教育王國

標題: 救恩與港小 [打印本頁]

作者: cammylau 時間: 11-11-18 07:24 標題: 救恩與港小

家住筲箕灣,揀港小還救恩好??

作者: spmok1999 時間: 11-11-18 09:18

都唔洗諗啦, 一間近一間遠...

作者: bbiloveu 時間: 11-11-18 09:20

"港小", do you mean HKUGA? My son is now studying here in P.1. In these few months, he develops a good reading habit which has never been in kinder and he even able to pronounce the words he doesn't know. The synthetic phonics being taught is quite effective. I love the moral education as well. I know I have make the right choice.

作者: tattc 時間: 11-11-18 09:31 標題: 回復 3# bbiloveu 的帖子

有人講港同依家差咗，你覺得有無？

作者: ziyi 時間: 11-11-18 09:49

差左?
在教學上,我覺得教深左就真,而德育及方向上沒有改,都是先培養小朋友喜歡閱讀先.

原帖由 tattc 於 11-11-18 09:31 發表
有人講港同依家差咗，你覺得有無？

作者: 已刪除用戶 時間: 11-11-18 09:50

深左就有人講, 差左邊方面? 可以講清楚D等我地D家長一齊研究下
FYI, 2次前學校小六畢業生PRE S-1(升中分班試)考得好好, 所以舊年既小六生亦"水漲船高", 所以舊年有40幾個畢業生走左(小學部學生原本就100%保証原校升中), HKUGA書院雖然未有公開成績, 但外界一般會評為BAND 2A英中, 如果唔係更上一層樓, D家長都唔會攪咁多野了
仲有, 今年考港同人數係創新高數字, 點會差左呢

原帖由 tattc 於 11-11-18 09:31 AM 發表
有人講港同依家差咗，你覺得有無？

作者: easydad 時間: 11-11-18 13:21

From my understanding, HKUGA is getting better and better.  In terms of school work, it is actually more demanding than before but still very very reasonable.

I have been followings this school quite some time as both my kids are now studying there.  It seems that the major disappointment from past parents was the school's decision not go IB direction.  I personally dislike this IB idea as it seems to be a waste of resources for the sake of getting a name only.

Again, it really depends on the priority of the parents.  If one wants a kid to work double hard and to drill on homework many hours a day to excel in hard skills, HKUGA is not for them.  If want to give a cheerful and happy time to the kids, HKUGA is very nice.  Yet, too many parents want both and ended up unhappy either way.

I like to keep things simple.

[ 本帖最後由 easydad 於 11-11-18 13:23 編輯 ]

作者: tattc 時間: 11-11-18 16:13

我本身都好鍾意活動教學，所以港同and救恩都係target，而小朋友就讀緊救恩KG，其實都心大心細，升救恩還是報港同，咁啱有個插班同學仔住港同果邊，我咪問下佢媽咪會唔會報港同，佢話有朋友個仔讀緊，覺得創校校長走咗之後無咁好，而佢自己都係鍾意呢位校長，所以幫阿女轉嚟救恩！所以有咁既問題......而呢位校長真係咁好，點解咁多人欣賞佢呢？

作者: 已刪除用戶 時間: 11-11-18 16:57

如果小朋友讀緊港小, 最大咪小6(同我個女一樣), 入學時創校校長都走左啦, 點有得比較"以前校長點"同"而家校長點"呢

不過作為港同家長, 我會認為港同好多野都係續漸上軌道, 例如普教中都教左十年了, 其他科目選同編課本都系統化左
而家校長講過一樣野, 佢話: 我地學生係有能力做到的, 不過需要一D少少既TRAINING, 要佢地知道對學習認真D, 例如總無理由去考公開試至第一次見份試卷........咁我覺得又合理WOR, 學EASYDAD話齋, 係多左, 但仲係好合理, 例如我仔P2, 見都未見過TSA(我女果時係P3聖誕第一次見), 我女小6, 一樣無操TSA, 好多學校P1已經勁做了; 咁樣"多左操練", 易接受吧

原帖由 tattc 於 11-11-18 04:13 PM 發表
我本身都好鍾意活動教學，所以港同and救恩都係target，而小朋友就讀緊救恩KG，其實都心大心細，升救恩還是報港同，咁啱有個插班同學仔住港同果邊，我咪問下佢媽咪會唔會報港同，佢話有朋友個仔讀緊，覺得創校校長走咗之後無咁好，而佢 ...

作者: easydad 時間: 11-11-18 17:19

Side track a bit -

I hope my kids can have a lively childhood because I hope they can excel in higher educations.  Pls don't think I don't believe in drilling.  I do too.

Timing is the key to me.  Starting too early has higher risk of burning out or get sick of studying.  Plus, thinking back.. I forgot what I learnt in primary school totally... does it really matter to know that much or do that fast for a small kid?  How can a kid be creative and imagine silly stuff if they don't have enough sleep and spent all their time doing structured homework?

Actually, I am telling this to myself.  Once in a while, I feel lost when comparing my kids to other super kids of same age ....

作者: tattc 時間: 11-11-20 03:24

唔該哂各位解答得咁詳細！我都相信港同係一間好學校！而兩間學校都幾相似，唯一係港同既兩文三語好似比救恩好少少，仲有一條龍中學，真係好吸引！

作者: sony_boy 時間: 11-11-20 09:10

兩間相似既原因, 其實就係救恩現任校長, 就是港同既創校校長, 另外, 亦有部份救恩老師, 是以前港同老師, 老實一點, 如果要選, 唔計遠近, 當然時港同, 他的直屬中學, 點都比救恩那間好!!!

作者: preciousstone 時間: 11-11-20 23:33

What? 救恩的聯系書院是匯基, 匯基是 Band 1 呀, 怎會比港同中學差?

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)