教育王國

標題: CKY, SMC 同 TSL 屬同類型嘅學校嗎? [打印本頁]

作者: alljodesign 時間: 11-9-27 13:06 標題: CKY, SMC 同 TSL 屬同類型嘅學校嗎?

知道3 間小學都以英語為主, 要額外學一科外語, 亦知 TSL 無一條龍, 不過仲有D 問題想問清楚:

1. 三間都係活動教學嗎?
2. 返學時間必修一種樂器?
3. 係咪都係唔洗考試排名次?
4. 三間學習氣氛會無咁大壓力?

MANY THANKS!!!

作者: Christi 時間: 11-9-27 14:46

最唔同之處,應該係CKY是行IB的,亦是IBO認可學校.

作者: NatBrown 時間: 11-9-27 15:19 標題: CKY & TSL

TSL only Primary stage and need to search Secondary school for your kid. However, their student English presentation skill is very impress and most of them are very confidence. That what I observe from their Open day. Before you apply u hv to choose your child language stream either English + Chinese (additional with basic Japanese/French learning) or English + French (baisc Chinese/Japanese).
They use project base learning, teaching are goods as told by my neighbour.

作者: motherotk 時間: 11-9-27 16:17

TSL traditional curriculum teaching, following edb curriculum, not IB type of teaching. Secondary school allocation by the government..no it's own secondary schools. School fee very reasonable.

Though project based learning in some subjects, mostly follow local EDB curriculum, except English using their own worksheets. Students are trained to be independent and has a third language, French or Japanese, though very elementary level.

CKY - more IB type of teaching....language enviornment better than TSL, of course $$$$ is more expensive..No secondary school allocation, but with their own secondary school, with supposingly IB curriculum or IB type of teaching..

[ 本帖最後由 motherotk 於 11-9-27 16:20 編輯 ]

作者: HaYi 時間: 11-9-27 20:43

我覺得cky 同 tsl 係同一種類型, cky advance D (包括硬軟件), 學生真愛閱讀, 我日日見樓下十幾個學生返學等校車都是拿住書看多. 但學費貴好多, 不過行ib 就真係預左貴. 可能貴得有道理.

tsl 就平民d同多南亞同學, 語言多元化. 課外活動又好多包括 golf, 係好物超所值的學校, 只是考中學的成績我又唔覺特別吸引, 好似好大比例入顏寶玲, 我想npl 好多家長未必會作首選 (有人說 npl 有提供 french, 但我想此都不算是 band1 中 ? ) 唔知 tsl 有冇機開中學.. 如果npl 真的結龍, 對我來說都冇咩意義... 所以我不禁對 tsl 作為一間冇back up 的小學, 學術level 如何可以配合香港選band1中學的方面有d保留.

反而smc 俾我感覺是傳統英文學校, 同 tsl, cky 都唔同類, 教學方面唔知有咩特點.

作者: cpcog 時間: 11-9-27 21:49 標題: 回復 1# alljodesign 的帖子

SMC:
If your kid learn an instrument outside school, he/she needn't learn instruments at school.
Students don't have exam in P1 but they will have them afterward. Honestly, I guess students would still have pressure because better students would be assigned to the same group.
Till now, I love SMC curriculum.

I feel CKY would exert less pressure to children in my opinion. But you need to consider that you might send your kid to study aboard in the future.

作者: ha! 時間: 11-9-28 08:26

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: cpcog 時間: 11-9-28 09:35 標題: 回復 7# ha! 的帖子

but the ratio for the non-Jupas would be fewer.

作者: ha! 時間: 11-9-28 09:47

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: penguin_chick 時間: 11-9-28 22:32

From U-beat issue 94, more than 25% enrolled were non-jupas (2008-09), about 4 thousand something, while jupas students were about 11 thousand.
I think non-jupas applicants should be must less than 25%!

作者: bbkingdombb 時間: 11-9-28 23:16 標題: 回復 10# penguin_chick 的帖子

May I know what is 'U-beat issue 94'? issued from?

作者: bbkingdombb 時間: 11-9-28 23:19 標題: 回復 6# cpcog 的帖子

May I know any 'secondary school allocation scheme' for SMC students?

作者: penguin_chick 時間: 11-9-29 09:42 標題: 回復 11# bbkingdombb 的帖子

http://www.com.cuhk.edu.hk/ubeat_past/

作者: bbkingdombb 時間: 11-9-29 17:28 標題: 回復 13# penguin_chick 的帖子

thx, may I know which page as this is a lengthy magazine. thx.

作者: cpcog 時間: 11-9-29 21:50 標題: 回復 12# bbkingdombb 的帖子

No, SMC doesn't offer that.

作者: bbkingdombb 時間: 11-9-30 02:38 標題: 回復 15# cpcog 的帖子

thank you.

作者: alljodesign 時間: 11-10-1 01:26

thank you all~

作者: penguin_chick 時間: 11-10-1 16:44 標題: 回復 14# bbkingdombb 的帖子

大學線︰
http://www.com.cuhk.edu.hk/ubeat_past/
選︰昔日大學線
從尋找期數選︰94期
再選 14 熱門科系......

作者: bbkingdombb 時間: 11-10-2 01:23 標題: 回復 18# penguin_chick 的帖子

thank you very much and the info. is very useful for reference.

There are around 4000 year 1 students '包括英國高考、國際文憑課程(IB)、本港以外學制的學歷(e.g. mainland)、拔尖(~400)、校長推薦等方法申請入學'
So far as i know and to my experience, what universities love most are the mainland students as they got to pay much higher tuition fee (around doubled, pls correct if it is wrong). Besides, there is a large number of places reserved for AD graduates. Thus, GCE, IB.... constitute only a bit and hence do not have too much expectations.

[ 本帖最後由 bbkingdombb 於 11-10-2 02:06 編輯 ]

作者: ANChan59 時間: 11-10-2 02:30 標題: 回復 19# bbkingdombb 的帖子

So far as i know and to my experience, what universities love most are the mainland students as they got to pay much higher tuition fee (around doubled, pls correct if it is wrong). [Most mainland students got scholarships, and they are very good academically, but not financially.]

Besides, there is a large number of places reserved for AD graduates. [I doubt it, AD students even less favourable than HD students. Most of them got in not so popular programs like engineering......]

Most local university favour IB > GCE AL > HD > AD.... What I mean is good IB score..... 30+

作者: ANChan59 時間: 11-10-2 02:41

The data from U-beat is misleading, e.g. MBBS in both HKU & CUHK are 1/3-1/3-1/3; EAS - JUPAS - non-JUPAS. The reporter forget to deduct EAS from non-JUPAS. Eventually, for non-JUPAS around 50+.

Also in in non-JUPAS of MBBS, another 1/3 are graduates.

作者: bbkingdombb 時間: 11-10-2 15:42 標題: 回復 21# ANChan59 的帖子

Dear ANchan, thx for your info.

May I know what is EAS? (advanced standing?)

'Also in in non-JUPAS of MBBS, another 1/3 are graduates.'
Are graduates = degree holders? Thx.

作者: bbkingdombb 時間: 11-10-2 15:55 標題: 回復 20# ANChan59 的帖子

Let's share my experience and observation. So far as I know, most graduate students are from Mainland china and they gain studentship/scholarship/...ship.
Professors like mainland students as they are perceived as more diligent and more productive and supposedly I do not discover there is limit on this.

But for undergraduate, most of them need to pay expensive tuition fee. Coz I work in university, I have chances to meet and chat with university students and professors, those mainlain students told me they need to pay around $80,000 per year. They withdraw offers from Peking U. and Tsing Wa and come here.

If you go to student canteen of HKU or CU, u will find there is significant proportion (~20-30%) are from mainland. To my estimation, I guess over 10-20% of total undergraduate are from mainland china. (though I don't have any offical figures)

作者: bbkingdombb 時間: 11-10-2 16:14 標題: 回復 20# ANChan59 的帖子

Besides, there is a large number of places reserved for AD graduates. [I doubt it, AD students even less favourable than HD students. Most of them got in not so popular programs like engineering......]

Perhaps due to articulation of their AD program and the degree programme, universities usually need to reserve a significant portion of year 1 and year 2 places to their AD students. (There are easily over 100 students in one AD prog. and only the top 10-20% can go to univiersity). the more AD graduates university accept, the most sucessful the AD prgram and then more stduents......

作者: bbkingdombb 時間: 11-10-2 16:21 標題: 回復 20# ANChan59 的帖子

Dear ANchan,

why do you think 'most local universities favour IB > GCE AL > HD > AD.... What I mean is good IB score..... 30+'. Are there any factual figures or is this saying coming from some prominent figures?

Frankly, I know IB is more popular than it was 5-10 years ago. At the moment, do you have any figures that universities places is occupied by IB gradautes? Please let us know so that parents of IB students can be more confident to go into this direction. thx.

作者: ANChan59 時間: 11-10-2 17:28 標題: 回復 22# bbkingdombb 的帖子

bbkingdombb

My reply as follow:

May I know what is EAS? (advanced standing?) [Early Admission Scheme 拔尖]

'Also in in non-JUPAS of MBBS, another 1/3 are graduates.'
Are graduates = degree holders?[Yes, correct]

ANChan59

作者: ANChan59 時間: 11-10-2 17:37 標題: 回復 23# bbkingdombb 的帖子

Mainland students are eligible to join Beijing and Tsing Hua, most likely will have a scholarship from local universities as local universities compete to take elites with BJ & TH. That's why I say so.

For international students, tuition fee around HK$110,000. If they are not elites, so they may not have full scholarship. That's may be the difference between our observations.

作者: ANChan59 時間: 11-10-2 17:55 標題: 回復 25# bbkingdombb 的帖子

I searched many times in universities' websites and I can't find the exact figures. I got some figures by attending admission seminars of HKU, CUHK and HKUST.

CUHK and HKUST provided more figures in their seminars about IB, like admission grades, language requirements......

Also, I chatted with professors from HKU, CUHK, HKUST & HKPU. They shared the info with me...... You can treat that as heresays. I suggest you join the admission seminars, like CUHK, which will be held on coming Sat and Sunday. The link as follow:
http://www.cuhk.edu.hk/oday/

You can go to the HKUST website of scholarship
http://join.ust.hk/apply/non-local/fees-and-support/scholarships

It lists the scholarship details of IB, no GCEAL, no AD or HD.......... It means something to me.

For AD is another issue, I would like to know 10-20% top AD students admitted to popular or not so popular programs.

If you want to know more about IB vs NSS, you can goto BK High School sub-forum and you can see more info to this topic.
http://forum.edu-kingdom.com/vie ... 14323&extra=&page=1

[ 本帖最後由 ANChan59 於 11-10-2 18:08 編輯 ]

作者: ANChan59 時間: 11-10-2 18:05

bbkingdombb

I am not selling IBDP, I struggled sometime before switched from local curricullum to IBDP. Both curricullum have pros and cons, if you read the posts I shared 18 months ago, you may know why I prefer IBDP >> HKDSE.

Personally, I support IBDP and authorised PYP and MYP, not IB approach schools.

With hindsight, our family made a right choice. My son is studying Yr1 IBDP this year and will take IBDP exam in 2013.

ANChan59

[ 本帖最後由 ANChan59 於 11-10-2 18:07 編輯 ]

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)