教育王國

標題: 蔡継友係備取生,唯有聖嘉勒 VS 陳守仁，二揀一 [打印本頁]

作者: TB 時間: 12-1-12 23:36 標題: 蔡継友係備取生,唯有聖嘉勒 VS 陳守仁，二揀一

本帖最後由 TB 於 12-1-16 09:55 編輯

各位你們好，真係唔好彩，心儀嗰間on waiting list, 打咗輸數, 剩番 St Clare's 同陳守仁. 兩間都幾鐘意, 由期係陳守仁語言好, 但無中學, 唔知中學派位會點，St Clare's 就有附屬中學, 這間都唔錯。所以想請大家有經驗嘅媽媽比D意見比小妹, 真係15，16，唔知點？

作者: 哈比 時間: 12-1-13 10:27

St. Clare's vs TSL

兩間都是好學校, 兩間都是英文小學,
St. Clare's 有英中直上 (75%)..
另一間 TSL 沒有...

比著我, 會考慮埋升中校綱..."中西區 vs 油尖旺"...

作者: strawberry11 時間: 12-1-13 10:59

TSL 最衰冇中學。但上年簡介會，楊校長說他都知道家長期盼一條龍中學！佢都知道，但找合適的中學結龍要時間同學校理念要相同。

我都有考CKY，昨天未收到信，我預了唔得，都諗緊TSL 和另外一間九龍英小，TSL ~ 學費平(千幾蚊—經濟如何，但負擔到！)，又有日文、法文學；課外活動仲有golf、攀石等… 真係好吸引。

上年有小6派位 ~ 有3個考到男拔、3個考到女拔、5個考到st paul co.ed. 其餘的都ok！女女冇考St. Clare

作者: ilj 時間: 12-1-13 11:13

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: strawberry11 時間: 12-1-13 11:24

回復 ilj 的帖子

你都講得對！

但注冊TSL當日，見到一對外國人 + 一對西人丈夫&中國人太太及3位有禮的南亞母親，感覺間學校係平價國際學校，語言環境應該好好…

作者: TheWiseMom 時間: 12-1-13 11:42

本帖最後由 TheWiseMom 於 12-1-13 14:55 編輯

I think strawberry11's data are for 2009-2011. I'm only on the waitlist of TSL, but it expired already. I'm considering if I should re-apply again this Jun., as this school is pretty far for me. ilj mentioned that only the very top students can go to the very top secondary schools. But is it easy to get to the top in TSL, as the students selected are very smart? I'm thinking I should choose a local good school by central allocation. That school places the top students to 1st-tier schools like St. Paul's Co-ed. College, DBS, La Salle as well (though very limited no.). I guess it's easier to get to the top in a local gov't school.

作者: strawberry11 時間: 12-1-13 11:57

是一年派位，不是2009/2011

TSL - SSPA Result

2010-2011 P.6

Secondary School Places Allocation Results (Last update on 11 July)
  CCC Ming Kei College 2 students
  Chan Sui Ki (La Salle) College 1 student
  Diocesan Boys' School 3 students
  Diocesan Girls' School 3 students
  Good Hope School 5 students
  Homantin Government Secondary School 1 student
  Jockey Club Ti-I College 1 student
  King's College 1 student
  La Salle College 3 students
  Madam Lau Kam Lung Sec Sch Of MFBM 1 student
  Marymount Secondary School 2 students
  Our Lady of the Rosary College 1 student
  PLK Laws Foundation College 4 students
  PLK Ngan Po Ling College 30 students
  Pentecostal Lam Hon Kwong School 1 student
  Queen Elizabeth School 6 students
  Queen's College 1 student
  Shatin Pui Ying College 1 student
  St Francis Xavier's College 3 students
  St Louis School 1 student
  St Paul's Co-educational College 5 students
  St Paul's College 5 students
  St Paul's Convent School 4 students
  St Rose of Lima's College 1 student
  St Stephen's College 2 students
  St Stephen's Girls' College 1 student
  Stewards Pooi Kei College 1 student
  Tak Nga Secondary School 1 student
  True Light Girls' College 4 students
  Tsuen Wan Government Secondary School 2 students
  TWGHs Wong Fut Nam College 1 student
  Wah Yan College, Kowloon 7 students
  Ying Wa College 3 students
  Ying Wa Girls' School 1 student

  Other DSS Schools:
  Creative Secondary School 1 student
  Delia Memorial School (Broadway) 1 student
  Delia Memorial School (Glee Path) 1 student
  ECF Saint Too Canaan College 1 student
  ELCHK Lutheran Academy 1 student
  Evangel College 1 student
  G. T. (Ellen Yeung) College 1 student
  HKBU A-Sch Wong Kam Fai Sec & Pri Sch 1 student
  HKMA David Li Kwok Po College 3 students
  Lam Tai Fai College 1 student
  Qualied College 1 student
  Tak Sun Secondary School 1 student
  Wai Kiu College 1 student
  YMCA of Hong Kong Christian College 12 students
  Other Local/International Schools 14 students

作者: TB 時間: 12-1-13 14:22

Hi all Mom: Many Thanks for your advices.Base on "strawberry11" information, only the a small amount of top students are able to get into the top schools (DGS. Good Hope...etc). Of course, 6 years later is another story.

I did ask the Sr. teacher during the second interview about on whether they have any plan to link or even expand to have a secondary school, she responsed that this is always one for their plan, but she did not answer me directly on whether it will be materialized in the near future.

PS: Any mom can share some information from both school, such as Homework Loading, school life and happiness of your child. your information is greatly appreciated.

作者: TheWiseMom 時間: 12-1-13 14:55

I quote some of the data on the last page of the green covered prospectus that I got during the 1st interview (9/10/11) :

SSPA Results
2009/2011 Secondary School Places Allocation

DBS--3 students
DGS--3 students
Good Hope School--5 students
La Salle College--3 students
PLK Ngan Po Ling College--27 students
St. Paul's Co-ed. College--5 students

HKMA David Li Kowk Po College--4 students
YMCA of HK Christian College--12 students

Other Local/International Schools--21 students

作者: TB 時間: 12-1-14 08:10

回復 TheWiseMom 的帖子

Thx for your information. I saw a lots of students get into plk ngan po ling college, what kind of college is it? Any good? Thx

作者: TheWiseMom 時間: 12-1-14 20:31

回復 TB 的帖子

Hi TB,

Actually, I just quoted some of them for reference. I don't know much about PLK Ngan Po Ling College. All I know it's related to PLK. But if you live near TSL, it's a good school for you w/economical fees. I'm still thinking about it, but it's too far for me.

作者: 小伊 時間: 12-1-14 22:51

問題系st. Clare 中學麻麻地。

作者: TB 時間: 12-1-14 23:23

回復小伊的帖子

Hi： So far what i have heard from st clare's is good. Can you please give me a bit more information on which area or why their secondary school is so so？ thx！

作者: 小伊 時間: 12-1-15 12:09

St Clare 只屬band 2 頭至band 1尾。

作者: TB 時間: 12-1-16 09:52

本帖最後由 TB 於 12-1-16 09:52 編輯

回復小伊的帖子

I see. Thanks for your information. But the question is I only have 2 choices between TSL vs St Clare's for primary school. If I choose St Clare;s and if my kid can achieve good results in the next 6 years, I still have St Clare's secondry school as a backup and still can apply for the good secondary school in the same district "中西區". My husband and I really like TSL and is cheaper too, but no secondary gets us worry!

作者: 哈比 時間: 12-1-16 10:26

冇錯! 你個情況係, 只得兩間可以選擇 (TSL vs St. Clare's)....

個人覺得, St. Clare's, 進可攻, 退可守, 如你囡囡叻叻, 可插其它更好小學..
同埋,中西區中學好過油尖旺區...

而TSL升中係 uncertainly...

當日很高興St. Clare's 都收咗我囡囡, 最可惜要放棄大抽獎...
幸好,有另一間中西區收咗, 亦有中學feeder...

我始終覺得, 有中學backup, 心理上安全得多....

作者: TB 時間: 12-1-16 15:58

回復哈比的帖子

Hi 哈比: Yes, this is exactly what I think as well after hear all information and advices from different people. Seriously, Childern competing on positions for secondary school are already very tuff these days and imagine what will happen in another 6 years. Just comparing this year vs 2-3 years ago on primary school places are two different stories and will get more and more tuff on the upcoming years. feel sorry for the kid these days.

作者: dwkw333 時間: 12-1-16 21:11

Totally agree with 哈比. "St. Clare's, 進可攻, 退可守"

P.S.: St. Clare's is Band 1B according to BK.

作者: TB 時間: 12-1-17 00:18

本帖最後由 TB 於 12-1-17 00:19 編輯

回復 dwkw333 的帖子

Hi： just for my information， can you please tell me where i can find the rating of st clare's as band 1b according to bk？ thx in advance！

作者: dwkw333 時間: 12-1-17 09:22

Hi TB,

You can refer to the Excel in the following BK thread:

http://www.edu-kingdom.com/forum ... &extra=page%3D1

P.S.: Please just take this as reference only. I think public exam result should not be the sole factor for your decision. :)

作者: TB 時間: 12-1-17 11:31

回復 dwkw333 的帖子

Of course, just another reference. Many Thanks!

作者: malakids 時間: 12-1-17 11:58

本帖最後由 malakids 於 12-1-30 18:47 編輯

Hi TB,

I agree with 哈比 that St. Clare's, 進可攻, 退可守. It is not easy for TSL to tie to a band 1 secondary school for the coming six years.

作者: TB 時間: 12-1-18 12:28

回復 malakids 的帖子

Hi malakids :

This is what I am thinking of as well. Of course, it will depend on the registration status on how many "Offer" students decide to go to other school and give up CKY place which I hope I am on of the lucky one to get an offer for my kid. Seriously, there are a lots of X factors involved and what I can do now is to sit and wait. I heard a case from last year that one student gave up hope on CKY, buy all the uniforms, books, school bus...etc for the other school, spend alomost $10K and ready to start at the other school. 4 days before school start, CKY called in and offer a place for her kid......

作者: bodor 時間: 12-1-30 17:17

CKY是一間好的中小學, 提供一個好的學習環境, 而且小班教學, 係個度讀書的學生個個都好SMART, 最重要是一條龍.....
至於, TSL都是一間不錯的小學, 不過沒有一條龍, 到小六又再頭痛, 都好麻煩, 你想一想吧.......!

作者: vincher 時間: 12-1-30 17:37

論英語學習環境，cky >TSL>St. Clare's

作者: CrabPincers 時間: 12-1-30 17:41

ST CLARE 衰極最多都係BAND 1 尾, 點都吾會係BAND 2 頭

比著我, 我一定會揀ST CLARE
未試過升中痛苦既, 吾會知道無直屬/聯繫中學的苦況
陳守仁係有好好的語言環境, 同埋好TOP 的學生, 會比D 好好的直資中學取錄
但自己去看下, 可以升讀好好的直資中學的學生有幾多個? (只計傳統出名直資), 你自問自己的仔女, 可吾可以做到呢10幾20個優秀的學生其中之一?

ST CLARE 勝在, 猛車邊BAND 2 頭的女仔, 都可以升讀返ST CLARE, 衰極, 都係英中

如果到時讀ST CLARE 成績好, 一樣可以比D 優秀直資中學取錄
進可攻, 退可守

叻的學生, 去到邊, 都可以好叻, 只要校風好

作者: TB 時間: 12-1-30 18:16

Hi CrabPincers :This is what I think too. I never expect my girl to be the top top student. I agreed with you that 校風好 is very important.In addition, 直屬/聯繫中學 is the most important thing I consider.

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)