教育王國
標題: 協恩VS德望 [打印本頁]
作者: tracylady 時間: 11-11-21 23:35 標題: 協恩VS德望
協恩小學及德望小學已收了小女，除了學費因素之外，請問你們會選哪一間呢?
作者: 786 時間: 11-11-21 23:42
除掉學費因素, 應該選德望.
協恩中學跟協恩小學來年小一正式脫釣(雖不至說脫釣, 但沒有了以前80%直上中學(直資了)的關係), 小學又未至直資自主收生, 所以這一屆的小一要上中學部難矣(八級鋼琴是最基本要有的條件). 這個情況要待小學也變成直資才有改善.
但德望因小學和中學都是自主收生, 所以依然有"一條龍"優勢.
作者: tracylady 時間: 11-11-21 23:53
Thanks.
你對協恩的見解亦是我所憂慮的....
作者: law_panda 時間: 11-11-22 00:08
I will choose Heep Yunn.
Teachers are good.
Usually no big problem getting in Secondary, as told by my friend teaching in Secondary.
Kids are more happy at Heep Yunn.
作者: palmchristy 時間: 11-11-22 00:14
咁今年入學的小一生到小六時有多少機會被協恩中學取錄呢?
作者: 786 時間: 11-11-22 00:49
咁今年入學的小一生到小六時有多少機會被協恩中學取錄呢?
> 今年(2011-12)度小一生, 即現在在協恩小學就讀的一年級生, 到升中仍有80%直升的直屬關係.
來年(2012-13)度小一生, 即今早公佈的第一輪新生及下年六月公佈的第二輪新生及其後的叩門生, 就沒有了80%直升的直屬關係. 敬請新生們在小六一開始就要有八級鋼琴, 因為中學校長說900個申請人, 有750已有八級鋼琴.一年一級計, 今日的新生, 應要已有二級鋼琴了.
我的親戚及朋友們分別是本年度協恩的中一生、小一生、小三生、小六生和幼園生, 所以知得很多.
[ 本帖最後由 786 於 11-11-22 08:17 編輯 ]
作者: 長生不老 時間: 11-11-22 00:58 標題: 回復 6# 786 的帖子
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: 786 時間: 11-11-22 01:00
http://mynews.coms.hk/art_main.php?art_id=15709142&iss_id=20111016&sec_id=4104
http://www.singtao.com/archive/fullstory.asp?andor=or&year1=2011&month1=10&day1=16&year2=2011&month2=10&day2=16&category=all&id=20111016a13&keyword1=&keyword2=
原帖由 長生不老 於 11-11-22 00:58 發表 
750個學生都有8級? 校長作大還是你作大啊!
[ 本帖最後由 786 於 11-11-22 01:02 編輯 ]
作者: lnp 時間: 11-11-22 01:01 標題: 回復 4# law_panda 的帖子
agree.....
my sister is graduated from Heep Yunn
作者: palmchristy 時間: 11-11-22 01:03 標題: 回復 6# 786 的帖子
如果只學一種樂器, 小六要達八級不是難事來的.
只是, 如果今天考到和明年六月考到的小一生, 沒有升讀協恩中學的優勢, 那樣就真是要好好考慮是否選讀協恩小學了.
作者: 786 時間: 11-11-22 01:09
其實協恩小學也早有準備, 未9月1日上課前, 已經給予每一位新生一樣樂器學習, 所以小一生在一年級已經學習樂器, 小六達八級...... 谷就不難. 對我而言, 難矣. 我的小朋友都是一年一級, 到六年級, 最多得六級.... 
原帖由 palmchristy 於 11-11-22 01:03 發表
如果只學一種樂器, 小六要達八級不是難事來的.
只是, 如果今天考到和明年六月考到的小一生, 沒有升讀協恩中學的優勢, 那樣就真是要好好考慮是否選讀協恩小學了. ...
作者: d2 時間: 11-11-23 11:03
協恩is better than Good hope, also no need to pay school fee la.
作者: onsyan 時間: 11-11-23 11:40
One of my friends' daughter is studying in P1 at Heep Yunn. My friend told me that Cantonese is using in all subjects except English lesson. English practice seems not enough.
作者: lcyaa 時間: 11-11-23 12:15
Heep Yunn. My friend's girl studied P1 in GH and changed to Heep Yunn in P2 too.
作者: law_panda 時間: 11-11-23 12:25 標題: 回覆 13# onsyan 的文章
It doesn't look very good in GH neither. English needs to be practiced, if everything in English in school, rest of time in Chinese, for sure, it's a bit better, only a bit!!
The most important is the school life in Heep Yunn is much more better, students enjoy school life in HY. In GH, students can only enjoy the "STUDY life" there with work load....
Want you kid to be happy or under pressure?
作者: Carelesswhisper 時間: 11-11-23 15:59
Both HY and GH are good and also dream schools for many parents. The ranking/ academic standard of them are also same/ no big difference. Just on different religions.
HY Primary School students do not need to pay school fee but GH students need to pay school fee (over 3K). GH students need to work hard but most of the girls are enjoying the school life with good facilities.
For all round development, HY may be better....Most of the girls from GH are able to speak fluent English.
Your girl is so smart!!
[ 本帖最後由 Carelesswhisper 於 11-11-23 16:01 編輯 ]
作者: Syamky 時間: 11-11-23 17:49
I think both are good schools and I dun think HY students' life are "easier" than GH ones. In HK, the reality is students at all traditional elite schools have heavy burden. Competition is so keen.
作者: tracylady 時間: 11-11-23 21:28
我覺得大家都認為協恩比Good Hope好一點, 但現在面對是協恩小學與協恩中學脫釣問題, 怎樣選呢? 是否博一博入讀協恩, 希望有機會升到協恩中學.
作者: ratafan 時間: 11-11-23 23:30
A bit exaggerated by school. I don't think all students have grade 8 by P6 and what's the point of learning the instrument for the sake of passing the piano exams? If the whole purpose is to pass the exams, logically u only need to learn 8 x 3 songs = 24 songs and attain grade 8?! It's a shame!
原帖由 786 於 11-11-22 01:09 發表
其實協恩小學也早有準備, 未9月1日上課前, 已經給予每一位新生一樣樂器學習, 所以小一生在一年級已經學習樂器, 小六達八級...... 谷就不難. 對我而言, 難矣. 我的小朋友都是一年一級, 到六年級, 最多得六級.... :cry ...
作者: 786 時間: 11-11-23 23:41
Absolutely agree with you. Actually my kid starts learning piano only at P2. A bit later than the others. No other instrument to learn. My kid at most obtain only Grade 4 at P6.
Neither HY Nor GH will accept my kid as she is not good in any sport neither. Hope she can be promoted to her current school secondary section by academic ranking.
原帖由 ratafan 於 11-11-23 23:30 發表
A bit exaggerated by school. I don't think all students have grade 8 by P6 and what's the point of learning the instrument for the sake of passing the piano exams? If the whole purpose is to pass the ...
作者: ratafan 時間: 11-11-23 23:48 標題: 回復 1# 786 的帖子
Agreed. In fact I myself have grade 8 qualification, I'm soooo sick of people going after this qualification for the sake of getting the cert. I spent more than 10 years to attain that qualification when i was small. A lot of tears and hardship. It requires both persistence and hard work. I neither push my kids to learn the piano hard even I know how to play!
作者: ratafan 時間: 11-11-23 23:51 標題: 回復 2# 786 的帖子
To 2#786
To my experience, P2 is perfect to start to learn the instrument. You are a good parent!
作者: 786 時間: 11-11-23 23:59
Thank you so much! This is the first time someone thinks the learning start time is good. piano teacher says nowadays no one starts learning piano so late.
原帖由 ratafan 於 11-11-23 23:51 發表
To 2#786
To my experience, P2 is perfect to start to learn the instrument. You are a good parent!
[ 本帖最後由 786 於 11-11-24 00:05 編輯 ]
作者: Bon_Bon_Pa_Pa 時間: 11-11-24 00:09
GH冇要求學生運動或音樂要叻，P1係完全冇課外活動，P2䦕始學校才有課外活動給學生參加。有些熱門的ETA可能需要選拔如羽毛球丶choir、田徑隊等。游泳都要P3以上才有得參加。學校想P1學生多些時間去習慣小學生活，因和幼稚園分別頗大，所以不主張給小朋友太多課外活動。但大家都知現今父母一般都會安排一些ETA給子女，但真係要小朋友應付到才好。
作者: ratafan 時間: 11-11-24 00:09
This is from the perspective of cultivating one's interest in music and the instrument. My kid's teacher who has over 30 years experience shares the same view. I also started in p2 and I'm still playing now in my leisure time. I truly respect it's an art, not a weapon... But of course, to most parents nowadays, p2 is too late.
原帖由 786 於 11-11-23 23:59 發表
Thank you so much! This is the first time someone thinks the learning start time is good. piano teachers says nowadays no one starts learning piano so late.
作者: celinapang 時間: 11-11-24 00:17
As I know, 排行榜 of HPS is higher than GHS, if I were you, I will choose Heep Yan, cheaper fee also.
作者: 786 時間: 11-11-24 00:20
Can't agree no more! Give me five! I learned violin in music office when I was 8. And it was painful to practice and I didn't do any exam after grade 3. But this is good enough to give me musical sense to appreciate music.
On the other hand, I admire my kid's school rather than HY. Although 99% of the class learn piano, music teacher will regard all the kids the same. If there is an excursion music trip, those who are willing to join can be there, not considering the grading they obtain. To me, this is a true education.
原帖由 ratafan 於 11-11-24 00:09 發表
This is from the perspective of cultivating one's interest in music and the instrument. My kid's teacher who has over 30 years experience shares the same view. I also started in p2 and I'm still playi ...
[ 本帖最後由 786 於 11-11-24 00:22 編輯 ]
作者: Gagagogo 時間: 11-11-24 12:32 標題: 回復 4# Bon_Bon_Pa_Pa 的帖子
似乎GH都唔錯喎，不用硬性規定學生要十項全能。
個人認為HY或GH是但一間都非常好，
HY. GH
基督教. 天主教
中學轉直資. 直上中學冇
運動均是叮噹馬頭，全港女學校兩間都
是頭三甲
多個60年歷史. 60年多少少
中學那邊的排名表，2010成績，6科14分人均比率，HY：71%,GH:85%,按成績又真的GH好好多,所以HY也要轉直資救忙
抽到HY,就去HY罷，留番GH個位比我流晒口水的朋友
作者: survivor 時間: 11-11-24 13:13
關於GH和HY的比較，又或者幾間女校(HY,GH,MCS,SMC,SPC..)之間的比較，每年都有不少BK家長分享經驗，大致上都是五五開！
以我所見，真是每一間都好，每一間每年都可以出10個左右的尖子。問題只在乎哪一間有offer(s)及哪一間學校文化最suitable。
GH一般意見為功課多，教材較organized！因為私校，平均考試分數80分，所以家長壓力肯定不少。
HY一般意見為較liberal，較着重獨立思考！因為仍為津小，學生水平參差應該大些，考試分數有80分，家長可能已經OK。
始終一句，看妳小女特質，看看哪一所小學讓妳小女踏上尖子之路。
作者: 嫦娥一号 時間: 11-11-25 00:52
協恩各階層都有,德望多公務員,新移民和有$人,試想幾千元學費 + 車資又要補習和課外活動,大部份人都是中產以上.
因為屋企有支持,好些人讀不上也不在乎,因可去外國升學......反觀協小要努力升中,升中後也別無他選,大都會乖乖讀好書!
所以讀書風氣是協恩好些.
如不計$ ,我都會要協恩! 樸素些.
作者: OB-father 時間: 11-11-25 17:55
邊間好D,真係好難比較,如$唔concern,就揀比較近個間啦
如你決定give up GH,請你盡快,我會很感激你,因我女是備取生
作者: cellon 時間: 12-2-10 23:06
palmchristy 發表於 11-11-22 00:14 
咁今年入學的小一生到小六時有多少機會被協恩中學取錄呢?
如果2012年入讀小一，升小六時已經和協恩中學脫鉤，協恩中學將不會再有預留學位。
入讀協中的機會和其他小學生一樣。
作者: winnietingting 時間: 12-2-11 12:31 標題: 引用：協恩小學及德望小學已收了小女，除了學費因
原帖由 tracylady 於 11-11-21 發表
協恩小學及德望小學已收了小女，除了學費因素之外，請問你們會選哪一間呢?
...
這只是本人愚見，未必對的。
作者: cherry媽咪 時間: 12-2-11 13:56 標題: 回覆：winnietingting 的帖子
但係德望小學都未必百分百升德望中學，所以係咪真係叫做back up呢？
作者: Elinor_Mama 時間: 12-2-11 17:49
回復 Bon_Bon_Pa_Pa 的帖子
唔好意思，Bon_Bon_Pa_Pa，小女十分幸運明年能入讀GH，但擔心小一入學時太多功課，較難適應。想問一問GH小一是否最後一堂做功課？開學時，做功課壓力大嗎？
作者: tko-parent 時間: 12-2-11 18:45
協恩應好些！
就算中學轉左直資，小學部學生水準如 OK，一定會優先收番，除非成績差不遠啦，不用太担心。
你在 GH 讀得太差，中學部一樣吾收你啦！間間直資中學都係咁啦。
| 歡迎光臨 教育王國 (/) |
Powered by Discuz! X1.5 |