教育王國

標題: SFA vs TSL 大家又點睇呢 ? [打印本頁]

作者: mstsangwm 時間: 12-11-20 13:47 標題: SFA vs TSL 大家又點睇呢 ?

假設兩間都收, 大家會揀邊間?

作者: sissysze 時間: 12-11-20 13:50 標題: 回覆：SFA vs TSL 大家又點睇呢

sfa

作者: siuyan1212 時間: 12-11-20 14:24

TSL；　學費平，有外語學，設備好。

作者: fion_yinyin 時間: 12-11-20 14:36

就黎要交留位費喇喎，你肯定1月tsl會收你個kid啊？

作者: mstsangwm 時間: 12-11-20 15:13

當收先啦, 要諗定! 只想聽聽意見, 唔收跟本冇得諗!

作者: siutingto 時間: 12-11-20 15:27 標題: 回覆：siuyan1212 的帖子

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: fion_yinyin 時間: 12-11-20 15:53

回復 mstsangwm 的帖子

一間月尾要收留位費，另一間出年至有final result，邊有得你諗啊？

作者: Eunicecat 時間: 12-11-20 16:16

SFS, 派中學好~

作者: brima 時間: 12-11-20 16:37 標題: 回覆：SFA vs TSL 大家又點睇呢 ?

我都同樣有疑問,大家都有外語，英文強。唔好理學費呢part 會點揀。一間學術較強，一間快樂多外藉同有泳池。真係好難揀，仲要考慮升中派位。兩間都各自有部份升上男女拔等名校

作者: MrBeast 時間: 12-11-20 16:39

Tsl

其實有外語對升中有乜好處?

作者: flyda 時間: 12-11-20 19:37

小兒上年都係有這兩個 offer, 結果我哋㨂了SFA。原因係我比較欣賞佢嘅資優教育同比較嚴及有教會的環境；我覺得仔要嚴教。另外我分析過TSL只是女仔派位比較好，男仔一般。很不捨得忍痛冇要TSL；到現時為止我覺得冇揀錯。純粹個人睇法。

作者: hoihoima 時間: 12-11-20 22:59

回復 flyda 的帖子

flyda, I understand that SFA has 資優教育 as you said, however, if the child is just a non-gifted child, is SFA suitable? Is most of the students in SFA gifted? Are non-gifted students in SFA minority? Is the school discouraging (or not paying attention) to non-gifted child? My child is a only a normal child, not a super kid.

作者: silvia_ng 時間: 12-11-20 23:13 標題: 引用：Tsl其實有外語對升中有乜好處?

原帖由 MrBeast 於 12-11-20 發表
Tsl

其實有外語對升中有乜好處?

到升中面試，就會考你語文能力，除左普通咁叫你英文介紹自己，亦會要小朋友朗讀文章等要求。

作者: Grace1010 時間: 12-11-21 00:53 標題: 回覆：SFA vs TSL 大家又點睇呢

我會揀SFA派得好啲！

作者: fishmeow 時間: 12-11-21 00:56

Sfa - is good!!!!

作者: HaYi 時間: 12-11-21 09:01

我覺得鬥心強專功形的可選SFA, 想多面發展的可選TSL,

我個人選了TSL, 冇報過SFA, 覺得SFA 雖是成績好的學校, 但學校理念同自己的期望完全不同, 道理等同幼稚園時選了SC, 完全不考KV一樣.

作者: isila 時間: 12-11-21 09:17

SFA除o左成績好, 運動成績亦佳, 上一上學界體育聯會網站睇下九龍西區成績就知, 所有球類比賽幾乎全部拎冠軍。同區陳守仁則於田徑方面表現較好。

再上一上youtube搵下SFA 同學debate的表現就知點解我話SFA得。

作者: LLaiWWong 時間: 12-11-21 10:05

My sister is a teacher in a secondary traditional government school. She said the academic standard of the graduates from TSL is far below those graduates from other primary schools. These graduates however are supposed to be on the top tier in TSL. Thus her school does not welcome those from TSL. I think if you choose TSL, your end target should be IB secondary school, not the traditional one otherwise, it is difficult for your children to catch up and they will feel like losers.

作者: BBCoffee 時間: 12-11-21 10:18 標題: 引用：My+sister+is+a+teacher+in+a+secondary+tr

原帖由 LLaiWWong 於 12-11-21 發表
My sister is a teacher in a secondary traditional government school. She said the academic standar ...

Really? My first time to hear this comments but last year they still have a few ppl went to dgs or DBS and therefore I really feel surprised to hear this!

作者: fion_yinyin 時間: 12-11-21 10:24

咪係law，咪鬼嚇人好喎。我同事d仔女係TSL讀，有個入到dgs喎。同埋TSL中學派位唔差的，上學校個網睇下就知啦

作者: LLaiWWong 時間: 12-11-21 10:29

本帖最後由 LLaiWWong 於 12-11-21 10:30 編輯

Well, this happened and is the truth, believe it or not. I have heard the same comments from another teacher of a secondary school in KT. I am not talking about other graduates going to other schools. I just talked about what I have heard for a number of years.

作者: coolpa 時間: 12-11-21 10:31

若家長想輕鬆d,而不期望仔女入讀傳統名中學，應該係TSL。其實TSL考得最好那些人，都要出外補習。只要家長要清潔自己的要求及小朋友的特性，總之沒有不勞而獲！

作者: odelia_ho 時間: 12-11-21 10:33

hoihoima 發表於 12-11-20 22:59
回復 flyda 的帖子

flyda, I understand that SFA has 資優教育 as you said, however, if the child is j ...

Hi Hoihoima,
My kid is an old boy of SFA.  In class, teacher won't classify pupils as gifted or not.  Teachers teach them as normal pupils.
If your kid is gifted, you would be able to enrol some gifted education training classes.  They just similar to ECA - they are "playing lessons".  No pressure at all.  Gifted children and pupils' exam ranking from no. 1 to 50 in grade would be qualified to enrol those gifted education lessons.  After finishing 10 subjects during six years period,  a gifted education certificate would be presented at the end of P.6.  However, I don't think this certificate would be very helpful for admission to secondary places.
For my point of view, SFA teaches Chinese in Putonghua is very favourable to pupils.  A very good help to pupils learn Putonghua.  Love this.

作者: hoihoima 時間: 12-11-21 12:23

回復 odelia_ho 的帖子

Thanks, odelia_ho for your detailed comments. Just curious whether those gifted students generally rank top in the grade? Is it very obvious that their academic results are better than non-gifted students?

作者: odelia_ho 時間: 12-11-21 14:32

hoihoima 發表於 12-11-21 12:23
回復 odelia_ho 的帖子

Thanks, odelia_ho for your detailed comments. Just curious whether those gif ...

General speaking is, but you would see exceptional cases, some gifted children's academic performance are not that good. Somehow, a number of non-gifted perform very good. No 100% guarantee

作者: MrBeast 時間: 12-11-21 14:39

silvia_ng 發表於 12-11-20 23:13
到升中面試，就會考你語文能力，除左普通咁叫你英文介紹自己，亦會要小朋友朗讀文章等要求。

...

多謝賜教，咁其他外語如日文法文又有冇直接幫助呢?

作者: silvia_ng 時間: 12-11-21 18:11 標題: 回覆：SFA vs TSL 大家又點睇呢

每個小朋友特質唔同，去邊間先發揮得最好，自己家長心裡有數。何必一定要乜乜vs 物物呢？你去到tsl 做top 果班，有本事既就入band 1. 唔見得我地班top 既小朋友差成咁，唔通教署同保良局有親，派哂佢地去好既中學嗎？
我個仔都考得唔差，但我可以大大聲話比大家知，我個仔從來冇補習。
sfa 都有band 2 band 3 學生，只要自己果個唔係咪得囉。反之tsl 都有大把band 1 學生，你個小朋友係咪得囉。油尖旺網定深水埗網，自己選啦。

作者: mstsangwm 時間: 12-11-22 09:32

For boy, 是否油尖旺中學網比深水埗中學網較好?? 請賜教.

作者: fion_yinyin 時間: 12-11-22 10:30

回復 silvia_ng 的帖子

同意，每間學校也有較中游/較差的學生

作者: sweetbaby999 時間: 12-11-22 11:05

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: winggear 時間: 12-11-22 11:31 標題: 引用：My+sister+is+a+teacher+in+a+secondary+tr

原帖由 LLaiWWong 於 12-11-21 發表
My sister is a teacher in a secondary traditional government school. She said the academic standar ...

我想問你sister係唔係教中中，大部份科目都係中文教?我覺得陳守仁中文唔及一般津校是有可能的要外出補習。至於英文差過一般津校我就不太相信。

作者: bakusensei 時間: 12-11-22 11:47

HaYi 發表於 12-11-21 09:01
我覺得鬥心強專功形的可選SFA, 想多面發展的可選TSL,

我個人選了TSL, 冇報過SFA, 覺得SFA 雖是成績好 ...

HaYi, concur with your assessment.

my fd's kid from a traditional kinder did have some adjustment needed after entering TSL, part. on the creative writing part. but kids are smart. not difficult to adapt.

Re. placement result, I guess as these two schools are so transparent, it's easy to conduct the analysis. My fd's girl got SFA offer and i had quickly checked the placement result of SFA in preceding year. Seems the one for girl is also v. promising.

作者: zzbchu 時間: 12-11-22 11:54 標題: 回覆：SFA vs TSL 大家又點睇呢

有些勁的SFA P1-3己经去了再勁D 學校,esp girl. But dont think TSL can 轉校

作者: mstsangwm 時間: 12-11-22 12:08

個人覺得SFA超大班 : 43人一班

作者: mstsangwm 時間: 12-11-22 12:09

其他官津校是否都有40幾人一班??

作者: MCLIAN 時間: 12-11-22 12:36

silvia_ng 發表於 12-11-21 18:11
每個小朋友特質唔同，去邊間先發揮得最好，自己家長心裡有數。何必一定要乜乜vs 物物呢？你去到tsl 做top ...

Do you mean TSL assign children to different classes by their academic results? If so, do the students change class every year?

BTW, how do they present the assessment results in the final school report. e.g. by aboslute marks or grade or any ranking etc.

Thank you.

作者: LLaiWWong 時間: 12-11-22 13:21

回復 winggear 的帖子

A long history traditional Girls secondary school, my sister has taught there over 20 years.

作者: HaYi 時間: 12-11-22 19:46

bakusensei 發表於 12-11-22 11:47
HaYi, concur with your assessment.

my fd's kid from a traditional kinder did have some adjustment ...

i think  for the middle tier ,  may be SFA is a bit better (if not  similar)  as  TSL . For the top tier TSL for sure will be samilar as SFA, KTS, APS etc, over 15 % to very top schools like LS , DGS, Marymount...
For Chinese level, may be TSL already aware that new p1 kids need to be push in Chinese as most of the kids hv stronger Eng knowledge. So Chinese is not so easy as outsiders'  expectation.  I aware this  after comparing with those traditional girl schools in both HK and kowloon recently.

On the other side,  TSL is quite demanding in composition / writing, so the teaching direction is a bit diff fm the  traditional schools,  and more close to IB's requirement in longer term.

作者: healthybaby 時間: 12-11-22 23:35 標題: 回覆：SFA vs TSL 大家又點睇呢 ?

我在band 1 英中教。坦白講，我有d同事都唔buy直資，因為老師無經驗，流失量高，但直資亦有好多好處，佢地無小朋友未必明白。有d同事唔係好了解，我有同事仲成日講阿Isabella 舊時讀TSL好渣，但Isabella 已是十幾年前讀架啦！而家好多野都唔同左。
不過坦白講，我覺得家長應自己考慮下自己適合d咩學校，因為某程度上，小學係家長讀既，中學先係由小朋友自律學習，所以我自己覺得，小學keep住小朋友的學習動機好重要，否則個小朋友一上到中學就會放軟手腳。
今日有同事研究兩個前幾年會考8A生，發覺佢地小學都唔係考頭十名既，只是中上成績，但學習主動積極。

作者: 556699 時間: 12-11-23 13:57 標題: 引用：Tsl其實有外語對升中有乜好處?

原帖由 MrBeast 於 12-11-20 發表
Tsl

其實有外語對升中有乜好處?

外語對升中未必好大幫助, 但卻是終生受用。中學只係人生一個階段而已。

作者: cowboy2007 時間: 12-11-25 00:02 標題: 回覆：SFA vs TSL 大家又點睇呢 ?

SFA 派位好，好重要！

作者: MyAshley 時間: 13-8-22 22:29

sweetbaby999 發表於 12-11-22 11:05
TSL上年好多女仔入女拔,成績幾好!

Yes my colleague's daughter who got an offer from DGS last year.

作者: C+B 時間: 13-8-23 10:45

healthybaby 發表於 12-11-22 23:35
我在band 1 英中教。坦白講，我有d同事都唔buy直資，因為老師無經驗，流失量高，但直資亦有好多好處，佢地 ...

咁請問有邊啲直資,私小,津校會keep到小朋友的學習動機?可否提議下?萬分感激!

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)