教育王國

標題: 原來而家維小都好難入 [打印本頁]

作者: Jane1983 時間: 12-6-14 21:08 標題: 原來而家維小都好難入

今日聽朋友講，而家Victoria 幼稚園學生只得不足20%可以入到維小，收咗要比4萬幾元費用留位。當初朋友仲有d吳中意維記歷史短，非IS，而家就好擔心小朋友無地方去。

吳聽佢講都吳意世界真係咁艱難。

作者: pollybell 時間: 12-6-14 23:16

我朋友講既同你剛剛相反,維小收返晒自己幼稚園既學生,外人得三五個重要好SAMART先收,自己學生收左唔洗比留位費,可以自行考私小.........可能唔同分校所以有唔同.

作者: poonseelai 時間: 12-6-14 23:41

pollybell 發表於 12-6-14 23:16
我朋友講既同你剛剛相反,維小收返晒自己幼稚園既學生,外人得三五個重要好SAMART先收,自己學生收左唔洗比留 ...

There was no longer a through train system between kindergarten and primary about 4 years ago, and all Victoria kindergarten students need to go through interviews.

作者: Jane1983 時間: 12-6-14 23:46

吳係話佢吳收自己學生，係得＜20%的幼稚園生入得番。以前以為好top的去私小直資，英文勁的去IS，有d吳中意IB、嫌貴吳讀，咁起碼有過半機會收....原來而家吳係咁！

吳使比留位費咁好！我朋友係銅鑼灣果間。

作者: pollybell 時間: 12-6-15 00:15

回復 Jane1983 的帖子

即係收80%出面既學生??咁奇怪自己學生唔收.......................定好似我朋友所講,唔係咁多自己學生.想讀返....學費太貴.

作者: Ving 時間: 12-6-15 00:31

Even if you are Victoria Kinder student, you still need to pay reservation fee once accepted by Victoria primary. And it is heard that Victoria primary is considering to collect debenture few years later

作者: panala 時間: 12-6-15 00:37

我諗你地講嘅都啱，因為我聽番黎係佢地自己幼稚園太多人（幾百人，唔記得係唔係大約800），但小一淨係得百幾個位，所以自己人都收唔晒，得唔夠20﹪嘅人入得番，同時因為全部都係自己幼稚園上，所以收得幾個外人。

作者: poonseelai 時間: 12-6-15 00:41

pollybell 發表於 12-6-15 00:15
回復 Jane1983 的帖子

即係收80%出面既學生??咁奇怪自己學生唔收.......................定好似我朋友所講 ...

Majority will still be from Victoria kinder. In prior years, only about 10% is from outside and I heard that the school may intend to take more from outside. For a full IB school, VSA's school is not considered particularly high, especially when there is no subsidy from government or from charitable organisation. Heard that debentures will be required from school year 2014 onwards.

作者: poonseelai 時間: 12-6-15 00:45

Every year there are about 600 kinder students from all campus. 20% means about 120 students, and this is roughly the number of intake in primary every year. I guess that's what 20% kinder students will go to VSA primary mean.

作者: 112200 時間: 12-6-26 14:37

回復 pollybell 的帖子

hi Pollybell,

The real situation is totally opposite to what you said. For sure not all K3 can promoted to P1, you can think there are so many Victoria kindergardten in HK but only 5 classes of P1 . And the reality is I know quite some existing K3 is " rejected " and quite some K3 kids are on waiting list until now. Once accepted, must pay the fee .

hope this info help la.

作者: patpaul_mama 時間: 12-6-26 21:49 標題: 回覆：原來而家維小都好難入

Really ? There are reject letter ? I original thought they only have waiting list .....

作者: elmostoney 時間: 12-6-27 11:26

pollybell, 冇可能唔收 deposit, 因為係劃一規定, 不分campus. 我都有朋友比左 (佢係九龍), 四萬幾. 另外, 我有朋友係維小讀緊, 所以佢都好update知道情況. 大家諗都諗到, 如果有d campus要比, 有d唔洗, 咁點解要留位比個d唔洗比訂嘅呢? 聽落去都唔合理啦, 咁隨時唔要個位, 又個個留左位先?有d sibling 都入唔返維小, 的確難入係真架. 今年in 維小的維幼K2生, 有27個sibling都入唔返.

作者: elmostoney 時間: 12-6-27 11:39

據我所聽聞, 維幼有800學生, 佢地會收300人左右, 因為預左有d學生會考IS同直資, 呢批人入到其他學校會走, 所以維小會收得超過佢地 actually有嘅位. 到每年六月, 大家都知道自己入邊間學校, 維小就會做個final count, 如果give up個位嘅小朋友多, 學校有空位, 咁就會通知waiting list嘅 applicants. 聽講今年九月開學, 佢地真係收突左, 因為冇預期咁多人唔要個位, 結果要開多一班.

作者: chansiub 時間: 12-6-27 12:18 標題: 回覆：原來而家維小都好難入

維小其實好唔好? 維小的評價好像比其幼稚園的還要恐怖。

作者: pollybell 時間: 12-6-27 12:18

留位費問題我當然有質疑啦,我朋友咁講咪咁聽..........佢小朋友讀緊唔通我同佢對質嗎....anyway聽返黎既野都係唔好發表避免誤導其他人.sorry.

作者: HKTHK 時間: 12-6-27 12:27

pollybell> Don't think you are right. Friend of mine just complained about having to pay the deposit to retain the spot. But of course many will have to do that as it is a good safety backup.

作者: patpaul_mama 時間: 12-6-27 17:58 標題: 回覆：原來而家維小都好難入

Is it work to send letter to the principal and ask for a seat ? My son in on waiting list but quite eager to get in.

Any parents can share your experience ? Thanks

作者: slamai 時間: 12-6-27 19:21

It will help if you talk directly to the Head of Academy ...

patpaul_mama 發表於 12-6-27 17:58
Is it work to send letter to the principal and ask for a seat ? My son in on waiting list but quite ...

作者: Jane1983 時間: 12-6-27 20:11

回復 chansiub 的帖子

其實維幼幾好，語文同presentation skills都好好, 考直資和私小成績都吳錯。起碼佢間間分校年年公佈學生升小學情況，透明度高。

維小就吳敢講，佢出過IB狀元，個女仔係由維幼讀起，出過去一、兩年，又由其他學校轉番去維記，好似吳差。不過，之前google過維小comment，有d家長鬧爆，講得好難聽，真係吳知真假。

作者: chansiub 時間: 12-6-27 21:33 標題: 回覆：Jane1983 的帖子

真係唔知真定假

。

作者: elmostoney 時間: 12-6-28 09:59

維記近年就算低年班都多左功課, 我朋友個小朋友一年級, 佢話每日大概都係一個鐘多d, 佢問左其他同學, 大至都係差唔多, 有時會去到個半, 多project就會兩個鐘.  佢地少搓寫, 好多功課 (包括閱讀理解)未必係小朋友能自己完成, 所以都靠父母同佢一齊做或引導.  如果父母返全職, 咁小朋友變相就要夜d先做得完功課.

大考(低年班)冇, 所以起碼唔會有閉關讀書呢d問題.  老師唔會announce名次/分數, 不過邊個小朋友叻, 其實大家心裏有數.

我另一個剛比左維小訂嘅朋友話, 佢唔申請蔡繼有啦, 雖然蔡小都好好, 但係佢比較過, 覺得英普語境, 維小好過蔡小.  我自己帶阿女去 in 過維小, 發覺d小朋友課餘全部都係講廣東話, 我只可以話, 想小朋友雙語都學得好係好難, 始終會有一樣強d.

另外有樣奇事, 上星期五我收到維小電話 (我個女係waitlist九月開學一年班), 咁啱我聽唔到, 打返去, 留左言, 佢地又唔覆. 後來打左好多次, 個電話又冇人聽, 真怪雞.  我自己諗, 佢打得比我, 應該係offer個位比我個女, 唔係打來做物? 但係又咁冇交帶, 唔覆  call 又唔跟進, 真係好攪笑.  我打左兩日, 搵唔到人就算, 因為都唔打算入, 都係好奇想知佢地搵我做物.

作者: 112200 時間: 12-6-28 11:33

Dear ,

How do you compare with 英普語境 of 維小 vs SIS vs 蔡小 ?

作者: bbaunt 時間: 12-6-28 12:28

我個朋友既女女，黎緊K3係維幼，己經被維小收左要交4萬按金
佢話維小，講明遲兩年要買債卷50萬

作者: chansiub 時間: 12-6-28 14:43 標題: 回覆：elmostoney 的帖子

看來是行政頗為混亂。學習環境亦不太好。唉。收得貴都唔一定好。找間好學校真的不易。

作者: Jane1983 時間: 12-6-28 15:36

維小係南區個校園吳靚咩？未入過去。

其實都係在肯收小朋友那些學校中，選間最好。希望在英文、中文和學術三方面找個平衡，IS最好，好的LS都無所謂，而家競爭咁大，真係吳敢太高要求。

作者: 4eyesDad 時間: 12-6-28 18:47

維小3/F飯堂的廁所及shower room保養比公廁差。

作者: babyzoe5 時間: 12-9-28 18:03

My friend visited Victoria Shanghai before and showed me this photos taken from the wall of their school. Maybe this is normal in HK but this is not the morale value I am brought up with.

"We need money to buy all the things we see in school."

作者: FattyDaddy 時間: 12-9-29 03:24

babyzoe5 發表於 12-9-28 18:03
Maybe this is normal in HK but this is not the morale value I am brought up with.
"We need money to buy all the things we see in school." ...

You must have been brought up in paradise where everything is free, lucky you, back on earth we humdrum folks do need to pay when we buy things

作者: babyzoe5 時間: 12-9-29 09:53

Maybe this kind of school is for you. You can pay the $500,000 debenture.

作者: Jane1983 時間: 12-9-29 12:36

May be they are teaching the concept of money in school.

作者: Wenjie 時間: 12-11-19 14:53

我覺得留位費一定要交，但係唔係4萬文咁誇張？

作者: avaya 時間: 12-11-22 16:11

The fact is VSA only takes around 20-25% of all Victoria Kindergarten K3 students from this year onwards due to large number of applicants and Principal doesn't want to over-admitt students. It is now a harsh competition!

作者: Jane1983 時間: 12-11-22 17:58

接放學時，成日都會聽d有仔女係維小讀的家長，講d小朋友幾咁鍾意返學，reading programme幾咁豐富。

我吾係維小fan，不過發覺近年真係多咗維幼小朋友係一心入去讀，吾係當佢水泡。收生好咗，加上學校有心機辦，係應該越來越好的。

作者: avaya 時間: 12-11-26 13:53

For those whose kids are admitted but decided not to go, please please please release the space. There are hundreds waiting for the chance.....please.

作者: 亞Boo 時間: 12-11-27 12:53 標題: 引用：For+those+whose+kids+are+admitted+but+de

原帖由 avaya 於 12-11-26 發表
該帖被管理員或版主屏蔽，或作者被禁止/刪除

Agreed. Some of my friends' kids are still on the waiting list. Please release the offer from VSA if you have other choices. IB school, like VSA is their cup of tea

作者: mamaishere 時間: 13-9-25 04:49 標題: 回覆：原來而家維小都好難入

請問今年有份考維小家長，面試內容大概是什麼？聽說debenture都不是人人可以買到，那有小朋友今年入year1嘅家長是沒有買debenture的嗎？我小朋友現在是九龍區維幼，想了解多些最新安排，始終維小在南區返學較遠，如果留位費要四萬多真的很難決定！謝謝！

作者: Jane1983 時間: 13-9-25 10:01

今年推的debenture得幾十個，所以入讀的多數係無買debentures的家長。學校公佈話超額11倍，可能想買亦未必有。

我無報，所以吾知考什麼，但有聽過其他家長呻無2nd in。4萬幾deposit係貴，睇吓你係咪鍾意佢果套，單係買個back up就太貴。

作者: juniorli 時間: 13-9-25 10:58

My boy attended the interview in March this year. The children were interviewed as groups. Two teachers read stories to them, one in English and one in Poutogua. They were asked some questions related to the stories. Then they were asked to draw a picture related to their favourite toy. It's quite simple. The interview lasted for 1 hour.

作者: mamaishere 時間: 13-9-25 14:36 標題: 回覆：原來而家維小都好難入

4萬蚊一個保險真係好貴，仲要個保險咁遠！係咪維小好早In，好早就要交留位費㗎啦？面試全部都係自己學生，唔知傾向收邊類呢？英普班會否較有優勢？

作者: Jane1983 時間: 13-9-25 15:04

回復 mamaishere 的帖子

佢早過人，所以收左你，4萬幾無得走。如果係以前的一萬幾，有個back up，就會報。

吾係維記幼稚園生，除非有debenture或人事，吾係應該比較難。

據了解，有2nd in果幾個，都係活潑外向型，文靜乖巧吾出聲就較吃虧。

作者: Bean2012 時間: 13-10-21 18:31

本帖最後由 Bean2012 於 15-8-28 18:34 編輯

deleted

作者: mamaishere 時間: 13-10-22 09:07 標題: 引用：我想問係咪維幼生,+可先報維小,+如吾收可等

原帖由 Bean2012 於 13-10-21 發表
我想問係咪維幼生, 可先報維小, 如吾收可等派位, 但如維小收左, 又可吾可以照參加派位呢???
...

維小係私校，應該唔影響派位，可以兩邊同時進行！

作者: Chloeorowen 時間: 13-10-27 21:53

There should be 7 classes in Year 1, around 29 students in each class.

作者: Chloeorowen 時間: 13-10-27 22:03

Anyone had the debenture on hand?

作者: helina 時間: 13-10-28 22:58

回復 mamaishere 的帖子

4月in，8月31日前通知學校放棄個位，退70%deposit，11月30日前通知，退50%

作者: helina 時間: 13-10-29 23:59

8月31日前放棄個位，退回七成留位費，11月30日前退回一半。OK啦

作者: helina 時間: 13-10-30 02:16

8月3l日前通知放棄個位，可退回70%留位費，11月30日前通知學校就退番一半。OK啦

作者: Noelmama 時間: 13-12-5 16:28

本帖最後由 Noelmama 於 13-12-5 16:29 編輯

其實個四萬幾( 5 個月學費) , 真正for deposit 只是相等於2 個月學費, 其他個三月既錢係會用來當頭三個月既學費 ( of coz, if school fee increse, we have to pay the difference.)

作者: victoryu19 時間: 13-12-10 12:31

I just asked the admission office a few days ago.

Debenture is optional

作者: Jupiter 時間: 13-12-12 15:13 標題: 回覆：原來而家維小都好難入

My girl is in K3 and was being interviewed in April 2013, but she was being put on waiting list. Just received email today asking us to attend 2nd interview next week, actually it's a parents' meeting with the principal. I think quite a number of students gave up offer after Nov.

作者: musicien 時間: 13-12-13 09:34 標題: 引用：My+girl+is+in+K3+and+was+being+interview

原帖由 Jupiter 於 13-12-12 發表
My girl is in K3 and was being interviewed in April 2013, but she was being put on waiting list. J ...

Gd on u. I don't hv that. Guess it means u r in.

作者: joeydesu 時間: 13-12-13 13:14

回覆 Jupiter 的帖子

May I know if your girl is studying in trilingual class or bilingual class? My daughter is also on waiting list, seems bilingual class has priority to be interviewed again.........

作者: jeff76916 時間: 13-12-13 13:17 標題: 回覆：joeydesu 的帖子

It seems it now becomes really hard to get into VSA

作者: Jupiter 時間: 13-12-13 13:32

joeydesu 發表於 13-12-13 13:14
回覆 Jupiter 的帖子

May I know if your girl is studying in trilingual class or bilingual class? My ...

My girl is now in trilingual class, LK campus. Seems no preference on bilingual class, my girl's classmate was accepted in the first round in May.

作者: irene_the_pooh 時間: 13-12-13 13:52

Jupiter 發表於 13-12-13 13:32
My girl is now in trilingual class, LK campus. Seems no preference on bilingual class, my girl's c ...

Many years ago, I heard that they prefer to accept kids from bilingual classes, and heard from some parents who attended the open day last year, they prefer kids can speak fluent eng and mandarin.
So may be your girl is smart enough to be accepted even though not in bilingual class!

作者: Jupiter 時間: 13-12-13 17:29 標題: 引用：Quote:Jupiter+發表於+13-12-13+13:32+My+g

原帖由 irene_the_pooh 於 13-12-13 發表
Many years ago, I heard that they prefer to accept kids from bilingual classes, and heard from some ...

If she is smart enough she would have been accepted in first round in May. Actually her first language is Cantonese, English is ok and teacher comments her English level is higher than most of her classmates, but mandarin is really very 普通，can only answer simple questions, not even conversation. I am still thinking whether to let her goto VSA even if being accepted coz I want her to have better Chinese and discipline, however we only have one offer out of 13 local schools we applied

作者: yaulinda 時間: 13-12-13 18:43 標題: 回覆：Jupiter 的帖子

Congratulations, VSA is a very good school

作者: musicien 時間: 13-12-13 19:14 標題: 回覆：原來而家維小都好難入

I guess language is just one thing. My sons Pth and eng both gd but he's passive. No offer. Maybe becox he's a dec kid too

作者: Jupiter 時間: 13-12-13 19:36 標題: 回覆：原來而家維小都好難入

My girl is Oct kid, but she is super talkative (a bit hyperactive I would say).....teachers in class complain about her keep talking to classmates during lesson

作者: musicien 時間: 13-12-13 19:39 標題: 引用：My+girl+is+Oct+kid,+but+she+is+super+tal

原帖由 Jupiter 於 13-12-13 發表
My girl is Oct kid, but she is super talkative (a bit hyperactive I would say).....teachers in class ...

Headmistress hinted that nov and dec kids will be difficult. This is in line with the change in veo policy in general. Nov and dec kids no longer accepted for k1

作者: musicien 時間: 13-12-13 19:40 標題: 引用：My+girl+is+Oct+kid,+but+she+is+super+tal

原帖由 Jupiter 於 13-12-13 發表
My girl is Oct kid, but she is super talkative (a bit hyperactive I would say).....teachers in class ...

Headmistress hinted that nov and dec kids will be difficult. This is in line with the change in veo policy in general. Nov and dec kids no longer accepted for k1

作者: Jupiter 時間: 13-12-13 21:15 標題: 回覆：原來而家維小都好難入

My son is again small kid in Nov and jut received Vic offer of K1, are you talking about K1 or PN? Anyway I plan to let him repeat K1 in a more difficult kg

作者: musicien 時間: 13-12-13 21:49 標題: 引用：My+son+is+again+small+kid+in+Nov+and+jut

原帖由 Jupiter 於 13-12-13 發表
My son is again small kid in Nov and jut received Vic offer of K1, are you talking about K1 or PN? ...

Oh I Thot they won't take nov and dec kids anymore! It's written on their admission policies! They accepted ur application?

作者: Jupiter 時間: 13-12-13 21:51 標題: 回覆：原來而家維小都好難入

They don't accept nov and dec for PN, but ok for K1

作者: bbbttt 時間: 13-12-16 10:17

大家可唔可以講多啲點解VSA好?
謝!

作者: poonseelai 時間: 13-12-16 11:32

回覆 bbbttt 的帖子

如果你要選一間行國際課程IB，而又中英並重，VSA 是其中一個選擇

作者: bbbttt 時間: 13-12-16 18:08

回覆 poonseelai 的帖子

我兒較內向, 好可以坐定定接受填鴨式教育... 我希望佢都會適合IB啦. 最怕揀錯條路, 讀得吃力. 冇得回頭, 累了他.

作者: kittyland06 時間: 13-12-19 18:48

How would all mommies rate KCIS and VIC bilingual K1?

作者: muimuimao 時間: 13-12-19 21:39

回覆 kittyland06 的帖子

if you aim at DSS or VSA, of course victoria k1, if you aim at international school, then kcis.

作者: kittyland06 時間: 13-12-19 22:39 標題: 回覆：原來而家維小都好難入

I aim kcs!

作者: Jupiter 時間: 13-12-20 21:01 標題: 回覆：原來而家維小都好難入

Got offer from VSA, need to decide and pay before 31 Dec....

作者: Jane1983 時間: 13-12-20 21:09

回覆 Jupiter 的帖子

鍾吾鍾意呢？定係心儀傳統名小？

作者: cytbaby 時間: 13-12-20 21:09

回覆 Jupiter 的帖子

Which other schools you are deciding between?

作者: Jupiter 時間: 13-12-20 21:35 標題: 引用：回覆+Jupiter+的帖子鍾吾鍾意呢？定係心

原帖由 Jane1983 於 13-12-20 發表
回覆 Jupiter 的帖子

鍾吾鍾意呢？定係心儀傳統名小？

My girl is with mild hyperactive and mildly gifted, CP said she needs a structured environment but cannot be in a very traditional way (I wonder if hk has such kind of school). She 對自己冇要求，but care a lot about what teacher said. IB requires 主動學習, I am afraid that she will求其. However due to her hyperactive problem , traditional schools seems "die hard". It is really a big headache

作者: Jane1983 時間: 13-12-20 21:54

回覆 Jupiter 的帖子

你形容個女的用詞，和我朋友講她個仔一樣，至少小學階段吾適合IB，她仔讀了一年ISF，就轉番傳統。

除維小，你有無覺得邊間口岩她？校網有無心儀？

其實6月大抽獎，抽完又一連串叩門，仲有好多變數。搵一間學術好、活動教學，吾系太逼死人的學校，可能更適合她。

作者: Jupiter 時間: 13-12-20 22:12 標題: 引用：回覆+Jupiter+的帖子你形容個女的用詞，

原帖由 Jane1983 於 13-12-20 發表
回覆 Jupiter 的帖子

你形容個女的用詞，和我朋友講她個仔一樣，至少小學階段吾適合IB，她仔讀了一年ISF， ...

Many thanks for your comments! So which school does your friend's son go to now? I only have 音小offer other than VSA

作者: Jane1983 時間: 13-12-20 22:31

回覆 Jupiter 的帖子

去咗英華，幾年前無咁難入的，so far都讀得ok。

除咗貴d之外，維小應該好過音小，聽d家長講維小而家幾重視培養gifted的小朋友，數學分stream分得好仔細，叻的吾會比hea的拖慢，可惜行IB可能吾係好啱佢。

作者: Jupiter 時間: 13-12-21 01:32 標題: 引用：回覆+Jupiter+的帖子去咗英華，幾年前無

原帖由 Jane1983 於 13-12-20 發表
回覆 Jupiter 的帖子

去咗英華，幾年前無咁難入的，so far都讀得ok。

My girl is not very brilliant and CP described her as having 小聰明 but learning attitude not good. She is good in English and leadership skills, but not those with brilliant Maths type. She is very talkative and sociable, teacher at school said she follows rules very well at school and learns things fast. I am worried that local schools would not be able to accept her. All the good schools in my area (net 16) are very pushy and harsh. I am sure she will be very happy going to VSA but just that it may not be suitable for her.

作者: shadeslayer 時間: 13-12-21 08:44 標題: 引用：Quote:原帖由+Jane1983+於+13-12-20+發表回

原帖由 Jupiter 於 13-12-21 發表
My girl is not very brilliant and CP described her as having 小聰明 but learning attitude not good. ...

All clever animals including humans like to play a lot, especially when they are young. When they find their passion and "purposes" in life, they will switch their energy to these things, and play less. It is about million times easier for kids to discover themselves and find passion and purposes in IS than in traditional schools.

I think you analyses the situation correctly. Is she going to "Hea" in IB? Probably. Is she going to improve and be influenced by classmates? Probably. Is she going to get better as she grow older? I think so. Which of the two situations is the lesser evil? Your girl "Hea" in IB school and is very happy, but you don't know if she is going to improve. Or your girl suffer in a traditional school and be seen as trouble maker?

Honestly your girl has a better chance of learning better "knowledge" in traditional schools. All kids do. But at what cost? Is knowledge the only thing we care in education?

Nothing in life is certain. You just take your best shot. Some people use definitive tone in giving you comments about whether your girl is suitable for traditional school or IB. I am not sure if you should take it at face value.

You may listen to comments but not literally, including mine. As parents I would advise you to go with your gut. Nobody knows your child better than you do. Other similar cases might be or might not be applicable to you. Nobody is to put up with whatever consequences your decisions are.

Trust yourself and trust your child.

作者: Radiomama 時間: 13-12-21 10:19 標題: 回覆：Jupiter 的帖子

仔仔幾年前的情況跟你女女相似，維幼的老師說：不要走太傳統的路。結果幫他轉了去國際學校，行IB課程，適合到不得了。
他好喜歡閲讀、超like數學，最重要給他空間發展。
IB/國際學校是否hea, 視乎家長和學生的態度，IB課程如教小朋友游海，教練要落水游，要有清晰目標和方法；傳統課程如游泳池，25米50米有板有眼、容易量度。
維小勝在IB之餘中文不弱，最近在朗誦節見到一些維小學生，英文發音好動聽。

作者: musicien 時間: 13-12-21 11:52 標題: 引用：Quote:原帖由+Jupiter+於+13-12-21+發表My+

原帖由 shadeslayer 於 13-12-21 發表
All clever animals including humans like to play a lot, especially when they are young. When they fi ...

Cannot agree more

作者: Jane1983 時間: 13-12-21 12:02

回覆 Jupiter 的帖子

你女女英文好、學嘢快，係學校能守規矩，其實都好好，在維小或活動教學的學校都應該讀得開心。

另外，你小朋友是否愛好音樂？如果吾係，音小可能吾係咁適合。

另外pm了你。

作者: poonseelai 時間: 13-12-21 12:14

朋友女兒超活躍、在傳統讀至小二轉入維小，轉校原因是小朋友無哂自信心，成績一般，父母接受但學校不滿意，叫小朋友食藥可坐定定，俾好大壓力父母和小朋友，連小朋友都認為自己好喳，小三入維小後多了時間去跳舞，又入泳隊，中學去英國。維小有老師跟進學習有困難小朋友，你不防問一下。

作者: Jupiter 時間: 13-12-21 12:40 標題: 回覆：原來而家維小都好難入

Really thank you so much for all your valuable comments, I think another good point about Vic is the parents' quality, your kids are so lucky to have parents like you all! I am not a good mom since I can't even figure out which type suits her more, while I should be the one who know her the best

How about conduct in VSA? This is also one of my worries....

作者: musicien 時間: 13-12-21 13:44 標題: 回覆：Jupiter 的帖子

I think if she can do well in Vic kg she will be gd in vsa. Ib is not hea at all. Enquiry based learning sud be better for ur kid in the long run. Although I want u to release vsa forme! Haha!

作者: Jupiter 時間: 14-1-1 23:41 標題: 引用：I+think+if+she+can+do+well+in+Vic+kg+she

原帖由 musicien 於 13-12-21 發表
I think if she can do well in Vic kg she will be gd in vsa. Ib is not hea at all. Enquiry based lear ...

Thanks for the encouragement! I have paid deposit to VSA, hope my girl can enjoy her school life there

作者: wwyee 時間: 14-1-5 14:27 標題: 回覆：原來而家維小都好難入

本帖最後由 wwyee 於 14-3-23 16:12 編輯

-------

作者: Elsa_chan 時間: 14-1-16 14:34 標題: 回覆：原來而家維小都好難入

真心想間下維小真係咁好？大家都爭住入讀？！

作者: Jane1983 時間: 14-1-16 17:20

回覆 Elsa_chan 的帖子

係咪真係「咁好」，係好難答到你，因為每個人要求和想法吾同。
Vsa係雙語，行IB，學校極鼓勵閱讀，IB成績吾錯，學校連續2、3年出到滿分狀元，個platform係可以培育到人才。

至於小朋友最終成吾成材，達吾達到家長目標，就有好多因素。

作者: mamaishere 時間: 14-2-1 09:06 標題: 引用：Quote:原帖由+Jane1983+於+13-12-20+發表回

原帖由 Jupiter 於 13-12-20 發表
My girl is with mild hyperactive and mildly gifted, CP said she needs a structured environment but c ...

想請教一下各位家長。我小朋友同你哋小朋友嘅情況聽落差不多，不過佢而家只有3歲，亦係返緊Vic K1。想早少少了解你哋提及學校俾你哋嘅建議，究竟咩性格嘅小朋友適合讀IB，邊啲唔適合？我小朋友10月細B，超級活潑好動，開朗多話專注力弱(除了看電視、畫畫和聽歌可以專心並安靜下來)。雖然只係K1，但老師都評語佢聰明醒目但真係坐唔定。照咁睇，如有幸上VSA，我又應否擔心佢會對自己無要求(佢真係對自己無乜要求)？或者學Jane講傳統但不太谷的學校比較適合？小朋友的老師喺家長日無俾乜建議，所以想請教下大家前輩。好多人話(包括我自己)都覺得維記好適合佢性格，又或者講，傳統學校太唔適合佢，只會被視為不合作嘅曳學生。但亦有人話應該俾佢去傳統訓練佢定性啲服從啲，頭都大！最慘係競爭大，唔到你話適合的又一定會俾offer你

作者: Jane1983 時間: 14-2-4 18:08

回覆 mamaishere 的帖子

小朋友仲細，多d觀察佢，和老師傾吓，小朋友真係日日吾同，突然開竅可以令你好驚喜。
至於搵學校，報多幾間你覺得好又適合小朋友的，IB又好、較structured的傳統教學又好，始終現在競爭大，維小亦吾係易入。

作者: hkparent 時間: 14-2-4 23:03 標題: 引用：回覆+mamaishere+的帖子小朋友仲細，多d

原帖由 Jane1983 於 14-02-04 發表
回覆 mamaishere 的帖子

小朋友仲細，多d觀察佢，和老師傾吓，小朋友真係日日吾同，突然開竅可以令你好驚 ...

As a relatively new school I think VSA has done quite well in its IB.

作者: Jane1983 時間: 14-2-4 23:34

本帖最後由 Jane1983 於 14-2-4 23:34 編輯

回覆 hkparent 的帖子

同意，同埋睇到近一、兩年課程做好咗好多，收生亦好咗。Keep住，以後幾年，IB成績應該會再上。
我無利益的，係真心意見。

作者: piglet123 時間: 14-2-15 08:58 標題: 回覆：原來而家維小都好難入

Everyone seems quite positive on vsa here.. Do the parents need to be very involved in all the projects and homework?

作者: tcbobo 時間: 14-2-15 09:09 標題: 回覆：piglet123 的帖子

VSA在ISA test for grade 3 的平均分，較其他國際學校（包括ESF)高頗多，相信學生的質素應該很好。

作者: Jane1983 時間: 14-2-15 14:47

回覆 piglet123 的帖子

詳情要等用家答。
不過凡係多中國人讀的學校，都有忍吾到手的家長。親友仔讀cndis，佢一樣話有d家長太involve。好似Vsa有個學生的媽媽是前model，前一排看雜誌，佢詳列個仔一星期15個興趣和補習班。

講咁多，其實想話也人都有，你有自己宗旨就係啦。

作者: cherubic 時間: 14-2-15 15:53

回覆 piglet123 的帖子

I observe that there are quite a number of parents who are heavily involved in the kid's homework, most of them are full time mom. Many kids have tutors mainly for Chinese.

作者: HKTHK 時間: 14-2-15 18:10

回覆 tcbobo 的帖子

I thought Acer only release the average score for all students who took the test but not the average for HK. How do you draw the conclusion that VSA is above other schools?

作者: poonseelai 時間: 14-2-15 18:43

HKTHK 發表於 14-2-15 18:10
回覆 tcbobo 的帖子

I thought Acer only release the average score for all students who took the test ...

tcbobo refers to International Schools’ Assessment (ISA):

"ISA is an annual assessment programme that has been specially developed to measure skills in mathematical literacy, reading and writing of students in international schools.

The ISA reports provide descriptive information about what students know and can do. The results are analysed from year to year so they can be used to track changes over time at individual and school level."

School will get a report on the overall performance and a report will be issued to each student. It is very useful to track one's results overs the years.

作者: HKTHK 時間: 14-2-15 18:56

回覆 poonseelai 的帖子

I think we are referring to the same test here:
http://www.acer.edu.au/tests/isa/participating-schools

The organisation is ACER but the test is ISA?

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)