教育王國

標題: 維記 vs st cat, 點揀？ [打印本頁]

作者: wailam99 時間: 13-10-18 10:19 標題: 維記 vs st cat, 點揀？

維記 vs st cat, 點揀？因可能面試撞時間

作者: kittyland06 時間: 13-10-18 10:27 標題: 回覆：維記 vs st cat, 點揀？

我覺得兩間都好，St cat 平啲上小學啲 allocation 又好，去 St cat 啦！

作者: breadbb 時間: 13-10-18 10:49 標題: 回覆：維記 vs st cat, 點揀？

我仔校車同學係維記轉去sc架!我諗兩間都好，不過維記仲free d

作者: picture 時間: 13-10-18 11:14 標題: 回覆：維記 vs st cat, 點揀？

Vic advantage over St Cat is putonghua exposure, IMHO, if you don't care about that, St Cat is more favoured by Primary Schools on Kowloon Side

作者: abby0624 時間: 13-10-18 12:49

如果想讀傳統小學，St Cat會適合啲

作者: picture 時間: 13-10-18 12:55 標題: 引用：如果想讀傳統小學，St+Cat會適合啲

原帖由 abby0624 於 13-10-18 發表
如果想讀傳統小學，St Cat會適合啲

Agree ·

作者: jason1978 時間: 13-10-18 13:41

當然SC英普班就更佳

作者: MrBeast 時間: 13-10-18 14:47

Sc.

作者: beautylion 時間: 13-10-18 14:50

選SC, VIC上傳統小一時, 中文追到你氣咳.

作者: bbalau 時間: 13-10-18 15:20 標題: 回覆：維記 vs st cat, 點揀？

維記never on my wish list. Sorry.

作者: achow 時間: 13-10-18 16:05

接駁小學St Cat 會較易適認.
Victoria 過份 free, 小朋友會好開心, 如杲Primary 打算讀國際學校就OK, 但如不是那就要三思.

作者: samchan2179 時間: 13-10-18 19:34 標題: 回覆：wailam99 的帖子

Vic 英文好過Sc ，開心，多活動，如果有錢可以直上小學，之後IB 或國際學校就維記。SC 就local 直資，或傳統名校，sc都開心，但一定無維記咁活動。

作者: wonderland07 時間: 13-10-18 19:41 標題: 回覆：bbalau 的帖子

My daughter had PN offer from both st cat and Victoria last year. I gave up st cat and chose Victoria. My bb enjoys the school very much. I am glad with this decision.

作者: samchan2179 時間: 13-10-18 19:50 標題: 引用：My+daughter+had+PN+offer+from+both+st+ca

原帖由 wonderland07 於 13-10-18 發表
My daughter had PN offer from both st cat and Victoria last year. I gave up st cat and chose Victori ...

My best fd's two kids studied in Vic n they gave up 神級traditional primary school offer n continue to study in Vic primary school n the kids are learning happily. My fd believe his kids can't cope with the workload in 神級primary school

作者: lanjarbi 時間: 13-10-18 20:31 標題: 回覆：維記 vs st cat, 點揀？

可能揰時間，即係未揰啦

作者: joywng 時間: 13-10-18 21:45

我小朋友讀維記pn,進步很大，每天放學都唱歌俾你聽，好開心，朋友嗰仔st cat k1,越讀越退步，現俾老師話佢唔聽話，評語唔好，沒有最好，只有最適合

作者: confidence 時間: 13-10-18 22:16 標題: 引用：我小朋友讀維記pn,進步很大，每天放學都唱

原帖由 joywng 於 13-10-18 發表
我小朋友讀維記pn,進步很大，每天放學都唱歌俾你聽，好開心，朋友嗰仔st cat k1,越讀越退步，現俾老師話佢 ...

Agree agree,要知自己想要乜！其實我相信vic is a good school, p1 allocation good!
但我不会讀，只因太貴

So different kids need different school! I will choose sc

作者: JoyceNgYY 時間: 13-10-18 22:44 標題: 引用：Vic+英文好過Sc+，開心，多活動，如果有錢

原帖由 samchan2179 於 13-10-18 發表
Vic 英文好過Sc ，開心，多活動，如果有錢可以直上小學，之後IB 或國際學校就維記。SC 就local 直資，或傳 ...

我囝係維記，個個月有唔同主題生日會，可以跟主題dress up番學，家長既參與機會又
多，可以睇到自己小朋友既校園生活。始終係細校，佢比到你既野唔係大校可以比到既。例如，開學適應週長達三個星期，期間有多達十名老師照顧14名小朋友，所以，即使有好幾名細b，但好快已經冇人喊。另外，即使到現在，我每日都可以送到佢入課室，係課室出面睇到佢地打鐘上堂唱哂國歌校歌早操歌先走。番咗學幾星期，幾乎所有staff, 連護士姐姐都叫得出我囝個名。順帶一提，IB課程本身係好好，認受性又高，其實一路讀上去個課程一d都唔hea架，但又冇local咁demanding, 所以我同意如果金錢上許可，我覺得可以讀IB 既小朋友真係好幸福 (regardless whether study in Vic or not)。

作者: confidence 時間: 13-10-18 22:57 標題: 回覆：JoyceNgYY 的帖子

Agree agree!!

作者: confidence 時間: 13-10-18 23:01 標題: 回覆：JoyceNgYY 的帖子

How about their chinese ?

Less ?

作者: wonderland07 時間: 13-10-18 23:13 標題: 引用：Quote:原帖由+joywng+於+13-10-18+發表我小

原帖由 confidence 於 13-10-18 發表
Agree agree,要知自己想要乜！其實我相信vic is a good school, p1 allocation good!
但我不会讀，只因太貴 ...

St cat school fees is actually more expensive than Victoria.

作者: confidence 時間: 13-10-18 23:19 標題: 回覆：wonderland07 的帖子

Really? How much each of them

作者: confidence 時間: 13-10-18 23:21 標題: 回覆：wonderland07 的帖子

I Heard vic is quite good! But 9000/month??

作者: confidence 時間: 13-10-18 23:22 標題: 回覆：JoyceNgYY 的帖子

I like ib tooo

作者: Barbayauyau 時間: 13-10-18 23:35 標題: 回覆：confidence 的帖子

Which is IB primary school?

作者: wonderland07 時間: 13-10-18 23:54 標題: 引用：I+Heard+vic+is+quite+good!+But+9000/mont

原帖由 confidence 於 13-10-18 發表
I Heard vic is quite good! But 9000/month??

U can check the school websites. St cat PN class is few hundreds more than Victoria if I remember correctly. Also st cat has other extra fees while Victoria has not

作者: JoyceNgYY 時間: 13-10-19 00:14 標題: 引用：I+Heard+vic+is+quite+good!+But+9000/mont

原帖由 confidence 於 13-10-18 發表
I Heard vic is quite good! But 9000/month??

$9000 is kind of debenture which is refundable with 2 months notice or upon k3 graduated. School fee around $5,xxx per month, 冇其他雜費，包茶點(佢地d茶點仲係一係有機既，一係由美心或嘉頓供應既)。

作者: c-wong 時間: 13-10-19 00:16

Two different schools. If ib choose vic, if traditional primary school must choose sc. In k 2 Vic only a few homeworks each week, vs sc a few homeworks each day. Agree Vic is a happy school with special events and performances.

作者: JoyceNgYY 時間: 13-10-19 00:25 標題: 引用：How+about+their+chinese+? Less++? +

原帖由 confidence 於 13-10-18 發表
How about their chinese ?
Less ?

其實你有興趣可深入研究下，IB裡的 language A 如選擇 take Chinese, 程度一啲都唔淺，當然未必可同DSE比，但掉轉頭英文又勁過DSE啫，始終針無兩頭利，睇您想要咩。

作者: JoyceNgYY 時間: 13-10-19 00:27 標題: 引用：Which+is+IB+primary+school? +

原帖由 Barbayauyau 於 13-10-18 發表
Which is IB primary school?

http://www.ibo.org/school/search/

作者: samchan2179 時間: 13-10-19 02:24 標題: 引用：Quote:原帖由+confidence+於+13-10-18+發表

原帖由 wonderland07 於 13-10-18 發表
U can check the school websites. St cat PN class is few hundreds more than Victoria if I remember co ...

How about k1-3 ?? SC more expansive than Vic????

作者: confidence 時間: 13-10-19 07:20 標題: 回覆：JoyceNgYY 的帖子

Thank you soo much!!!useful information to choose school!!i will try to se hows ib

but i think i like it!!!

作者: confidence 時間: 13-10-19 07:22 標題: 回覆：wonderland07 的帖子

Wow!!!if vic is cheaper…no doubt i will choose vic!!!

作者: confidence 時間: 13-10-19 07:26 標題: 回覆：JoyceNgYY 的帖子

5000 per month is nit too bad!! Many famous school charge that pricr!
By the way is vic international school? Cos i hope my kids can have better chinese in kinder! Thanks!!!

作者: MrBeast 時間: 13-10-19 07:48

Not all vic kgs r created equal and as far as i know, not all of them r ib certified.

作者: picture 時間: 13-10-19 09:58 標題: 引用：I+Heard+vic+is+quite+good!+But+9000/mont

原帖由 confidence 於 13-10-18 發表
I Heard vic is quite good! But 9000/month??

PN 5xxx only

作者: picture 時間: 13-10-19 10:10 標題: 引用：Not+all+vic+kgs+r+created+equal+and+as+f

原帖由 MrBeast 於 13-10-19 發表
Not all vic kgs r created equal and as far as i know, not all of them r ib certified.

All Vic kgs use the same inquires based learning approach but some schools attained certification first.  Others are still working towards it.

Like Woodlands, nit all areMontessori certified but teaching approach is uniform across all campuses.

Agree with other jms that if you don't have the resources to support iB stream learning, you had better choose kindergarten with a more traditional teaching approach.  Afterall, Victoria kids will not trained to be the 受教 type, but rather encouraged to have their own ideas and opinion.  This puts them at disadvantaged position when being interviewed by local traditional primaries.

If money is not a concern, you should pick kindergarten based on the kid's character.

The worst thing that could happen is a mismatch -----putting  a curious eenergiser bunny in a cage or placing a submissive quiet little fellow amongst a bunch of noisy ramping monsters.

作者: JoyceNgYY 時間: 13-10-19 11:05 標題: 回覆：samchan2179 的帖子

for Vic in kowloon campus, K1 - K3 is around $4900 per month, versus SC K1 around $4200 per month and K2 - K3 around $4600 respectively. I would say two school fees are more or less the same as Vic don't have many other fees to pay, and include 茶點費 as well, which I know SC doesn't included.

作者: MrBeast 時間: 13-10-19 11:18

picture 發表於 13-10-19 10:10
All Vic kgs use the same inquires based learning approach but some schools attained certification fi ...

I agreed, if target vic ps or is, then vic kg is a good choice.

作者: JoyceNgYY 時間: 13-10-19 11:21 標題: 引用：5000+per+month+is+nit+too+bad!!+Many+fam

原帖由 confidence 於 13-10-19 發表
5000 per month is nit too bad!! Many famous school charge that pricr!
By the way is vic internation ...

Vic is not an international school, it just a private school. If u have concerns on Chinese, may be you can consider to apply 英普班，they have native mandarin speaking teacher as class teacher.

作者: confidence 時間: 13-10-19 11:30 標題: 回覆：JoyceNgYY 的帖子

Oh…i thought they are international school!thank you for let me know

作者: samchan2179 時間: 13-10-19 11:35 標題: 回覆：JoyceNgYY 的帖子

No 茶點費for sc as kids bring their own snack

作者: wonderland07 時間: 13-10-19 14:11 標題: 回覆：samchan2179 的帖子

Victoria provide snacks without extra payment

作者: lalawowo 時間: 13-10-20 06:32 標題: 回覆：維記 vs st cat, 點揀？

My kid studies at Vic k1 now and i am not worried about his p1 allocation even i m targeting for traditional school. He is v. presentable and can master v well the eng, pth, even we just speak cantonese mainly at home. I m definitely vote for Vic if anyone ask for my opinion. My kid has chinese n maths homework everyday but still hv nothing for eng. He is so outspoken that he could ask (in eng n pth) for what he wants at restaurants/shops when we travel abroad. I think for a kid just turned 3, this is amazing!

作者: picture 時間: 13-10-20 19:21 標題: 引用：My+kid+studies+at+Vic+k1+now+and+i+am+no

原帖由 lalawowo 於 13-10-20 發表
My kid studies at Vic k1 now and i am not worried about his p1 allocation even i m targeting for tra ...

Are you sure about having chinese and Maths homework everyday?!?!?

I don't get K1 homework this often.

作者: iamadc 時間: 13-10-21 19:14 標題: 回覆：維記 vs st cat, 點揀？

我個仔係維記讀k1. 他可以讀很多英文書（oxford reading tree level 3). 中文字我剛開始教，學校亦開始要認字，佢都學得幾快，日月手等字已記得，有些幾深的詞語如開心佢都讀到,算不錯吧？還是sc或kv教得更快？

作者: kongman 時間: 13-10-21 19:27

picture 發表於 13-10-19 10:10
All Vic kgs use the same inquires based learning approach but some schools attained certification fi ...

你的意思是說維幼學生在紀律方面表現較差，不愛聽老師指令？這樣他們在小一面試時豈不比較吃虧？德育方面的培養又如何呢？維幼學生進了傳統小學，適應上會有困難嗎？

作者: picture 時間: 13-10-21 19:54

kongman 發表於 13-10-21 19:27
你的意思是說維幼學生在紀律方面表現較差，不愛聽老師指令？這樣他們在小一面試時豈不比較吃虧？德育方面的 ...

紀律方面表現較差... this I don't know because discipline is basically habits like going to bed early, waking up early and not be late for school, handing in homework on time....etc are taught both at home and in school.

Victoria does require kids to observe rules in the classroom and those rules may not be as strict as other traditional kindergartens.  One example will be, kids are encouraged to participate in discussions after the teacher reads a story to tell.  And putting up your hand and waiting to be called to express your idea is not often required.  Also, some Catholic schools do reprimand 3 years old for not being able to sit absolutely still during class.

Kids in Victoria learn in a "free" way mainly because (in my opinion), they are not seated at individual desks facing the blackboard and being lectured to.  The class of around 30 kids are split into 3 groups so that each teacher would guide his/her subgroup of 10 kids when teaching about a subject.  The kids will gather around a larger table or sit in a circle close to the teacher to observe, listen, ask questions and may be participate in demonstrations.  The teaching and learning process is two-way (bilateral) through active discussions.

不愛聽老師指令....who likes to be bossed around?  no kid will be 100% obedient.  But i can assure you that Vic teacher do impose rules in class.  however, given the fact that Victoria kids are encouraged to be curious, i do believe, they will make more attempts to be adventurous.  Hence, may put them at a disadvantaged position when interviewing for local primaries.

Nevertheless, I do like the way Victoria teaches young kids as I believe kids learn best when they are unpressured and happy.  Perhaps they are perceived as bad students by local primary schools, but learning is a long journey, I want my kid to learn well and happily and I don't want to focus on marks.

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)