教育王國

標題: 英華女校及上智 [打印本頁]

作者: bau 時間: 12-5-29 17:09 標題: 英華女校及上智

心儀這兩所中學, 請問有什麼評價.

作者: smallfoothk 時間: 12-5-29 17:26

校舍英華女校比上智好, 名氣英華女校比上智高,老師和學生關係英華女校不及上智因見有人讚上智老師 ,但英華女校就不清楚...交通方便英華女校不及上智 ,以上個人見解,不合匆插.

作者: bau 時間: 12-5-29 18:07

收生方面是否英華要求較高? 英華將暫時搬往深水埗, 因此若成績允許想自行博一博. 始終英華是傳統名校水準有保證. 上智也是一所十心好學校. 而且較近屋企, 因此兩間都是心目中的選擇

作者: sirlo 時間: 12-5-29 20:25

其實有否想過那一間會適合你囡囡？我兩間簡介會都參加過,兩間校長都好有heart,兩位都各在現任學校唸中學,足見兩校的教學理念是多麽薪火相傳!
個人觀察上智比較唸書型,可能同校舍少地方有關。故小女都報了英華,等待中

作者: bau 時間: 12-5-29 21:28

我個女比較慢熱,上智及英華都沒小學, 她認識新同學比較易, 英華我不知同學會否大多來自富裕家庭, 因地處於中半山, 上智感覺比較平實D,而且她學校比較多同學派往去, 所以仍十五十六....不過仍然是要自她的成績才能作判定

作者: cman_li 時間: 12-5-29 22:43

本帖最後由 cman_li 於 12-5-29 22:44 編輯

bau 發表於 12-5-29 21:28
我個女比較慢熱,上智及英華都沒小學, 她認識新同學比較易, 英華我不知同學會否大多來自富裕家庭, 因地處於 ...

因為校舍近屋企所以經常見到學生回校，英華女校絕對係一所平民學校，亦有鄰居的女兒讀這校，都是很樸素。

作者: bau 時間: 12-5-29 22:51

可否告之英華活動多嗎? 識好多中學同學比大人上班仲要忙...

作者: cman_li 時間: 12-5-29 23:32

回復 bau 的帖子

英華女校活動以體藝為主，學生較文靜。

作者: ssdiana 時間: 12-5-30 08:56

兩間都很好, 個人喜好英华女校

作者: bb86 時間: 12-5-30 09:25

英華將暫時搬往深水埗----I like 英華 but seems location not convenient for HK island students

作者: bau 時間: 12-5-30 09:50

As Ying Wah will be temporarily move to Sham Shui Po, maybe some HK island students will not consider it and this is why I want to consider it (I am living in SSP)
BTW, if my daughter is Band 1 student but not the top ten in the school, do you think she has chance?? What kind of students Ying Wah like to take?

作者: Netbrowser 時間: 12-5-30 10:08

本帖最後由 Netbrowser 於 12-5-30 11:03 編輯

My child was interviewed by Ying Wa and SSGC 2 years ago, and was admitted by SSGC finally. I live in Central-Western disctrict and so SSGC was my 1st choice in round one.

Personally, I like Ying Wa more in your case. As your child is not on the same school zone (quota for cross-zone is much less), it's hard to enter except in round one (DP). For your child to be successful in round one, try to improve the interview skill of your child.

One more point to note is that Ying Wa will refuse to accept your designed portfolio, they accept the pre-formated application form only.

作者: bau 時間: 12-5-30 10:52

Yes, can only try in Round One and now thinking to put it in 1st choice and Holy Trinity in 2nd choice, but the most important thing is to push my daughter to get better result so to have the chance to be interview (she is in P5 now). Preformated application form means the form as from Ying Wah? I want to gather more information at this stage so I can be well prepare.

作者: cman_li 時間: 12-5-30 13:14

本帖最後由 cman_li 於 12-5-30 19:51 編輯

當英華女校公佈要臨時調遷校舍，確實給中西區的家長打亂陣腳。原本只須幾分鐘的路程(小女步行速度)，變成舟車勞頓，既然如此就改變整個選校計劃。但對英華女校的印象始終不變，樓主不妨一試。

作者: bau 時間: 12-5-30 16:53

少了中西區學生, 但多了我們九龍學生申請, 好學校搬到那裡也不愁學生.
其實英華上智是旦一間收都於願足矣....
只希望學校能有好的學習環境, 中學朋輩影響最為重要, 家長幫不了什麼,最多只可鼓勵她們.另外中學是人生中最重要階段, 人的價值觀亦是在這時建立...

作者: bb86 時間: 12-5-30 17:07

本帖最後由 bb86 於 12-5-30 17:13 編輯

但當英華調返校舍去西區會唔會九龍學生一樣唔方便呢

作者: cman_li 時間: 12-5-30 19:48

bb86 發表於 12-5-30 17:07
但當英華調返校舍去西區會唔會九龍學生一樣唔方便呢

四年後英華調返校舍去中西區，MTR港島西線已開通至般含道，只是一路之隔便到羅便臣道。

作者: laiping 時間: 12-5-30 20:44

插吓咀!今年我都有去這兩間學校的簡介會,(因為她們都是我明年報自行的目標之二),兩間學校都真係好好好好好,對上智更是'驚為天人'!

有一點要提提樓主,如果上智是你杯茶,記住一定要去聽簡介會!

作者: bau 時間: 12-5-30 21:00

回復 laiping 的帖子

I went already. I didn't go to Ying Wah but it is one of the top school for girls. Honesty, HTC should be more fit my girl because we are very close to it and many of the students in her school allocated to HTC. But every mom wants to get the best for their kids, so if her result is good enough to try Ying Wah, I have no reason no to consider it. BTW, if MTR opens in 2016, it is really a good news to us.

作者: laiping 時間: 12-5-31 09:13

Oh! Really! If you like both YWG & HTC, why not put them both in 明年報自行? For my girl, she does not belong to this district! We really need to consider more! Regarding the opening of the Island West Line, it can really save the travelling time!

BTW, let's work hard for the coming exam!

作者: cman_li 時間: 12-5-31 12:31

No hardsell to YWGS since my daughter is studying in another school. I only clarify it with pleasure. Anyway, Good Luck to you!

作者: johnnywalker 時間: 12-6-3 00:01

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: johnnywalker 時間: 12-6-3 00:02

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: MimiCactus 時間: 12-6-3 00:15 標題: 回覆：bb86 的帖子

上智是傳統的天主教女校，校風較嚴。兩年前在報章上看見一則報道：將香港九龍新界的考入大學的百份比公佈，上智是99.8%。

作者: johnnywalker 時間: 12-6-3 00:38

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: bau 時間: 12-6-3 11:07

什麼大學也有, 但所有中學也是同樣計算, 上智其實真是一所幾實在的好學校, 近年成績令人眼前一亮. 不過為人父母當然希望在有選擇下可入到一所成績好又出名的中學. 問心講我也認為上智不會比英華差,但兩所可以選我想大部份人會選英華.

作者: Yanamami 時間: 12-6-3 11:57

MimiCactus 發表於 12-6-3 00:15
上智是傳統的天主教女校，校風較嚴。兩年前在報章上看見一則報道：將香港九龍新界的考入大學的百份比公佈， ...

根據Redkoni & HTC Annual School Report 2010~11 (p.9)所顯示, 入local U 應是70%.

作者: 莎莎莉莉 時間: 12-6-3 17:55

本帖最後由莎莎莉莉於 12-6-3 17:57 編輯

Yanamami 發表於 12-6-3 11:57
根據Redkoni & HTC Annual School Report 2010~11 (p.9)所顯示, 入local U 應是70%.

我係上智畢業, 如果計入到預科果班計, 入U應該係超過九成的.(我印象中預科同學無人入唔到...起碼我自己玩開果班係咁, 其他或者我唔識.)
理科班入三大的比率都多過九成啦...好少同學入唔到.
當然, 被篩出來果班另計.
當年還有中大暫取生, 我果年, 全部60個中六同學, 有十個讀完中六已直入中大了.
依家玩文憑試就唔知了.....

作者: 小伊 時間: 12-6-3 18:42 標題: 回覆：莎莎莉莉的帖子

答句咀，我在上智隔離間中學畢業，當年dang嘢過黎嘅就系我。記得那些年我哋都勁過上智，為何這十年大迹轉？

作者: panbaby 時間: 12-6-3 19:33

去到咁高班差唔多級數的中學, 其實好多時都是看學生本身, 多幾個百分點少幾個百分點, 呢啲數據每年都會有波幅. 我相信皇仁女拔如果某一年少一個或幾個百分點入大學, 唔會有損佢哋响家長心目中的地位.

我自己偏向老牌學校. 此乃純粹個人喜好.

作者: miffy 時間: 12-6-4 08:48

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: jelly-pudding 時間: 12-6-4 09:25 標題: 回覆：英華女校及上智

I was graduated from HTC in 1995 (form 7). We had totally 90 students in that year, i remember 89 out of 90 got into University. Most of us went to HKU and CU.

作者: bau 時間: 12-6-4 09:42

回復 miffy 的帖子

Yes Band 1 top

作者: miffy 時間: 12-6-4 10:03

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: fafayu 時間: 12-6-4 11:03

So far, I have found HTC a very good school for my daughter depsite the small campus almost after 1st year in her secondary school life. She was accepted by a band 1A school in Kowloon City before (ranked 30-35th in Khmama's list) a year ago but we decided to move to HTC as recommended by other parents. I think HTC is also conveniently located and most fit for band 1 girls if they live in NT west or northwest Kln.

HTC is a younger girls' school and low-profiled when compared with those renowned you have mentioned. I hope it is the school and the teachers there help students grow by providing an excellent learning atmosphere instead of a place where people only think kids got the fame because of the school history.

作者: cman_li 時間: 12-6-4 18:50

題外話講下件校服，阿女話HTC好醒目，英華就端莊。

作者: laiping 時間: 12-6-4 21:06

本帖最後由 laiping 於 12-6-4 21:12 編輯

回復 cheesenut 的帖子

真的是一間好好的學校,今年去了三間女校的簡介會(YWG,HTC &BPS),她給我的印象(如果三揀一,一定要揀一的話)是最好的!其餘兩間當然是優秀的傳統名女校,但上智,我膽敢說,她的優秀傳統正在努力建立中,假以時日,她的氣勢是不容忽視的!不過,假如亞女是又玩得又讀的話,YWG & BPS較適合!(純屬個人意見!)

作者: 莎莎莉莉 時間: 12-6-5 00:32

小伊發表於 12-6-3 18:42
答句咀，我在上智隔離間中學畢業，當年dang嘢過黎嘅就系我。記得那些年我哋都勁過上智，為何這十年大迹轉？ ...

你係銘X???

我記得以前兩校差不多, 但我都唔知點解近年好似上智標出來, 或者同校長換左有關.
依家的校長, 以前有教我, 係位好認真的人...當然我還覺得她有點惡.
但我覺得佢真係好愛上智.

作者: 莎莎莉莉 時間: 12-6-5 00:33

laiping 發表於 12-6-4 21:06
回復 cheesenut 的帖子

真的是一間好好的學校,今年去了三間女校的簡介會(YWG,HTC &BPS),她給我的印象(如果 ...

同意你的分析! 我自己當年都係偏向文靜, 入左U後才開始變得活潑.

作者: 莎莎莉莉 時間: 12-6-5 00:35

fafayu 發表於 12-6-4 11:03
So far, I have found HTC a very good school for my daughter depsite the small campus almost after 1s ...

對~~上智一向好低調, 我反而欣賞呢樣野~~真心係想教好學生, 唔係要追求甚麼名氣.
講真, 佢收既都係Band 1學生. 假如肯谷下體育音樂之類, 點會怕唔出名,
但我覺得學校唔係呢個方向囉.
創校校長係一個好平實, 好德高望重的修女.
我相信, 呢種就係學校特質的本源.

作者: Yanamami 時間: 12-6-5 08:07

莎莎莉莉發表於 12-6-5 00:32
你係銘X???

我記得以前兩校差不多, 但我都唔知點解近年好似上智標出來, 或者同校長換左有關.

Her love to HTC is undeniable and she devotes herself to the School, so do all other teachers who graduated from the same school(there're almost 40% of them, quite a high percentage).

作者: miffy 時間: 12-6-5 09:14

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: jiwawa 時間: 12-6-5 10:01 標題: 回覆：miffy 的帖子

上智係女校。

作者: johnnywalker 時間: 12-6-5 15:06

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: johnnywalker 時間: 12-6-9 23:24

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: cellon 時間: 12-6-9 23:29

上智　　：好好好。
英華女校：好好好好好。

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)