教育王國

標題: 有關Trinity Gese 考試集體投訴 [打印本頁]

作者: roybee103 時間: 12-5-4 08:44 標題: 有關Trinity Gese 考試集體投訴

由於今期有眾多Gese考生考試成績不滿考試結果及對考試結果有懷疑。亦有多個例子證明有能力獲得好成績的考生竟然出現不及格或強差人意的結果。本人身為教育界的前線員工，願意做代表為大家爭取一個公義的答覆及重考。如果有需要的家長可以在這裡回覆你的名字，我會pm你們資料
我們要一個公平公正的考試！而不是基於考試制度的改變或個別考官的問題，而犧牲家長及考生的時間和金錢！

作者: shirleycnf 時間: 12-5-4 10:18

Pls pm me. I also find it strange why my kid gets only pass in grade 2 exam when he gets distinction in grade 1.

作者: roybee103 時間: 12-5-4 16:38 標題: 引用：Pls+pm+me.+I+also+find+it+strange+why+my

原帖由 shirleycnf 於 12-05-04 發表
Pls pm me. I also find it strange why my kid gets only pass in grade 2 exam when he gets distinction ...

Sure I will pm u. My son's mother tongue is English and got distinction in grade 1. However , he got failed in grade 2. This really shocks me! I can't believe the examination could fail my son

this is totally ridiculous n unacceptable! We will fight for a fair result!!!!

作者: bellbellbear 時間: 12-5-4 22:16

我的女兒今次GESE Grade 2 拿了Distinction , 其他的一齊考的共4位小朋友,成績有3個也有Distinction, 一個pass, 賽果合理,不知是否個別考官的問題,也聽過有些center 考官要求較高,但本人及其他朋友小朋友也滿意今次結果!

作者: fw9166 時間: 12-5-4 22:48

本帖最後由 fw9166 於 12-5-4 22:49 編輯

回復 bellbellbear 的帖子

請睇下張評分紙考官名否Mr B Milward? 若果是,妳的小朋友英文能力相當好....因為好多人投訢呢個考官,太過嚴...

我囝都是這個考官.....Grade 1 得 Merit. 起初收到張評分紙,有點不開心,事關n咁多媽咪話易囉dist....
不過算喇...今次唔得,寄望下次,再唔得咪當囉到考試經驗.....

作者: LittlePanda101 時間: 12-5-4 23:59

I only received the certificate. Is it we can collect the 分紙？我只記得我個仔的考官是 Mr. Mil ward. 是否可上訢？thx

作者: EggEgg08 時間: 12-5-5 00:31 標題: 回覆：有關Trinity Gese 考試集體投訴

我地冇這個問題-我小朋友3歲多，考Grade 2, 都係 B Milward 考，好幸運拿了distinction.

作者: JJ2005 時間: 12-5-5 00:34 標題: 回覆：roybee103 的帖子

Pls pm me!

作者: kkhon 時間: 12-5-5 02:33

我囝考garde2是遇到Mr.B Milward但好彩地得到Distinction

作者: strawberry11 時間: 12-5-5 10:43

我女1/4 係上環佢地個center 考 grade 3，考官係Mr.B Milward ，幸運地有Distinction。我個女昨晚和我說考官有問這她 what is the day today? and what is the date today? 又問 weather，我女望望間房的窗答 it's quite warm and sunny, 之後又話 sorry! no, it's quite cool because i wear the jacket. 事實當天是乍暖還有小小寒。最後一條，考官要求我女問他一條問題，我女問他 what is your job? 考官答他是 teacher & examiner，我女又話 teacher ... when i grow up, i want to be a teacher. i like my teacher, Ms xx very much, she teaches me ... 反問他 examiner 做乜？個人覺得 Mr.B Milward ok ！

作者: roybee103 時間: 12-5-5 14:26 標題: 回覆：有關Trinity Gese 考試集體投訴

my examiner was Mr Bernard. Very strict without smile

my son felt scared of him during the exam

作者: roybee103 時間: 12-5-5 14:59 標題: 引用：I+only+received+the+certificate.+Is+it+w

原帖由 LittlePanda101 於 12-05-04 發表
I only received the certificate. Is it we can collect the 分紙？我只記得我個仔的考官是 Mr. Mil ward ...

If u want appeal I can help to complain

作者: helenli 時間: 12-5-5 18:42 標題: 回覆：strawberry11 的帖子

無錯，能互動，自信，自然溝通才能攞A。

作者: bellbellbear 時間: 12-5-6 09:07

考官是Mr. Mil ward, 考到Distinction, 我見考官O.K, 唔覺得惡,

作者: Tatyi 時間: 12-5-6 11:38 標題: 引用：考官是Mr.+Mil+ward,+考到Distinction,+我

原帖由 bellbellbear 於 12-05-06 發表
考官是Mr. Mil ward, 考到Distinction, 我見考官O.K, 唔覺得惡,

之前睇過你話女女同考官對答嗰幾句！你女女啲Oral 同反應確實頂瓜瓜

我個女考兩次都係Merit 咋

作者: PQRegine 時間: 12-5-7 18:29

Pls pm me!

作者: sze8 時間: 12-5-7 20:55

我的女兒在3月份考試時的考官都是Mr. B Milward,都只是拿pass(grade 2),連教她英文的老師都很驚訝,聽聞上次啲考官很手緊,因為是最後一次under5歲可以考。

作者: happystar 時間: 12-5-7 22:20

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: Harrietyee 時間: 12-5-7 23:55

I want to 集體投訴 too, pls pm me

作者: 妹妹豬媽媽 時間: 12-5-8 17:48 標題: 回覆：有關Trinity Gese 考試集體投訴

Me too! Want to complain, pls contact me!

作者: lion321 時間: 12-5-9 07:40 標題: 引用：Me+too!+Want+to+complain,+pls+contact+me

原帖由 妹妹豬媽媽 於 12-05-08 發表
Me too! Want to complain, pls contact me!

Me also, complaint about Mr Bernard, please PM me, tks.

作者: BeBeMa1012 時間: 12-5-11 10:43

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: mouseandcat 時間: 12-5-11 16:11

My Son also attended this exam in March 2012, and the examiner is also Mr Bernard Millward, My son had responded very well, and I understand that he had answered all the questions correctly, and even right after the exam, he had cheerfully said 'hi' to the examiner. I was surprised and disappointed to know that he just got Merit in Grade 1. What can we do if we are not satisfied with the exam results? Could you pm back to me for details. Thanks..

作者: roybee103 時間: 12-5-11 23:37 標題: 回覆：有關Trinity Gese 考試集體投訴

由於有眾多投訴，請各位媽媽預備以下資料，然後Pm我。我會收集所有投訴，然後想trinity經理投訴！如果經理坐視不管！我會向報章或傳媒舉報

Student name
Age
Exam grade
Date of exam
Exam center
Name of examiner
Result
Previous result if applicable
Contact number

Thank you!

作者: roybee103 時間: 12-5-11 23:39 標題: 回覆：有關Trinity Gese 考試集體投訴

---Student name :---Age :---Exam grade :---Date of exam :---Exam center: ---Name of examiner: ---Result: ---Previous result if applicable: ---Contact number :---
Thank you!

作者: muibaby 時間: 12-5-17 08:22 標題: 回覆：roybee103 的帖子

pm u the details, have u receive it?

作者: roybee103 時間: 12-5-21 18:39 標題: 引用：pm+u+the+details,+have+u+receive+it? +

原帖由 muibaby 於 12-05-17 發表
pm u the details, have u receive it?

sorry I didn't receive urs. Can u send again pls

作者: Little-crab 時間: 12-5-23 15:02

I want to complain too.........

作者: ma1015 時間: 12-5-26 14:40

請問今天比資料可以嗎？請查pm!

作者: MeiLingHo 時間: 12-5-28 10:15

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: bellbellbear 時間: 12-5-31 23:47

回復 MeiLingHo 的帖子

Grade 2 wow, 重答單字,個Distinction 咁易羅, 同Grade 1有乜分別,分Grade原因係要求同評方準則唔同,如果人人答個單字都得Distinction, 學校都知水平低,就冇公信力!

作者: jamiesonbaby 時間: 12-6-2 00:55

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: Little-crab 時間: 12-6-11 16:31

If i send you the information now, will it be too late? please advise.

作者: mary2000 時間: 12-6-11 23:37

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: roybee103 時間: 12-6-15 17:32 標題: 回覆：有關Trinity Gese 考試集體投訴

各位trinity已回覆，以我們的case，不可集體處理，要獨立處理，家長可以付錢appeal 原來因為每次考試考官都會錄音，
萬一有家長吾滿意考試結果，可以比大約200$港幣去比trinity 叫另外一個考官去評分。但我個人覺得解決吾到問題，官官相護，如果第二個考官比及格甘米等於自大嘴巴！所以我覺得就算再評核結果都係一樣我對佢地回覆好失望

作者: ANChan59 時間: 12-6-17 11:13 標題: 回覆：有關Trinity Gese 考試集體投訴

如果個個小朋友取得distinction，我會懷疑examiner有問題多d。不合常理，亦另父母有錯誤期望。

作者: lcdtopcon 時間: 12-6-17 13:40 標題: 引用：我是路過的，看了以上各位家長的投訴內容，

原帖由 mary2000 於 12-06-11 發表
我是路過的，看了以上各位家長的投訴內容，大家好像都是為考而學，去坊間上堂，小朋友的會話基本功不夠扎實 ...

Totally agree！

作者: yipoitai 時間: 12-6-20 20:54

請問你地係邊度學GESE?

作者: mary2000 時間: 12-6-21 00:11

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: helenli 時間: 12-6-21 03:03 標題: 回覆：mary2000 的帖子

簡單來說就是測試溝通能力，考試範圍其實都是一般日常對話，溝通能力是長時間浸淫出來，不是take一兩個坊間的所謂應試課程就可以。

作者: CPSKWW 時間: 12-7-18 22:54

Just read the messages and understand parents' frustration. I was one of the frustrated mother when I knew my daughter just got 'Pass' in Grade 2, who got distinction in Grade 1. I called Angie and understood the complaint procedure was not that easy and the most important point was they would not 're-grade' in an easy way.
The solution was to enrol my daughter in the exam again to prove her capability and she got distinction in July exam. Just want to convey a message to those with my same experience. Trust your kids and they can make it!

作者: zuzu888 時間: 12-7-19 13:25

Hope all of you get a satisfy result finally,

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)