教育王國

標題: ESFPrimary or Harrow [打印本頁]

作者: soecec 時間: 12-4-25 22:07 標題: ESFPrimary or Harrow

Can anyone share the comments on both schools please? Is it very easy to get in Harrow?

作者: mrshoho 時間: 12-4-25 23:34

I would say no school is easy to get if you are going through the normal procedure... unless you have connections!!!

作者: Hedgies 時間: 12-4-26 10:24

my kid is lucky enough to get offers from esf primary and harrow..it was a tough decision to be made... but we ended up choosing esf because of its established track record... hope my choice is right.

作者: nintendo 時間: 12-4-26 11:12

harrow 名氣應該比 esf 高，但問題係，harrow 係新校，始終覺得要觀望
考得 harrow，應該即係能銀根不缺，應該中學都會諗去英國罷
係我會小學讀 esf，到中學考 harrow，甚至去英國當地讀都得，大把好學校你揀

作者: Onsen 時間: 12-4-26 16:38

Depends on what you are looking for. Harrow in Hong Kong is not the same as Harrow in the UK. Your kids will mostly be friend with the wealthy Mainland students. They just hired the Chief Executive from the ESF. At the ESF school my kid is attending, the overall percentage of English, Australian, Americans and Canadians and other Europeans countries are over 70 percent. In school, kids learn from each other. Don't be fool by the name alone. Just consider that as a franchise store of the original one!

作者: 4eyesDad 時間: 12-4-26 17:18

Onsen: Can you please tell us what role will the Chief Executive from the ESF be taking at Harrow International? I heard that Harrow International already has a Head Master-elect who is presently Deputy Head Master of Harrow, UK.

作者: soecec 時間: 12-4-26 22:44

HEAD MASTER

Mel Mrowiec (Christ Church, Oxford) from Harrow School, England

SENIOR LEADERSHIP TEAM

Head of the Lower School and the Prep School
Jason Taylor (University of Lancaster) formerly of Quarry Bay School, Hong Kong and Harrow International School, Bangkok
Director of Studies
James Thomas (Trinity Hall, Cambridge) from Wellington College, England
Director of Pastoral Care and Boarding
Barnaby Durrant (University College, London) from Stowe School, England
Director of Extra-Curricular Activities
Sarah Delaney (The University of New England, NSW, Australia) from The Cheltenham Ladies’ College, England
Deputy Head of Lower School and Pre-Prep Phase Leader
Cordelia Cripps (University of Liverpool, Chester) from Kennedy School, Hong Kong

作者: 4eyesDad 時間: 12-4-27 09:51

soecec 發表於 12-4-26 22:44
HEAD MASTER
Mel Mrowiec (Christ Church, Oxford) from Harrow School, England

It appears that Harrow International has an impressive list of staff. How does this list compare to the ESF's staff list?

作者: hkparent 時間: 12-5-2 12:57

If I have the money and distance is not a concern, I will go for Harrow HK. Heard that Harrow HK is not allowed to admit Mainland students. They should go to Harrow Beijing.

I've heard that chance for getting in Harrow UK is very very slim - only a few boys from HK every year - little hope then.

ESF - a good choice for money saving.

作者: elizatyy 時間: 12-5-5 08:53

一間是本地名校、另一間是國際知名學府

作者: mirage 時間: 12-5-7 21:08

回復 hkparent 的帖子

I'm afraid you are wrong,my neighbourhood's kid will enter Harrow kinder in coming September, they are both from Mainland.

作者: do123alex 時間: 12-5-7 21:19

Heard that a lot of local parents not going for Harrow even though they have offer.
Secondly what would you value more, IB vs traditional UK curriculum?
And the quality of teaching staff, at ESF just depend on your luck to have good teacher in your class.

作者: happyeasy 時間: 12-5-7 22:42 標題: 回覆：hkparent 的帖子

Correct me if I am wrong. Harrow HK admits students from the Mainland, if they are HK ID card holders (permitted to stay in HK but they may not have the permanent residency status). Their parents come to HK under work visa or investment scheme. Harrow Beijing cannot admit Mainland students unless they hold a foreign passport (because of the Mainland government policy).

作者: kaplanmeier 時間: 12-5-8 12:13

I believe the policy remains the same asbefore: Chinese residents of the Mainland and Taiwan can only be admitted todegree programmes but not to primary or secondary schools. See

http://www.immd.gov.hk/ehtml/id996.htm

Sorry for being discouraging but I amafraid that the notion that Harrow is a placefor networking with wealthy families from the Mainland is perhaps nothing morethan fantasy. Those who can go to Harrow(HK) can go to any international schools in HK, such as CIS, HKIS, GSIS, etc. Those who cannot go to other internationalschools in HK cannot go to Harrow (HK), but when reach the age for year 9, goto Harrow (UK), Eton, Westminster,...

Harrow (HK) has not been granted anyexemption. In contrast, the restrictionthat she could not admit more than 50% local passport holders has not been imposedon any other schools.

I attended a briefing session for confirmedfamilies, and found that about half of the attendees were Caucasians whilst theother half were Asians. Wealthy ornot? I could not tell and nobody cared; weonly cared about the curriculum, the experience of the teaching staff and theschool life.

作者: do123alex 時間: 12-5-8 21:42

Those wealthy mainland kids are simply classified the local group so long as they have HKSAR ID and passport, so how many are from real local family in the 50 % bucket?

作者: kaplanmeier 時間: 12-5-9 09:08

本帖最後由 kaplanmeier 於 12-5-9 09:12 編輯

回復 do123alex 的帖子

Whenever a person is holding a local passport, he is a local person. Being a local person, he is eligible to apply to any schools. If he doesn't speak Cantonese but does speak English as an alternative language, then he can enjoy a higher priority than Cantonese speaking children, when applying to ESF. (Of course, this is just a stated policy; I am aware of the hearsay that for some ESF schools, some unlucky Category 1 applicants may not be interviewed at all.) However, when applying to Harrow, a local person, no matter what languages he speaks, will suffer from this 50% cap. Being a child of a wealthy family or not is, I believe, irrelevant.

It would be hard for me to imagine that wealthy families living at the Peak, Repulse Bay, South Bay etc will give up GSIS, HKIS, CIS nearby and send their children to a school at Tuen Mun.

The couple I met in the car park after the briefing session drove a compact Mazda. Well, perhaps because I, as well as those whom I had a conversation with, showed interest only in our children’s education, and so all of them seemed ordinary. So, you met some wealthy and blue-blooded families?

Sorry, in fact I am not so sure if I understood the concerns you were trying to raise.

作者: mirage 時間: 12-6-5 13:13

I just met a new neighbourhood who move from SE asia to live in Gold Coast area as they want their daughter to study in Harrow. And when chatted with them, the availability of boarding house in Harrow is one of the reason they choose Harrow.

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)