教育王國

標題: St. Joseph Primary School [打印本頁]

作者: patpatc1668 時間: 11-7-2 00:57 標題: St. Joseph Primary School

Most parents would scare this school's standard and attitude toward their studends in terms of academics. They afraid their son cannot stand or tough to handle such kind of pressure. English advanced two levels, math advanced one level..etc If someone has told you that you got a chance to enter in coming year, would you take it or let it go? Assuming your kids are average in all ability, good only in english.

作者: redkoni 時間: 11-7-2 01:14

原帖由 patpatc1668 於 11-7-2 00:57 發表
Most parents would scare this school's standard and attitude toward their studends in terms of academics. They afraid their son cannot stand or tough to handle such kind of pressure. English advanced two levels, math advanced one level..etc If someone has told you that you got a chance to enter in coming year, would you take it or let it go? Assuming your kids are average in all ability, good only in english.

Why are you so sure about "most parents"? Are they all diagnosed as having "school phobia"?

作者: SCKnight 時間: 11-7-2 07:04

原帖由 patpatc1668 於 11-7-2 00:57 發表
Most parents would scare this school's standard and attitude toward their studends in terms of academics. They afraid their son cannot stand or tough to handle such kind of pressure. English advanced ...

Why not? If your kid can handle both English and Maths OK plus he could tolerate traditional education methodology, I think you should let your kid try.

作者: sheep30 時間: 11-7-2 22:27

SJP is not as "scary" as most parents think.

作者: cutekiddy 時間: 11-7-2 22:55

It's not as difficult as you thought!

作者: ha! 時間: 11-7-3 00:29

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: patpatc1668 時間: 11-7-3 00:40

原帖由 cutekiddy 於 11-7-2 22:55 發表
It's not as difficult as you thought!

is your kid studying at St.Jo? heard from my friend's friend that they put huge pressure on both parents and students to meet their average standards which mostly at least 90 marks. Is that right? So my friend's friend have made a lot of works after school to make sure his kid keep in pace with the school requirements. " At least 8 out of 10, of my friend refuse to consider this school. So i want your opinion, but anyway thanks a lot. I will keep it on mind.

作者: patpatc1668 時間: 11-7-3 00:54

原帖由 SCKnight 於 11-7-2 07:04 發表

Why not? If your kid can handle both English and Maths OK plus he could tolerate traditional education methodology, I think you should let your kid try.

"If your kid can handle both english and maths OK"? What do you mean OK? pass? then how do i know a K2 student can or cannot tolerate traditional education methodoly? My kid study kumon english, chinese and math in normal level, do you think is that ok?

作者: patpatc1668 時間: 11-7-3 00:55

原帖由 ha! 於 11-7-3 00:29 發表
have referral ?

sorry, no comment on this issue

作者: cutekiddy 時間: 11-7-3 00:56

My kid is studying P.1 there and he can handle all the work by himself without any private tutor. I just checked his homework after he finished and did the revision with him 1 day before the test/exam.

I don't know if there is huge pressure on both parents and students but my son once told me that below 90% will be deemed as fail.

原帖由 patpatc1668 於 11-7-3 00:40 發表

is your kid studying at St.Jo? heard from my friend's friend that they put huge pressure on both parents and students to meet their average standards which mostly at least 90 marks. Is that right? S ...

作者: patpatc1668 時間: 11-7-3 00:56

原帖由 sheep30 於 11-7-2 22:27 發表
SJP is not as "scary" as most parents think.

Please share your experience with me as i dont know someone studying at this school. Thanks

作者: patpatc1668 時間: 11-7-3 00:59

原帖由 cutekiddy 於 11-7-3 00:56 發表
My kid is studying P.1 there and he can handle all the work by himself without any private tutor. I just checked his homework after he finished and did the revision with him 1 day before the test/exa ...

you kid is really genius.

作者: Tata1668 時間: 11-7-3 01:06

<90% = fail??

原帖由 cutekiddy 於 11-7-3 00:56 發表
I don't know if there is huge pressure on both parents and students but my son once told me that below 90% will be deemed as fail.

作者: cutekiddy 時間: 11-7-3 01:08

From the perspectives of the teachers only! Officially should be 60%.

原帖由 Tata1668 於 11-7-3 01:06 發表

作者: Tata1668 時間: 11-7-3 01:34

係咪如果時時8x分都要見家長? 如果持續冇改變, 係咪校長會勸諫離校?

原帖由 cutekiddy 於 11-7-3 01:08 發表
From the perspectives of the teachers only! Officially should be 60%.

作者: annienorman 時間: 11-7-3 21:44

Rumors!!!!

Please don't believe otherwise your son will lose a chance to study in such a good school!

作者: sheep30 時間: 11-7-3 23:01

我個仔今年P1，我覺得功課量不算多，和其他學校的小一功課量差不多，由於返半天，早上還可以參加興趣班、閱讀和玩。

小一第一次家長會時校長已再三強調學校非常傳統，覺得不合適的請考慮其他學校。當時我也覺得校長有點“寸”，但我想她的意思是選了就要接受他們的做法，和他們配合。

仔仔很喜歡ST. JOE，我曾不只一次問他喜歡小學還是幼稚園，他都總説是小學，他説因為較多東西學，所以他並不覺得讀小學辛苦。仔仔性格比較靜和受教，英文和數學都較好，他做數學的英文文字題比中文文字題做得好，所以ST. JOE相當適合他。

仔仔説班內的同學上課時一般都很聽話，就只有三個同學很不合作，常常談話，甚至出位，他們會被老師責罵和懲罰，懲罰包括罰企、無小息（要留在班房內罰抄）或在小息時到操場的長凳罰坐，可以吃東西和喝水，但不可以玩。至於乖的同學會得到老師的讚賞和獎勵，阿仔基本上覺得老師賞罰分明，所以很聽老師的話，也很喜歡老師。

其實，我覺得學校的做法和我們讀書時比較已有進步，他們懲罰的方法都不敢太過份，只是現在的家長都很保護子女，很難接受子女被罰，甚至不能接受子女在一所會罰學生或責罵學生的學校內讀書。我覺得如果你認為這套方法不會教好你個仔，就真的不要報這間學校。

原帖由 patpatc1668 於 11-7-3 00:56 發表

Please share your experience with me as i dont know someone studying at this school. Thanks

作者: Tata1668 時間: 11-7-4 00:06

得15分，怕且我都係幻想吓自己個仔入左去讀算了！唔知叩門位多唔多呢？

Sheep30, 多謝你既分享！

作者: patpatc1668 時間: 11-7-4 00:26

Thanks for your sharing sheep 30, is ur son is genius too?

作者: patpatc1668 時間: 11-7-4 00:29

I don't understand for deemed fail and official fail？what is the consequence?

作者: patpatc1668 時間: 11-7-4 00:33

Rumors? Less than 90% is deemed fail is rumor?

作者: Tata1668 時間: 11-7-4 00:38

Official fail = 冇得留底，即走！（我估）

原帖由 patpatc1668 於 11-7-4 00:29 發表
I don't understand for deemed fail and official fail？what is the consequence?

作者: patpatc1668 時間: 11-7-4 00:44

Tata1668,
First imagine, then vision, then action, finally completion. Please dont give up if u start imagine otherwise please don't. Be one of "most parents". So willing to take risk or not? I'm still consider both risk and rewards from parents with their son studying at st Joseph before going to next step.

作者: patpatc1668 時間: 11-7-4 00:45

Tata1668
Do know that what is deemed fail?

作者: annienorman 時間: 11-7-4 10:53 標題: 回復 21# patpatc1668 的帖子

Less than 90% is deemed fail----- this is rumor!

作者: annienorman 時間: 11-7-4 11:13 標題: 回復 1# patpatc1668 的帖子

SJPS 係一間好傳統的學校，中英數都不是讀高一級或半級！正常程度！

學校重視閱讀，常有不同的reading scheme,獎勵型式，不做便沒有獎囉！我想不致放罰！不過我相信每個孩子都有能力應付有餘！因為只是三四個月完成二十本書矣！

它們是大班教學，一班三十二人，要有效控制秩序，適當地去應付騷擾份子是無可口非的！本人常有參與做家長義工，也略可窺到班內情況，真的有時會聽到老師鬧不要再傾計吧！不過我相信孩子除了學習課本上的知識外，學習守紀律也十分重要！

至於功課，毎天五樣左右，專心的一小時內一定可自己完成！我甚至覺得比幼稚園的功課輕鬆！

只要每天都做妥功課，略有溫習，考試一定沒問題！臨急抱佛腳什麼也不行吧！

不要小看自己孩子的能力！

作者: kidder 時間: 11-7-4 13:32

The headmistress told the parents at the P1 orientation day that the school was a traditional one and those parents cannot accept it should choose another school. They use same level of textbooks as other local schools, i.e. P1 uses P1 level textbook. So far for P1, the homework is reasonable and can be finished within half an hour, similar to other local subsidary schools. My boy told me that 2 classmates in his class failed in the exam and will repeat P1. Not sure it is true or not.
Do trust the kid's ability and they can easily adopt to fit the school. Some kids are 遇强越强. St Jo is good school. Most importantly it has a linked secondary school otherwise you have to go through another 'interview process' after 6 years.

作者: patpatc1668 時間: 11-7-4 23:56

thanks a lot to kidder and annienorman,

I have pushed a lot on my kid to do math, english and chinese homework everyday since k1. My kid has already adapted a daily schedule to complete all the daily task before watching tv or play toys. But sometimes, I observed that he is not smart enough to enter St. Jo as I'm might made a mistake in academic requirements . After you both shared your experience, I will take the shot. Thanks a lot. God bless your kids.

作者: Tata1668 時間: 11-7-5 09:56

想問吓你地小朋友多唔多同學係細仔？我仔係12月出世

作者: lugano 時間: 11-7-12 18:12

SJPS 係一間好學校, 我都好想個仔入, 又免費

去年第一 round 自行計分抽唔到, 結果考入了間直資男校, 我打算等 P2 試下當插班生再去考下

作者: uarecheap 時間: 11-7-12 19:02

剛去左小一迎新曰，我初次聽梁校長演講，感覺非常好，她聲音動聽清楚很有校長台型。感覺她很關心學生。老師也很nice 她們原全沒有講很傳統會怎樣對學生，和叫妳退學。好像和論壇完全不一樣。她們很關心家長學生和資源充裕,可能是宿班能更有效改善得愈來愈好，如時並進。

作者: Tata1668 時間: 11-7-13 01:33

聽落都冇咁擔心... 不過入到先算

原帖由 uarecheap 於 11-7-12 19:02 發表
剛去左小一迎新曰，我初次聽梁校長演講，感覺非常好，她聲音動聽清楚很有校長台型。感覺她很關心學生。老師也很nice 她們原全沒有講很傳統會怎樣對學生，和叫妳退學。好像和論壇完全不一樣。她們很關心家長學生和資源充裕,可 ...

作者: elytis 時間: 11-7-13 14:27

heard that the teachers are not very caring? always leave the responsibility to parents? is it true?

作者: Isaacmommy 時間: 11-7-13 23:30 標題: 回復 30# lugano 的帖子

Why you prefer SJP over the DSS school? For the DSS school, majority of its students can go to its secondary school, whereas for SJP, the percentage is much smaller.

作者: lugano 時間: 11-7-29 11:16

原帖由 Isaacmommy 於 11-7-13 23:30 發表
Why you prefer SJP over the DSS school? For the DSS school, majority of its students can go to its secondary school, whereas for SJP, the percentage is much smaller.

6 年直資 primary + 6 年直資中學, 條數好貴, 而且 SJPS 名氣很好

Isaacmommy, 分享下我去年九月的經歷, 天主教家庭, 拿著 20 分, 家住港島, 心儀華仁和聖約瑟兩所男校, 思前想後, 最後選了聖約瑟, 因相對學位數目多少少, 希望抽中的機會大一點, 最後都是抽不到

直資方面, 報考了港同, 聖保羅男校, 高主教, 聖類斯, 最後選讀聖保羅男校, 放棄參加中央派位階段

無論入到直資或津貼, 其實都盡量讓小朋友去盡, 事關競爭很大, 唔通入到直資, 放軟手腳, 搏大霧就可穩升中學? 我自己打算小二起去考插班華仁和聖約瑟, 讓個仔試試實力

作者: piggy-ma 時間: 11-7-29 14:06 標題: 回覆 35# lugano 的文章

你今年有無叩門呀?有小一成功叩門入華仁。

朋友兒子去年成功叩華仁小四，努力以赴啊。

作者: lugano 時間: 11-7-29 14:55

原帖由 piggy-ma 於 11-7-29 14:06 發表
你今年有無叩門呀?有小一成功叩門入華仁。

朋友兒子去年成功叩華仁小四，努力以赴啊。

多謝 piggy-ma

小兒今年九月先讀小一, 出年會試試

thx again

作者: Tata1668 時間: 11-8-1 23:59

有冇人可以 confirm 一下 st joseph 有冇小二至小五既扣門位? 因為好似d人講到 "有出冇入"...
lugano, 多謝你既分享, 我都會幫阿仔報你講既幾間, 唔知有冇多d資訊可以分享一下呢?

但我仔就冇咁好彩, 得15分... 怕且都

加上係超細仔, 考直資/私小係冇都係 "陪跑"呢??

作者: lugano 時間: 11-8-2 10:26

原帖由 Tata1668 於 11-8-1 23:59 發表
有冇人可以 confirm 一下 st joseph 有冇小二至小五既扣門位? 因為好似d人講到 "有出冇入"...
lugano, 多謝你既分享, 我都會幫阿仔報你講既幾間, 唔知有冇多d資訊可以分享一下呢? 但我仔就冇咁好彩, 得15分 ...

手拿 15 分可以話希望不大, 因太多 20 分在手的小朋友, 在灣仔網可以摶下軒官, 但不要太大期望

我諗大抽階段聖約瑟和華仁命中率更高, 是旦入到一間都開香檳, 小二至小五一定有插班位, 不用擔心

不用太擔心超細仔考學校的問題, 現在並非考 K1

多點資訊有關 St. Paul's, St. Louis's, Raimondi, 請參考這個貼

http://forum.edu-kingdom.com/viewthread.php?tid=2316693&page=1#pid33860639

祝福你成功

作者: sh_yip 時間: 11-8-11 18:21

原帖由 lugano 於 11-7-29 11:16 發表

6 年直資 primary + 6 年直資中學, 條數好貴, 而且 SJPS 名氣很好

Isaacmommy, 分享下我去年九月的經歷, 天主教家庭, 拿著 20 分, 家住港島, 心儀華仁和聖約瑟兩所男校, 思前想後, 最後選了聖約瑟, 因相對學位 ...

Lugano,
多謝你的分享? 請問你是否用"灣仔區/12Net"去大抽獎? 我仔仔得15分咪等於無望

. 第一輪"自行"100%無望, 但唔知第二輪(地址)有無機會呢?

作者: holokmom 時間: 11-8-19 00:27

原帖由 lugano 於 11-7-29 11:16 發表

6 年直資 primary + 6 年直資中學, 條數好貴, 而且 SJPS 名氣很好

Isaacmommy, 分享下我去年九月的經歷, 天主教家庭, 拿著 20 分, 家住港島, 心儀華仁和聖約瑟兩所男校, 思前想後, 最後選了聖約瑟, 因相對學位 ...

見你有計劃，有準備，只係欠運氣，現在已下決心，祝你囝插班成功！

作者: tseleebb 時間: 11-8-19 01:57 標題: 回覆 26# annienorman 的文章

May I know which kindergarten your kid studied before? It sounds like your boy was in a tough school. KV? Tks

作者: Ching_Mammy 時間: 11-8-19 10:12

原帖由 sh_yip 於 11-8-11 18:21 發表

Lugano,
多謝你的分享? 請問你是否用"灣仔區/12Net"去大抽獎? 我仔仔得15分咪等於無望 . 第一輪"自行"100%無望, 但唔知第二輪(地址)有無機會呢?

我有朋友last year第一Round, 15分入咗, good luck.

作者: TIGERBAMA 時間: 11-8-19 10:26

15分??? 沒可能吧!!!!

作者: Ching_Mammy 時間: 11-8-19 10:45

原帖由 TIGERBAMA 於 11-8-19 10:26 發表
15分??? 沒可能吧!!!!

真人真事

作者: qoo_pooh 時間: 11-8-19 11:43

聽聞有人20分都抽唔到喎...........
會不會係2nd round 呀?

原帖由 Ching_Mammy 於 11-8-19 10:12 發表

我有朋友last year第一Round, 15分入咗, good luck.

作者: traeh 時間: 11-8-19 11:59

會唔會係彩雲聖若瑟小學、佐敦谷聖若瑟天主教小學、聖公會錦田聖約瑟小學、馬鞍山聖若瑟小學？灣仔聖若瑟真係20分都未必得，除非靠大抽獎或叩門。

原帖由 Ching_Mammy 於 11-8-19 10:45 發表

真人真事

作者: bobotang 時間: 11-8-19 12:08

原帖由 traeh 於 11-8-19 11:59 發表
會唔會係彩雲聖若瑟小學、佐敦谷聖若瑟天主教小學、聖公會錦田聖約瑟小學、馬鞍山聖若瑟小學？灣仔聖若瑟真係20分都未必得，除非靠大抽獎或叩門。

...

我都認為無乜可能,
我都想知, 第一輪係咪一定由最高分開始收,
如15分都收, 即是20分所有收晒.
如果係咁, 有20分而入唔到者, 可以點做 ?

作者: traeh 時間: 11-8-19 12:21

網上言論無證無據，如果你單憑網友話有朋友（仲要唔係自己）以15分第一輪獲取錄，但你20分不入，應該都無乜可做。

但如果你真係知邊個手持15分第一輪獲取錄，但你20分不入，我相信咁就可以去教育局投訴。不過我諗你要有佢少少資料，教育局可以trace到先得。

你就係20分入唔到聖若瑟？

原帖由 bobotang 於 11-8-19 12:08 發表

我都認為無乜可能,
我都想知, 第一輪係咪一定由最高分開始收,
如15分都收, 即是20分所有收晒.
如果係咁, 有20分而入唔到者, 可以點做 ?

作者: bobotang 時間: 11-8-19 12:30

原帖由 traeh 於 11-8-19 12:21 發表
網上言論無證無據，如果你單憑網友話有朋友（仲要唔係自己）以15分第一輪獲取錄，但你20分不入，應該都無乜可做。

但如果你真係知邊個手持15分第一輪獲取錄，但你20分不入，我相信咁就可以去教育局投訴。不過我諗你要有佢少少資料 ...

我不是, 但一直都想問呢個問題,
唔知學校會唔會就人事或任何原因收左15分,
而有20分學生收唔到.
但若該15分者唔講出黎, 便無人知囉.
因第一輪係自行收生, 學校可以按自己標準揀學生, 是嗎?
只是想知道而已.

[ 本帖最後由 bobotang 於 11-8-19 12:32 編輯 ]

作者: ysnmama 時間: 11-8-19 12:42

說自己15分能入的. 會不會其實有宗教分而你不知? 或可能計錯分? 其實是20分在手? 發現不少人可能不懂計分. 又或其實不是第一輪, 而是第二輪? 又或者......朋友也可能迫著有不能說的真話.

作者: TIGERBAMA 時間: 11-8-19 13:59

原帖由 traeh 於 11-8-19 11:59 發表
會唔會係彩雲聖若瑟小學、佐敦谷聖若瑟天主教小學、聖公會錦田聖約瑟小學、馬鞍山聖若瑟小學？灣仔聖若瑟真係20分都未必得，除非靠大抽獎或叩門。

...

非常同意.....

作者: Sumyeema1 時間: 11-8-19 15:49

St Jo 無左 KG 后，以后仲有無叩門位呢？

作者: kidder 時間: 11-8-22 11:24

15分入 st jo 根本沒可能。應該可能round 1 failed and admitted in round 2 （lucky draw）。

沒有幼稚園，當然還有叩門位，人人叩門機會均等。去年小一有人開學後通知有位即時入學。

作者: qoo_pooh 時間: 11-8-22 12:16

叩門只收st. jo kg生嗎?
有沒有收外校生?

原帖由 kidder 於 11-8-22 11:24 發表
15分入 st jo 根本沒可能。應該可能round 1 failed and admitted in round 2 （lucky draw）。

沒有幼稚園，當然還有叩門位，人人叩門機會均等。去年小一有人開學後通知有位即時入學。 ...

作者: yymouse313 時間: 11-8-22 20:24

天主教同基督教唔一樣KA呵?

作者: patpatc1668 時間: 11-8-23 19:31

maybe they know someone on the board, so even you want to complain to education department, at least you have to proof it, so you cannot say that someone told me in BK....etc
So if the kid can go in at 15 points, the kid really save a lot of time in school selection in terms or private or public school. Principal must have a right to select a student in some particular area.

作者: lugano 時間: 11-8-25 13:59

原帖由 sh_yip 於 11-8-11 18:21 發表

Lugano,
多謝你的分享? 請問你是否用"灣仔區/12Net"去大抽獎? 我仔仔得15分咪等於無望 . 第一輪"自行"100%無望, 但唔知第二輪(地址)有無機會呢?

我住在中西區校網的, 亦沒有參加大抽獎

因在第一階段計分抽不到 SJPS, 而自行考直資被取錄就決定放棄第二階段大抽獎的機會

作者: lugano 時間: 11-8-25 14:06

原帖由 traeh 於 11-8-19 11:59 發表
會唔會係彩雲聖若瑟小學、佐敦谷聖若瑟天主教小學、聖公會錦田聖約瑟小學、馬鞍山聖若瑟小學？灣仔聖若瑟真係20分都未必得，除非靠大抽獎或叩門。

...

十分同意

作者: traeh 時間: 11-8-25 15:40

原帖由 lugano 於 11-8-25 13:59 發表

我住在中西區校網的, 亦沒有參加大抽獎

因在第一階段計分抽不到 SJPS, 而自行考直資被取錄就決定放棄第二階段大抽獎的機會

我記得你係LS舊生，有25分，點解唔報LS？如果你只係中學舊生，叩門都容易D？

作者: annienorman 時間: 11-8-27 18:33

原帖由 tseleebb 於 11-8-19 01:57 發表
May I know which kindergarten your kid studied before? It sounds like your boy was in a tough school. KV? Tks

Yes, he is from KV

作者: wttclh 時間: 11-9-21 23:07 標題: 回復 22# sh_yip 的帖子

sh_yip,

咁你第一輪會抽ST.JO嗎?

作者: wttclh 時間: 11-9-21 23:08 標題: 回覆 24# lugano 的文章

但好似第二輪都好少位喎.

作者: Janicelobby 時間: 11-9-21 23:27

樓主, 你有"someone has told you that you got a chance to enter in coming year", 好過好多人啦, 仲駛騐, 除非你又有"someone has told you that you got a chance to enter "DBS" in coming year"姐.

作者: wttclh 時間: 11-9-27 14:00 標題: 回復 11# kidder 的帖子

即係依家有得叩門呀?

作者: lugano 時間: 11-9-27 23:00

原帖由 traeh 於 11-8-25 15:40 發表

我記得你係LS舊生，有25分，點解唔報LS？如果你只係中學舊生，叩門都容易D？

但我不是喇小的, 個仔只得 20 分, 報 St. Joe, 華仁, 喇小機會都一樣...."難"

第一 round 直資收了, 唔會亦唔敢放棄個直資學位而入第二階段玩 pure luck, 至於八月叩門, 更加難過登天

但我都認識幾個師兄的兒子有25分在手, 獲喇沙取錄, 同時直資報了 DBS 並獲取錄, 最後放棄喇沙, 入讀 DBS, 吹脹

作者: SCKnight 時間: 11-9-28 00:09

原帖由 lugano 於 11-9-27 23:00 發表

但我不是喇小的, 個仔只得 20 分, 報 St. Joe, 華仁, 喇小機會都一樣...."難"

第一 round 直資收了, 唔會亦唔敢放棄個直資學位而入第二階段玩 pure luck, 至於八月叩門, 更加難過登天

但我都認識幾個師兄的兒子 ...

我覺得你報ST Jo機會會大過LS，起碼冇咁多人排。

作者: SCKnight 時間: 11-9-28 00:11

原帖由 lugano 於 11-9-27 23:00 發表

但我都認識幾個師兄的兒子有25分在手, 獲喇沙取錄, 同時直資報了 DBS 並獲取錄, 最後放棄喇沙, 入讀 DBS, 吹脹

咁又唔駛覺得吹脹，初戀對象都未必係將來嘅枕邊人喇！

作者: wttclh 時間: 11-9-28 11:32 標題: 回復 8# annienorman 的帖子

想問下,你囝囝係第幾ROUND入呀?

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)