教育王國

標題: 階梯閱讀和I-learner [打印本頁]

作者: mom2006 時間: 12-9-8 11:52 標題: 階梯閱讀和I-learner

有沒有小二或高年級家長可分享訂閱那一項較好，較吸引，還是兩個也訂？似乎i-learner是中英並存，階梯只有中文。前者只供看和聴，後者有練習。不知分析有冇錯⋯

作者: thomasha 時間: 12-9-8 22:58

mom2006 發表於 12-9-8 11:52
有沒有小二或高年級家長可分享訂閱那一項較好，較吸引，還是兩個也訂？似乎i-learner是中英並存，階梯只有 ...

根據經驗，中英各一個就夠了，再多就有可能沒有時間兼顧，而且內容也可能重疊。i-Learner的中文好像也有練習(最少小二有)，但閱讀起來沒有階梯那麼方便(例如看拼音時)，而且階梯任選文章，i-Learner則限定某一天要讀某一篇。

作者: mom2006 時間: 12-9-8 23:00 標題: 回覆：thomasha 的帖子

Thanks al lot thomasha ! U are so helpful as always !

作者: hoihoima 時間: 12-9-8 23:17

回復 thomasha 的帖子

Hi thomasha, how are these on-line readings different from buying exercise books on reading comprehension? One of the benefits that I can think of is the large quantity. Thanks for your comment.

作者: thomasha 時間: 12-9-9 09:42

hoihoima 發表於 12-9-8 23:17
回復 thomasha 的帖子

Hi thomasha, how are these on-line readings different from buying exercise boo ...

In my humble opinion, there are a wider variety of exercise books available in the market that you can choose from. In terms of reading comprehension only, i-Learner (English) for P1 is rather easy compared to YW's curriculum, whereas 階梯閱讀 is about the same level as YW's Chinese curriculum. Of course, the online comprehension exercises can only offer mulitple choices, whereas exercise books may require students to write the words, which online platforms cannot offer, and this is in some way important to a certain extent. However, for P1, getting the kids to grab an understandinig of a passage and answering questions thereof is probably more important than copying words they don't know from the text, though it is unavoidable in real exams.

作者: hoihoima 時間: 12-9-9 10:19

回復 thomasha 的帖子

Hi thomasha, thank you so much!

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)