教育王國
標題: 東區14 綱, 請問點排位好?? [打印本頁]
作者: JANETHIM 時間: 12-1-9 14:53 標題: 東區14 綱, 請問點排位好??
我住１４綱，心儀以下４間小學，請問點排位好呢??
請指教?
1, 北角循遁衛理小學
２丹拿山循衛理小學
３北角官立小學
４滬江小學
作者: Vickymouse 時間: 12-1-10 12:58
北角官立小學.....雲景道 ? 定....英皇道 ???
作者: JANETHIM 時間: 12-1-10 16:48
回復 Vickymouse 的帖子
係英皇道果間呀!
作者: 已刪除用戶 時間: 12-1-10 17:01
我朋友住以上其中一間隔離, 佢形容"日日小息, 個唔知校長定訓導主任都拎住個咪不停鬧", 我建議你不妨搵日抽空去校外聽聽, 睇下事實如何
作者: takiko 時間: 12-1-10 17:01
你連校名都未搞清楚 ?? 沒有 1, 北角循遁衛理小學
２丹拿山循衛理小學
只有 >> 北角循道學校, 丹拿山循道學校, 北角衛理上午小學,
北角衛理下午小學
作者: JANETHIM 時間: 12-1-10 19:49
回復 takiko 的帖子
我只是打錯咗校名, 是那一間學校我好清楚的!
作者: hialice 時間: 12-1-10 20:09
如果大抽獎, 我會選學位較多的學校, 機會好像大一點~ 不過同意樓上所說, 北官確實麻麻, 因有朋友的仔在讀緊~
作者: JANETHIM 時間: 12-1-10 20:20
回復 hialice 的帖子
你指是 英皇道定 雲景道 北角官立小學
.?? 因有兩間的!
作者: takiko 時間: 12-1-11 09:41
本帖最後由 takiko 於 12-1-11 09:45 編輯
JANETHIM 發表於 12-1-10 19:49 
回復 takiko 的帖子
我只是打錯咗校名, 是那一間學校我好清楚的!
打錯咗校名都可以估到~ 但 net 14 真是沒有 "循道衛理", "循道"有兩間, "衛理"有兩間, 你清楚, 人地唔清楚呢~ 所以咪無人答你囉~~
作者: ha8mo 時間: 12-1-11 11:57
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: mengtakparent 時間: 12-1-11 13:15
北角衛理..好多學生入band one
http://www.npmps.edu.hk/result_pop10-11.html
作者: 曲曲 時間: 12-1-11 17:15
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: anaBB 時間: 12-1-11 17:17
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: ANChan59 時間: 12-1-11 23:43
回復 mengtakparent 的帖子
62-67% students are band 1, my son graduated from NPMPS. (Banding only for students, not for schools.)
作者: ha8mo 時間: 12-1-13 14:55
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: 婕婕媽 時間: 12-1-13 17:01
回復 ha8mo 的帖子
今年小一.....一班30-32人, 聽聞每班好似有9個男生, 比起以前比例多左
作者: Jasmine-4711 時間: 12-1-14 21:32
本帖最後由 Jasmine-4711 於 12-1-14 22:50 編輯
Sorry my Chinese writing pad is not working.
Wukong >75% goes to band 1 secondary. Even better than Wai Lee half day, 65-70%. But Wukong drills a lot, lots of homework, recite poems and projects. Life is much happier in Wai Lee half day, with only minor difference in %, I will choose Wai Lee if my kid is not drilling material. But it only has 60 seats for am school, 60 for pm.
北角循: old bulding, but 55% goes to band 1. kind teachers. 100seats.
丹拿山循: new buidling, but under40% goes to band 1 . Strict teachers and only 75 seats, less than北角循.
作者: ANChan59 時間: 12-1-14 21:52
回復 Jasmine-4711 的帖子
I check the 滬江小學 website, 75% only for first choice in allocation, not band 1.http://www.sap.edu.hk/CustomPage/openInIFrame.aspx?webPageId=11&nnnid=13
I think NPMPS has more band 1 students % than 滬江小學.
作者: Jasmine-4711 時間: 12-1-14 22:57
本帖最後由 Jasmine-4711 於 12-1-15 22:26 編輯
回復 ANChan59 的帖子
I went to all 4 schools' open days for 2 years or more. The average is more reliable than one particular year.
Also, top choice of some weak students may not be band 1 school already. The 75% you said is top 3 choices, so I think the 3 rd choice is not likely a band 1 school.
I made an excel speedsheet to track how may went to each school and do not include so called band 1 that has only one all English class and 3 Cantonese classes (1 out of 4 is not really band 1 standard, agree?). In conclusion, the 2 year data shows Wukong is better than NP Wai Lee (Wai Lee included some 1/4 English schools in their band 1 calculation). Old Chun Dao is 3rd and Dan Chung is 4th.
ps. I ruled out NP Govt Primary and Pao Mai due to personal reasons. Traditional Schools do not fit my over-active naughty son. 3 years ago their band 1 % is under 40%, but I have not collected their data (Govt Primary and Pao Mai) in the recent 2 years.
Canossa is over 60%, but they have a related girls' secondary. for boys, I will not pick that.
作者: ANChan59 時間: 12-1-14 23:20
My son studied in NPMPS, I know Net 14 pretty well including Shanghai Alumni.
You can check the data in the link I provided, better than your memory years ago. Some schools in the left hand column are "Band 1", all on right column are "Band 2 & 3".
I give you and other parents a suggestion, go to khmama's table and identify "Band 1" schools and you can see 75% may not true.
I bracket Band 1 as you also know, eventually no banding for schools, banding only for students. So the 1st choice not necessary related to "Banding of schools".
作者: Jasmine-4711 時間: 12-1-15 00:31
本帖最後由 Jasmine-4711 於 12-1-15 22:27 編輯
I went to all the school website and their open day and took pictures of the allocation for those which do not post results on websites. I tracked the results of 2-3 years in excel. Those are not only distant data. I went a few months ago the last time to see this summer's results.
Definition of "band 1" secondary are not the same in these primary schools and I am just trying to make parents aware of that....ie. don't just believe everything they post on the website, % can be misleading if their definitions are not the same. I define that if half the classes are taught in English, then it is a band 1 school to me. Some schools have loose definitions of what band 1 is. I respect others, including you, who may think differently. To me 1/4 English class is not a band 1 secondary school, as defined in some websites.
I am not saying NPMPS is not a top rate school. It is my top choice for my child too.
I hope there are no hard feelings, I am just sharing my experience...one person's top school may be a bad choice for another kid....nothing is absolute, everything is relative...
作者: ANChan59 時間: 12-1-15 00:41
本帖最後由 ANChan59 於 12-1-15 00:44 編輯
回復 Jasmine-4711 的帖子
Ok, I understand your rationale and logic.Most parents will consider a school as 'Band 1" when over 80% students are Band 1, not 25% English Classes.
Also, I have no hard feeling. I just worry about your logic may mislead other parents.
作者: jelly-pudding 時間: 12-1-20 13:35
Thank you for sharing! We are also in net 14, although my son is only studying in N1 now I am trying best to know/understand more about the primary schools in net 14 (because I lived and studied in Kowloon side when I was young so I do not have much knowledge and informations about schools in HK Island)
作者: Jasmine-4711 時間: 12-1-21 19:45
回復 jelly-pudding 的帖子
If u are interested in Wai Lee Primary, better enrol in Methodist Church Kindergarten which is related to it and is just next door to it. Seats are not reserved for their related kindergarten, but you stand a much better chance in the 'knock door' stage. If you are a Christian, 5 more points.
But if you are worried by the time your kid is k3, Wai Lee will change to whole day school and it is even harder to get into (before pm class is sure win if you have 20 points as it is not so popular), Wukong is a good choice with no religious points and less inherited seats due to its short history. But it is very tough on drilling from p1.
作者: jelly-pudding 時間: 12-1-30 12:30
回復 Jasmine-4711 的帖子
Thank you for your sharing.
We are not Christian so we only have 15 points. My son is now studying in Mingwai N1 and will probably continue his K1-K3 in the same school. But, since we are renting an apartment only we can also consider moving to net 12 or net 16 two years later.
There are some famous schools in net 12 and net 16, but net 14 is comparatively 平均一點?
作者: ANChan59 時間: 12-1-30 15:08
jelly-pudding 發表於 12-1-20 13:35 
Thank you for sharing! We are also in net 14, although my son is only studying in N1 now I am tryin ...
作者: jelly-pudding 時間: 12-1-30 15:29
回復 ANChan59 的帖子
Thank you for your comments. I will spend more time to investigae the primary schools in net 14.
作者: carson_ma 時間: 12-1-31 01:09
我係北循下午舊生，但我想我仔入北循而非丹循，我又唔係基督徒，咁係唔係只有15分？或者會唔會叩門機會大d
作者: catiou627 時間: 12-1-31 17:14
我都係14校網, 大女係蘇浙讀K1, 如果比錢讀蘇浙小學, 又值唔值呢?
作者: Jasmine-4711 時間: 12-2-3 16:10
回復 catiou627 的帖子
如你要普教中,又有over 50%入band 1, net 14不作他選
因net 14只有炮米同太古p.2起普教中,但入band 1 <40%.
net 14而入band 1 >50%都教粵語為主,如你唔介意咁可試嘉諾撒(天主教,有联系女校)/沪江/衛理/北循(舊上午校).以上4校如2nd choice唔洗旨意入倒.除左衛理下午未轉全日前可博下.
蘇小可留位做back up.
作者: queenmiffy 時間: 12-2-6 19:50 標題: 引用：回復+catiou627+的帖子
如你要普教中,又有
原帖由 Jasmine-4711 於 12-02-03 發表
回復 catiou627 的帖子
如你要普教中,又有over 50%入band 1, net 14不作他選
作者: Jasmine-4711 時間: 12-2-7 00:51
本帖最後由 Jasmine-4711 於 12-2-7 01:02 編輯
回復 queenmiffy 的帖子
net 14眾多官津只有嘉諾撒有聯系band 1女中学,女仔入band 1 chance高.
但如你堅持男女校,北衛及北循成續好,老師又較有愛心及包容.不過你得15分,女兒會不會洗礼.如否,北循及北衛上午1st round 20分只可抽.但現時北衛下午15分就可抽.過3-4年上下午會合併就15分都冇得抽了.
如你女兒在衛理堂幼園讀,有校長推介信,叩北循及北衛是同一教會,都有优勢.此兩校校長都不要求儲很多cert及背面試答案.臨塲表現及'誠意'才重要, ie.round round 1st choice係該校先好叩佢.
北官我個人喜欢傳统教学同嚴厲的教師,因吾兒只是活潑,係貪玩又坐定.如入北官俾老師日日鬧/罰都似.北官啱乖同叻人,老師冇咁有愛心.
以上学校(除北衛下午) 2nd choice已冇機會.
其實好多人忽略了沪江,冇宗教分,歷史短少d世襲生,>70%入band 1.但好谷.15分有機入.
作者: queenmiffy 時間: 12-2-7 14:24
回復 Jasmine-4711 的帖子
差五分真係差好遠~~而家會否太遲...
我囡係兩年後的, 不過而家開始了解下d小學, 因為本身唔係呢區長大, 乜都唔知>.<
我又想佢開心,又想佢唔好讀太差, 又唔想太谷(怕自己跟唔到,要返工),真係針冇兩頭利
作者: Jasmine-4711 時間: 12-2-7 18:36
回復 queenmiffy 的帖子
大部份教會唔俾你即刻洗礼,要父/母先讀慕道班一年半載,有d校要孩子本身洗礼.側聞區內有些教會開方便之門会快d洗倒礼.你如有興趣可打聽下.
我自已不是信徒,不想用此法.過不了自己.
作者: queenmiffy 時間: 12-2-8 09:25
回復 Jasmine-4711 的帖子
OIC~
所以心水中又會揀北官, 官校人人平等
作者: hialice 時間: 12-2-8 11:04
如不想選有宗教的, 可考慮滬江, 相信校風比官校好多~
作者: MaMa2008 時間: 12-2-9 23:44
觀乎咁多間學校嘅學生
1) 北角循遁 : 程度中等, 校風好, 學生純樸有童真
2)丹拿山 : 程度中等, 著重親子
3)北角官立 : 程度中上, 但學生太串, 或者佢過份自信
4)滬江 : 唔講程度, 今非昔比, 小二小三已講粗口同黃色笑話故仔, 真係嚇死你
作者: MaMa2008 時間: 12-2-9 23:51
還有, 就有關"有各種障礙"嘅學生
北角循遁 : 會有社工跟進輔導
Canossa : 會採取逃避, 只係不停話個小朋友成績差, 唔會深入了解 (但普通話程度好好, 一般學生都可以大膽用普通話自然交談, 其他學校嘅學生都比較生硬) (另一個問題係D女生好公主, 男仔讀可能未必慣)
作者: 婕婕媽 時間: 12-2-10 15:59
canossa.....唔覺佢地唔會逃避有障礙學生, 佢地有專責一名老師加一位姑娘全職去輔導, 去了解需要,
學校好注重品格培養, 希望課外活動係適量....唔贊成"勝在起跑點"
女生同男生所見相處融合
作者: Jasmine-4711 時間: 12-2-11 00:06
回復 queenmiffy 的帖子
如你選冇宗教的,沪江會比北官成績好很多及有愛心d.
以上都提過北官老師嚴厲,傳统教学,小息都廣播訓令学生.
成績差之學生冇老師幫已算好彩,有些被老師侮辱及x(幾年前好大件事).我一定不選北官.
作者: ahkit0425 時間: 12-2-11 00:09
沪江校風如何?有沒有音樂方面發展?
作者: Jasmine-4711 時間: 12-2-11 01:01
沪江校風好,但好谷,9月open day見小一首月已背默中英課文.很多project與背書.70%上band 1,但包容成績差学生.很多学器班及其他課後班.
如吾兒肯努力讀書,它是我首選.又冇宗教分又少世襲生.可惜吾兒無心向学.谷唔倒就米選此校...怕打擊佢自信.
作者: MaMa2008 時間: 12-2-11 05:42
婕婕媽 發表於 12-2-10 15:59
canossa.....唔覺佢地唔會逃避有障礙學生, 佢地有專責一名老師加一位姑娘全職去輔導, 去了解需要,
學校好 ...
咁我教嗰個一定係特別例外嘅一個, 我跟咗佢五年, 小三開始, 佢嘅情況已經開始好嚴重, 媽媽向老師查詢, 老師又唔理佢, 返轉頭嚟問我, 講真每日應付玏課佢都已經唔掂, 學校唔做啲嘢, 淨係靠屋企幫到幾多, 私家嘅治療師又付擔唔起
相反另外一個讀循道嘅男仔, 每星期學校有輔導, 兩年間見到佢情況好轉好多, 成績未係突飛猛進, 但至少學習能力好咗好多
有時學生喺家長面前係一個樣, 老師面前又係另一個樣, 喺open day見嘅係學校學生, 我反而鐘意喺街睇學生嘅品行, 嗰個先係真正嘅佢
作者: kochiman2004 時間: 12-2-11 06:26
MaMa2008 發表於 12-2-11 05:42
咁我教嗰個一定係特別例外嘅一個, 我跟咗佢五年, 小三開始, 佢嘅情況已經開始好嚴重, 媽媽向老師查詢, 老 ...
"喺街睇學生嘅品行, 嗰個先係真正嘅佢", ... 100% agree, many students are specially training for the school opening show, it's quite common in many HK schools....
作者: 已刪除用戶 時間: 12-2-11 16:22
MaMa2008 發表於 12-2-11 05:42
咁我教嗰個一定係特別例外嘅一個, 我跟咗佢五年, 小三開始, 佢嘅情況已經開始好嚴重, 媽媽向老師查詢, 老 ...
講開對有需要學生有所支援, 咁我就真係要讚讚我小朋友果間--港大同學會
我知道港同有語言治療, 有教育心理學家, 社工係"租"返黎長駐學校的, 小一有遊戲學社交單元及免費iq test, 及早適別有特別需要既學生, 推薦入小組: 有社交小組, 自理小組, 親子寫字小組等, 全部係社工同學校訓輔組in house自己做的(當然全部都係optional, 你唔去學校亦唔會迫你去)
小2開始已經有中英數補底, 平時上堂, 如果發現某d學生學習某一課似乎跟唔上, 老師就會安排入小組, ok就返大班, p4開始數學會全級根程度分小組教, 其他主科繼續有小組(如需要)
我仔有專注力失調既問題, 所以"使用"過唔少上面既服務
, 平時上課有咩e郁, 班主任亦會打俾我聯繫 (特別提提, 學校同中大港大等亦一直有合作攪資優培訓)
好彩有間咁包容既學校, 唔係我生活會好難過................港同唔係無人爭既學校, 亦有好多好叻既學生, 學校肯拔尖之餘(聽家長講舊年5個有spcc offer, 亦有唔少去左d所謂band one傳統名校), 亦肯花時間補底, 從來無放棄任何一個學生, 呢樣我作為用家, 真係要公開讚一讚
作者: Jasmine-4711 時間: 12-2-11 17:08
本帖最後由 Jasmine-4711 於 12-2-11 17:08 編輯
回復 Charlotte_mom 的帖子
港同非官津,对'特別'之輔導是否額外收費?
我曾打去問港同有冇語言治療,校服處那小姐答:"我們全校精英,冇d咁既服务".佢既語氣咁唔包容弱学生,令我心當堂泠了一大截,所以冇報到,可能那小姐唔清楚吧...咁語言治療是用中文定英文?收費多少?
作者: carebaby 時間: 12-2-11 22:58 標題: 回覆：MaMa2008 的帖子
請問讀邊間遁道呢？我個女有好多讀寫障礙的徵狀（包括鏡面字，文字處理弱，數字混亂，調亂字，左右不分），想找一間功課不太多的學校！
作者: Jasmine-4711 時間: 12-2-12 00:58
本帖最後由 Jasmine-4711 於 12-2-12 00:59 編輯
回復 carebaby 的帖子
如net 14,北循(原上午校)的融合教育與成績都比丹循(原下午校)好,位亦多些.
在net 14,北衛與北循的融合教育最出色,老師有愛心.成績都是中上.
作者: carebaby 時間: 12-2-12 01:00 標題: 回覆：Jasmine-4711 的帖子
謝謝！
作者: 已刪除用戶 時間: 12-2-12 15:39
Jasmine-4711 發表於 12-2-11 17:08
回復 Charlotte_mom 的帖子
港同非官津,对'特別'之輔導是否額外收費?
我唔係想challenge你, 不過真係好難相信學校職員會咁答............我地從來都無claim自己全校精英啊
st我係聽過, 不過我仔無用過, 而其他所有補底/社交小組/寫字小組, 仲有小一既遊戲社交小組, 仲有iq test等等, 都係免費的 (佢有開班訓練家長成為遊戲小組既家長導師, 果個就收費既)
作者: joanthony 時間: 12-2-12 18:54
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: 已刪除用戶 時間: 12-2-12 21:55
joanthony 發表於 12-2-12 18:54
Charlotte mum, 想問如果仔一早已第二round都入唔到, 但如果movers exam 有14個盾, 有無可能入到呢?? ...
sorry老實講, 我so far未見過有case係第一輪出局而叩門入到的.........當然如果你想繼續試, 我衷心祝你all the best, 另一方面我更加祝你小朋友早日搵到心儀既學校
作者: joanthony 時間: 12-2-12 22:19 標題: 回覆：Charlotte_mom 的帖子
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: ha8mo 時間: 12-3-5 17:11
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: roybeema 時間: 12-3-7 12:27 標題: 回覆：Jasmine-4711 的帖子
我想問自行首輪，誇區20分入北衛的機會大嗎？
作者: whywhite22 時間: 12-3-7 12:39
首輪20分上午校舊年要抽中先入到,下午校20分舊年唔使抽都入到.
| 歡迎光臨 教育王國 (/) |
Powered by Discuz! X1.5 |