教育王國

標題: St Catherine's VS 嘉諾撒聖心幼稚園 [打印本頁]

作者: CF2010 時間: 12-9-4 12:09 標題: St Catherine's VS 嘉諾撒聖心幼稚園

聖心好大機會可以直升小一。另一方面，St Cat英文程度高。怎麼好呢？真心求意見！多謝l

作者: Vlone778 時間: 12-9-4 12:15 標題: 回覆：St Catherine's VS 嘉諾撒聖心幼稚園

收咗未

作者: CF2010 時間: 12-9-4 14:02

我都知難！如果真的呢?你說該怎麼揀？真心求教！

作者: cmir 時間: 12-9-4 16:25

don't tell me you are still holding the seat until now.....

作者: CF2010 時間: 12-9-4 16:37

今天己經是九月五日，好似大部份幼稚園己經開學啦！

只想知道如果有這樣機會，應該怎樣揀？我十分喜歡St Cat，但是如聖心收了又真可以有機會直升小一，真的十分吸引。請問有否過來人分享一下！

作者: CF2010 時間: 12-9-4 16:38

今天是九月四日才對！

作者: hayley1328 時間: 12-9-4 16:53

收咗先來問

作者: wonderland07 時間: 12-9-4 16:53 標題: 回覆：St Catherine's VS 嘉諾撒聖心幼稚園

這兩間超難入，但樓主好似好有信心兩間都會收，是否有背景人任呢?

作者: Ononma 時間: 12-9-4 16:58

Opt for 聖心。

作者: CF2010 時間: 12-9-4 17:04

我十分心儀這兩間幼稚園，真的各有好處！請賜教！

作者: SaBB 時間: 12-9-4 17:46 標題: 回覆：St Catherine's VS 嘉諾撒聖心幼稚園

聖心識人都吾係實收，要見校長
如果只係心儀，坦白講，收左先唸，不需自尋煩惱因好大機會兩間都吾收，以往個幾年報名既人數都有成二、三千人

作者: CF2010 時間: 12-9-4 17:49

You are right !

作者: gwlam 時間: 12-9-4 17:51

一間香港一間九龍。邊間近樓主？

作者: CF2010 時間: 12-9-4 17:59

I live in Kowloon. So I perfer St.Cat more. I don't like my girl go to HK side for studying, but I am also looking for straight train to P1. Sacred Heart really is a good school.

作者: lkf_leung 時間: 12-9-4 18:01 標題: CF2010 的帖子

for girl, 一定聖心.

作者: gwlam 時間: 12-9-4 18:07

I personally prefer SH. If you are looking for dragon school. Good Hope is another through train school at Kowloon side for your consideration.

作者: CF2010 時間: 12-9-4 18:13

Why? My son is a graduate of St Cat. My son's English is very good. I think St. Cat's teacher very much. That is why I hope my girl to study in St.Cat also. But, I know Sacred Heart is a good school, and got a "straight train" to P1 is very very attractive.

作者: winnietingting 時間: 12-9-4 18:18 標題: 回覆：St Catherine's VS 嘉諾撒聖心幼稚園

I just doubt when to wake up to go to sh primary school if living in kln.

作者: CF2010 時間: 12-9-4 18:19

That is my major concern !!

作者: raymond338hk 時間: 12-9-4 18:20

如果只係心儀，坦白講，收左先唸

作者: winni_ng 時間: 12-9-4 18:20 標題: 回覆：St Catherine's VS 嘉諾撒聖心幼稚園

兩間都收我個女，我揀左聖心，因為女龍校，德育又教得好，我唔想3年後又玩升小遊戲，太辛苦。

作者: LWL1212 時間: 12-9-4 18:22 標題: 回覆：St Catherine's VS 嘉諾撒聖心幼稚園

聖心！

作者: CF2010 時間: 12-9-4 18:24

Thanks for your reply !

I just wonder why so many parents perfer SH.

作者: CF2010 時間: 12-9-4 18:34

I think the standard of St. Cat is much higher than SH.

作者: gwlam 時間: 12-9-5 15:23

CF2010 發表於 12-9-4 18:34
I think the standard of St. Cat is much higher than SH.

聖心係一間傳統名女校，重德育亦重各科目，比較平均。St. Cat主打language training.

In fact, these are 2 different types of kindergartens and are not comparable at all. I just wonder about your statement "the standard of St. Cat is much higher than SH" was concluded on what basis? English? Chinese? Math? Morality and discipline training? If you aimed at English training, St. Cat. will be more suitable for you.

作者: rabbitsheasl 時間: 12-9-5 16:02

CF2010,

Could you mind disclose your son is studying which primary school? How about his schoolmate, please? Bec my son is studying N in St Cat, I don't know which option for him is better eg study K1 in St Cat or apply other drogon school or apply other KG eg KV, KM etc.

Thanks in advance.

作者: CF2010 時間: 12-9-5 18:27

回復 gwlam 的帖子

Yes.  I agree with you that they are 2 different type of Kindergarten.  My son have studied in St. Cat years ago and I have no idea about the standard of SH at all.  It is not fair to comment/judge the standard of SH.

I am satisfied with my son's acamedic standard (like Chinese, Maths, general knowledge and English of course).  I thank St.Cat's teachers very much.  I would say my son might have achieved P2 standard already when he gradurated from St. Cat.  It will be quite obvious when you look into the course of P1 (even in the top primary school) and you will find St. Cat teachers had taught them already.  He pick up easily.

For personal growth and development,  I am sure that St. Cat is the first choice.  BUT, when you need to apply P1 later, you might find that "LUCK" is very very important. That is why I have to re-consider and think about what is the best to my girl.  SH definitely is a good school and I have no doubt about it.  "Straight Train" to P1 is my dream also.  It is a very painful experience in application of P1, especially 2 years later.  I dont want to go through again.

作者: CF2010 時間: 12-9-5 18:36

回復 rabbitsheasl 的帖子

I would say that my son is now studying in one of the Top Primary School.  He is pretty outstanding among his classmates.  Thank St Cat's teachers again.

Like other St Cat Moms, I got a number of offers when I applied P1 years ago in fact.  But, it is still a very painful and stressing experience.

I think you dont need to consider KV/KM, other non-dragon school.  If your child is a boy, you dont have any other choice!  Right ?

作者: ScarlettShannon 時間: 12-9-5 18:52 標題: 回覆：St Catherine's VS 嘉諾撒聖心幼稚園

Once u have chosen dragon school, u have to take its total package ie. agree on their religion, values, discipline, straight policy and more importantly academic standard. Sometimes, I think it is not necessary to have kid to achieve or over-achieve academic standard so early, not all kid can be push to be like this, just like if u are only in an executive age and someone push u to be a manager in a company, what will u feel? Stressful, tiring, depress! I am the one who give up St Cat offer to take Dragon gal school this year. I have no regret so far because I understand when the school plan their curriculum they are planning in 9 years ahead not 3 years, kids can have rooms to play and learn something not necessarily important for P1 application.

作者: pluto_yuen 時間: 12-9-5 19:01

CF2010 發表於 12-9-4 17:59
I live in Kowloon. So I perfer St.Cat more. I don't like my girl go to HK side for studying, but I ...

JUst out of curiosity, if u live in kowloon. WHy dont u target on Good Hope/Pui Ching/Heep Yunn? WHy bother travel so far since kindergarten to primary school everyday ??? I'm taking about 9 yrs , not 3 yrs.....

作者: CF2010 時間: 12-9-5 20:00

Pui Ching is Chinese School.
Heep Yunn Primary School is not "Dragon" School with the kindergarten.
Good Hope is one of the choice, but I think SH is better.

I love SH too

作者: CF2010 時間: 12-9-5 20:11

Hi! ScarlettShannon,

I see your point! I understand what you are talking about.
But,
As one Tiger Mon said, "I believe my child CAN achieve, so he/she achieved". Maybe, I am one of the Tiger Mon! I think there is no limitation for a child. I hope I can help them as much as possible!

作者: ScarlettShannon 時間: 12-9-5 20:24 標題: 回覆：St Catherine's VS 嘉諾撒聖心幼稚園

Hong Kong side, so u can apply SPN too, I think I am a lazy mom rather than Tiger mom.

作者: CF2010 時間: 12-9-5 21:33

I don't want be a tiger mom too ! But it is sad we have to play this Game in Hong Kong.

作者: ScarlettShannon 時間: 12-9-5 22:58 標題: 回覆：St Catherine's VS 嘉諾撒聖心幼稚園

香港的教育特色與世界相比是快、多、早，即教得快，功課多，早讀書，但不見得教出來的學生特別醒，反而特別不快樂！

作者: rabbitsheasl 時間: 12-9-6 11:44

Thanks for your replied. Many friends said if I give up St Cat K1, many mama will say thank you. Anyway, I will try to apply dragon school first. If they give offer to my son, I will consider at that moment. Don't bring vexation on myself now.

作者: rabbitsheasl 時間: 12-9-6 11:46

回復 ScarlettShannon 的帖子

agree

作者: zzmom 時間: 12-9-6 11:53

回復 rabbitsheasl 的帖子

For boys, what dragon school will you apply? I found that there are not many choices for boys.

作者: benjuli 時間: 12-9-6 12:02

CF2010 發表於 12-9-4 18:13
Why? My son is a graduate of St Cat. My son's English is very good. I think St. Cat's teacher ver ...

Hi, CF2010, I would like to know if you use English at home that your son's english is good?

作者: CF2010 時間: 12-9-6 13:45

回復 benjuli 的帖子

No. We dont speak English at home at all. My maid come from Indoneisa.
That why I thank St. Cat's teacher very much.
Of course, my son's English can't comparable with the native speaker, but I found his English standard higher than the other boys from other kindergarten.

作者: sheffield 時間: 12-9-6 16:27

回復 winnietingting 的帖子

depends where you live in kowloon. it takes my girl about 20-25 minutes to travel from home to SH while it takes more than 45 from home to kowloon tong kinders.....

作者: keio 時間: 12-9-6 18:51 標題: 引用：回復+winnietingting+的帖子 depends+wher

原帖由 sheffield 於 12-09-06 發表
回復 winnietingting 的帖子

depends where you live in kowloon. it takes my girl about 20-25 minutes ...

Agree. It took 1hr from my home to the kinder that my gal studied in Kowloon tong last year as my home was the first stop of the route. Now, it only takes around 40-45 mins from my home to
SHCK. The only issue is SHCK am class starts at 8.25am instead of 9.00am like most kinders so our kids have to wake up half hour earlier to catch the school / nanny bus.

作者: harrybb2008 時間: 12-9-7 10:50

回復 CF2010 的帖子

You said you don't want your girl to go to Kowloon, so you have chosen already.

For me, I would choose Sacred Heart, because direct to P.1, no need to find primary school again, actually my eldest girl studied in there b4. The school is actually good and very disciplined.

作者: harrybb2008 時間: 12-9-7 10:53

回復 CF2010 的帖子

It is because St. Cat. has is not direct to any primary school, that's why they have to have higher standard in order to prepare the kid for P.1 admission.

For SH, its standard is also ok woh. And once you get in, all the P.1, F.1 admission issues are solved!!!

作者: CF2010 時間: 12-9-7 21:26

Learning English is NOT solely for P1 Application. P1 enrollment is fought, but is not everything. There is a long long way to go!

A child in his 3-6 years old is the golden age of learning language, especially for non-native speaker like me.

作者: CF2010 時間: 12-9-7 21:31

P1 application make me crazy! I don't want to go through again. But, it is not everything for a child growth! There is a long way to go! Good English is a solid foundation for future development.

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)