教育王國

標題: Kv vs Sc [打印本頁]

作者: nor.nat. 時間: 14-12-11 19:11 標題: Kv vs Sc

請問大家
Kv am vs SC am
應該點揀？

作者: nor.nat. 時間: 14-12-11 19:15 標題: 回覆：Kv vs Sc

邊間會有世襲？

作者: TsurugaRen 時間: 14-12-11 19:29

I have to decide between these two as well. I am still debating the pros and cons but I think I will make my choice based on my child's character.

My child is super active and strong-willed (or down right stubborn) , but very shy in front of strangers. I like SC cos it can boost my child's confidence and presentation skills. However KV is famous for decipline which my child really needs to improve as well.

作者: nor.nat. 時間: 14-12-11 19:34 標題: 引用：I+have+to+decide+between+these+two+as+we

原帖由 TsurugaRen 於 14-12-11 發表
I have to decide between these two as well. I am still debating the pros and cons but I think I will ...

同我個囡都好相似！活潑好動型！
係未sc 無咁谷，會開心啲呢？

作者: TheaHong 時間: 14-12-11 19:40

回覆 TsurugaRen 的帖子

My daughter share the same character, althought my son study at KV but my husband and I also think SC much more suitable for my daughter character indeed^^

作者: nor.nat. 時間: 14-12-11 19:54 標題: 引用：回覆+TsurugaRen+的帖子 My+daughter+shar

原帖由 TheaHong 於 14-12-11 發表
回覆 TsurugaRen 的帖子

My daughter share the same character, althought my son study at KV but my hu ...

想問KV既家長洗唔洗經常陪讀？我同先生工作都幾忙，所以担心無時間跟功課

作者: nor.nat. 時間: 14-12-11 19:56 標題: 引用：回覆+TsurugaRen+的帖子 My+daughter+shar

原帖由 TheaHong 於 14-12-11 發表
回覆 TsurugaRen 的帖子

My daughter share the same character, althought my son study at KV but my hu ...

我諗每天最多跟到一個鐘多少少！

作者: bubuG 時間: 14-12-11 20:00 標題: 引用：Quote:原帖由+TheaHong+於+14-12-11+發表回

原帖由 nor.nat. 於 14-12-11 發表
想問KV既家長洗唔洗經常陪讀？我同先生工作都幾忙，所以担心無時間跟功課

...

陪養閱讀習慣是每個家長也應該做的。

作者: BBking07 時間: 14-12-11 20:17 標題: 引用：邊間會有世襲？ +

原帖由 nor.nat. 於 14-12-11 發表
邊間會有世襲？

kv 通常細佬妹好大機會收返

作者: BBking07 時間: 14-12-11 20:19 標題: 引用：Quote:原帖由+TheaHong+於+14-12-11+發表回

原帖由 nor.nat. 於 14-12-11 發表
想問KV既家長洗唔洗經常陪讀？我同先生工作都幾忙，所以担心無時間跟功課

...

kv 向來出名train 到小朋友自理功課

作者: TheaHong 時間: 14-12-11 20:34

KV k2 開始多功課,不過佢地train 到可以自己做然後家長check, 不過每週默書要溫習,雙職家長真的不須要太多的參與! 但Net 不夠,英文要補,中數很强,多看書和做paper 便ok^^

作者: TheaHong 時間: 14-12-11 20:40

回覆 nor.nat. 的帖子

My daughter on waiting list for KV, I can say she perform very well during the interview, even better than SC interview,But SC admit her, 所以真係學校會選適合的小朋友。緣份嚟嘅 KV and SC both are very good school.

作者: rai_fc 時間: 14-12-11 21:28

回覆 TsurugaRen 的帖子

My son character is very similar to your girl. I also have these two offers, but most likely I will stick to SC.I truly believe both are good schools. Just my guts tell more SC may be more suitable.

作者: conniemar 時間: 14-12-11 21:35 標題: 回覆：Kv vs Sc

我大女讀sc 已畢業，現讀津小小一。細女現讀kv k1。我嘅感受係sc 比kv 多好多需要家長參與嘅功課和project. 開心學習，語境良好，但課程不夠應付小一，暑假需要惡補。相對kv 細女在做功課，閱讀及認字咭都很獨立，現在已能認讀30+中文字。我慶幸細女選讀kv , 我才有時間跟大女功課和溫習。所以真係好睇你想培養小朋友那方面的能力和將升讀什麼小學。

作者: fishyee 時間: 14-12-11 22:24 標題: 回覆：conniemar 的帖子

我都有SC，係咪上小一真係吃力D？但又可以培養到閱讀習慣，真係有好有唔好

作者: bubuG 時間: 14-12-11 22:32 標題: 回覆：Kv vs Sc

兩間學校在九龍塘䇄立幾十年，必有其優點。揀其中一間也不會錯。恭喜！

作者: yeunglps 時間: 14-12-11 23:11

其實真是好視乎你小朋友的性格和你想,他過一些咩的幼稚園生活，各幼稚園各有所長，都是好好的學校。我可以分享下我之前的考慮，我大女當時亦有K V am & S C pm offer,我知道K V是train小朋友服從，聽,教聽話，將幼稚園學生train到好似小學生咁，所以K V的学生非常適應小學的生活，但唸深一層，為何小小年纪，明明是幼稚園學生，應該充滿好奇心去探索身邊的事，去認,識为甚麼植物會長高、蘋果切開會變色……等，但偏偏我們要他們努力學寫字、學計數、學做一個小學生，所以我想,我的小朋友擁有一個幼稚園學生應有的幼稚園生活，最终我揀了S C,而我囡囡亦很開心很有自信咁成長，亦考到最想入的小學。此乃我個人的抉擇，每人都有不同考慮，要想想自己最想要乜，揀一間適合自己小朋友的学校。希望你揀到心儀理想的幼稚園啦！

作者: creama 時間: 14-12-11 23:21 標題: 回覆：Kv vs Sc

個人意見，St cat! 你見咁多名人揀sc就知，同埋要考慮一個因素，kv我有聽過跟唔上要留級，sc就少d. 另外如果你想入私校同直資，sc培育到小朋友自信心同表現自己，sc成功率應大d, 而kv學術重d, 叩津小可能受歡迎d。

作者: bbalau 時間: 14-12-11 23:25 標題: 引用：個人意見，St+cat!+你見咁多名人揀sc就知，

原帖由 creama 於 14-12-11 發表
個人意見，St cat! 你見咁多名人揀sc就知，同埋要考慮一個因素，kv我有聽過跟唔上要留級，sc就少d. 另外如 ...

留班？未聽過。

作者: bubuG 時間: 14-12-11 23:32 標題: 引用：個人意見，St+cat!+你見咁多名人揀sc就知，

原帖由 creama 於 14-12-11 發表
個人意見，St cat! 你見咁多名人揀sc就知，同埋要考慮一個因素，kv我有聽過跟唔上要留級，sc就少d. 另外如 ...

學校唔會叫人留班呀？報小一要適齡十分㗎。除非嗰個係細B啦。

作者: creama 時間: 14-12-11 23:37 標題: 引用：Quote:原帖由+creama+於+14-12-11+發表個人

原帖由 bubuG 於 14-12-11 發表
學校唔會叫人留班呀？報小一要適齡十分㗎。除非嗰個係細B啦。

而家好多幼稚園會留班的，我身邊有個朋友讀救世軍，k2都有同學留班，我喺呢度刨左幾年文，都有家長講過。

作者: Margaret66 時間: 14-12-11 23:40 標題: 引用：回覆+nor.nat.+的帖子 My+daughter+on+wai

原帖由 TheaHong 於 14-12-11 發表
回覆 nor.nat. 的帖子

My daughter on waiting list for KV, I can say she perform very well during the ...

do u know others have same situation as you even their brother or sister study in KV but still got waiting only?

作者: keep-calm 時間: 14-12-11 23:46 標題: 引用：I+have+to+decide+between+these+two+as+we

原帖由 TsurugaRen 於 14-12-11 發表
I have to decide between these two as well. I am still debating the pros and cons but I think I will ...

Same struggle here.....

作者: keep-calm 時間: 14-12-11 23:49 標題: 引用：我大女讀sc+已畢業，現讀津小小一。細女現

原帖由 conniemar 於 14-12-11 發表
我大女讀sc 已畢業，現讀津小小一。細女現讀kv k1。我嘅感受係sc 比kv 多好多需要家長參與嘅功課和project. ...

功課方面KV是否比較多抄寫？SC比較多專題報告（需家長協助）？

作者: Gooblovebb 時間: 14-12-11 23:53 標題: 引用：Quote:原帖由+TheaHong+於+14-12-11+發表回

原帖由 Margaret66 於 14-12-11 發表
do u know others have same situation as you even their brother or sister study in KV but still got w ...

我仔剛KV畢業，宜家小一，阿女就waiting, 不過講真我都覺阿女性格不太適合KV，所以學校都幾識揀

作者: Margaret66 時間: 14-12-12 00:02 標題: 引用：Quote:原帖由+Margaret66+於+14-12-11+發表

原帖由 Gooblovebb 於 14-12-11 發表
我仔剛KV畢業，宜家小一，阿女就waiting, 不過講真我都覺阿女性格不太適合KV，所以學校都幾識揀

...

Thx for your reply ! my daughter is in k2 and i still not yet received the KV letter for my younger son...i feel a bit nervous because he got waiting for SC only

作者: ka@bb 時間: 14-12-12 00:06 標題: 引用：我大女讀sc+已畢業，現讀津小小一。細女現

原帖由 conniemar 於 14-12-11 發表
我大女讀sc 已畢業，現讀津小小一。細女現讀kv k1。我嘅感受係sc 比kv 多好多需要家長參與嘅功課和project. ...

請問st.cat多唔多參觀活動或特別活動？

作者: 99dogdog 時間: 14-12-12 01:20

我都在選擇中，阿女比較活躍好動，感覺SC比較適合；只怕中文較弱，升小一會吃力啲！

作者: TheaHong 時間: 14-12-12 02:48

回覆 Margaret66 的帖子

Yes, even brother or sister study at KV doesnt gaurantee a place for the younger child. I think KV really know what kind of children they want. Even my daughter do well, I am sure many applicant do brilliant too! So the one last thing I ask myself, is that the most suitable school for my child. I really admire and trust the teacher in KV, they are so experience to pick the most suitable one for their school.
Although my girl on waitlist and might not able to get a seat, but I truely thank them to teach my son so well. They give me lots of valuable advice, and my son, my husband and I really love the school very much. My daughter is a bit disappointed not able to go to the same school as her brother.

作者: rai_fc 時間: 14-12-12 07:06

My elder son graduated from SC and now in P1 as well. He actually adopted well in p1 without problem and he is the class monitor. His Chinese standard is enough for P1 ( I give me extra exercise myself) but really not the best in class. I need to say that the best student in his class in terms of academic is from KV.
Really... Both SC and KV are good schools.

作者: MrBeast 時間: 14-12-12 07:41

fishyee 發表於 14-12-11 22:24
我都有SC，係咪上小一真係吃力D？但又可以培養到閱讀習慣，真係有好有唔好

...

中文或許會吃力少少by comparison.
Isnt life full of compromises?

作者: MrBeast 時間: 14-12-12 07:46

nor.nat. 發表於 14-12-11 19:34
同我個囡都好相似！活潑好動型！
係未sc 無咁谷，會開心啲呢？

我覺得sc係會開心d，不過好動的又唔一定代表kv 唔適合。如你工作忙，我會建議kv, 另外可考慮埋target 什麼小學。

作者: H小B媽 時間: 14-12-12 07:57 標題: 引用：Quote:nor.nat.+發表於+14-12-11+19:34+同

原帖由 MrBeast 於 14-12-12 發表
我覺得sc係會開心d，不過好動的又唔一定代表kv 唔適合。如你工作忙，我會建議kv, 另外可考慮埋target 什麼 ...

想問KV會適合邊啲小學/受邊類小學歡迎？

作者: kim107 時間: 14-12-12 08:10 標題: 回覆：Margaret66 的帖子

Here. I am the one. My elder daught graduated at KV, therefore, my younger son in waiting list this year.

作者: bebe26 時間: 14-12-12 08:55

Is it really more homework in KV?? The English is not as good as SC? Have any net teacher or daily English class? Personally, both SC & KV are good school for developing kids. I'm struggle in which school is more suitable for my son who is active and good in English.

作者: MrBeast 時間: 14-12-12 09:18

H小B媽發表於 14-12-12 07:57
想問KV會適合邊啲小學/受邊類小學歡迎？

Both kv and sc 都受小學歡迎，其實大校咁多學生，不能保證考小一一定ok，但我見在6月小一叩門階段有某程度優勢。
兩間各有特色，kv 上傳統官津小學較易適應。

作者: keep-calm 時間: 14-12-12 09:35 標題: 引用：Quote:H小B媽+發表於+14-12-12+07:57+想問K

原帖由 MrBeast 於 14-12-12 發表
Both kv and sc 都受小學歡迎，其實大校咁多學生，不能保證考小一一定ok，但我見在6月小一叩門階段有某程度 ...

6月小一叩門：官津會prefer KV多D嗎？直私會prefer SC 多嗎？

作者: MrBeast 時間: 14-12-12 12:46

keep-calm 發表於 14-12-12 09:35
6月小一叩門：官津會prefer KV多D嗎？直私會prefer SC 多嗎？

直C最主要都係睇面試表現，同kg 沒直接關係，當然程度和教學摸式會有幫助，直覺上sc會好d，不過身邊也有讀KV朋友考到dxs, cky, yw, etc.
至於叩門，我沒有complete picture, 只能說兩間都好

作者: 艾文兒B 時間: 14-12-12 13:11 標題: 回覆：Kv vs Sc

我同係一樣，已決定選sc am,明天註冊去

作者: nor.nat. 時間: 14-12-12 13:47 標題: 回覆：Kv vs Sc

多謝大家意見！我囡係丶好動型，總合大家意見！我估SC係首選！因小學想考直資或私校！

作者: creama 時間: 14-12-12 13:51 標題: 回覆：Kv vs Sc

其實如果爬返以前d文，sc call waiting係少過kv好多，呢d係家長嘅選擇，兩間都係名幼，考小成績亦好好，只不過以小朋友仍keep住快樂自由的童年來考慮，sc真係稍勝。

作者: kleeeenex 時間: 14-12-12 13:54

Same here, KV am v.s. SC am, will choose SC anyway. Will notify KV after tomorrow's registration. Good luck to all in waiting list

作者: gv2009 時間: 14-12-12 13:57

Same here, will probably choose sc, see u gals tmr ~~

作者: jcpama 時間: 14-12-12 15:11

For me, KV waiing, but also think that teachers had chosen the most suitable candidates they want, 我個仔答問題太有創意,not the type they want.

作者: mamath 時間: 14-12-12 16:48

yeunglps 發表於 14-12-11 23:11
其實真是好視乎你小朋友的性格和你想,他過一些咩的幼稚園生活，各幼稚園各有所長，都是好好的學校。我可以 ...

I have KV offer and my son is studying PN in another good KG. I share your view and therefore am more inclined to decline KV based on the characters of my son. I know KV offers are rare but we should pick a school suitable for our kids, not the most popular ones.

My son is already a rather quiet and disciplined one. So the advantages of KV discipline may not be much useful to his case, while I want to boost his presentation and level of confidence. Besides, I don't want to load him with much homework and tests/quiz too early..... I hope I will make a right choice.

作者: nor.nat. 時間: 14-12-12 20:59 標題: 回覆：Kv vs Sc

大明天見！

作者: jason1978 時間: 14-12-12 21:59 標題: 回覆：Kv vs Sc

學校真係識揀啱佢哋嘅學生：大仔見sc時反問老師問題。到細仔見sc時佢以“唔答”去答老師問題

兩個都係第一輪正取生

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)