教育王國

標題: LH vs SC - review [打印本頁]

作者: retriever 時間: 13-9-11 11:19 標題: LH vs SC - review

本帖最後由 retriever 於 13-9-11 11:20 編輯

it is not another post asking your help to make decision between 2 schools.

just to post a short review to help those who are going to apply for both schools.

from the material and seminar we have seen from sc and lh, i noted there are a nos of similarities between two schools, the approach and curriculum. just name a few as follows:

- dual class teachers
- school based curriculum
- reading scheme
- show and tell
- learning aid/kits
- materials with their own characters wearing school uniform
- parent story telling
- seminars for parents

you will not make a false decision between these two schools if you are looking for the above.

作者: kwansara 時間: 13-9-11 11:29

As you know the kid will normally attend one kindergarten only, how would you make decision between LH & SC ?

作者: breadbb 時間: 13-9-11 11:35 標題: 回覆：LH vs SC - review

我最後揀左sc 其實LH am真係好唔捨得放！！但係見個仔面家返學返得咁開心，咁就唔好諗咁多！！

作者: retriever 時間: 13-9-11 11:35

回復 kwansara 的帖子

pick the one suit your kids most, e.g. location, other minor things.

there are still some differences between two schools, but i would say similarities are much more than differences.

作者: summato 時間: 13-9-11 11:40

回復 retriever 的帖子

我都覺呢兩間學校既apporach好似, 反而類似根德既就吾多有. right?

作者: retriever 時間: 13-9-11 11:52

回復 summato 的帖子

yes, what really surprised me is they both have their own character (pak ching, mei mei, hei hei)

i bet they had learned from each others.

作者: jason1978 時間: 13-9-11 12:41 標題: 回覆：LH vs SC - review

Lh learnt from sc?

作者: 咪臣 時間: 13-9-11 12:51

jason1978 發表於 13-9-11 12:41
Lh learnt from sc?

Definitely not. LH has it own school based development section since 2003 to create all learning materials.

作者: retriever 時間: 13-9-12 12:39

本帖最後由 retriever 於 13-9-12 13:10 編輯

回復咪臣的帖子

i think sc in general is the role model of most commercial kg in hk including lh, given the fact that sc was established in 1970 while lh was formed after yr 2000. however, i bet a couple of good things that sc might have learned from lh, e.g. theme book with their own characters and the puff dolls.

also, i really appreciate the effort that lh had made on organizing seminars for parents and the inter-campus sport day!

作者: retriever 時間: 13-9-12 13:04

本帖最後由 retriever 於 13-9-12 13:08 編輯

here below i summarize the differences:

- outdoor playground (sc)
- school scale (800x for sc while 1xx for one lh campus)
- class size (sc has big class of around 30 kids, and small class of around 18 kids)
- source of students (more localized for lh campus, more wider span for sc)
- net (only full time in k1 for sc, while full time for 3/4 yrs for lh)
- course for enhancing p1 interview skill (free for lh, optional for sc)
- mode of teaching (more interactive for sc, active but more discipline for lh)
- visibility (much more for lh, e.g. web album/tea with principal/parent day/emails notice, web notice/parent day for sc)
- phonic (sc own phonic sys vs. letterland for lh)
- curriculum (read from the forum: more general knowledge in daily life for sc, more academic for lh)
- ps placement (bid for dss/private school for safe but target on elite aided school for sc, target on dss/private school for lh)
- parents circle

correct me if you find any of the above mistaken.

作者: babyhazel106 時間: 13-9-23 18:18

- phonic ( letterland for LH only PN and K1,) K2 and K3 use synthesis phonic (LH 校本課程)

作者: daughterkingdom 時間: 13-9-23 19:02

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: samchan2179 時間: 13-9-23 19:19 標題: 引用：咁+SC,+英文用邊套+phonic?

原帖由 daughterkingdom 於 13-09-23 發表
咁 SC, 英文用邊套 phonic?

Sc phonic 係自己出品

作者: samchan2179 時間: 13-9-23 19:30 標題: 引用：+本帖最後由+retriever+於+13-9-12+13:08+

原帖由 retriever 於 13-09-12 發表
本帖最後由 retriever 於 13-9-12 13:08 編輯

here below i summarize the differences:

- net (only full time in k1 for sc, while full time for 3/4 yrs for lh)
- course for enhancing p1 interview skill (free for lh, optional for sc)

To be more exact , For SC , NETs teach English everyday n also show up in the "grouping" time. Only k1 has NET 班主任 but not K2n k3

SC gave training on school interview skill in K2/k3??during school time at No additional fee n it is NOT only optional. If u join their K2 to K3 summer class, it include additional interview training too.

作者: DevilPig 時間: 13-9-24 00:12 標題: 引用：Quote:原帖由+retriever+於+13-09-12+發表

原帖由 samchan2179 於 13-09-23 發表
- net (only full time in k1 for sc, while full time for 3/4 yrs for lh)
- course for enhancing p1 in ...

So, K2 and K3 summer course need to pay? Btw, LH has its own learning kit (one set per 2 months) to let parent play/ teach kid at home, does SC has something like this?

作者: csy_0101 時間: 13-9-24 00:34 標題: 回覆：LH vs SC - review

2間學校好似都鐘意請對方的老師

作者: samchan2179 時間: 13-9-24 01:12 標題: 引用：Quote:原帖由+samchan2179+於+13-09-23+發

原帖由 DevilPig 於 13-09-24 發表
So, K2 and K3 summer course need to pay? Btw, LH has its own learning kit (one set per 2 months) to ...

Summer course for sure need to pay ! Is there any kindergarten provide summer course free ???

Learning kit- I don't know what LH learning kits like .for st cat they provide English n Chines word cards , not a fancy one. Sc also gave a basic phonic cd for parents

作者: DevilPig 時間: 13-9-24 08:58 標題: 引用：Quote:原帖由+DevilPig+於+13-09-24+發表So

原帖由 samchan2179 於 13-09-24 發表
Summer course for sure need to pay ! Is there any kindergarten provide summer course free ???

Learn ...

So u mean SC provide interview class during summer course? And summer course need to pay , right?

作者: JC_mami 時間: 13-9-24 09:29

Learning kit我估應該是大小肌肉訓練的玩具。例如串珠仔，

作者: minirat 時間: 13-9-24 09:38

本帖最後由 minirat 於 13-9-24 09:38 編輯

retriever 發表於 13-9-12 13:04
here below i summarize the differences:

- outdoor playground (sc)

From what I read, there are not much similarities especially in terms of teaching style which is one of the most crucial considerations. In short, SC seems more interactive whereas LH is more academic.

作者: HaYi 時間: 13-9-24 10:03

我大仔是SC 的畢業生, 佢個時K2都有參加SC 的summer course, 要自費的, 都唔便宜, 因我個時有左細佬, 佢又有校車接送, 就參加, 係有包幾堂面試班, 不過幾普通的問答, 我估同坊間的面試班不大相同 (我冇去過坊間的). LH 的面試訓練是如何呢?

我個細佬要考K1, SC, LH 都是我的目標之一, 因2間各有好處,

作者: retriever 時間: 13-9-24 11:04

本帖最後由 retriever 於 13-9-24 11:07 編輯

回復 DevilPig 的帖子

sc did provide learning kits, flash cards and chinese character and phrase cards shaped like trains so that parents could play with kids at home while LH provided very toy-like kits.

作者: retriever 時間: 13-9-24 11:05

回復 HaYi 的帖子

what kind of summer courses provided by sc would include interview training as well?

作者: retriever 時間: 13-9-24 11:14

回復 HaYi 的帖子

as far as i know, the interview training provided by LH for free is scheduled for the summer in k2. the training session will be delivered by LH teachers. there will be mock interview for kids. the teachers will give remarks to highlight what the kids should improve for ps interview.

not pro as those provided by the centers, in which they may have sample test and questions collected from target school.
i think the interview training by LH is to offer a chance the kids to practise their presentation skills.

作者: retriever 時間: 13-9-24 11:20

回復 samchan2179 的帖子

sam, could you talk a bit more about the interview train provided at school time?

btw, when will sc start the show and tell session? i know LH starts it in K1. actually LH asked the PN kids to brings personal items to share with other during the last few months of PN time.

作者: kitmantsoi 時間: 13-9-24 12:22 標題: 引用：回復+HaYi+的帖子 as+far+as+i+know,+the+

原帖由 retriever 於 13-09-24 發表
回復 HaYi 的帖子

as far as i know, the interview training provided by LH for free is scheduled for ...

無上坊間既interview class，所以比較唔到。LH既面試内容認真，嘗試制造考試場景，例如其中一堂係坐同睇書，令佢地明白有時係要長時間等，係等既時候可以點做。
Mock interview同父母一齊面試會發現小朋友比平常緊張，學校係希望預習，比經驗小朋友。
每堂課後會有記錄，如蹺櫈，挖鼻，玩手指，回應是否流暢等。
不論小朋友最後是否入到心儀學校，我都非常欣賞LH既用心教學。校長一句:“考小學有問題隨時搵我傾一傾。“ 傾完有無用唔知，但至少有份支持。

作者: kitmantsoi 時間: 13-9-24 12:25 標題: 回覆：kitmantsoi 的帖子

啓迪班由k2下學期開始至k3上學期逢星期六上午上課並跟躆學生個性分組。

作者: daughterkingdom 時間: 13-9-24 12:55

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: jantan28 時間: 13-9-24 14:35

回復 retriever 的帖子

any example of how SC's teaching more interactive?

作者: kitmantsoi 時間: 13-9-24 15:02

retriever very supportive principal

which campus?

LV

作者: kitmantsoi 時間: 13-9-24 15:09

daughterkingdom 發表於 13-9-24 12:55
OK, 如果係啟迪班發現問題, 咁老師有無建議家長點樣 train 小朋友呀? 有無話邊D個性學生要訓練多D呀? ...

其實未上啟迪班係有個啟迪班課程簡介會比家長, 教家長點樣 train 小朋友.

作者: retriever 時間: 13-9-24 15:17

回復 jantan28 的帖子

my boy just started his term. however, i was told by my boss that in sc kids were encouraged to discuss with the teacher in the class. i participated in parent story telling session in lh. kids sat quietly (some not nicely though) in the class even the story we told were not very interesting... i could feel the kids were well trained.

作者: samchan2179 時間: 13-9-24 19:42 標題: 回覆：retriever 的帖子

I participated in parents story telling in K1! I found kids in SC were active n were encouraged to ask m answer questions. I remember at the beginning of my story telling , I asked a question n so many kids actively answered my question n I really didn't expect it !! , it took me 2 mins to listen to their answers n settle them down to start my story telling !!

LH must be a very good school in training discipline which make all the k1 kids sit still to listen to story telling

that's very important

作者: DevilPig 時間: 13-9-24 19:52 標題: 引用：Quote:原帖由+DevilPig+於+13-09-24+發表So

原帖由 samchan2179 於 13-09-24 發表
Summer course for sure need to pay ! Is there any kindergarten provide summer course free ???

Learn ...

學之園都有好多 learning kits 比家長，開學已經比左中文字卡，英文 letterland cards, 數數目既遊戲樂 (一樣野包括顏色分辨，小肌肉訓練，數目 counting) ，letterland 書比小朋友 painting, 中文兒歌 (連簡單樂譜）, 英文兒歌，每星期有中／英文歌 video 比家長 (係高年級小朋友錄製，校長話升上去後，每位小朋友都有機會錄影），另有中英文學校書本派發係屋企睇，中文書仲好有特式，如班主任姓黃，書入面老師又叫黃老師，書入面圖畫仲參照學校環境繪製，例如滑梯係一樣樣！因為我係 pn 家長，開學只有一個月，知道唔多！

作者: samchan2179 時間: 13-9-24 19:53 標題: 引用：回復+samchan2179+的帖子 sam,+could+you+

原帖由 retriever 於 13-09-24 發表
回復 samchan2179 的帖子

sam, could you talk a bit more about the interview train provided at school ...

I didn't attend the interview training by SC myself n I m lazy parents who don't ask all the single details from kids , so I can't share too much but I guess it is more or less like interview training provided by other schools.

Not sure what u mean show n tell.

I believe LH is stronger than Sc in training kids for primary school interviews. Reason: one mum who has kids in both SC n LH told me that during school seminar by principal of LH , principal emphasize LH can train kids to get into good primary school n she found homework in LH is more difficult , so I will not surprise LH provide more school interview training than SC as this is their selling point !

作者: samchan2179 時間: 13-9-24 19:55 標題: 引用：retriever++very+supportive+principalwhic

原帖由 kitmantsoi 於 13-09-24 發表
retriever very supportive principal

which campus?

What is LV?

作者: samchan2179 時間: 13-9-24 21:06 標題: 引用：Quote:原帖由+samchan2179+於+13-09-24+發

原帖由 DevilPig 於 13-09-24 發表
學之園都有好多 learning kits 比家長，開學已經比左中文字卡，英文 letterland cards, 數數目既遊戲樂 (一 ...

Sure LH is a much better school

作者: sbux 時間: 13-9-24 21:33 標題: 回覆：LH vs SC - review

我個囡只讀過一間，比較唔到，但可以肯定嘅係LH學費超值，學費以外只有書簿費，無其他巧立名目嘅徵費

作者: elizatyy 時間: 13-9-24 21:47

LHK 未必是家長心目中的名校、學費又唔平、但我小朋友在那四年所學所得到的經驗、已經令我十分滿意學校的用心辦學。希望LHK繼續進步!

作者: DevilPig 時間: 13-9-25 00:09 標題: 引用：我大仔是SC+的畢業生,+佢個時K2都有參加SC+

原帖由 HaYi 於 13-09-24 發表
我大仔是SC 的畢業生, 佢個時K2都有參加SC 的summer course, 要自費的, 都唔便宜, 因我個時有左細佬, 佢又 ...

可以分享大仔最後有邊幾間 offer ma?

作者: retriever 時間: 13-9-25 12:26

samchan2179 發表於 13-9-24 19:53
I didn't attend the interview training by SC myself n I m lazy parents who don't ask all the single ...

if i understand you correctly, there will be kind interview practice in class, it that rite?

show n tell is the kids are required to bring one of their personal items to school, and speak to their classmates about the things they bring to school.

作者: samchan2179 時間: 13-9-25 13:24 標題: 引用：Quote:samchan2179+發表於+13-9-24+19:53+I

原帖由 retriever 於 13-09-25 發表
if i understand you correctly, there will be kind interview practice in class, it that rite?

show n ...

You are right.

Do LH offer any summer class other than school interview training??

作者: samchan2179 時間: 13-9-25 13:27 標題: 回覆：retriever 的帖子

Show n tell - i think it is a very common practise in most kindergarten including SC.

作者: lyhv 時間: 13-9-25 13:56

samchan2179 發表於 13-9-25 13:24
You are right.

Do LH offer any summer class other than school interview training??

no, the summer holiday for LH is only lasting for three weeks, most parents will take their kid to somewhere for vacation

作者: aquasee 時間: 13-9-25 22:18 標題: 回覆：LH vs SC - review

There is suer class in lh but organized by outsider nit the kindergarten. They juat use tge campus for the summer class. Last summer we have the art / creative class, but most parents prefer to get travel to oversea as the holiday is 3 weeks only

作者: annayu 時間: 13-9-25 22:58 標題: 引用：Quote:原帖由+retriever+於+13-09-24+發表

原帖由 kitmantsoi 於 13-09-24 發表
無上坊間既interview class，所以比較唔到。LH既面試内容認真，嘗試制造考試場景，例如其中一堂係坐同睇書 ...

請問係LH邊間分校？

作者: kitmantsoi 時間: 13-9-26 14:11

annayu 發表於 13-9-25 22:58
請問係LH邊間分校？

紅墈, 但4間課程一樣.

作者: DevilPig 時間: 13-9-27 19:50 標題: 引用：Quote:daughterkingdom+發表於+13-9-24+12:

原帖由 kitmantsoi 於 13-09-24 發表
其實未上啟迪班係有個啟迪班課程簡介會比家長, 教家長點樣 train 小朋友.

學之園黎緊會有免費既溺愛主題講座比家長，係油天舉辦，學校唔只教育小朋友學術，仲會教育埋家長，讚

作者: Miumiulab 時間: 13-9-27 20:12 標題: 回覆：LH vs SC - review

Yes, just received circular

作者: elizatyy 時間: 13-9-27 22:18

是的、年年都有家長講座、

作者: DevilPig 時間: 13-12-5 18:45 標題: 回覆：LH vs SC - review

Push up for parent's reference

作者: retriever 時間: 13-12-10 10:01

回覆 DevilPig 的帖子

tks for your push up, hehehe

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)