教育王國

標題: K1 and K2 result for P1 admission [打印本頁]

作者: Ving 時間: 11-4-21 11:56 標題: K1 and K2 result for P1 admission

Hi,

Just want to know which private/DSS school will look at both K1, K2 result and which one will look at K2 result only. And actually, will the primary school emphasis on the K1, K2 result as I wonder most Kinder will write good result, is it true?

作者: thomasha 時間: 11-4-21 16:12

May I know if you are concerned about whether only K2 result or K1+K2 results are reviewed? What are your worries?

Kindergarten results are just an indication for the primary schools. Interview performance is usually more important.

原帖由 Ving 於 11-4-21 11:56 發表
Hi,

Just want to know which private/DSS school will look at both K1, K2 result and which one will look at K2 result only. And actually, will the primary school emphasis on the K1, K2 result as I wond ...

作者: Sumyeema1 時間: 11-4-21 16:22

阿女學校得評估表，小學 interview 睇唔睇架？

作者: thomasha 時間: 11-4-21 16:52

I don't think most kindergartens have "report cards" but just assessment reports. Primary schools will review these reports as background information but they may not be used specifically in interviews unless some items require special attention.

原帖由 Sumyeema1 於 11-4-21 16:22 發表
阿女學校得評估表，小學 interview 睇唔睇架？

作者: Sumyeema1 時間: 11-4-21 17:03 標題: 回覆 4# thomasha 的文章

多謝 thomas 解答。（我由舊年開始追你 post 架）

系了，不如你好似 ziyi, KaHeiBaBa 甘，多 d 上來幫下大家啦。

作者: thomasha 時間: 11-4-21 18:50

**blushing**

What a coincidence - all you named are daddies.

I'll try my best to share information and experience with parents in this forum, especially on procedural matters. I benefitted greatly from this forum - literally starting from scratch - thanks to the help of many here, including those you named, of course. :D

原帖由 Sumyeema1 於 11-4-21 17:03 發表
多謝 thomas 解答。（我由舊年開始追你 post 架）

系了，不如你好似 ziyi, KaHeiBaBa 甘，多 d 上來幫下大家啦。

作者: moonychan 時間: 11-4-22 01:26

K1 K2 成績表都幾重要, 我仔仔本PROFILE 靠晒佢....(因為我仔仔冇乜特別CERT, 而家好多DSS/ PRIVATE SCHOOL都會要求附上學校成績)

作者: Ving 時間: 11-4-22 01:45

Thanks, but my question is most of the kindergartens will write good results for their students so they can go to good schools to maintain the name of the kindergarten. If so, is the K1 K2 成績表 such important?

原帖由 moonychan 於 11-4-22 01:26 發表
K1 K2 成績表都幾重要, 我仔仔本PROFILE 靠晒佢....(因為我仔仔冇乜特別CERT, 而家好多DSS/ PRIVATE SCHOOL都會要求附上學校成績)

作者: thomasha 時間: 11-4-22 10:30

Your assumption that "most of the kindergartens will write good results for their students" may be true to a certain extent, but it should not go so far as to hide known problems. Above all, it is the most comprehensive and least biased review that primary schools can get.

If you think kindergarten reports are biased, portfolios are worse.

What you need to understand is why primary schools require K2 (or K1 as the case may be) assessments, but it is not up to us to challenge them why primary schools need them. If they need the results, just comply.

原帖由 Ving 於 11-4-22 01:45 發表
Thanks, but my question is most of the kindergartens will write good results for their students so they can go to good schools to maintain the name of the kindergarten. If so, is the K1 K2 成績表 such ...

作者: ChuLuLu 時間: 11-4-22 12:30 標題: K1 and K2 result for P1 admission

原帖由 Ving 於 11-4-22 01:45 發表
Thanks, but my question is most of the kindergartens will write good results for their students so they can go to good schools to maintain the name of the kindergarten. If so, is the K1 K2 成績表 such ...

The majority of Private Schools and DSS do require parents to submit school reports for both terms of K2. They ask for them presumably because they want to look at them so their importance cannot be understated. If your child’s kindergarten issues awards concerning position in class or if its school reports do mention your child’s position in class, you will be well-advised to redouble your efforts at improving your child’s performance in the major exams.

作者: survivor 時間: 11-4-22 14:31

In relation to the importance of the K2 school report / assessment report, I would say it all depends on which primary schools you are targeting.

If you talks about St Paul Co-ed, DB and DGJS, you need to get full A / 5 stars to get shortlisted for second interviews. Unless your kids have a special background, e.g an elder sibling in the same school / a parent teaching in the same school, 80% of candidates in second interviews need to have an excellent, if not perfect, K2 school report.

作者: iantsang 時間: 11-4-22 18:21

I guess that's probably not true since my daughter's kindergarten doesn't give full A's to students. In fact, you hardly get many "A"s. But at this point, at least there are three offers from DGJS and one from co-ed this year (and certainly more who had attended the second interviews). The assessment report reflects more of the fact and give indications to parents to know which areas they really do well and areas where improvement are needed. I don't think this affect the chance of being offered.

Of course, it may be possible that these primary schools already have an idea there are different arrangement of some more popular kindergartens. For those which give full "A"'s, then obviously it will be important.

原帖由 survivor 於 11-4-22 14:31 發表
In relation to the importance of the K2 school report / assessment report, I would say it all depends on which primary schools you are targeting.

If you talks about St Paul Co-ed, DB and DGJS, you n ...

作者: kellyjason 時間: 11-4-22 21:42

Just want to share that both academic reports and portfolio will not be examined in the first round interview of DGJS. Pure interview performance will be considered. This arrangement was already reported by 親子王. So, getting excellent academic results does not gurrantee getting offers from schools. Each school has its own requirements on selecting want kind of students it prefers.

原帖由 survivor 於 11-4-22 14:31 發表
In relation to the importance of the K2 school report / assessment report, I would say it all depends on which primary schools you are targeting.

If you talks about St Paul Co-ed, DB and DGJS, you n ...

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)