教育王國
標題: 學普通話是必需呢? [打印本頁]
作者: kitkit1025 時間: 11-12-7 08:04 標題: 學普通話是必需呢?
仔仔就讀P.1,學普通話己半年有多,但最近討厭去學,因為常有黙書,我都唔知是否要停學?請交流下。
作者: Yanamami 時間: 11-12-7 08:14
默書? 我女學果度重教拼音&讀/ 講. 唔洗默喎.....佢輕鬆又一日, 同老師傾偈讀書好開心. 係學校考普通話筆試都唔洗點溫.
原帖由 kitkit1025 於 11-12-7 08:04 發表 
仔仔就讀P.1,學普通話己半年有多,但最近討厭去學,因為常有黙書,我都唔知是否要停學?請交流下。
作者: motherotk 時間: 11-12-7 09:19
The school usually separate PTH lesson and Chinese lesson (some use cantonese and some use PTH for teaching Chinese).
Which subject your son feel difficult, PTH class or Chinese class (using Cantonese of PTH as medium of instruction)?
I know some kids may have difficulties learning Chinese using PTH, some teachers may accommodate that. Usually PTH lessons are easier to handle than Chinese lessons (if teach in PTH), Chinese lesson has more learning expectations for students, thus some students, especailly in P1, quite difficult to adjust if they are not coming from PTH speaking families or coming from kider without PTH training.
For those schools really care about diversities of children, they will give time for P1 to adjust to the language environment......e.g. P1 use Cantonese, then P2 -P6 use PTH in teaching Chinese.
If you really find it difficult, talk to other parents in your school seeing how they handle this issue, or talk teachers if they are helpful or really care about diversities among children. If they don't care or if the school is not really helpful, find a helpful school that best fit your child's need.
Meaningless to communicate with schools without any genuine wish to accommodate diversities among children. They will not care about your specific kid, but the general goals of school.
Sorry, handicapped in Chinese typing, has to use English to respond (old fashioned)...
原帖由 kitkit1025 於 11-12-7 08:04 發表
仔仔就讀P.1,學普通話己半年有多,但最近討厭去學,因為常有黙書,我都唔知是否要停學?請交流下。
[ 本帖最後由 motherotk 於 11-12-7 09:20 編輯 ]
作者: kitkit1025 時間: 11-12-7 11:09
原帖由 Yanamami 於 11-12-7 00:14 發表
默書? 我女學果度重教拼音&讀/ 講. 唔洗默喎.....佢輕鬆又一日, 同老師傾偈讀書好開心. 係學校考普通話筆試都唔洗點溫.
作者: kitkit1025 時間: 11-12-7 11:18
原帖由 motherotk 於 11-12-7 01:19 發表
The school usually separate PTH lesson and Chinese lesson (some use cantonese and some use PTH for teaching Chinese).
Which subject your son feel difficult, PTH class or Chinese class (using Cantones ...
作者: Yanamami 時間: 11-12-7 12:00
哦....默拼音. 所以K3開始會好d, 果時無禁忙. 但英文又好, PTH又好, 學好拼音就一勞永逸喎......呢個年代sales都要識PTH呀.
原帖由 kitkit1025 於 11-12-7 11:09 發表
無錯係默書，默數個詞語拼音有時重默韻母加深印象，平時功課又忙加上又要中英默書，而且又加普通話默書溫習，對小一來講確辛苦，自己又唔識教，真係好矛盾。 ...
作者: motherotk 時間: 11-12-7 14:07
Personal opinion:
1) It's nonsense to ask P1 kids to 默拼音, more reasonable when they are older, and after P1 adjustment
2) Not all kids will benefit from 拼音, if this is really difficult for your kid, don't compare with others, some kids will have difficulties and some kids are brilliant in 拼音, and both may have good results in language development when they grow up.
Take it easy and use the best ways that suit your kid's learning pattern and pace..but still keep on learning the foundations..
帖由 kitkit1025 於 11-12-7 11:18 發表
佢平時上普通話課無問題，只是在外學PTH常要默書感到吃力，我知道PTH老師想佢keep住學，唔係上完堂就算果隻。 [/quote]
作者: annie40 時間: 11-12-7 14:20 標題: 回復 1# Yanamami 的帖子
Yes, it's essential to speak fluent Mandarin.
作者: kitkit1025 時間: 11-12-7 15:28 標題: 回復 7# motherotk 的帖子
好多謝你的關心同意見，我或者考慮幫他轉去另一間學PTH，不用再默書，讓他輕鬆去學習。
作者: motherotk 時間: 11-12-7 19:18
you are welcome..
My son: Brilliant in PTH and English phonics, but his speaking PTH is not that "original", he's a theory person, but practically he cannot speak beautiful PTH. Exam or dictation, can do well in all kinds of PTH spelling.
My daughter, it is extremely difficult for her to memorize all PTH spelling, but she can speak beautiful PTH and read the books with PTH, but theorietically, she is really weak. I expect exam and test will fail in all spelling.
So, you have to believe in God, that's really fair, each has their strengths, we appreciate that strengths and differences.
原帖由 kitkit1025 於 11-12-7 15:28 發表
好多謝你的關心同意見，我或者考慮幫他轉去另一間學PTH，不用再默書，讓他輕鬆去學習。
[ 本帖最後由 motherotk 於 11-12-8 09:44 編輯 ]
作者: 大個仔係我 時間: 11-12-12 09:44
反學冇錯係要令小朋友學到野,但係都要令佢地開心,我覺得學普通話對而加既小朋友呢講係一種相對能力,所以學係有需要,但可能轉另一種模式,而加SPC,YPC既普通話著重聽講,唔曬默書.YOU CAN TRY TRY~
作者: kitkit1025 時間: 11-12-12 16:58 標題: 回復 11# 大個仔係我 的帖子
Thank you!:good: :good:
作者: hk_packychan 時間: 12-1-18 01:13
其實我老公都要學， 所以我都比我個仔早D學， 不過而家仲細， 未開始學拼音住
作者: vincher 時間: 12-1-18 23:16
回復 kitkit1025 的帖子
係0吾係淨係默簡單韻母a o e ... ai ei ao ou 和聲母?
作者: vincher 時間: 12-1-18 23:19
pth 絕對要學！係香港滿街是自由行，很多行業都要接觸說普通話0既人！
作者: hk_packychan 時間: 12-1-19 00:54
我都覺得係，溝通好係好多方面都有幫助
作者: mavlam 時間: 12-1-22 17:09
依家咁多內地客，香港同內地連系咁緊密，長遠睇，唔學好普通話都幾麻煩。
細個學好過大個學，快好多，發音又會好好多，不過咁細默拼音就真係ｈａｒｓｈ左Ｄ喎
作者: winchoy16888 時間: 12-1-24 07:55
普通話老師想他底子好些
將來米冇咁辛苦
作者: connie333 時間: 12-1-31 12:28
兩文三語已經係搵食技倆基本, 幼稚園都開始加普通話堂. 我都lim住同我個女一齊學. 可能有日遇到自由行明閙交用得著.
作者: Akuliba 時間: 12-2-2 14:22
小朋友從小有機會接觸和學習不同語言是件好事,學普通話和學英文是同等重要,想想連外國小學已經將普通話當作重要外國語
作者: kitkit1025 時間: 12-2-2 16:13
回復 Akuliba 的帖子
佢學校都有上普通話課及中文堂都是用普通話上課的。只是確外出面再報讀，佢話辛苦所以無再學。
作者: awah112 時間: 12-2-2 17:39
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: 天天譯 時間: 12-2-3 08:36
kitkit1025 發表於 12-2-2 16:13 
回復 Akuliba 的帖子
佢學校都有上普通話課及中文堂都是用普通話上課的。只是確外出面再報讀，佢話辛苦所 ...
作者: kitkit1025 時間: 12-2-3 11:16
天天譯 發表於 12-2-3 08:36 
比心機讀好學校果Ｄ都夠啦，樣樣野都係貴精不貴多。
佢老師都係咁講，學校課程已足夠，不如花錢報其它好過。
作者: sukisa 時間: 12-3-23 23:16
學多一種語言係好架, 而且而家普通話都幾重要
作者: winniewongpy 時間: 12-3-24 17:46
現在既社會兩文三語實在少不得 
作者: cat囝 時間: 12-3-25 14:47
作者: Amanda2025 時間: 12-3-26 12:10
學多一樣語言都冇壞
作者: 已刪除用戶 時間: 12-3-27 20:38
如果學校係推行得好, 小朋友唔會討厭PTH, 我仔而家睇PTH版喜羊羊, 一睇幾個鐘笑到卡卡聲
學拼音係基本, 要學好PTH首先要MASTER到拼音, 包括一睇就識讀(當然唔係單指識背個表啦, 係要識純熟運用), 如果小朋友底子打得好, 唔會怕默(默拼音咋, 唔係講默字呀), 如果小朋友怕默, 即係運用唔夠熟, 呢樣至係最ALARMING的
作者: 囝囝mama 時間: 12-3-28 00:11
回復 kitkit1025 的帖子
http://www.quickmandarin.com/chinesepinyintable/
這個國語拼音網站有用!一按拼音出晒四聲!!!
作者: babyislove 時間: 12-3-28 09:48
kitkit1025 發表於 12-2-2 16:13
回復 Akuliba 的帖子
佢學校都有上普通話課及中文堂都是用普通話上課的。只是確外出面再報讀，佢話辛苦所 ...
唔一定去上堂先學到o野!先聽後講，多聽自然講都好喇
作者: kitkit1025 時間: 12-3-28 17:32
回復 囝囝mama 的帖子
唔該呀!好有用。
| 歡迎光臨 教育王國 (/) |
Powered by Discuz! X1.5 |