教育王國

標題: 請問有冇小朋友收到York rejected letter? [打印本頁]

作者: kittytse 時間: 11-12-21 17:22 標題: 請問有冇小朋友收到York rejected letter?

請問有冇小朋友收到York rejected letter?

作者: ronniedad 時間: 11-12-21 19:53

我諗呢個問題都好難有人答到你. 個個都只會話佢收生易, 商業味重, 如屬實, 在商言商佢全部都係WAITING一D都唔出奇. 如否, 我諗會好多家長都唔想或唔敢講出來吧. 但我印象中係有家長收REJECTED LETTER的.

作者: kittytse 時間: 11-12-21 20:01

其實係因為我真係未聽過佢地有發過reject信！

作者: ronniedad 時間: 11-12-21 20:16

咁重點我只係諗會唔會真係會讀該校囉(邊間學校都係咁講), 理得人收咩信啫. 最終都唔關你事.

作者: chongnicole 時間: 11-12-21 23:24

幾年前，有聽過家長收過reject letter。現在有無改policy就不清楚。
慕道班事件後，本來對York的觀點很差。但近來看到很多家長詳細分享學校對小朋友升小一的支援，覺得好難得，難怪發生咁多事之後，仍然有咁多支持者。

作者: dubyboy 時間: 11-12-21 23:25

many extra expenses in this school, if u don't mind, their english standard is good.

作者: gskw 時間: 11-12-21 23:34

dubyboy 發表於 11-12-21 23:25
many extra expenses in this school, if u don't mind, their english standard is good.

but according to the "mama users", those extra expenses are all optional!

作者: yslgirl 時間: 11-12-21 23:39

老實講, o係我心目中reject同waiting差唔多. waiting係比條後路學校, 比個希望家長.

作者: jvcfamily 時間: 11-12-22 09:52

ronniedad 發表於 11-12-21 20:16
咁重點我只係諗會唔會真係會讀該校囉(邊間學校都係咁講), 理得人收咩信啫. 最終都唔關你事. ...

同意ronniedad..而且一個學校好與不好唔係一定睇容唔容易入, 有出過幾多Accepted or Rejected letter. 最緊要岩唔岩自己小朋友讀..父母最清楚自己小朋友性格, 天資加後等因素... "理得人收咩信啫. 最終都唔關你事" >>> 100% agree.

作者: 藤媽 時間: 11-12-22 18:43

聽完york既講座，聽完校監備受批評既演說，我反而覺得佢係有信心咩人都收，到可以教得到。呢個亦係校監俾人感覺arrogant既原因。

個人意見，不喜勿插

作者: Yipapa 時間: 11-12-22 20:28

To be honest， if a school never issue reject letter， will it make you more eager to go into that school？

I have lot of friends' kids studying in York, they are all satisfied with the school.

作者: lum_lum 時間: 11-12-23 01:19

i guess there should be no reject letter as a 'waiting list' letter is the same meaning somehow ... if there are over 1000 applicants, waiting and reject are the same la ...

作者: 已刪除用戶 時間: 11-12-23 11:01

聽聞, 幾年前某小學, 出左OFFER, WAITLIST同REJECT, 點知最後無咩人讀, 最後要CALL返D REJECT生, 好尷尬姐!

所以如果學校夠聰明, 會全部WAITLIST(除左正選同衰到貼地果D), 咁就進可攻退可守, 咁做法, 同商唔商業亦無關係呀

作者: shirleylee_0514 時間: 11-12-23 11:48

reject 不等同 waiting !!!
reject面試既表現都唔合格, 未達標
waiting必定pass, 但學位不足...

作者: loveannis 時間: 11-12-23 12:22

其實York系咪accept仲多過waiting呢？

作者: namkaman 時間: 11-12-23 12:45

其實如果有睇幼兒園果邊啲post，應該知道係有人收到reject letter 而且要再in過的，而且pn位得160個，又點會係人都accept呢？
我問過佢地，waiting list 只有係100人之內的。一定少過accept的小朋友。

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)