教育王國

標題: St. Clare's VS RC [打印本頁]

作者: msz006 時間: 11-11-17 15:54 標題: St. Clare's VS RC

My daughter got both offers. Can anyone share some information about these two school and how to choose

作者: Sorb 時間: 11-11-18 00:19

Same here, anyone can share?

作者: cmchang0927 時間: 11-11-18 01:17

Just share my case with u...
2 yrs ago
1. My girl got an offer from Raimondi, then True Light
2. On the day of 1st round allocation, I got a seat from St Paul's primary catholics School with 15 marks
3. Then my girl got an offer from St Clare's
4. Since Raimondi wanna u to give up the seat from government allocation, I gave up the seat of Raimondi (Cos' girls: boys ratio is so imbalance)
5. Then I think True Light is similar to St Paul's, so I gave up true light
6. I was struggling between English primary and Chinese Primary School, so I held St Clare's till June
7. Finally I chose St Paul's.

So for girls, I prefer St Clare's rather than Raimondi (Just my personal opinion!)

Moreover, my girl's three kindergarten classmates are in St Clare's P.2 now, the moms are satified with the school and the girls are happy there.

[ 本帖最後由 cmchang0927 於 11-11-18 01:24 編輯 ]

作者: TB 時間: 11-11-18 01:27

Hi cmchang0927
Thx for sharing ur experience.

I currently have 2 offers （ st clare's and hk truelight ） and waiting for the 陳守仁 and 蔡繼友results。 if u have to rank them， who will go 1st and who will go last？ please advice！

作者: Sorb 時間: 11-11-18 01:34

cmchang0927, thank you very much for your sharing. Appreciated!

作者: cmchang0927 時間: 11-11-18 01:38

我自己個人選校, 一定會選d有直屬中學.. 可能我個人冇咩志氣, 我覺得做人最緊要穩陣, 細路仔讀書d野好難講, 而家叻, 大d又唔知叻唔叻, 一陣呈分試粗心大意失手......... 再加上而加考幼稚園, 小學都咁難, 遲d唔知中學又要d咩超人..... 所以呢.... if I were u:
1. St Clare (Eng primary school)
2. True Light
3. TSL
(Sorry, 我當年都冇考cky因為我唔係太buy international Schools 個種教法)

原帖由 TB 於 11-11-18 01:27 發表
Hi cmchang0927
Thx for sharing ur experience.

I currently have 2 offers （ st clare's and hk truelight ） and waiting for the 陳守仁 and 蔡繼友results。 if u have to rank them， who will go 1st and who wil ...

作者: cmchang0927 時間: 11-11-18 01:40

You are welcome.

原帖由 Sorb 於 11-11-18 01:34 發表
cmchang0927, thank you very much for your sharing. Appreciated!

作者: cmchang0927 時間: 11-11-18 01:46

其實有一間ok既直屬中學, 係呢個時勢我覺得好緊要:
1. 和小朋友之間的關係好d, 唔駛逼到最緊
2. 如果小朋友叻, 可以考比直屬中學還要好的中學

e.g st paul's primary catholics is similar to St clare's
- around 70 to 80% girls are promoted to the feeder's secondary
- top students: can go 英華, st stephen's girl's, st paul's co edu, DGS, etc.....

作者: spmok1999 時間: 11-11-18 09:25

聖嘉勒

[ 本帖最後由 spmok1999 於 11-11-21 00:25 編輯 ]

作者: spmok1999 時間: 11-11-18 09:37

原帖由 TB 於 11-11-18 01:27 發表
Hi cmchang0927
Thx for sharing ur experience.

I currently have 2 offers （ st clare's and hk truelight ） and waiting for the 陳守仁 and 蔡繼友results。 if u have to rank them， who will go 1st and who wil ...

hk truelight

[ 本帖最後由 spmok1999 於 11-11-21 00:27 編輯 ]

作者: 3A1Y 時間: 11-11-19 18:33 標題: 回復 8# cmchang0927 的帖子

hI cmchang0927, I got the offer from St. Clare's this year but they ask us to give up the P1 allocation. So please could you advise how you could hold the seat until June?

Also, my 1st choice of P1 allocation is also St. Paul Catholic Primary. Could you give me some advice on this school?

Many thanks.

作者: Trackspecials 時間: 11-11-19 19:20

I have the same question too. Much appreciate if someone can advise. Thanks in advance!

作者: cmchang0927 時間: 11-11-19 22:19

I don't think it means giving up the p1 central allocation...........
But if enrol for the central allocation, the Education Department ll inform the school......
In my case, I received a letter from the Education Department before the result of 2nd round of central allocation announced (I got st paul in the 1st round), the letter said that the Education Department knew that I have kept 2 seats, to avoid the waste of seat, they asked me if I would keep the seat of st paul's, if I did, they ll inform st clare's.........

作者: TB 時間: 11-11-20 10:33

Hi cmchang0927
Thx a lot for all your suggestion， juz received letter that the TSL put my daughter on waiting list。after thinking for a few days， i am more towards going after st clare's unless my daughter receive straight offer from CKY。

作者: endaddy 時間: 11-11-20 14:08

--DELETED---

[ 本帖最後由 endaddy 於 11-11-20 14:23 編輯 ]

作者: imdaddy 時間: 11-11-20 17:30

St Clare for girl. It is a real girls school

作者: EllaHN 時間: 11-11-20 21:49

Hi TB,
請問妳住邊區? 我住九龍，唔知點返學? 請比D 意見，謝謝!

作者: TB 時間: 11-11-20 23:39

Hi ellahn

I live in Tsing Yi. Also thinking of how to get there。 i know that there are school bus which can pick up the chidern at IFC。 any other mom can share some information？

作者: hehe1016 時間: 11-11-21 09:08

Hi TB,

I also live in Tsing Yi. My daughter will most likely to study in St. Clare next year. Let find the school bus info together.

Just now, same as you, I know that there is a school bus to pick up student at IFC. But I may need to confirm how long it take from IFC to St. Clare. By taxi, it just 10 to 15 mins. So I think it's acceptable for me to travel daily.

I hope our little girls can make friend next year.

作者: hehe1016 時間: 11-11-21 10:19

Hi TB,

Confirmed that there is a route from
IFC --> 港內線碼頭--> 學校
7:25 am 7:45am

IFC 放學是頭站.

兩個站都可接受啦!

作者: TB 時間: 11-11-21 13:46

Hi Hehe1016:

Thanks for the info. If I have more info, I will post it here. Just wonder whether there are any bus route for the kowloon west side. I was wondering as if we gather enough students at the Kowloon West side, I wonder whether there will be any "補母車" take the order.

作者: 3A1Y 時間: 11-11-23 00:31

I guess the competition is so keen this year so the offer letter stated "we will take it as an indication that you are surrendering the school place at St. Clare's Primary School for opting to stay in the Central Allocation System of the EDB."

Sadly my girl didn't get allocated for St. Paul in the 1st round so now I'm really worry if I decide to stay for 2nd round allocation and St. Clare's will cancel my seat....

Wondering if you remembered having the same sentence included in your offer letter?

Many thanks.

原帖由 cmchang0927 於 11-11-19 14:19 發表
I don't think it means giving up the p1 central allocation...........
But if enrol for the central allocation, the Education Department ll inform the school......
In my case, I received a letter from ...

作者: cmchang0927 時間: 11-11-23 00:37

I m sorry that my letter didn't have the same statement as yr letter....
So I think as this yr's competition is so keen, they just want ppl to give up the lucky draw....
Btw, which school do u want to put in yr form for first choice and which district are u in?

原帖由 3A1Y 於 11-11-23 00:31 發表
I guess the competition is so keen this year so the offer letter stated "we will take it as an indication that you are surrendering the school place at St. Clare's Primary School for opting to stay in ...

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)