教育王國

標題: 9優何凱琳轉讀心理學「志不在醫」棄4年苦功 [打印本頁]

作者: kenfu 時間: 11-10-24 09:04 標題: 9優何凱琳轉讀心理學「志不在醫」棄4年苦功

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: 701003 時間: 11-10-24 10:05

我反而'登"佢開心wor

作者: gigivinda 時間: 11-10-24 10:43 標題: 回復 1# kenfu 的帖子

本帖最後由 gigivinda 於 12-7-27 21:24 編輯

我覺得中五會考未必能分高下，因為課程沒有中七那麼艱深，單是努力操練也會有不錯的成績。

而且，一般地區學校著重為學生安排每一個課程的小節，筆記來讀。學生習慣了給人操練的方式，就在大學對自發學習的模式感到不適應。

對於凱琳能成功轉系，這是一件好事。她能找到自己的方向，不勉強自己符合別人的期望

作者: Annie123 時間: 11-10-24 12:38

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: annie40 時間: 11-10-24 13:08

太好了, 何凱琳才十八岁就明白应该为自己而活! 境界高出我们终日营营役役,对子女诸多期望的父母好多.

虽然好多隐形的Auntie , Uncle 当左凱琳系dream daughter(如我), 听到她无念医科就有D失落感, 好似阿女唔多听话甘.

但只要阿女开心又懂事, 绝对应该鼓励她: 女大女世界, 不用理会阿爸阿妈姨妈姑姐阿猪阿狗的想法. 我们的意见有时跟路人甲, 丙的水平差不多的. 最终决断应在阿女手中

原帖由 kenfu 於 11-10-24 09:04 發表
【明報專訊】2007年憑會考9優1良成績，以16歲之齡破格入讀中大醫學院的何凱琳，本有望成為本港史上最年輕的醫生，不過中大發言人昨證實，凱琳實習期間發現自己「志不在醫」，未有如期於今年完成醫科課程後完成實習。凱琳上月起 ...

作者: Naurto 時間: 11-10-24 15:27

作者: peter_pan 時間: 11-10-24 17:14

If she chose an academic subject rather than medicine, I don't think she would have had any problem.
On paper, medicine is a noble profession in that you are helping people in need, and that you are well respected.
That is the 'glamorous' notion most kids have about medicine.
But in reality you'll have to deal with breaking bad news, comforting the dying, confronting griefing relatives.....not to mention facing blood, pus & broken limbs!
It would have been better for her to study a science degree first and then apply for medicine as a graduate student later when she was more mature.

原帖由 kenfu 於 11-10-24 09:04 發表
我覺得有點可惜!!
亦反映了太早入大學可能未有成熟的心智了解自己的意向.

作者: ANChan59 時間: 11-10-24 20:42

My son told me he would like to take medicine in HK last year.

The first thing I arranged for him was clinical attachment in public hospital, he saw open surgeries (bloody....), a patient died in operation, complaining patients in the ward and out-patient, long working hours......

Is it the profession you want for coming 40 years? If yes, good luck to him and work hard to achineve excellent academic results and interviews. If not, don't waste the space, do something else......

**************************

I am happy to know she found the right profession and will contribute to the community in the future.

作者: khmama 時間: 11-10-24 22:20 標題: 回復 8# ANChan59 的帖子

我朋友既女本來都想讀Medicine, 但一聽師姐講話每人派條屍比你, 用足一個月學劏屍, 即刻打退堂鼓.

作者: panbaby 時間: 11-10-25 11:14

喺呀, 我細個讀書時, 有一日在飯堂見到個 Medic 仔, 咁走上去同佢傾偈, 但見他神色不善, 咁問他有咩事? 我到現在都仲記得佢講 : "我呢排解剖, 有次一刀切下去, 俾嚸液體 (我唔知是咩...) 唧到自己, ..." 　佢仲玩　gag，　"好彩有副眼鏡頂住，　'啡' 唔到去隻眼到..."

讀醫年期長又辛苦, 見盡人間生老病死, 唔係個個都適合讀.

原帖由 khmama 於 11-10-24 22:20 發表
我朋友既女本來都想讀Medicine, 但一聽師姐講話每人派條屍比你, 用足一個月學劏屍, 即刻打退堂鼓.

作者: awah112 時間: 11-10-25 20:36

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: hhma 時間: 11-10-25 21:56

聽講唔係派, 係每人"買"一條.....

原帖由 khmama 於 11-10-24 22:20 發表
我朋友既女本來都想讀Medicine, 但一聽師姐講話每人派條屍比你, 用足一個月學劏屍, 即刻打退堂鼓.

作者: khmama 時間: 11-10-25 23:02 標題: 回復 12# hhma 的帖子

吓, 仲要比錢? 其實邊o的人會賣自己條屍比人劏?

作者: ha8mo 時間: 11-10-26 10:01

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: ANChan59 時間: 11-10-26 10:55 標題: 回覆 14# ha8mo 的文章

Thanks for your info.

作者: ha8mo 時間: 11-10-26 12:10

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: annie40 時間: 11-10-26 12:35

刚好相反, 小女不一定读医,而我亦非常唔想她读, 因为少了年青人应享受的social life, 很可惜!

但有次看书,见D初哥们第一次劏屍时滕滕震, 就问阿女要劏屍惊否? 她回问: 那人已否死去? 我说: 当然已死. 然后她回答: 那就毫不是问题矣!

技术上这种天生可以把理智和感情分隔的人比较罕见.

原帖由 khmama 於 11-10-24 22:20 發表
我朋友既女本來都想讀Medicine, 但一聽師姐講話每人派條屍比你, 用足一個月學劏屍, 即刻打退堂鼓.

作者: ANChan59 時間: 11-10-26 18:10 標題: 回覆 17# annie40 的文章

技术上这种天生可以把理智和感情分隔的人比较罕见.

********************

Agreed, don't waste the space and the funding from the tax-payers if the student not ready.

作者: tongyimtong 時間: 11-10-26 19:16

15歲就決定終身職業，對小孩來說太大壓力。

所謂天才都要有一點運氣才會成功。如果凱琳的父母好像ANCHAN59一般有見地，她的成就會不同。可惜她的父母只是草根工人，不懂得為女兒打算。

當年她家人如果不是虛榮﹐讓女兒低調地，一步一腳印地先完成一個本科學位，再慢慢進修上去。她在大學的老師指引和經驗洗禮下，一定會有正確的選擇。

其實金錢和時間的損失其次，聞說凱琳近一年不敢接觸從前的老師和朋友。可見不快的學習經歷對她打擊多大。希望她快些走出不快的陰霾，從新投入校園生活。相信憑她的聰明，會有更好的發展。

作者: ANChan59 時間: 11-10-26 19:32 標題: 回覆 19# tongyimtong 的文章

當年她家人如果不是虛榮﹐讓女兒低調地，一步一腳印地先完成一個本科學位，再慢慢進修上去。她在大學的老師指引和經驗洗禮下，一定會有正確的選擇。

****************************

I am not sure study Medicine was her parents' wish or school's wish. I will put benefit of doubt to her parents.

We all share the same disappointment as her parents and herself. Wish her recover and bounce back soon.

作者: eschung 時間: 11-10-27 00:37

It is not easy for a Form 5 student to take medi. Even students finished AL find it difficult to cope with. Many students want to be a doctor just because of high income and social status without realising their own interest and capability. The School should set a higher requirement for medi as the training is very costly, about 4 million dollars per student.

作者: gigivinda 時間: 11-10-27 12:20

本帖最後由 gigivinda 於 12-7-27 21:25 編輯

當初傳媒太高調變了她現在的負擔

作者: 天使麵 時間: 11-10-27 14:13

知道這個消息，感可惜的是如果這個醫學位沒有因為大學急搶人，而讓一個正常學習、考量多兩年的學生去讀，是不是較少錯配....

作者: iodine 時間: 11-10-27 16:45

入醫學院唔一定要做醫生。

做醫生亦有性質完全唔用的各種專科比唔同興趣的人做。

凱琳個case其實應該做一年intercalated degree program拿個BSc先再轉.

作者: mio8390 時間: 11-11-1 13:43

她的一句"志不在醫"就浪費了另一個想做醫生的學位又浪費了納稅人的錢。

作者: caeme 時間: 11-11-3 21:18

作者: caeme 時間: 11-11-3 21:21

作者: motherotk 時間: 11-11-18 08:35

A part of growing up for this young lady.. to explore, to understand life ..., to make life decisions

University education should allow students to explore and to change their study focus after their exploration, irrespective of what subjects, every year, young university students change their majors, I do think this is good..

Good to see Chinese U be able to accommodate young people's growing up needs.

Sometimes it is impossible for u students to understand their interest without changing their mind, irrespective of what subjects and irrespective of what age they are...

作者: ANChan59 時間: 11-11-18 12:56 標題: 回復 28# motherotk 的帖子

I echo your views and appreciated CUHK accommodating to her personal need & goal.

In my time, it's more difficult to change majors as i studied in HK & UK. Nowadays, we may have more than single degree and switching fields instead of jobs...... everyone deserves a second option

作者: gigivinda 時間: 11-11-18 16:52

本帖最後由 gigivinda 於 12-7-27 21:23 編輯

原帖由 ANChan59 於 11-11-18 12:56 發表
I echo your views and appreciated CUHK accommodating to her personal need & goal.

In my time, it's more difficult to change majors as i studied in HK & UK. Nowadays, we may have more than single degr ...

I guess it may be easier but still a bit difficult. See the following under "CU Undergraduate Admission". I think it refers to both inter-faculty and inter-university transfers:

>>>
For applicants currently undertaking undergraduate studies in UGC-funded institutions and seeking transfer admissions
According to the guidelines of the University Grants Committee (UGC), unless under exceptional circumstances, applicants who may have to repeat a year of study on transfer across institutions should generally be given a lower priority in admissions.
>>>

作者: ANChan59 時間: 11-11-18 18:37 標題: 回復 30# gigivinda 的帖子

Thanks for your detail info.

For my time, only HKU & CUHK, then HKP.

作者: Annie123 時間: 11-11-19 11:59 標題: 回復 21# eschung 的帖子

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: 橘子Orange 時間: 12-7-27 19:50

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: talent2000 時間: 12-7-27 20:52

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: talent2000 時間: 12-7-27 20:55

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: andy.ma 時間: 12-7-27 22:39

medical讀到都難捱實習

作者: lcdtopcon 時間: 12-7-29 01:14 標題: 引用：medical讀到都難捱實習

原帖由 andy.ma 於 12-07-27 發表
medical讀到都難捱實習

其實讀medi少啲IQ和EQ都唔得，見到啲醫生得個做字,還時時比大佬鬧都幾慘!

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)