教育王國

標題: KV vs. St. Clare K1? How to choose [打印本頁]

作者: tktc100 時間: 12-6-3 22:37 標題: KV vs. St. Clare K1? How to choose

Hi my girl accepted into both KV and St. Clare's AM K1 class. We like one-dragon St. Clare's but also like more studying environment of KV esp as KV is famous for self disclipline.

How to choose?

作者: pluto_yuen 時間: 12-6-3 22:55

st clare!! very good primary school as backup.

作者: dwkw333 時間: 12-6-3 23:04

本帖最後由 dwkw333 於 12-6-3 23:04 編輯

I vote St. Clare. Not everyone in KV will get a good offer...

作者: flopsybunnies 時間: 12-6-3 23:38

Where do you live?

作者: spmok1999 時間: 12-6-4 00:41

幾千蚊學費  vs  一百蚊學費

冇小學 backup  vs  有英文私小 backup

地獄式訓練  vs  輕輕鬆鬆騎牛搵馬

作者: LL222 時間: 12-6-4 01:01

spmok1999 發表於 12-6-4 00:41
幾千蚊學費 vs 一百蚊學費

冇小學 backup vs 有英文私小 backup

講得exactly!!

作者: cmir 時間: 12-6-4 09:31

i will choose St.Clare as well...as it has primary back up....

作者: Ackl1002 時間: 12-6-4 11:30

St. Clares is an English primary school, though the secondary school campus is a bit 吊腳, it is definitely a good school in many perents' minds.

作者: tktc100 時間: 12-6-5 00:31

Thanks! I agree with your comments... but anyone have a different view that we should 'risk' KV? The KV kids do seem to have better learning by time P1 interviews start in K2...

作者: twolilmonkeys 時間: 12-6-5 02:24

Agree with spmok1999
If you are ambitious and your kid is smart go for KV.

作者: spmok1999 時間: 12-6-5 08:34

本帖最後由 spmok1999 於 12-6-5 08:46 編輯

其實你考得聖嘉勒幼稚園我相信你都有考慮過是否會直上小學, 若果你最後揀o左 kv, 咁到你考小一的時候你又會否報聖嘉勒小學呢? 若果真的決心揀 kv 的話你就要有個心理準備往後的兩年多時間要辛苦積極備戰去考小一, 唔好再諗返之前放棄聖嘉勒了, 我並唔係話讀聖嘉勒有得直上就乜都唔洗理, 只不過是讀聖嘉勒可以容許你和你的小朋友在較少的壓力環境下去選擇興趣或按照小朋友的特質去啟發小朋友的潛能... 咁讀 kv 都可以咁做...(若果你小朋友係 IQ & EQ 高的話), 不過小朋友的進展係好難估計的, 有時唔係你話谷就谷到, 若果因為一些學習上的問題而令小朋友厭惡讀書就麻煩了, 希望你能選擇一條適合你小朋友o既路去行...

作者: sarubuta 時間: 12-6-5 09:24 標題: 回覆：KV vs. St. Clare K1? How to choose

ST Clare 是否100% 直上小學？

作者: gwlam 時間: 12-6-5 09:52

sarubuta 發表於 12-6-5 09:24
ST Clare 是否100% 直上小學？

係。St. Clare's 同真光（both 大坑&堅道）都 guarantee 100%可升小。但出生率不停升，今年 guarantee 100%升小係講緊2006出生的小朋友，唔知幾年後仲係唔係。

作者: Amymichelle 時間: 12-6-5 10:53

St Clare's進可攻,退可守!
而KV兩年後又要再戰江湖

作者: mykate 時間: 12-6-5 13:59

gwlam 發表於 12-6-5 09:52
係。St. Clare's 同真光（both 大坑&堅道）都 guarantee 100%可升小。但出生率不停升，今年 guarantee 100 ...

2007 都係 guarantee 100%上~
我女2008年, 問過老師, 話應該都係!

作者: mykate 時間: 12-6-5 14:03

本帖最後由 mykate 於 12-6-5 14:04 編輯

spmok1999 發表於 12-6-5 08:34
其實你考得聖嘉勒幼稚園我相信你都有考慮過是否會直上小學, 若果你最後揀o左 kv, 咁到你考小一的時候你又 ...

Totally agree with your points!
我同我認識的家長, 都對升小學沒有壓力

同個女搵興趣班, 都唔會一定要有 certificate OR 去比賽

可以因應個女的興趣, 專長去學習

St Clare's 唔係最 top 的, 但一定是好學校!

作者: sarubuta 時間: 12-6-5 23:30

想問St Clare 是否好傳統, 好嚴的學校? 我想知幼稚園和小學是否都係.
同埋, 我知小學係英文小學, 咁幼稚園係中文為主? 是否每天有英文堂? 有NET教? 唔出去上課外英文班上小學跟唔跟到?
我想幫囡囡找間校風好, 英文好, 一條龍(或有七八成人可以一路上), 學習氣氛好, D人唔會太勢利太複習.

作者: Luiluichu 時間: 12-6-6 00:43

我會選St.Clare, 因為100%入番小學. 我朋友的女兒上年都從KV畢業, 唔好彩的佢個女派到第6/7志願, 好彩佢最後都入了St.Clare. 但聽聞很多功課和測驗, 佢話如果呀女唔係由KV畢業出嚟, 睇怕佢都會追得好辛苦.

作者: caramom 時間: 12-6-6 13:35

本帖最後由 caramom 於 12-6-6 13:39 編輯

tktc100 發表於 12-6-3 22:37
Hi my girl accepted into both KV and St. Clare's AM K1 class. We like one-dragon St. Clare's but als ...

I was from St. Clare's primary school and I'm proud to be one of their students.
Yes, I used to have 2 form tests and 1 exam per semester.
The English teaching in St Clare is really good, the syllabus is a bit harder than other schools, eg: normal schools teach past tense in P.3 and we learned it in P.2, plus present perfect tense.
We learned Cursive in P.3 and starting to use Cursive to do hw, dictation in P.4.
Apart from English textbook, we have another 'Reader', there were several stories in it and the level of difficulty is high, after reading it we have to finish a worksheet with some questions about the story and memorize it for exams.
I would say St. Clare's is a school that focus on academic, as well as other aspects especially on Moral education.
I have had a good time in St. Clare's and I missed it so much when I left the school, though we often have quizzes/test/exam, I was very happy studying in it, teachers and the pricipal are nice and patient. My classmates are well-behaved too.
I was from an ordinary kindergarten, but I didn't found that much pressure, in fact, I have only spent maximum 1.5 hours for doing homework and 1 hour for revision every day, I think it's acceptable.
If your child concentrate in class, she can probably complete her homework within 1.5 hour.
St. Clare's is in fact a very good school, they are very strict in discipline, students are well behaved, this is what I have observed in the past years.

作者: cmir 時間: 12-6-6 15:09

一條龍 is very important especially the competition is keen....less pressure for the parents and the students as well

作者: tktc100 時間: 12-6-6 22:01

Thank u!! I agree with you all. Seems nobody will recommend KV over SC.

作者: behappydad 時間: 12-6-7 00:15

如去Kv , 你希望去邊小学?
可以好過st clare?

作者: tktc100 時間: 12-6-11 22:12

Thank you to everyone who replied. We know what to do now.

Good luck to everyone!

作者: sweetieboy 時間: 12-6-13 13:46

Yeah. Vote for St Clare for sure.

作者: klm402 時間: 12-6-13 14:19

St.Clare with no doubt

作者: Cheungvirginia 時間: 12-6-13 16:10

St. Clara for sure!

作者: SCKnight 時間: 12-6-13 21:43

開心學習，St. Clare！
想做鐵人，KV！（正所謂抄默背諗，KV至強！）

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)