教育王國
標題: 讀醫成績 [打印本頁]
作者: 20072010 時間: 14-4-15 17:00 標題: 讀醫成績
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: ChiChiPaPa 時間: 14-4-15 21:06 標題: 引用：請問能成功入讀醫科的學生DSE或AL通常詳成
本帖最後由 ChiChiPaPa 於 14-4-15 21:58 編輯
原帖由 20072010 於 14-04-15 發表
請問能成功入讀醫科的學生DSE或AL通常詳成績?
港大醫學院計4C+2X，上年最低收37分。即係等於一科5**五科5*或三科5**一科5*兩科5。
這只是最低。即係取得37分，都不一定入得到。
要入醫學院，每科目標都要定在5**，那樣一、二科些微失手，都重有望入到。
注：2012 - 36, 2013 - 37, 2014 - 未知
作者: Shinyma 時間: 14-4-15 21:22
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: ngwong2 時間: 14-4-23 11:37
要求5科要有5**
作者: judy 時間: 14-4-23 11:44
其實真係唔需要咁高。只要看一看每年有多少3A，有多少4**就知。以前3A入港大2A入中大穩陣。
作者: ANChan59 時間: 14-4-23 14:09
ChiChiPaPa 發表於 14-4-15 21:06 
港大醫學院計4C+2X，上年最低收37分。即係等於一科5**五科5*或三科5**一科5*兩科5。
這只是最低。即係取 ...
I don't think 37 is the min., lower than that.
作者: ANChan59 時間: 14-4-23 14:32 標題: 引用：+本帖最後由+ChiChiPaPa+於+14-4-15+21:58+
原帖由 ChiChiPaPa 於 14-04-15 發表
本帖最後由 ChiChiPaPa 於 14-4-15 21:58 編輯
作者: 73662710 時間: 14-4-23 15:13
本帖最後由 73662710 於 14-4-23 15:15 編輯
HKU: 4 + 2X: minimum 36.
CU: 4 +3x (M1/M2 taken into account in some cases): cut-off line for interview 41 ( several candidates with 40.5 were admitted because of prior good interview performance before the disclosure of DSE results, recommended by their school principals )
作者: ANChan59 時間: 14-4-23 15:23
73662710 發表於 14-4-23 15:13
HKU: 4 + 2X: minimum 36.
CU: 4 +3x (M1/M2 taken into account in some cases): cut-off line for interv ...
作者: 73662710 時間: 14-4-23 15:26
本帖最後由 73662710 於 14-4-23 15:28 編輯
Medical schools only gave offers in the main round of jupas, they sometimes admit candidates who appeal successfully in their dse results, eg. from 40 upgraded to 41, after satisfactory interview performance. Any vacancies arising because some students give up will be relocated to non-jupas. But usually only very rarely is a place given up and so these places can easily be filled up by the appealing case. Thus, medical schools probaly never admit students in the left over round as the good students are already admitted by their 2nd choices in the jupas.
作者: ANChan59 時間: 14-4-23 15:59
73662710 發表於 14-4-23 15:26
Medical schools only gave offers in the main round of jupas, they sometimes admit candidates who app ...
I am more familiar with NJ, as some students can have more than one offers.
作者: JuiceMum 時間: 14-4-30 11:23
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: yukimum 時間: 14-4-30 13:45
http://www.als.hku.hk/admission/ ... HKDSE-Scores-13.pdf
作者: judy 時間: 14-4-30 15:44
去年，以6科最高25%, 50%, 最低25%和最低分數計：
港大: 39,38,37,36.
中大*:37,36,35 (中大無公佈最低分).
以最高25%分計，港大39分，平均6.5, 即3科5**，3科5*。中大37分，平均6,17, 即1科5**，5科5* 即可。所以，兩大醫科收生不是傳說咁高。
今年，港大公佈會收75%DSE學生，我預計收生大致都係(39,38,37,36)。中大話唔設限，大概也是(37,36,35)咁上下，别忘記佢冇公佈最低分數，分分鐘33,34都人到。34即多少:5個5*加两個5。
注：中大公佈7科，港大公佈6科，為方便此較，一律以6科計。
作者: msj 時間: 14-5-2 01:40
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: judy 時間: 14-5-2 10:04
cu medic cut-off score for interview was 41. Theoretically the lowest possible score of 4+2x was 34 + 5** for the 3rd subject.
Without a third subject, a student with a score of 40 (4 個5** 2個5*） was not even granted a chance for an interview. It is quite brainless to state that a student with 33, 34 can be admitted to medicine.
根据考評局出版的2013年成績，考获5科5*嘅成績大有795人。34分，即5個5*加两個5，唔係小嘢。别忘記唔係人人都想考"神科"，别忘記唔係人人有考化學等理科。
37,36,35 (最高25%, 50%, 最低25%).係從中大公佈分數計出。我估最低34都合理。
中大公佈7科，港大公佈6科。你估考入港大的第7科或少於中大麽？
作者: Shootastar 時間: 14-5-2 10:15
I am not familiar with JUPAS system, but I suspect that so long as you meet a minimum requirement (for example, 35, 36 or 37), the tie breaker on the lowest group would depend on her facts such as the performance in the interview and his/her passion on medicine.
作者: judy 時間: 14-5-2 10:28
讀書，最重要揾最喜歡的。幾年前無人報電腦，但我的做電腦朋友，無不揾到豐厚收入。我有两侄仔讀中大、港大精算，今年實習，晚晚十一點到才回到家中。佢地話，依家做工程嘅，好景過佢地好多。
不過，如要考"神科"的，最好上网自已看資料。DSE係一個好難考嘅試，競爭對手是港人，好多科只有10%左右嘅人考到5嘅成績。考到5己很好，别在這里俾人吓一吓而唔敢報。
作者: ANChan59 時間: 14-5-2 13:25
Shootastar 發表於 14-5-2 10:15
I am not familiar with JUPAS system, but I suspect that so long as you meet a minimum requirement (f ...
CU's calculation is a bit complicated.
********
In GPS, HKDSE 45/47 base on 7 subjects. IB, 44/45 base on IBDP. Reasonable comparison.
作者: ANChan59 時間: 14-5-2 13:29
msj 發表於 14-5-2 01:40
cu medic cut-off score for interview was 41. Theoretically the lowest possible score of 4+2x was 34 ...
For 2 electives only, the 3rd elective will be counted as 0, even 40/42, the chance for interview can be 0.
作者: msj 時間: 14-5-2 17:07
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: ACE2126 時間: 14-5-12 03:02
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: ANChan59 時間: 14-5-12 09:37 標題: 引用：請問6科計不計M1/M2?
原帖由 ACE2126 於 14-05-12 發表
請問6科計不計M1/M2?
中大計在第3科選修科，都要看成績是否M1，M2高於第3科，才將兩科平均計算！
作者: ACE2126 時間: 14-5-12 16:46
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: samsam123321 時間: 14-5-12 18:50
ACE2126 發表於 14-5-12 16:46
唉，神科要神人，神人都要拜神。
心臟弱點，膽囊細點都唔店
作者: samsam123321 時間: 14-5-12 18:56
仲有法醫果d 要去睇個人係點死，可能個頭係雪櫃拿返出黎，你要驗下佢點死?錢係賺得多，但你小朋友頂得順?其實如果唔怕，同死人化妝都好賺錢ga,唔使讀咁多書ga
作者: ACE2126 時間: 14-5-12 19:11
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: samsam123321 時間: 14-5-12 19:12
當然，可能真係去到急症專科，外科先要咁做。醫傷風咳的應該唔使。
作者: ACE2126 時間: 14-5-12 19:24
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: samsam123321 時間: 14-5-12 19:39
陰風我想小朋友都接受到，斷手斷腳斷頭我自己都接受唔到，不如大家問下自己仔女做個統計。
作者: samsam123321 時間: 14-5-12 20:10
我想我小朋友連打曱甴都唔敢，就算成績好都讀唔到醫。
作者: ACE2126 時間: 14-5-12 20:17
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: JuiceMum 時間: 14-5-14 11:50
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: JuiceMum 時間: 14-5-14 11:52
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: samsam123321 時間: 14-5-14 12:55
解剖條屍係處理過，基本上無血，無屍味。
但真屍係血淋淋，同有機會有屍味。
作者: judy 時間: 14-5-16 18:06
It is definitely brainless to make a conclusion based on the the score of 4+2x while the requirement is 4+3x. For example, do you think that students with 35+5, 36+4 can be admitted to medicine or not
我凈係話中大 4+2x 的最低分可能是34。根據2013中大嘅出生資料，最低1/4 4+2x 收生為35。
當然，我知道中大收4+3x，但最後一科，應是最差嘅，所以，4+3x.為35+5有咩出奇呢？
港大雖然話收 4+2x，但，佢收生中，有幾多冇考7科呢？佢收生中，有幾多第7科差過中大呢？要知道，成績越好的人，選修越多科。
作者: judy 時間: 14-5-16 18:16
仲有一樣最简單嘅嘢，不過啲人死蠢咁都諗唔到:
想讀醫嘅人，明知中大收4+3x，佢會唔會走去考4+2x 呢？
作者: jessimm 時間: 14-5-16 23:38
本帖最後由 jessimm 於 14-5-17 09:58 編輯
judy 發表於 14-4-30 15:44
去年，以6科最高25%, 50%, 最低25%和最低分數計：
港大: 39,38,37,36.
中大*:37,36,35 (中大無公佈最低分). ...
2013 unsuccessful cases of CUHK medicine
4c+2x 4c+3x interview result
33 39 no Physiotherapy (HKPU)
34 40 yes (school nomination) Dentistry (HKU)
35 41 yes Science (HKU)
36 41.5 yes IFAA/Qfin (CUHK)
It seems that interview performance is so crucial.
作者: qingdynasty 時間: 14-5-21 21:51
本帖最後由 qingdynasty 於 14-5-21 21:52 編輯
For the CUHK medic unsuccessful cases, what are their 3 electives subjects?
作者: jessimm 時間: 14-5-21 22:22
回覆 qingdynasty 的帖子
All of them took phy chem bio. Coincidentally, none of them got 5* or 5** in English
作者: judywan 時間: 14-5-21 22:54
唔知HKU遲啲會唔會又話,讀醫唔使要phy chem bio。
作者: liloNstitch 時間: 14-5-22 11:25
jessimm 發表於 14-5-16 23:38
2013 unsuccessful cases of CUHK medicine
4c+2x 4c+3x interview ...
41.5分 報 MEDICINE, NEXT CHOICE 風馬牛不相及, 呢位同學對MEDICAL FIELD 既 PASSION 有限, 唔收都係岩既
作者: friendlyguy 時間: 14-5-22 11:41
liloNstitch 發表於 14-5-22 11:25
41分讀science超晒班, 浪費左d
41.5分 報 MEDICINE, NEXT CHOICE 風馬牛不相及, 呢位同學對MEDICAL FIELD ...
作者: liloNstitch 時間: 14-5-22 12:01
friendlyguy 發表於 14-5-22 11:41
讀 science，點叻都唔會超班，如果有 passion，唔會浪費。
我意思係~~超晒同佢一齊讀果一班,
科學探索無極限, 我當然唔會認為甘係超班
作者: ANChan59 時間: 14-5-22 16:41 標題: 引用：Quote:friendlyguy+發表於+14-5-22+11:41+
原帖由 liloNstitch 於 14-05-22 發表
我意思係~~超晒同佢一齊讀果一班,
科學探索無極限, 我當然唔會認為甘係超班
作者: annie40 時間: 14-5-22 22:57
最難是「服侍」病人，要非常慈愛的人，才能做到。遊走於非常有同理心，又邏輯性地平常心之間，鬆容包容，非常人也。
作者: talent2000 時間: 14-5-23 03:25
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: talent2000 時間: 14-5-23 23:51
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: qingdynasty 時間: 14-6-22 19:14
回覆 jessimm 的帖子
The official speaker from CU Medic Admission told talk attendants on 21/6 that they admitted ALLcandidates with 41 points while only one with 40.5 was admitted last year. Is your information accurate about 41.5 being rejected or purely a rare case being rejected for "not showing proper attitude to become a good doctor" (as how they put it) or some other reasons?
作者: jessimm 時間: 14-6-22 21:45
回覆 qingdynasty 的帖子
Anyways, there are two successful cases with 35(4c+2x) 41(4c+3x) points being admitted in 2013. One of them took chem/bio/econ, the other took phy/chem/bio. According to the student helper's information delivered yesterday, DSE candidates with 41 points or above are very likely to be given an offer from CU medic provided that the interview performance is satisfactory.
作者: qingdynasty 時間: 14-6-22 22:35
回覆 jessimm 的帖子
Thanks.
作者: youma 時間: 14-6-23 20:43
qingdynasty 發表於 14-6-22 19:14
回覆 jessimm 的帖子
The official speaker from CU Medic Admission told talk attendants on 21/6 that they admitted ALLcandidates with 41 points while only one with 40.5 was admitted last year. Is your information accurate about 41.5 being rejected or purely a rare case being rejected for "not showing proper attitude to become a good doctor" (as how they put it) or some other reasons?
作者: Jilli 時間: 14-6-24 01:11
youma 發表於 14-6-23 20:43
If all candidates with 41 (4C+3X) are admitted, does it mean that CU counts merely academic results ...
I think "All candidates" means the students with 41 (4C+3X) and "satisfactory performance in the interview".
Obviously it is impossible for medic to intake students only by considering the results, esp. CUHK medic which counts more on the interview. In CUHK medic's interview, the format is 2 prof. vs 1 student, which can really test the students' ability to deal with difficulties (prof. like to ask difficult questions and require immediately responds).
Earlier in this post, there is a student with 41.5 (4C+3X) but he is also rejected by CUHK med. I can be sure there are some other cases. In addition, in the old HKALE, even 3A students can be rejected by medic.
Interview maybe isn't really important in other subjects, but is crucial in medic.
| 歡迎光臨 教育王國 (/) |
Powered by Discuz! X1.5 |