教育王國

標題: 小學坐校車可以倾計嗎? [打印本頁]

作者: sarachk 時間: 14-11-24 13:29 標題: 小學坐校車可以倾計嗎?

以前細個果陣都可以, 但阿仔間學校唔可以, 會寫家課册。你哋可以嗎?

作者: chanwendy 時間: 14-11-24 14:28

可以, 但太嘈保姆會鬧的.

作者: kenwong888 時間: 14-11-24 15:59

sarachk 發表於 14-11-24 13:29
以前細個果陣都可以, 但阿仔間學校唔可以, 會寫家課册。你哋可以嗎?

I think the school may abuse her authority right?
It is the children right to chat provided that they are not affecting others right?

作者: marcuscyrus 時間: 14-11-24 19:38 標題: 引用：以前細個果陣都可以,+但阿仔間學校唔可以,+

原帖由 sarachk 於 14-11-24 發表
以前細個果陣都可以, 但阿仔間學校唔可以, 會寫家課册。你哋可以嗎?

我主動叫啲仔唔好傾阿，佢地一開始係傾，傾傾下就玩，如果我係司機都會覺得好騷擾阿

作者: Carsonsh 時間: 14-11-24 19:44 標題: 回覆:小學坐校車可以倾計嗎?

有乜理由要班小朋友坐校巴唔出聲，可以叫小朋友唔好太大聲，但唔可以唔畀佢哋傾計，如果係，我一定會向學校反映

作者: Jane1983 時間: 14-11-24 19:55

其實我都吾明所謂吾准傾計，係吾准大聲嘈，定係完全吾准傾計。吾准太嘈，可以理解，完全吾准傾，係幾吾合理的，又吾係上緊堂。

小朋友係獨立和需要尊重的小人兒，要教導，但佢地吾係犯人。

作者: MrBeast 時間: 14-11-24 20:14

如果太嘈影響c機叔叔不能專心架駛導致意外，咁又點睇呢？

作者: kenwong888 時間: 14-11-24 20:19

本帖最後由 kenwong888 於 14-11-24 20:20 編輯

MrBeast 發表於 14-11-24 20:14
如果太嘈影響c機叔叔不能專心架駛導致意外，咁又點睇呢？

How about I ban you from talking with your friends in public transport like mini-bus?
I can also say you and your friends disturbing the driver woo!

作者: chunheimama 時間: 14-11-24 21:40

細細聲可以.

作者: IloveJJ 時間: 14-11-24 22:24 標題: 引用：以前細個果陣都可以,+但阿仔間學校唔可以,+

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: sarachk 時間: 14-11-24 22:40 標題: 回覆：小學坐校車可以倾計嗎

thanks各位, 我都覺得倾計係正常社交。

作者: MrBeast 時間: 14-11-25 04:44

kenwong888 發表於 14-11-24 20:19
How about I ban you from talking with your friends in public transport like mini-bus?
I can also sa ...

In japan, passenges r not allowed to talk on the phones while travelling on the train. Have u ever been inside a bus w a bunch of yelling kids? Its horrible.
i agree its probabaly too harsh to prohibit talking completely.

作者: kenwong888 時間: 14-11-25 06:38

本帖最後由 kenwong888 於 14-11-25 06:40 編輯

MrBeast 發表於 14-11-25 04:44
In japan, passenges r not allowed to talk on the phones while travelling on the train. Have u ever b ...

The issue Is that the train is so congested while talking to phone may divert people attention and cause danger!
It is totally irrelevant and off-the-topic!

Oppositely MTR in HK deliberately leaks the mobile phone signals to cover all station area as well as platform and train right? Why?

作者: caa 時間: 14-11-25 07:20

MrBeast 發表於 14-11-25 04:44
In japan, passenges r not allowed to talk on the phones while travelling on the train. Have u ever b ...

Yelling is different from chatting. It is inhuman to forbid people from chatting on bus. Can't imagine what the kids will grow up to be if they are forbidden to develop normal social skills throughout the day, from lessons in school to riding bus. How sad to study in a local school, always being forced to do things against kids nature

作者: kenwong888 時間: 14-11-25 07:28

caa 發表於 14-11-25 07:20
Yelling is different from chatting. It is inhuman to forbid people from chatting on bus. Can't imagi ...

Exactly true!

作者: MrBeast 時間: 14-11-25 08:16

本帖最後由 MrBeast 於 14-11-25 08:18 編輯

caa 發表於 14-11-25 07:20
Yelling is different from chatting. It is inhuman to forbid people from chatting on bus. Can't imagi ...

I agree. Only raise those questions so others can think abt this from diff perspectives. At the end of the day, what defines inhuman is in the mindset and culture.

作者: Jane1983 時間: 14-11-25 08:33

有聽聞搭校車，吾准傾計；有話有d學校，低年班小息吾准玩，一定要留係課室坐；有話學校吾准小朋友跑，操場都吾得...

不過都要睇執行係點，吾一定係傳聞中咁硬咁吾人道。

作者: caa 時間: 14-11-25 08:54

MrBeast 發表於 14-11-25 08:16
I agree. Only raise those questions so others can think abt this from diff perspectives. At the en ...

It is just so normal for any person to want to talk to his/her friend after work or school unless you are talking about countries like North Korea

作者: little_yolky 時間: 14-11-25 09:42

本帖最後由 little_yolky 於 14-11-25 09:43 編輯

sarachk 發表於 14-11-24 13:29
以前細個果陣都可以, 但阿仔間學校唔可以, 會寫家課册。你哋可以嗎?

唔好話傾偈, 打人都得, 我囡囡小一時被膠樽打過。你果間一定唔係國際學校。

作者: MrBeast 時間: 14-11-25 12:29

http://youtu.be/tO4X8_c80kg

大家唔好太認真ar

作者: sarachk 時間: 14-11-25 12:46 標題: 引用：+http://youtu.be/tO4X8_c80kg大家唔好太認

原帖由 MrBeast 於 14-11-25 發表
http://youtu.be/tO4X8_c80kg

大家唔好太認真ar

作者: sweethoho 時間: 14-11-25 13:30 標題: 回覆：小學坐校車可以倾計嗎

幼稚園和小學也可以, 但都不能大聲, 因為會騷擾司機叔叔, 跟車保母也會控制大家秩序! 我小朋友幼稚園時, 如車上有小朋友太曳, 保母會告知班主任和家長呢!

作者: sweethoho 時間: 14-11-25 13:39 標題: 回覆：小學坐校車可以倾計嗎

以前幼稚園, 聽女回來說, 都幾好笑, 有些小朋友帶貼紙上學, 貼在校車玻璃窗或座位, 司機叔叔話下次再發現, 就要幫忙抹窗, 司機又在車上執到很多紙碎, 貼紙, 校車到校後, 就交平日在車上愛玩愛說的其中一人, 不理你是否有份, 我女也試過收到一次, 司機會說, 還返比你們, 我女說不是她的, 司機說交你處理, 我女說回到課室就掉晒垃圾桶, 哈哈…

作者: sarachk 時間: 14-11-25 21:32 標題: 引用：以前幼稚園,+聽女回來說,+都幾好笑,+有些小

原帖由 sweethoho 於 14-11-25 發表
以前幼稚園, 聽女回來說, 都幾好笑, 有些小朋友帶貼紙上學, 貼在校車玻璃窗或座位, 司機叔叔話下次再發現, ...

作者: kenwong888 時間: 14-11-25 22:27

Jane1983 發表於 14-11-25 08:33
有聽聞搭校車，吾准傾計；有話有d學校，低年班小息吾准玩，一定要留係課室坐；有話學校吾准小朋友跑，操場 ...

有話學校吾准小朋友跑 is ok woo!
It prevent the students from bumping and injured!

作者: Jane1983 時間: 14-11-25 23:12

回覆 kenwong888 的帖子

喪跑梗係唔好，但如果學校夠大，在操場少少跑動得吾得，係咪跑吓都會摘名？
返全日、功課多、默書測考密，仲有體藝，學校規矩又嚴又多，這一代人豐衣足食，父母痛愛，但比我果代，真係吾知幸福咗，定痛苦咗！

作者: kenwong888 時間: 14-11-26 06:12

Jane1983 發表於 14-11-25 23:12
回覆 kenwong888 的帖子

喪跑梗係唔好，但如果學校夠大，在操場少少跑動得吾得，係咪跑吓都會摘名？

But General Studies model answer is "running in school is wrong"!

作者: Jane1983 時間: 14-11-26 07:28

回覆 kenwong888 的帖子

Running in school可以是指跑樓梯、在走廊跑、在課室跑，梗係吾啱。
我地吾係咬文嚼字，校規係咁，多數人都要遵守，但學校在執行上如果係鬆d，比到多d空間小朋友。小朋友係要學做人、要教育，有時亦好曳，但真係吾係犯人，無謂太高壓。

作者: nintendo 時間: 14-11-26 08:20

kenwong888 發表於 14-11-25 06:38
The issue Is that the train is so congested while talking to phone may divert people attention and ...

I think the reason no one talks on trains in japan is that, it is politeness not to make people listen to you talk as well. Not sure whether you have this experience in Hong Kong. There are people that talk loudly or even watch online movies or listen to music with the speaker on public transport. I personally find that annoying.

I think it would be quite impossible to make primary school kids not talk on school bus. And also I think it is perfectly ok to talk on school bus, only if they were not too loud. However, it is probably hard for bus mom to judge whether it is "loud". That is probably why the school simply made it a rule that no talking is allowed.

In any case, I do not think talking would really be totally not allowed. If the kids are merely chatting in low voice, I think bus mom would keep her eyes closed. Complain would probably be made if someone speaks loudly or yells.

作者: nintendo 時間: 14-11-26 08:35

sarachk 發表於 14-11-24 13:29
以前細個果陣都可以, 但阿仔間學校唔可以, 會寫家課册。你哋可以嗎?

I was studying in a catholic school in Hong Kong when I was small. Many things were not allowed. No running on school campus, no talking on school bus. I found that unfair, I still think these rules are harsh. However, most of the time, even top students would break these rules. Someone would always tries to run a little bit on campus. Students always talk (mostly in soft voices) on school bus. If I remember, no complaints would be made if the situation is not too serious.
Since you created this topic, have your son been complained about talking on school bus? Well, as a parent, I would simply explain to my child that school rules are school rules. There are probably a lot of rules that we do not agree to. But still, we have to follow the rules.
It is better to be positive towards these things. In any case, I do not think it is a serious matter. Kids would learn from his lessons and be smart next time. There will be more of these little incidents where both kid and parents feel that it is "unfair" in the future. Unless you are able to persuade the school to change their rules to meet your needs, I guess we have to follow. So why not simply be more positive.

作者: kenwong888 時間: 14-11-26 09:18

本帖最後由 kenwong888 於 14-11-26 09:19 編輯

nintendo 發表於 14-11-26 08:20
I think the reason no one talks on trains in japan is that, it is politeness not to make people li ...

One hand we need ecouraging children to establish their social and communications (oral) skill!

One hand the school prohibit the students to chat with school-mates in bus!

Interesting right?

作者: sarachk 時間: 14-11-26 09:41 標題: 引用：Quote:sarachk+發表於+14-11-24+13:29+以前

原帖由 nintendo 於 14-11-26 發表
I was studying in a catholic school in Hong Kong when I was small. Many things were not allowed. No ...

yes, i asked my son to follow the rules coz the teacher will put a remark in his handbook. i studied 3 well reputated catholic primary schools before. None of them were so strict b4.

作者: MrBeast 時間: 14-11-26 09:51

The pt is to explain the rationals behind these rules.

作者: kenwong888 時間: 14-11-26 09:53

Let's say to reflect this out-dated rule in the 家教會 meeting!

作者: MrBeast 時間: 14-11-27 08:28

kenwong888 發表於 14-11-26 06:12
But General Studies model answer is "running in school is wrong"!

Perhaps this is the reason
http://www.edu-kingdom.com/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=2954537&extra=page%3D1

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)