教育王國
標題: 懇請各位有小一面試經驗家長給予選幼稚園意見！ [打印本頁]
作者: pigpig33 時間: 12-1-3 23:24 標題: 懇請各位有小一面試經驗家長給予選幼稚園意見！
如題，其實我個女今年先入讀K1，目前有兩個offer係手，一個係KV, 另一個係九龍民生。
老公想個女入KV，原因係想她學多些，不應只因我地作為家長害怕面試壓力而抺殺阿女學得更多的機會。
自己則想阿女入龍校多些，純粹因為怕小一面試，和欣賞該校有外藉老師教英文。
大家可否以過來人身份給我些意見，尤其係究竟KV生是否真的享有較大優勢呢？
其實類似我呢種問題係幼稚園版經常出現，但我係小學版搵資料時忽然諗不如在此出個帖，聽下有實戰經驗的家長分享不是更好嗎？
希望好心家長能賜教！
作者: dwkw333 時間: 12-1-3 23:38
Would you satisfy if your daughter is studied at 九龍民生. If yes, then 九龍民生. Otherwise, KV. Good luck.
作者: karen55407 時間: 12-1-3 23:39
I vote KV
作者: smallfoothk 時間: 12-1-3 23:44
Some parent think: "名幼"家長都是好緊小朋友的家長, 所以放好多心機去教小朋友的比例多d, 所以整體升好小學比例可能是多d.
2. "名幼"一般都是貴d, 學校多d資源, 比如net 或 普通話母語的老師, 語言環境好, 小朋友面試時口語能力几好.
我認識不少"名幼"家長覺得沒有幫助, 說穿了, 還是家長努力行先.
作者: GIPW 時間: 12-1-4 00:58
Quite agreed. Being in a 名幼 benefit is
1) you will have a peer group pressure that will push you ( as a parent) to do better.
2) with all the smart kids together, you will know what level your kids are?
3) some 名幼 teacher is nice and is good with training the manner of the kids
After all agreed that parents 要放的資源及時間是好多的, 只靠學校是不行的
So, 努力加油
作者: joeyxlma 時間: 12-1-4 01:22
好難比意見, 只可以給一下知道的情報:
KV是名幼, 從一些教育界朋友口中得知, KV在好多小學的心目中是有一定的優勢, 原因不是課程而是它重DISCIPLINE, 上學的氣氛比較似小學. KV與民生之間是不是KV會學多D, 真係要問一下讀緊D家長. 如果讓我猜, KV應該是學多D (估計基準只是FEELING, 因為KV與SC程度應差不多, 而SC應比民幼深少少.)不過值得一提, 以前的民幼與明年的相信不太一樣. 因為以前
民幼的名氣只是很大程度是基於直上小學之便, 而民幼語境方面是不太著重英文及普通話. 但聽現民幼K3家長說, 民幼換了校長, 是從VICTORY 過來的, 所以已聘了不少外籍老師, 而亦加強了普通話. 估計民幼生將來的出路會更廣.
作者: magiccandy 時間: 12-1-4 08:32
Personally, I think a happy kindergarten with more exposure to various experiences and good language environment is the most important. They are just 3-5-year-old-kids, I wouldn't push them too hard, but equip them with good language foundation and wide experiences, Besides,I like one-dragon school which saves lots of trouble.
作者: haihaimom 時間: 12-1-4 09:23
Do u have confidence to get a good DSS/private school. IF yes, go for KV. If u think it is 50/50, Munsung is also good,since u can still apply for other DSS/private after accepting its offer. The primary competition is very keen, don't count on the school for good interview performance, y need to equip yor own kid. Of course some get good offers, many don't, the outcome may out of your expectation.
作者: spmok1999 時間: 12-1-4 09:50
保險 vs 冒險
作者: 仔仔錫錫你 時間: 12-1-4 10:14
3年後小朋友要考小學，你試下list 8間小學出來，如果—間都無民小份就KV，有民小就選民幼
作者: BB成長期 時間: 12-1-4 10:19
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: myac 時間: 12-1-4 11:15
SUCCESS = SCHOOL INPUT + PARENTS' INPUT
So you need to ask yourself whether you are capable and willing to put in the hard work required of educating and grooming your child in the next 15 years! With Munseng, you can still apply for other schools. I vote for Munseng if you are not sure of your child's ability. If you choose KV, be prepared to put in efforts. KV has no magic ... you have the magic as you are the child's mom!
作者: BB成長期 時間: 12-1-4 18:09
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: tkyy 時間: 12-1-4 18:23
樓主，三年前小兒考幼稚園時，有kv, 民幼、聖羅撒，sc 收，最後我們選左kv, 因為喜歡它傳統，程度深，接小一容易些。我們要返工、亦不是虎媽，完全交比學校，今年小一，SFA, KTS, KTS, 收左，dbs 去到second in, 可惜小兒不是他們杯茶。我對kv 有信心，我們呢d 平傭家庭、懶媽和平凡犬兒都有這個戰績，已經吾錯。如果你放棄kv, 好多waiting 的人會多謝你。kv 係深，但老師有方法搞惦的，放心。
作者: sytw 時間: 12-1-4 22:01
龍校始終有龍校好處，進可攻退可守，不過聽朋友講民幼並唔係100%上到民小，當然比率不會太低。而KV我相信一定有它優勢，但正如其他人講做家長都要配合，我偏向相信名幼考名小係會有少少著數，但講到尾都要睇小朋友面試時表現，名幼咁多學生都不可能個個入到DBS/DGS，都有好多其他野配合。
作者: pigpig33 時間: 12-1-5 18:08
本帖最後由 pigpig33 於 12-1-5 18:52 編輯
deleted
作者: pigpig33 時間: 12-1-5 18:09
smallfoothk 發表於 12-1-3 23:44 
Some parent think: "名幼"家長都是好緊小朋友的家長, 所以放好多心機去教小朋友的比例多d, 所以整體升好小 ...
Very inspiring! Thanks!
作者: pigpig33 時間: 12-1-5 18:14
GIPW 發表於 12-1-4 00:58
Quite agreed. Being in a 名幼 benefit is
1) you will have a peer group pressure that will push you ...
都明白.......揀得冇小學backup, 又有係首名子女, 又冇靚校網地址+信仰........max 15 分, 預咗黎緊3年都會係要放好多心機時間同小朋友溫習, 學英語 (針對KV而言, 學phonix)........等, 一諗到呢度, 又開始猶疑了!
作者: pigpig33 時間: 12-1-5 18:18
joeyxlma 發表於 12-1-4 01:22
好難比意見, 只可以給一下知道的情報:
KV是名幼, 從一些教育界朋友口中得知, KV在好多小學的心目中是有一 ...
係呀......我都有聽過民幼的新校長之前係Victoria做的, 我家姐個女讀過呢間的playgroup, 認為佢地的curriculum偏向淺和少少hea.
又今年民幼退出學卷, 改用NET+本地雙班主任制, 加設英普班..........跟Victoria好相似, 所以又打咗少少折啦!
作者: pigpig33 時間: 12-1-5 18:23
magiccandy 發表於 12-1-4 08:32
Personally, I think a happy kindergarten with more exposure to various experiences and good language ...
部份同意啦, 人地話KV的culture就係有本事可以令小朋友好鐘意返學, 雖然佢地要學要記要做的功課比其他幼稚園多好多. 加上, 小朋友只係一張白紙, 佢地冇得比較"谷"定係"唔谷". 只要慢慢適應了, 反過來或可激發他們的潛能呢?
當然, 龍校的好處真係fun and learn, 可能可以係academic和 fun for learning中取得好的平衡, 但是, 好多家長又會覺得, 3年開心的代價就是換來之後幾年的辛苦, 因為就算係龍校, 銜接小學未必盡如人意,
各有各好處, 這個是肯定的!
作者: pigpig33 時間: 12-1-5 18:31
仔仔錫錫你 發表於 12-1-4 10:14
3年後小朋友要考小學，你試下list 8間小學出來，如果—間都無民小份就KV，有民小就選民幼 ...
我又未做資料搜集, 況且個女真係仲細, 未認清佢的性格, 強項, 弱點和發展潛力時我又不想太早下定論, 但當然心目中都有些所謂的dream school想佢試下, 如:-
1. SPCC
2. DGJS
3. APS
4. KTS
5. GH (呢個機會好渺茫, 阿女面試當日表現唔夠sharp)
6. HY
7. Maryknoll
只是諗到就寫, 未做功課唔係間間知道佢地係唔係DSS, 如果要靠大抽獎就機會唔大啦, 因為我又冇讀過呢幾間, 爸爸都冇, 又冇人事關係..........
作者: pigpig33 時間: 12-1-5 18:34
haihaimom 發表於 12-1-4 09:23
Do u have confidence to get a good DSS/private school. IF yes, go for KV. If u think it is 50/50, Mu ...
哈哈......本身都有信心的, 但係看得多了你們的血淚史, 又有些怯怯地啦~~~~
作者: pigpig33 時間: 12-1-5 18:38
BB成長期 發表於 12-1-4 10:19
回復 仔仔錫錫你 的帖子
good idea.
加油, 今年幼稚園競爭好激烈, 民生的校工親口同我講, 今年收3000+ 申請, 學位300; 培正盛傳有6000+ 申請; 德望都話有3000+ 喎; SC 和 KV 就話有約8000+申請...........不敢想像到升小時又係一個什麼境況!?
作者: pigpig33 時間: 12-1-5 18:39
本帖最後由 pigpig33 於 12-1-5 18:39 編輯
myac 發表於 12-1-4 11:15
SUCCESS = SCHOOL INPUT + PARENTS' INPUT
So you need to ask yourself whether you are capable and wil ...
Agreed! No matter which school we finally adopted, it's always true that parents can make a difference for the child!
作者: pigpig33 時間: 12-1-5 18:47
tkyy 發表於 12-1-4 18:23
樓主，三年前小兒考幼稚園時，有kv, 民幼、聖羅撒，sc 收，最後我們選左kv, 因為喜歡它傳統，程度深，接小 ...
我真係好開心, 終於俾我可以同KV應屆畢業生家長交流意見, 妳的意見好有份量, 令我有些釋懷, 放心去揀KV的感覺. 但真係想問, KV是否完全零家長參與? 那麼, 同班同學的家長有會否私下組織一下班活動?
又, 你的囝囝真的完全沒有讀課外進修班嗎? 好多人話KV英語會話唔夠SC好, 但我見小一面試好多時都考考生英語表達能力, 係呢方面, 你囝囝是否都能在沒有家長太多的"訓練"和"模擬面試"的情況下應付自如嗎?
在BK看到有家長話KV會要跟唔上的學生退學, 是真的嗎?
對不起, 問題太多了, 但您的出現令我太興奮了, 一直覺得KV家長係BK較為沉默和少留言!
謝謝妳的好心幫忙!
作者: pigpig33 時間: 12-1-5 18:50
sytw 發表於 12-1-4 22:01
龍校始終有龍校好處，進可攻退可守，不過聽朋友講民幼並唔係100%上到民小，當然比率不會太低。而KV我相信一 ...
幣在民幼唔俾參加大抽獎, 參力抽獎會視為放棄直升資格, 係九龍區的龍校黎講, 只得佢有呢個要求! 所以, 另謀出路只可向DSS看, 咁又去番同一個問題, 如果係咁, KV似乎優勢較大!
作者: pigpig33 時間: 12-1-5 18:53
dwkw333 發表於 12-1-3 23:38
Would you satisfy if your daughter is studied at 九龍民生. If yes, then 九龍民生. Otherwise, KV. Goo ...
因為據聞民生只係收大概60-70%幼稚園生上小學
, 而中學又只收約70%的民小學生, 計起上黎, 由幼稚園到中學只剩少於50%? 咁好自己就會諗, 如果阿女一個唔好彩, 升唔到上去要出去考直資的話, 優勢會否比KV差......我老公就是就著呢一點去分析成件事...........anyway, 多謝你的回覆和幫忙!
作者: lcdtopcon 時間: 12-1-5 22:17
回復 tkyy 的帖子
haha!你嘅case同我一樣，我喺在職媽媽，我仔都考倒SFA, KTS, APS 和 SMC，如果讀傳统小學，kv可以幫小朋友打好學術上基礎。
作者: 仔仔錫錫你 時間: 12-1-6 10:34
7 間中有2間唔係DSS/私小。我比多4間你 : SFA，TSL，CKY，民小。你選3間，如果都無民小就真係無必要讀民幼。
作者: Gerard 時間: 12-1-6 11:25
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: HaYi 時間: 12-1-6 13:40
但如果去左一條龍的幼稚園, 小心到 in 小學時人地小學見你有龍校小學, 可能會感覺你當佢地係 back up, 未必會俾 offer ,今年我識不少的半龍校生, 全部表現都不錯, 但沒收幾個 offer, 所以入得MS 就預90% 會留在 MS好些..
KV 就寫字同紀律都不錯, 但面試時是看小朋友本身為主, 如果小朋友是靜的, 就keep 在 MS 較安全, 因 interview對靜的 小朋友不太有利, 就算KV 出來亦未必在 interview 有特出的表現..
作者: pigpig33 時間: 12-1-8 23:25
HaYi 發表於 12-1-6 13:40
但如果去左一條龍的幼稚園, 小心到 in 小學時人地小學見你有龍校小學, 可能會感覺你當佢地係 back up, 未必 ...
作者: hyatt 時間: 12-1-9 08:59
pigpig33 發表於 12-1-8 23:25 
咁我個女又真係偏靜的, 坐定定佢就可以好好, 反而叫佢好好奇咁四圍探索又未必可以好雀躍.............不過, ...
你係大囡定細囡? 嗰d好奇周圍望探索的反而在interview中都幾吃虧，坐定定乖乖地的就較受歡迎。
小朋友而家靜d唔等於佢三年後都係咁。
作者: PWHPOPO 時間: 12-1-9 23:19
亞仔當年考到 民生、KV、SC 及中環聖公會。我們選了SKH.不過,亞仔有個家姐讀緊有直屬英中的津小,亞仔到時(乜都考不到)都可以入硬家姐間小學,基於這原因我才會比他讀SKH。若果亞仔是獨子、頭生、家姐讀女校,我就會揀民生。
作者: PS0325 時間: 12-1-10 04:02
我個小朋友是KV畢業, 現讀小一. KV是中英數要dictation and quiz, 但我不覺得幼學生感到有壓力, 不是想像中咁hard. 因為課程教快咗, 可以唔駛出外補習添.
作者: JoshuaN 時間: 12-1-10 11:15
回復 pigpig33 的帖子
我仔仔今年KV K3, 考小學都算理想(請check PM), KV 的確為小兒打好基礎, interview 有幾間學校著重考學術如APS, KTS, SFA, 我覺得KV都有點優勢, 我見今年嘅KV 生很多都考得不錯 . 如果民小並非你心儀的小學, KV 是不錯的選擇!!
作者: ottomum 時間: 12-1-10 13:00
The choice really depends on
1. do you like Munsang Primary School?
2. what kind of eduction you want to provide to your daughter?
As a parent of two sons who are now studying in Munsang kindergarten, I find this is a great kg. I understand some of you may think that MSC kg's curriculum is too easy. I want to tell you that it is not. Someone has already mentioned that there is a lot of changes in these years. Some of you like some kg because they teach in higher level of curriculum. Just want to ask that do you really want your kids start to have dictation, quiz and just sit in the classroom in their early school life. Do you think it is called discipline? MSC kg has a lot of different visitings among the year (K3) like visiting library, fire station, Road safety center(??) and he is visitng Ocean Park today. What a varity school life!
May be some of you think that some very famous school has advantages to apply for their primary school. I agree that some smart kids really get a lot of offers, however, please surf for some forums that there is still a lot of kids did not get any seat upto this moment.
Good luck to you.
作者: pigpig33 時間: 12-3-16 13:44 標題: 回覆：懇請各位有小一面試經驗家長給予選幼稚園意見！
真的很感謝各位KV & MS家長跟我分享，終於決定揀KV，因為希望阿女升小時有更佳的準備。
作者: cheungmingwai 時間: 12-3-16 14:14
My daughter is studying k3 at KV. She has several offers like SFA, KTS, APS, 優才、港大同學會、禮賢、培道、王錦輝、音小。we already made the decision on SFA. You can let your kid to apply more schools to get chances. You may not know the criteria of school admission.
But the academic standard, good social skills and presentation, and good character and manner are so important to face interview.
Good luck!
作者: bbmylove09 時間: 12-3-16 16:45
tkyy 發表於 12-1-4 18:23
樓主，三年前小兒考幼稚園時，有kv, 民幼、聖羅撒，sc 收，最後我們選左kv, 因為喜歡它傳統，程度深，接小 ...
tkyy 你好, 我也是有點擔心KV 太著重學術, 小孩是否每日也正常的遊戲/音樂/美術/戶外活動等........
另外, KV 是否可以 train up小朋友自信心呢?
Thanks
作者: bbmylove09 時間: 12-3-16 17:06
cheungmingwai 發表於 12-3-16 14:14
My daughter is studying k3 at KV. She has several offers like SFA, KTS, APS, 優才、港大同學會、禮賢 ...
"But the academic standard, good social skills and presentation, and good character and manner are so important to face interview"
請問這些都是在KV 培養出來嗎? 當年你囡囡考K1 時, 是個靜態的還是活潑型的呢? 我囡囡是靜態型的, 也缺乏自信, 你認為KV 能改變這類型小朋友嗎?
作者: bbmylove09 時間: 12-3-16 17:20
pigpig33 發表於 12-1-8 23:25
咁我個女又真係偏靜的, 坐定定佢就可以好好, 反而叫佢好好奇咁四圍探索又未必可以好雀躍.............不過, ...
hello 我囡囡也是這樣, 才令我擔心, 雖然我另一個offer 不是名校/龍校, 但是一間開心快樂的kinder, 我也很想女兒讀, 希望她的性格變得主動/開朗些.
但真的擔心, 到小一時, 又要再上戰場, 而我們同齡的小孩 又更多, 真的唔敢搏
如有機會, 我們可否再交流下. 你巳決定KV了嗎?
作者: cheungmingwai 時間: 12-3-16 18:40
My daughter is so passive to face in front of the stranger,but she is too active On her body. She cannot sit properly without self control. I changed her from a happy active learning style nursery to KV. Also, she only likes to talk and watch the cartoon in English at that moment. I hope KV can train up her discipline and Chinese. At the end, KV help her and me so much. The teachers are nice. You can share how to teach kids when you bring them to school or after school. My daughter loves KV and all teachers.
In the past, I also like you to hear many "bad" things of KV in the forum, but it is not truth that we see. We like KV. It is good foundation to be built for adapting primary 1.
作者: cheungmingwai 時間: 12-3-16 18:46
You can find those KV students who are so active and happy to wait for school in the morning. If u have time, u may go to see those schools in the morning time. Then you can feel those students whether enjoy schooling and their behavior. It may be more real picture.
| 歡迎光臨 教育王國 (/) |
Powered by Discuz! X1.5 |