked to do? Can you give me few examples?

Besides, i heard that parents-teachers communication is very close in rhs. What is the ratio of teacher:student in your existing pn class? Do you think caring or attention from teachers to each students are adequate? My boy is quite active and aggressive, to certain extent i think he likes to perform and "show off", so i dont think he would be neglected in the class anyway, but in such small age like pn, i prefer to have small class(ratio). Whether teachers are caring and kind-hearted, is what i concern the most, more than how many qualification or education cert that rhs teachers had obtained.

作者: dragonb2012 時間: 15-1-16 08:03 標題: 回覆：candeelian 的帖子

A top band 1 girls' school on hk island, then got a full scholarship to cambridge

作者: candeelian 時間: 15-1-16 14:19

回覆 dragonb2012 的帖子

I see. same as my sister. I went to U.K. and attended Cambridge's rival university, O 記.
That aside, are you trying to bring out that RHS has given you a solid foundation?

作者: candeelian 時間: 15-1-16 14:38

回覆 erikobb823 的帖子

Hi Erikobb823,

Since my girl has just started school for the 1st term, I have one project so far. It was about how to deliver a raw egg to the school safely without breaking the egg. I have to explain to my girl what I did to protect the egg. She has to present the method in front of other children. On a weekly basis, she has homework once a week. The homework is parent-and-child activity that you could do it together with your child.

There are 25-26 students a class with one class teacher, two English teachers, one assistant and one Mandarin teacher. The caring from my class teacher is very sufficient. Probably, my class teacher is one of the best in the school. She is very caring to my child to things as little as how many clothes my child put on to how to hold a pen correctly. She notised my girl is quiet while she understands everything. The teacher will encourage my child to go out and present her ideas. During our last parents' meeting, she told me I can boost my girl's maths as the school is not very strong in this area. She gave me a thorough review of my child's development more than I am aware of my child.

作者: erikobb823 時間: 15-1-16 15:30 標題: 引用：回覆+erikobb823+的帖子 Hi+Erikobb823,Si

原帖由 candeelian 於 15-01-16 發表
回覆 erikobb823 的帖子

Hi Erikobb823,

Thank you Candeelian, after reading your comments, I feel much more relax and comfortable about my planning to put my boy to Rhs instead of pods.

Dragon, what's your comment towards rhs? Did u put your daughters to this kinder?

作者: dragonb2012 時間: 15-1-16 19:36 標題: 回覆：erikobb823 的帖子

I'm forever grateful for the strong foundation built by rhs in my early years. My classmates were very competitive and many of them ended up in top notch secondary schools and became quite successful. That said, the bottom 25pc had to stay in rhs secondary. My daughter is attending pn in the coming year and i trust she will be equipped with whatever is required when graduating and there wont be any pain catching up wherever we chooses to leave rhs. That gives me comfort because I'm a working mum. .

作者: caroljoyful 時間: 15-1-16 23:08 標題: 回覆：candeelian 的帖子

Thanks for your comments abt rhs. My girl s going to rhs pn class in the cuming sept. I usually hear ppl saying that rhs is good in acadamic, but for the teachers' quality, caring, patience..... Ppl rarely comment. This makes me kind of worry abt.
Apart from your the-best-class teacher, do u know that whether other parents hv the close relationship with their class teachers too? The whtsapp thing s a compulsory?
So lucky to hv a great pn class teacher since the child s so young to sch and i think it s really important to meet some gd teachers so that the child likes going to sch
Thx again

作者: caroljoyful 時間: 15-1-17 09:16

本帖最後由 caroljoyful 於 15-1-17 09:28 編輯

wrong msg

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)