教育王國

標題: 女拔D學生真係好叻﹗ [打印本頁]

作者: Crabmeatsoup 時間: 10-12-12 22:27 標題: 女拔D學生真係好叻﹗

今年我同囡囡參加了幾個校際朗誦節比賽﹐包括英文和普通話。唔知係咪算唔好彩﹐每次同場都有幾個小女拔嘅學生。結果點呢﹖就係差不多所有冠亞季軍嘅獎都比佢地囉晒。唔好誤會﹐我意思唔係話D評判唔公平﹐而係女拔D學生表現真係好出色﹐好有自信。就算係一年級嘅學生都一樣。尤其是英文朗誦﹐佢地嘅表現可以說是贏其他學校幾條街。試過有一次在一個英文朗誦比賽中﹐同場除了DGJS外﹐還有SPCC﹐St. Pauls Convent﹐ St. Stephen 和聖心等嘅學生﹐其實大家嘅水準都算高﹐但結果冠亞季軍共四人都係DGJS嘅學生囊括。
我相信DGJS D學生成績好﹐未必全部和學校有關﹐家長嘅功勞應該佔大多數。所以當我們個個家長都希望幫自己仔女入讀名校時﹐都要看看自己能夠付出多少 ﹕包括金錢﹐時間和心血。

作者: brian61950 時間: 10-12-12 22:42

單對單英語朗誦訓練公價係$500-$800或以上一個鐘·
就算有錢都可能會肉赤·

作者: 35C9 時間: 10-12-12 22:59

仲使問, 女拔喎, NO ONE 啦.

作者: CiaoEveryone 時間: 10-12-12 23:03 標題: 回復 1# Crabmeatsoup 的帖子

Agree with you that parents and also the kids ability is important. I was in a normal Secondary school. But our school had full "A" in HKCEE and also 5A in HKALE (one of the top 5 in that year). But bear in mind that our school is just a normal school, not famous one. Also, only 2 of us is brilliant. Whether it is the smart kids make the school famous or the school train the kids to be smart ? I think it is both sides. The famous school is always have a better chance to have good result in different aspect as they can choose smart kids via the interview.

作者: CiaoEveryone 時間: 10-12-12 23:11

Sorry, I mean two schoolmates in our class get full A in HKCEE. Not all of us get full A. (=^.^=). One of us get 5A in HKALE. All our class having the same teacher and have the same lessons, but some of the students has very good result and some of them get really bad results.

作者: WChan 時間: 10-12-13 00:03

天才都要有錢培訓先可以成材.

作者: daisy17772 時間: 10-12-13 00:17 標題: 回復 1# WChan 的帖子

(天才都要有錢培訓先可以成材.) Agreed.  With funding, children could be able to further develop their potential.

This year was my girl's 1st year to enter English speech, she won 2nd place.  She is quite expressive in nature, so I didn't need to take so much effort and time to coach her.

In my girl's mandarin speech, there was a few DGJS girl, my girl won 3rd place, while only one of those girls won 2nd place.

DGJS girls won quite a lot of those competitions 'cause they have the talents, their families are willing to spend money.

作者: Astoria 時間: 10-12-13 00:44

Hi daisy17772,
Read from other post that your girl is from St Paul Convent, right?

作者: daisy17772 時間: 10-12-13 01:10

Sorry, no ah!

[ 本帖最後由 daisy17772 於 10-12-13 01:16 編輯 ]

作者: 天瑜 時間: 10-12-13 07:44 標題: 回復 9# Crabmeatsoup 的帖子

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: Lyn 時間: 10-12-13 08:11

我的case同你相似.

dg girls 真係好勁, 如果安排失當同場多幾個, 就真係俾佢地攞晒d 奬, 其他人無份.

明天亞囡有一場, 真係對佢地又愛又恨.

原帖由 Crabmeatsoup 於 10-12-12 22:27 發表
今年我同囡囡參加了幾個校際朗誦節比賽﹐包括英文和普通話。唔知係咪算唔好彩﹐每次同場都有幾個小女拔嘅學生。結果點呢﹖就係差不多所有冠亞季軍嘅獎都比佢地囉晒。唔好誤會﹐我意思唔係話D評判唔公平﹐而係女拔D學生表現真係 ...

作者: 天瑜 時間: 10-12-13 08:46 標題: 回復 1# Lyn 的帖子

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: mimame 時間: 10-12-13 09:56

there are 3 DGJS girls in my daughter's group on the competition day. All of them lost, not even a 3rd place.

the winner is from Singapore international school.

作者: kellyjason 時間: 10-12-13 10:09

How you all know what schools the students came from ? Are they wearing school uniforms ?

作者: CiaoEveryone 時間: 10-12-13 10:14

原帖由 brian61950 於 10-12-12 22:42 發表
單對單英語朗誦訓練公價係$500-$800或以上一個鐘·
就算有錢都可能會肉赤·

好貴啊!!! 假設一天5個鐘, 每月都有約12萬!!!好羨慕啊而我們的普羅大眾就要做多幾份工, 死慳死抵了.

作者: brian61950 時間: 10-12-13 10:20 標題: 回復 1# CiaoEveryone 的帖子

阿女學校好好,之前為參加了朗誦節的同學免費補3粒鐘.

作者: mimame 時間: 10-12-13 10:20

most of the famous schools' students are wearing school uniforms.

作者: newbkmember 時間: 10-12-13 10:26

My girl's session only has 1 dgjs girl. My girl got the champion but the dgjs girl didn't have any placing.
I think it also depends on the preference of the judge as well.

作者: Loso 時間: 10-12-13 10:38

基本上女拔一直都係一間好勁嘅女校，而近幾年相比其他名校如SPCC、SPC、Maryknoll ...等亦好似突出咗D ( 完全個人觀感，不喜勿插 )，叻學生入叻學校，加上家長肯撥多D 資源 back -up ，出外比賽勁D都真係唔出奇!

作者: **芳芳** 時間: 10-12-13 11:38

非一般的操練===非一般的成績

作者: Gerard 時間: 10-12-13 12:15

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: babyhappy88 時間: 10-12-13 12:34 標題: 回復 4# newbkmember 的帖子

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: Planet 時間: 10-12-13 12:44

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: smallhorse 時間: 10-12-13 12:51

DGJS also has its own training at school for speech, its free of charge, my girl and her classmates were trained by the school teacher during lunch time once a week for almost 10 weeks.

作者: Planet 時間: 10-12-13 13:10

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: KK07 時間: 10-12-13 13:38

忍唔住都係插口, 點解呢D獎咁重要?重要到要特別花錢請人教? 對教育一個孩子有咁大幫助? 講真我真係唔明

作者: **芳芳** 時間: 10-12-13 13:59

最緊要對學校有幫助........

作者: catcatmom 時間: 10-12-13 14:02

A & B 女孩都係女拔畢業

A女孩係我前老板既女.(報紙佬話我的前老板有50億身家喎!)

B女孩係同事既妹, 當年係小學之後抽入女拔,讀到中學畢業.

A 女孩係藍血, 小學起讀到中學畢業去外國,英文很好, 佢媽媽係瑪利"落" 係OLD GIRL, 不過不會太多時間教個女, 因經常和名流來往, 又上吓報紙, 佢都係請人番來教.

我同 A 女孩開會, 全程講英文, 同鬼婆差唔多, 不過佢長期係美國住.

B女孩最後讀本地大學, 屋企亦無$比佢去外國讀, 再去星加坡讀了一段短時間既大學, 同事說佢細妹去到星加坡D英文追得好辛苦,上堂聽唔明, 教授講得很快,(說香港D教授D英文慢), 佢話星人D英文好勁.

作者: Gerard 時間: 10-12-13 14:13 標題: 回復 6# Planet 的帖子

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: Sevendwarfs 時間: 10-12-13 14:49

其實我都覺得女拔學生好勁是不可否認的事實。她們出色的地方﹐不是用一兩個朗誦比賽獎去衡量。如果要我用一個字去形容DGJS學生﹐我會用“smart". 她們行出來就給人自信的感覺﹐而且學生整體的語文能力亦很高。家長的培育﹐與及學生本身的質素﹐當然不容置疑。但我相信這間學校﹐的確為學生提供了一個很好的語文學習環境, 而同學之間互相影響和學習﹐亦是主要因素。我記得有個朋友跟我說﹐女拔是一間真真正正以全英文授課的 local 英文小學。除了中文課外﹐平時所有時間﹐包括小息﹐課外活動等﹐老師和同學之間都是用英文溝通。所有學生由一年級開始﹐已經可以說出一口流利英語﹐這是有別於其他的 local 英文小學的。
無疑﹐ 女拔學生很多時都會比人高傲﹐過份自信(即是自大)的感覺﹐這個是很多家長要面對和解決的問題。
我老公是男拔的畢業生﹐他時常對我說女拔生比男拔生勁好多(我想他意思是平均成績來說)﹐又夠“霸氣”。所以以前佢地見到女拔生都怕怕..

[ 本帖最後由 Sevendwarfs 於 10-12-14 12:36 編輯 ]

作者: 天瑜 時間: 10-12-14 10:14 標題: 回復 5# KK07 的帖子

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: EMILY03 時間: 10-12-14 12:29 標題: 回覆 1# 天瑜的文章

好明顯佢地攞獎是用錢操回來的 , 值唔值就見仁見智

作者: OCEP 時間: 10-12-14 14:32

My understanding is DGJS has always viewed the HK Schools Speech Festival as an opportunity to allow its' students to perform in a public arena so that they gain the confidence and also the enjoyment of public speaking. As previous post mentioned, majority of girls have been selected by DGJS to represent the school and therefore scheduled rehearsals took place at school during lunch breaks over a 2 months period. This is all completely Free of Charge. For those who haven't been chosen could elect to join the competition themselves but received no training whatsoever from the school so I assume they might choose to join outside organizations to help them. As for the girls chosen by the school, the rehearsals was more than sufficient to enable them to take part in the event having learned the necessary skills. I cannot speak for everyone, but we never pay any extra costs to outside organizations. It is true that most DGJS girls scored very high in the competition because the school trained them well. Not all DGJS girls were placed in the Top 3 in their respective group as this depends on the "luck of the draw" and the adjudicator's preferences. As parents, I have to admit it is the most enjoyable experiences to see your child performing confidently and coming out really enjoying themselves. It is NOT the most important thing to be in the Top 3 but the sheer experiences of having this wonderful opportunity.

作者: VKwan 時間: 10-12-14 15:18

我反而好想知道女拔d家長點樣栽培細路咁有自信咁bright？我個仔直情成舊飯咁

作者: Charlotte_mom 時間: 10-12-14 15:32

我相信training固然重要, 但天生都要有個"勢"
我女由k2已參加speech festival, 雖然佢未必有獎(都有試過), 但每次都好有信心好enjoy咁上台演出, 呢d唔駛train都自然出黎
我相信dgjs o係小一interview階段, 亦會好留意小朋友係咪有自信, 有要求既學生 (我女唔係呢種喇, 佢屬於開心無憂型, 所以我亦無考dgjs), 有d小朋友, 真係4,5歲已經識為自己plan, 對自己要求好高, 好似我女細個去學體操, 大家都係咁上下(4,5歲), 有d小朋友, 企o係度都成個奧運選手咁, 超pro! 呢種小朋友, 去到dgjs自然如魚得水了

作者: mcheung1 時間: 10-12-14 15:45

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: 天瑜 時間: 10-12-14 15:57

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: I/LOVE/3T 時間: 10-12-14 16:00

原帖由 EMILY03 於 10-12-14 12:29 發表
好明顯佢地攞獎是用錢操回來的 , 值唔值就見仁見智

小朋友嘅資質先係最重要嘅一環，金錢只不過係錦上添花，幫佢更上一層樓。我相信 DGJS 嘅小朋友大多數都好有自信心。而我覺得自信心一大部分是天生。

作者: ricenoodle 時間: 10-12-14 16:20

Your girl is excellent, may I know which school she attends?

原帖由 newbkmember 於 10-12-13 10:26 發表
My girl's session only has 1 dgjs girl. My girl got the champion but the dgjs girl didn't have any placing.
I think it also depends on the preference of the judge as well.

作者: BookloverJ 時間: 10-12-14 17:18

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: Sevendwarfs 時間: 10-12-14 17:44 標題: 回覆 38# I/LOVE/3T 的文章

Absolutely Agree!

作者: KwanPark 時間: 10-12-14 20:20 標題: 回覆 38# I/LOVE/3T 的文章

自信心大部分是天生 !

作者: newbkmember 時間: 10-12-15 00:00

Hi ricenoodle, pls check pm.

原帖由 ricenoodle 於 10-12-14 16:20 發表
Your girl is excellent, may I know which school she attends?

作者: Lyn 時間: 10-12-16 08:17

我非常認同這一句. 我仔以前我要求咁咁, 佢唔中意就話, 使唔使呀? 或者, 得啦, 我上台時就做好啦. 到時因緊張, 邊記得? 仲差過排練時.
我囡就好好多, 態度好, 跟足指點, 所以成績亦較好.

原帖由天瑜於 10-12-14 15:57 發表
用錢多或少不是重點! 你有料冇錢一樣惦!
重點是排練時那份認真的精神!

作者: natpa 時間: 10-12-16 08:32

女拔學界D1游泳連繼23年獲全埸總冠軍！真不簡單！

作者: SarsMum 時間: 10-12-16 14:47

Last year, my daughter got 1 winner and 1 first runner in School Speech Festival. This year, she got 2 winners and 1 second runner. She is not studying in DGJS.
While I agree with you that girls are smart and confident from DGJS, the effort by the kids, parents and teachers is the key for success.
DGJS provides a good environment in hardware and software to train her girls. Girls, parents and teachers of it cannot slow down even a minute. When you admire their rewards, please don't forget their effort.

作者: goodmama2003 時間: 10-12-16 15:11

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: BusyFather 時間: 10-12-19 01:48

According to a friend who is a DGJS P3 parent, the school is actually not pushy at all. They have only two examinations a year. Each exam includes only one session for English, Chinese and Maths. They've never had any exam after long holidays like Christmas, Chinese New Year or Easter. It is the parents who are proactive and let their girls participate in a wide spectrum of extra-cirricular activities. Every year, the girls get numerous prizes in different sorts of inter-school competitions and only those who have got champion can go onto the stage on prize presentation day.
There is no doubt that DGS girls are smart in general. However, only few of them are really brilliant in the society. If you look at the notable alumni, many other elite schools are actually far better than DGS.

原帖由 goodmama2003 於 10-12-16 15:11 發表
女拔喎, 梗係叻 !

作者: 3lamma 時間: 10-12-19 15:30

我識的家長也是這樣說. 學校的功課不多. 看學校網頁的資料就最中肯, 全校得600多人, 竟有500多個ENTRIES, 獎多到數不清, 不用以一兩場賽去比較. 可能女孩始終對朗誦較有興趣. 以我所知學校只派二年級以上, 不被選中的學生可自行報名, 所以也不一定是DGJS一定WIN, 天時地利人和加努力吧!老師選中的絕對免費加成日練, 其他選不中而請人教或家長教也大有人在.
小女只是幼稚園, 自己教及第一次參加, 同場也有2位DGJS生, 也好彩有名次, 自己當然是有花心思, 女肯練, 老師俾意見. 所以大家都要付出啊!

原帖由 BusyFather 於 10-12-19 01:48 發表
According to a friend who is a DGJS P3 parent, the school is actually not pushy at all. They have only two examinations a year. Each exam includes only one session for English, Chinese and Maths. They ...

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)